Skip to main content
Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Experimental and Finite Element Investigation of Reinforced Concrete Corbels Strengthened with CFRP, Steel Plates, and Cementitious Repair Mortar Cover

Experimental and Finite Element Investigation of Reinforced Concrete Corbels Strengthened with CFRP, Steel Plates, and Cementitious Repair Mortar

Open Access
|Nov 2026
Read online

Figures & tables

Figure 1:

Test setup for double sided corbel

Figure 2:

Corbel reinforcement

Figure 3:

Corbel strengthen strategy

Table 1:

Beam description and strengthening method

No.Corbel IDDescription
1C0Corbel control
2A1CFRP full
3A2CRRP two sides
4C1Steel strip full
5C2Steel strip two side
6D1Full steel plate
7E1CFRP plat strip
8G1Sika Mono-Top 612
Table 2:

Mechanical properties of steel reinforcement

Bar diameter [mm]Yield strength [Mpa]Ultimate strength [Mpa]Modulus of elasticity [GPa]
12510680199.9
10490635199.7
8465620198.3
Table 3:

Mechanical properties of externally bonded steel plate

Yield strength [Mpa]Ultimate strength [MPa]Modulus of elasticity [GPa]
310378207
Table 4:

Concrete mixture material quantity per m3

MaterialMass [kg/m3]
Cement370
Fine aggregate740
Coarse aggregate1100
Water181.3
W/C (%)0.49
superplasticizer2.22
Table 5:

Concrete mechanical properties

TestResults
Modulus of rupture [MPa]4.31
Compression strength [MPa]34.8
Splitting tensile strength [MPa]2.17
Figure 4:

Load deflection curves for the tested corbels

Table 6:

First crack and ultimate load values

Corbel IDFirst crackUltimate load∆ control [%]
C01403310
A145047042
A23003609
C118040823
C220040121
D132048045
E129040522
G112055066
Figure 5:

Control corbel testing and failure

Figure 6:

Specimen C1 and C2 failure

Figure 7:

Specimen E1 failure

Figure 8:

Specimen D1 failure

Figure 9:

Specimen G1 failure

Figure 10:

Specimen A1 failure

Figure 11:

Specimen A2 failure

Table 7:

Initial stiffness

Corbel IDInitial stiffness [kN/mm]∆ control [%]
C09680
A1166772
A2122427
C110175
C29993
D1130435
E1133338
G1117622
Table 8:

Displacement-ductility values

Corbel ID∆y∆Uμ∆∆ control [%]
C00.340.6982.040
A10.280.7002.4822
A20.260.6202.4018
C10.401.0802.6932
C20.401.1002.7434
D10.371.2803.4870
E10.300.7582.5022
G10.471.5003.2157
Table 9:

Energy absorption values

Corbel IDArea under the curve [kN.mm]Change in absorbed energy relative to control [%]
C0166.010
A1238.9744
A2165.350
C1340.14105
C2323.8395
D1440.70165
E1239.2844
G1537.67224
Figure 12:

The geometry of the finite element model, the assembly of the concrete, reinforcement, and strengthening components, the boundary conditions, and the mesh for a representative strengthened specimen

Table 10:

Experimental and FE model ultimate load values

Corbel IDPU [kN]PUFE [kN] PU-PUFEPU% PU – PUFE [kN]
C0331316.2−4−14.8
A1470502.5732.5
A2360391.5931.5
C1408404.1−1−3.9
C2401404.313.3
D1480498.9418.9
E1405435.3730.3
G1550570.0420.0

[i] PU: Experimental ultimate load

[ii] PUFE: FE model ultimate load

Table 11:

Experimental and FE model ultimate load displacement

Corbel ID∆U [mm]∆UFE [mm] ΔUFE-ΔUΔU% ∆UFE − ∆U [mm]
C00.700.84200.142
A10.701.24770.541
A20.620.50−19−0.120
C11.081.49380.406
C21.101.50360.396
D11.281.15−11−0.134
E10.760.86130.101
G11.301.68290.380

[i] ∆U: Experimental ultimate load deflection

[ii] ∆UFE: FE ultimate load deflection

Figure 13:

Experimental and FE load displacement curve for spacemen C0 (control corbel)

Figure 14:

Experimental and FE load displacement curve for spacemen C1 and C2

Figure 15:

Experimental and FE load displacement curve for spacemen D1

Figure 16:

Experimental and FE load displacement curve for spacemen E1

Figure 17:

Experimental and FE load displacement curve for spacemen A1

Figure 18:

Experimental and FE load displacement curve for spacemen A2

Figure 19:

Experimental and FE load displacement curve for spacemen G1

Table 12:

The experimental and FE area under the curve value

Corbel IDAEx [kN.mm]AFE [kN.mm] AFE-AEXAEX%
C0166.0123642
A1238.9731331
A2165.35144−13
C1340.1450548
C2323.8351057
D1440.7067353
E1239.2829322
G1537.6779448

[i] AEX: Area under the experimental curve

[ii] AFE: Area under the FE curve

Figure 20:

Full CFRP S, Mises stress in (a) the reinforcement bar, (b) in the corbel concrete part

Figure 21:

Steel plate strip S, Mises stress in (a) the steel strip, (b) in the corbel concrete part

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/cee-2027-0035 | Journal eISSN: 2199-6512 (formerly 1336-5835) | Journal ISSN: 1336-5835
Language: English
Submitted on: Aug 22, 2026
Accepted on: Oct 1, 2026
Published on: Nov 19, 2026
Published by: University of Žilina
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 4 issues per year

© 2026 Dolfocar Witwit, Maytham Khalid Gatea, Mohammed F. Ojaimi, Hayder Kadhem Adai Al-Farttoosi, published by University of Žilina
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.