Have a personal or library account? Click to login

Enhanced biological control of root-knot nematode, Meloidogyne incognita, by combined inoculation of cotton or soybean seeds with a plant growth-promoting rhizobacterium and pectin-rich orange peel

Open Access
|Jun 2021

Figures & Tables

Figure 1:

Effects of orange peel power (OPP) amendment on the mortality of J2 of M. incognita in vitro by B. velezensis AP203.
Effects of orange peel power (OPP) amendment on the mortality of J2 of M. incognita in vitro by B. velezensis AP203.

Figure 2:

Effects of B. velezensis AP203 with an orange peel power (OPP) or glucose amendments on the number of M. incognita eggs on the roots of soybean at 45 days after planting in greenhouse trials.
Effects of B. velezensis AP203 with an orange peel power (OPP) or glucose amendments on the number of M. incognita eggs on the roots of soybean at 45 days after planting in greenhouse trials.

Figure 3:

Effects of B. velezensis AP203 with an orange peel power (OPP) or glucose amendments on the number of M. incognita eggs on the roots of cotton at 45 days after planting in greenhouse trials.
Effects of B. velezensis AP203 with an orange peel power (OPP) or glucose amendments on the number of M. incognita eggs on the roots of cotton at 45 days after planting in greenhouse trials.

Figure S1:

LC-MS/MS spectra of the peaks eluted at 6.69 min (m/z of 211.11).
LC-MS/MS spectra of the peaks eluted at 6.69 min (m/z of 211.11).

Figure S2:

LC-MS/MS spectra of the peaks eluted at 2.40 min (m/z of 206.12).
LC-MS/MS spectra of the peaks eluted at 2.40 min (m/z of 206.12).

Figure S3:

LC-MS/MS spectra of the peaks eluted at 6.63 min (m/z of 253.12) and 3.39 min (m/z of 295.17).
LC-MS/MS spectra of the peaks eluted at 6.63 min (m/z of 253.12) and 3.39 min (m/z of 295.17).

Effect of B_ velezensis AP203 amended with orange peel powder (OPP) or glucose on soybean growth at 45 days after planting in greenhouse trials_

Treatmenta Shoot length (cm)b Root length (cm)Shoot fresh weight (g)Root fresh weight (g)
TSB-grown cells58.0a22.5ab6.51ab3.91ab
OPP (supernatant)67.4a21.9abc8.12ab4.20ab
Glucose (supernatant)66.8a19.9cde7.55ab3.98ab
OPP (Cells)72.3a22.0abc9.06ab4.92a
Glucose (Cells)62.5a20.1bcde8.43ab3.42ab
OPP (Culture)72.0a22.6a10.20a4.11ab
Glucose (Culture)60.8a19.0e8.25ab4.00ab
OPP62.5a21.4abcd8.12ab3.65ab
Glucose67.9a20.0cde5.95ab2.53b
M. incognita nematode
Untreated control

Predicted secondary metabolites found in cell-free supernatants of B_ velezensis AP203 after 48 hr growth in 0_5% (w/v) OPP amended Tris Spizizen Salts (TSS) media_

Treatmenta RT (min)b Product ions (m/z)RA/CFUc Predicted metabolites
OPAP203 16.69 min211.1121.111,3-Diphenyl-2-propanone
OPAP203 26.63 min253.1225.31p-(3,4-Dihydro-6-methoxy-2-naphthyl) phenol
OPAP203 33.39 min295.1729.51(E)-1,1,-(1,2-Diethyl-1,2-ethenediyl) bis (4-methoxybenzene)
OPAP203 42.40 min206.1220.613-(Dimethylamino) propyl benzoate
GluAP2030000
OPP0000
Glucose0000

List of predicted secondary metabolites found in cell-free supernatants of B_ velezensis AP203 after 48 hr growth in 0_5% (w/v) orange peel power (OPP) amended Tris Spizizen Salts (TSS) media_

Query IDQuery m/zName of the bioactive compoundsFormulaExact mass
1101.0711Gyromitrin;Acetaldehyde methylformylhydrazoneC4H8N2O100.0636629
2103.0559Indoleacetic acidC10H9NO2175.0633285
3103.05595-HydroxyindoleacetaldehydeC10H9NO2175.0633285
4104.05492-Ethyl-1-hexanol, 9CI; (±)-form, O-SulfateC8H18O4S210.0925798
5104.05682-Ethyl-1-hexanol, 9CI; (±)-form, O-SulfateC8H18O4S210.0925798
7104.0585Histidinyl-GlycineC8H12N4O3212.0909403
8104.0585D-Glycero-D-galacto-heptitolC7H16O7212.0896029
9104.0585Glycyl-HistidineC8H12N4O3212.0909403
10104.0707N-methyl-beta-alanineC4H9NO2103.0633285
11104.0707(2S)-2-NitrobutaneC4H9NO2103.0633285
13104.0707Ethyl carbamic acid methyl esterC4H9NO2103.0633285
14104.0707N-Methyl-L-alanineC4H9NO2103.0633285
15104.0707HBAC4H9NO2103.0633285
16104.0707DL-3-aminobutyrateC4H9NO2103.0633285
17104.0707Mefenamic acidC15H15NO2241.1102787
18104.0707N-[2-(4-Hydroxyphenyl)ethyl]benzamideC15H15NO2241.1102787
19104.07072-Amino-2-methylpropanoate;2-Aminoisobutyric acidC4H9NO2103.0633285
20104.0707(R,S)-3-Amino-2-methylpropanoateC4H9NO2103.0633285
21104.0707beta-alanine-methyl-esterC4H9NO2103.0633285
22104.0707N,N-Dimethylglycine;DimethylglycineC4H9NO2103.0633285
23104.0707N-EthylglycineC4H9NO2103.0633285
24104.0707(R)-2-Aminobutanoic acid;(S)-2-AminobutanoateC4H9NO2103.0633285
25104.07071-nitrobutaneC4H9NO2103.0633285
26104.07074-Aminobutanoate;4-Aminobutanoic acidC4H9NO2103.0633285
27105.03663-methylthiopropanalC4H8OS104.0295856
28105.0366Acutifolane AC16H22O3262.1569
29105.0366tetrahydrothiophene 1-oxideC4H8OS104.0295856
30105.03673-methylthiopropanalC4H8OS104.0295856
31105.0367tetrahydrothiophene 1-oxideC4H8OS104.0295856
32105.03723-methylthiopropanalC4H8OS104.0295856
33105.0372tetrahydrothiophene 1-oxideC4H8OS104.0295856
34105.03763-methylthiopropanalC4H8OS104.0295856
35105.0376tetrahydrothiophene 1-oxideC4H8OS104.0295856
37105.0443-cyanopyridineC6H4N2104.0374481
38105.0442-CyanopyridineC6H4N2104.0374481
39105.0444-CyanopyridineC6H4N2104.0374481
40105.0441(+)-18-Hydroxy-7,16-sacculatadiene-11,12-dialC20H30O3318.2195
41105.0441ent-7alpha-hydroxykaur-16-en-19-oic acidC20H30O3318.2195
42105.04412-CyanopyridineC6H4N2104.0374481
43105.0441OxymesteroneC20H30O3318.2194948
44105.04414-CyanopyridineC6H4N2104.0374481
45105.04413-cyanopyridineC6H4N2104.0374481
46105.04418-oxo-5E,9Z,11Z,14Z-eicosatetraenoic acidC20H30O3318.2195
47105.04419-oxo-5E,7Z,11Z,14Z-eicosatetraenoic acidC20H30O3318.2195
48105.044111-oxo-5E,8Z,12Z,14Z-Eicosatetraenoic acidC20H30O3318.2195
49105.0441(+)-7beta-Hydroxy-15-beyeren-19-oic acidC20H30O3318.2195
50105.0557Tyrosyl-TyrosineC18H20N2O5344.1372218
51105.0651AminoserineC3H8N2O2104.0585775
52105.0651L-2,3-DiaminopropionateC3H8N2O2104.0585775
53105.0651HydroxyaminoalanineC3H8N2O2104.0585775
54105.06622,3-Diaminopropanoic acidC3H8N2O2104.0585775
55105.06724,-O-MethylbavachalconeC22H24O4352.1675
56105.0672OvalichalconeC22H24O4352.1675
57105.0672Pongagallone AC22H24O4352.1675
58105.0672CandidoneC22H24O4352.1675
59105.0672Methylhildgardtol AC22H24O4352.1675
60105.0672Methylhildgardtol BC22H24O4352.1675
61105.0672XuulaninC22H24O4352.1675
62105.0715ValganciclovirC14H22N6O5354.1651678
63105.073312-hydroxyjasmonic acid 12-O-beta-D-glucosideC19H30O8386.1941
64105.0733Citroside AC19H30O8386.1940679
65105.07336,9-Dihydroxy-4,7-megastigmadien-3-oneC19H30O8386.1940679
66107.0845p-Xylene;1,4-Dimethylbenzene;p-MethyltolueneC8H10106.0782503
67107.0845Ethylbenzene;Phenylethane;Ethylbenzol;EthylenzeneC8H10106.0782503
68107.0845o-Xylene;o-Dimethylbenzene;o-MethyltolueneC8H10106.0782503
69107.0845m-Xylene;1,3-Dimethylbenzene;1,3-XyleneC8H10106.0782503
70107.0848o-Xylene;o-Dimethylbenzene;o-MethyltolueneC8H10106.0782503
71107.0848m-Xylene;1,3-Dimethylbenzene;1,3-XyleneC8H10106.0782503
72107.0848p-Xylene;1,4-Dimethylbenzene;p-MethyltolueneC8H10106.0782503
73107.0848Ethylbenzene;Phenylethane;Ethylbenzol;EthylenzeneC8H10106.0782503
74107.0848O-6-deoxy-a-L-galactopyranosylC20H33NO14511.1901048
75107.0851o-Xylene;o-Dimethylbenzene;o-MethyltolueneC8H10106.0782503
76107.0851m-Xylene;1,3-Dimethylbenzene;1,3-XyleneC8H10106.0782503
77107.0851p-Xylene;1,4-Dimethylbenzene;p-MethyltolueneC8H10106.0782503
78107.0851Ethylbenzene;Phenylethane;Ethylbenzol;EthylenzeneC8H10106.0782503
79107.0858p-Xylene;1,4-Dimethylbenzene;p-MethyltolueneC8H10106.0782503
80107.0858Ethylbenzene;Phenylethane;Ethylbenzol;EthylenzeneC8H10106.0782503
81107.0858o-Xylene;o-Dimethylbenzene;o-MethyltolueneC8H10106.0782503
82107.0858m-Xylene;1,3-Dimethylbenzene;1,3-XyleneC8H10106.0782503
83107.0858DaunorubicinC27H29NO10527.1791462
84107.0859m-Xylene;1,3-Dimethylbenzene;1,3-XyleneC8H10106.0782503
85107.0859p-Xylene;1,4-Dimethylbenzene;p-MethyltolueneC8H10106.0782503
86107.0859Ethylbenzene;Phenylethane;Ethylbenzol;EthylenzeneC8H10106.0782503
87107.0859o-Xylene;o-Dimethylbenzene;o-MethyltolueneC8H10106.0782503
88109.02871,2-BenzoquinoneC6H4O2108.0211294
89109.0287Quinone;p-Benzoquinone;ChinoneC6H4O2108.0211294
90109.0306Hordatine B glucosideC35H50N8O10742.3649899
91109.0306HydroxymethylmethylsilanediolC2H8O3Si108.0242707
92109.0309HydroxymethylmethylsilanediolC2H8O3Si108.0242707
93109.0309MonothioglycerolC3H8O2S108.0245002
94109.0315HydroxymethylmethylsilanediolC2H8O3Si108.0242707
95109.0316HydroxymethylmethylsilanediolC2H8O3Si108.0242707
96109.0316HydroxymethylmethylsilanediolC2H8O3Si108.0242707
97109.0321HydroxymethylmethylsilanediolC2H8O3Si108.0242707
98109.0642Benzenemethanol;Phenylmethanol;PhenylcarbinolC7H8O108.0575149
99109.0642o-Cresol;2-Hydroxytoluene;o-MethylphenolC7H8O108.0575149
100109.06423-Cresol;m-Cresol;3-HydroxytolueneC7H8O108.0575149
101109.06424-Cresol;p-Cresol;4-HydroxytolueneC7H8O108.0575149
102109.0642Anisole;Methoxybenzene;Methyl phenyl etherC7H8O108.0575149
103111.0434Resorcinol;Resorcin;1,3-BenzenediolC6H6O2110.0367794
104111.0434Hydroquinone;p-Benzenediol;1,4-BenzenediolC6H6O2110.0367794
105111.04345-Methyl-2-furaldehyde;5-Methyl-2-furfuralC6H6O2110.0367794
106111.0434o-BenzosemiquinoneC6H6O2110.0367794
107111.0434Catechol;1,2-Benzenediol;o-BenzenediolC6H6O2110.0367794
108111.0434Benzosemiquinone;p-BenzosemiquinoneC6H6O2110.0367794
109111.0437Resorcinol;Resorcin;1,3-BenzenediolC6H6O2110.0367794
110111.0437Hydroquinone;p-Benzenediol;1,4-BenzenediolC6H6O2110.0367794
111111.04375-Methyl-2-furaldehyde;5-Methyl-2-furfuralC6H6O2110.0367794
112111.0437Catechol;1,2-Benzenediol;o-BenzenedioC6H6O2110.0367794
113111.0437Benzosemiquinone;p-BenzosemiquinoneC6H6O2110.0367794
114111.04382-FuranmethanolC5H6O298.03677944
115111.0438Benzosemiquinone;p-BenzosemiquinoneC6H6O2110.0367794
116111.0438Resorcinol;Resorcin;1,3-BenzenediolC6H6O2110.0367794
117111.0438Hydroquinone;p-Benzenediol;1,4-BenzenediolC6H6O2110.0367794
118111.04385-Methyl-2-furaldehyde;5-Methyl-2-furfuralC6H6O2110.0367794
119111.0438o-BenzosemiquinoneC6H6O2110.0367794
120111.0438penta-2,4-dienoic acid;beta-vinyl acrylic acidC5H6O298.0368
121111.0438Catechol;1,2-Benzenediol;o-BenzenediolC6H6O2110.0367794
122111.04385-Methyl-2(3H)-furanoneC5H6O298.03677944
123111.0447o-BenzosemiquinoneC6H6O2110.0367794
124111.0447Catechol;1,2-Benzenediol;o-BenzenediolC6H6O2110.0367794
125111.0447Benzosemiquinone;p-BenzosemiquinoneC6H6O2110.0367794
126111.0447Resorcinol;Resorcin;1,3-Benzenediol;1,3-DihydroxybenzeneC6H6O2110.0367794
127111.0447Hydroquinone;p-Benzenediol;1,4-BenzenediolC6H6O2110.0367794
128111.04475-Methyl-2-furaldehyde;5-Methyl-2-furfuralC6H6O2110.0367794
129111.0448o-BenzosemiquinoneC6H6O2110.0367794
130111.0448Catechol;1,2-Benzenediol;o-BenzenediolC6H6O2110.0367794
131111.0448Benzosemiquinone;p-BenzosemiquinoneC6H6O2110.0367794
132111.0448Resorcinol;Resorcin;1,3-Benzenediol;1,3-DihydroxybenzeneC6H6O2110.0367794
133111.0448Hydroquinone;p-Benzenediol;1,4-BenzenediolC6H6O2110.0367794
134111.0451Catechol;1,2-Benzenediol;o-BenzenediolC6H6O2110.0367794
135111.0451Benzosemiquinone;p-BenzosemiquinoneC6H6O2110.0367794
136111.0451Resorcinol;Resorcin;1,3-Benzenediol;1,3-DihydroxybenzeneC6H6O2110.0367794
137111.0451Hydroquinone;p-Benzenediol;1,4-BenzenediolC6H6O2110.0367794
138111.04515-Methyl-2-furaldehyde;5-Methyl-2-furfuralC6H6O2110.0367794
139121.0316DimethylsulfonioacetateC4H8O2S120.0245002
140121.03163-(Methylthio)propionic acid;3-MethylthiopropionateC4H8O2S120.0245002
141121.0316sulfolaneC4H8O2S120.0245002
142121.032DimethylsulfonioacetateC4H8O2S120.0245002
143121.0323-(Methylthio)propionic acid;3-MethylthiopropionateC4H8O2S120.0245002
144121.032sulfolaneC4H8O2S120.0245002
145121.0324DimethylsulfonioacetateC4H8O2S120.0245002
146121.03243-(Methylthio)propionic acid;3-MethylthiopropionateC4H8O2S120.0245002
147121.0324sulfolaneC4H8O2S120.0245002
148121.0325DimethylsulfonioacetateC4H8O2S120.0245002
149121.03253-(Methylthio)propionic acid;3-MethylthiopropionateC4H8O2S120.0245002
150121.0325sulfolaneC4H8O2S120.0245002
151121.0325DimethylsulfonioacetateC4H8O2S120.0245002
152121.03253-(Methylthio)propionic acid;3-MethylthiopropionateC4H8O2S120.0245002
153121.0325sulfolaneC4H8O2S120.0245002
154121.0325DimethylsulfonioacetateC4H8O2S120.0245002
155121.03253-(Methylthio)propionic acid;3-MethylthiopropionateC4H8O2S120.0245002
156121.0325sulfolaneC4H8O2S120.0245002
157121.0373-nitro-1-propionateC3H6NO4120.0296827
158121.03793-nitro-1-propionateC3H6NO4120.0296827
159121.052,3-dihydroxy-2-methyl-propanoic acidC4H8O4120.0422587
160121.05L-(+)-Erythrose;D-threo-Aldose;D-ErythruloseC4H8O4120.0422587
161121.053-Deoxytetronic acidC4H8O4120.0422587
162121.054-Deoxyerythronic acidC4H8O4120.0422587
163121.05L-Erythrulose;L-glycero-TetruloseC4H8O4120.0422587
164121.053,4-Dihydroxybutyric acidC4H8O4120.0422587
165121.05D-Threose;D-threo-Tetrose;D-ErythroseC4H8O4120.0422587
166121.0516PurineC5H4N4120.0435961
167122.09623,4-DIMETHYLANILINEC8H11N121.0891494
168122.09621-Phenylethylamine;alpha-PhenylethylamineC8H11N121.0891494
169122.0962N-Ethylaniline;N-EthylbenzenamineC8H11N121.0891494
170122.0962Phenethylamine;2-Phenylethylamine;beta-PhenylethylamineC8H11N121.0891494
171122.09622,4-Dimethylaniline;2,4-DMAC8H11N121.0891494
172122.0962N,N-Dimethylaniline; N,N-DimethylbenzenamineC8H11N121.0891494
173122.09651-Phenylethylamine;alpha-PhenylethylamineC8H11N121.0891494
174122.09652,6-DimethylanilineC8H11N121.0891494
175122.0965N-Ethylaniline;N-EthylbenzenamineC8H11N121.0891494
176122.09652,5-DimethylalanineC8H11N121.0891494
177122.09652-Phenylethylamine;beta-PhenylethylamineC8H11N121.0891494
178181.0694Sorbose;xylo-Hexulose;D-FructoseC6H12O6180.0633881
179181.06942-Deoxy-D-gluconateC6H12O6180.0633881
180181.0694KetoseC6H12O6180.0633881
181181.0996Methylphophonic acid diisopropyl esterC7H17O3P180.0915309
182229.12351,1-Bis(4-hydroxyphenyl)propaneC15H16O2228.1150298
183229.1235Mansonone CC15H16O2228.1150298
184229.1235Bisphenol A;2,2-Bis(4-Hydroxyphenyl)propaneC15H16O2228.1150298
185229.1235dihydropinosylvin monomethyletherC15H16O2228.1150298
186229.1285Deoxyguanidinoproclavaminic acidC9H16N4O3228.1222404
187229.1298DeoxyamidinoproclavaminateC9H16N4O3228.1222404
188230.058Lamivudine;3TC;2’,3’-Dideoxy-3’-thiacytidineC8H11N3O3S229.0521119
189230.058Carbonylphophonic acidC9H12NO4P229.0503944
190230.0582,3-Dihydroxy-2’-carboxybiphenylC13H9O4-229.0500838
191357.1718RutamarinC21H24O5356.1623739
191357.1718Gingerenone AC21H24O5356.1623739
192357.1718alpha,beta-dihydroxanthohumolC21H24O5356.1623739
193357.1718Kadsurenone;Denudatin BC21H24O5356.1623739
194371.0795RebamipideC19H15ClN2O4370.0720347
195371.0795Digalacturonate;Digalacturonic acidC12H18O13370.0747407
196371.07951,2-beta-D-Glucuronosyl-D-glucuronateC12H18O13370.0747407
197371.145Napththalene-2-sulfonamideC20H22N2O3S370.1351133
198371.1501iso-dehydrocycloxanthohumol hydrateC21H22O6370.1416384
199371.1501xanthohumol DC21H22O6370.1416384
200371.15015’-Prenylhomoeriodictyol;Sigmoidin B 3’-methyl etherC21H22O6370.1416384
201371.1501xanthohumol BC21H22O6370.1416384
202371.1501curcuminC21H22O6370.1416384
203371.1501Alkannin beta,beta-dimethylacrylateC21H22O6370.1416384
204371.1501Sophoraisoflavanone AC21H22O6370.1416384
205371.1509iso-dehydrocycloxanthohumol hydrateC21H22O6370.1416384
206371.1509xanthohumol DC21H22O6370.1416384
207371.15095’-Prenylhomoeriodictyol;Sigmoidin B 3’-methyl etherC21H22O6370.1416384
208371.1509xanthohumol BC21H22O6370.1416384
209371.1509curcuminC21H22O6370.1416384
210371.1509Alkannin beta,beta-dimethylacrylateC21H22O6370.1416384
211371.1509Sophoraisoflavanone AC21H22O6370.1416384
212371.1528Galactan;AmyloseC14H26O11370.1475117
213371.1528Galactan;AmyloseC14H26O11370.1475117
214371.1541Galactan;AmyloseC14H26O11370.1475117
215404.1365trifluoperazineC21H20F3N3S403.1330029
216404.1484Ampicillin trihydrateC16H25N3O7S403.1413209
217405.1191Spectinomycin dihydrochlorideC14H26Cl2N2O7404.1117066
218405.1267Sulfinpyrazone;SulfoxyphenylpyrazolidineC23H20N2O3S404.1194632
219405.1269Sulfinpyrazone;SulfoxyphenylpyrazolidineC23H20N2O3S404.1194632

Effect of B_ velezensis AP203, amended orange peel powder (OPP) or glucose on cotton growth at 45 days after planting in greenhouse trials_

Shoot lengthRoot lengthShoot freshRoot fresh
Treatmenta (cm)b (cm)weight (g)weight (g)
TSB-grown cells26.0ab18.5abc2.6a1.7a
OPP (supernatant)27.3ab20.2ab2.5a1.7a
Glucose (supernatant)26.8ab18.2abc2.5a1.6a
OPP (Cells)30.7a21.2ab2.2a1.9a
Glucose (Cells)27.0ab16.1bc2.7a1.6a
OPP (Culture)30.6ab20.1ab2.4a1.4a
Glucose (Culture)28.8ab18.1abc2.5a1.6a
OPP23.2ab17.7abc2.1a1.7a
Glucose22.6b16.1bc2.3a1.1a
M. incognita nematode20.0b14.3c1.7a0.9a
Untreated control26.2ab21.8a2.7a1.3a
DOI: https://doi.org/10.21307/jofnem-2021-058 | Journal eISSN: 2640-396X | Journal ISSN: 0022-300X
Language: English
Page range: 1 - 17
Published on: Jun 22, 2021
Published by: Society of Nematologists, Inc.
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 1 times per year

© 2021 Mohammad K. Hassan, Kathy S. Lawrence, Edward J. Sikora, Mark R. Liles, Joseph W. Kloepper, published by Society of Nematologists, Inc.
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.