Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Methodological Advances in Understanding Environmental Constraints on Sustainability and Industrial Periodicity of Ancient Copper Smelting in Southeast Arabia Cover

Methodological Advances in Understanding Environmental Constraints on Sustainability and Industrial Periodicity of Ancient Copper Smelting in Southeast Arabia

Open Access
|Apr 2025

Figures & Tables

oq-11-147-g1.png
Figure 1

Iron Age and Early Islamic primary copper production sites and associated aggregation areas in southeastern Arabia.

oq-11-147-g2.png
Figure 2

Sites from top to bottom, left to right: Raki 1, Raki 2, and Tawi Raki.

oq-11-147-g3.png
Figure 3

Fuel biomass survey in Wadi Raki. FBS1: Raki 2, FBS2: Raki 1, FBS3: Tawi Raki, FBS4: Qurun al Khabab.

Table 1

Recorded data sheet for individual trees.

CATEGORIESATTRIBUTES
TreeNumerical
Area of InterestFBS 1, FBS 2, FBS 3, FBS 4, or FBS 5
SquareNumerical
Stems at Stump HeightNumerical
Stems at Breast HeightNumerical
Circumference of Stem(s) at Stump Heightcm values divided by commas
Circumference of Stem(s) at Breast Heightcm values divided by commas
Tree HeightNumerical
Tree IDGenus and Species
Confidence of IDPossible, Probable, Likely, or Unidentified
ConditionAlive, Dead, or Horizontal
Landform ClassBedrock slope, scree slope, plateau, gravel terrace, bedrock terrace, wadi silts, wadi channel
Slope0–5 degrees, 5–15 degrees, 15–30 degrees, >30 degrees
DepositionAlluvium, colluvium, or other
Camera TypeMake and Model
Photo RangeUnique Photo Number
oq-11-147-g4.png
Figure 4

Point and Polygon features recorded in the field. Note that the misalignment between the GPS-collected polygons representing tree canopies and the satellite imagery basemap is a consequence of inaccuracy of satellite imagery georeferencing.

oq-11-147-g5.png
Figure 5

Fuel biomass survey measurements of trees being taken in the field.

Table 2

Above Ground Biomass (AGB) allometric equations estimated from DBH: Diameter at Breast Height 1.3 m above ground (cm) H: Height (m) stem_Circum: Stem Circumference and DSH: Diameter at Stump Height (cm) measured at 0.3 above ground.

TREE IDFORMULAREFERENCE
Acacia ehrenbergiana1.07 exp(–4.23 + 1.63 ln(DBH) + 1.05 ln(H) – 1.89 ln(0.72)(Moussa et al. 2019)
Acacia nilotica subsp. indica0.071 + 0.0818(DBH2 × H)(Maguire et al. 1990)
6.9319 × (DSH)  – 43.731(Raizada et al. 2007)
Acacia tortilisexp(–3.043) × (DBH)1.411 × (H)2.266(Feyisa et al. 2018)
Acacia gerrardii subsp. negevensis2.692 × (Stem_Circum) – 2.699(Shackleton and Scholes 2011)
Ziziphus spina-christi1.07 exp(–4.23 + 1.63  ln(DBH) + 1.05  ln(H) – 1.89 ln(0.72)(Moussa et al. 2019, Vreugdenhil et al. 2012)
Salvadora persica1.07 exp(–4.23 + 1.63 ln(DBH) + 1.05 ln(H) – 1.89 ln(0.6)(Moussa et al. 2019)
Prosopis cineraria(DBH2)2×π×H×0.063(Jaiswal et al. 2018)
Moringa peregrina2– 852.262 + 433.93 ln(DSH)(Abdoul-Salam et al. 2021)
Table 3

Regression models and their parameters.

PARAMETERSINDIVIDUAL LOG-LOG MODELAGGREGATE LINEAR MODELAGGREGATE LOG-LOG MODEL
Coefficients (Slope, Intercept)1.255, 0.4007.294, –62.0781.272, 0.176
Slope and Intercept [Lower 95% to Upper 95%][1.082 to 1.428]
[–0.161 to 0.963]
[4.844 to 9.745]
[–1069 to 945]
[1.087 to 1.456]
[–0.819 to 1.159]
Multiple R0.6730.7680.941
R Square0.4540.590.885
Adjusted R Square0.4510.5740.881
Standard Error1.2031717.900.522
F204.66937.446200.825
Significance F3.434E-341.811E-069.669E-14
t-Stat1.403, 14.306–0.127, 6.1190.354, 14.171
P-value0.161, 3.434E-340.9, 1.811E-060.726, 9.669E-14
Observations2482828
oq-11-147-g6.png
Figure 6

Six most common tree species observed during the Wadi Raki biomass survey. (a) Acacia tortilis, (b) Acacia nilotica, (c) Acacia ehrenbergiana, (d) Salvadora persica, (e) Prosopis cineraria, and (f) Ziziphus spina-christi.

oq-11-147-g7.png
Figure 7

The regression analysis process on the aggregated crown areas (CA) in square meters vs. aggregated above-ground biomass (AGB) in kilograms in 27 observed 100 × 100 m areas of land. There are some overlapping points in the yellow rectangles.

oq-11-147-g8.png
Figure 8

Biomass availability in the vicinity of Wadi Raki divided by half-hour walking time intervals.

oq-11-147-g9.png
Figure 9

Histogram of woody biomass (kg) per hectare.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/oq.147 | Journal eISSN: 2055-298X
Language: English
Submitted on: Jun 30, 2024
Accepted on: Mar 18, 2025
Published on: Apr 14, 2025
Published by: Ubiquity Press
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 1 issue per year

© 2025 Amir Zaribaf, Joseph W. Lehner, Abigail Buffington, Ioana A. Dumitru, Smiti Nathan, Paige Paulsen, Alexander J. Sivitskis, Eli Dollarhide, Michael J. Harrower, published by Ubiquity Press
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.