Skip to main content
Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Optimal PID Level Control of a Nonlinear Spherical Tank Using a Hybrid WOA–GA Optimization Approach Cover

Optimal PID Level Control of a Nonlinear Spherical Tank Using a Hybrid WOA–GA Optimization Approach

Open Access
|Sep 2026
Read online

Figures & tables

Figure 1.

Schematic of a spherical tank

Figure 2.

Block diagram of level setup

Figure 3.

Schematic of interfacing of NI DQA USB 6001 module with spherical tank system

Table 1.

Technical specification of experimental setup

Sr.NoComponentsSpecification
1Spherical TankSS, H-25 cm, D-25cm, R-12.5 cm
2DAQ DeviceNI USB6001, 14 bit, AI-4, AO-2
3Level TransmitterTwo wires, Range 0-250mm, O/P=4 to 20 mA
4Dosing PumpPDDP with adjustable stroke
5VFD1-ph 200 VAC, 1.1 A, O/P AC 3-ph, 0-230v
6Manual outlet valveCd = 19.69 cm2/s
7Input flow ratefin = 0 (Min) and 420 (Max) LPH
8Output flow ratefout = It is kept 150 LPH for study
Figure 4.

Open loop response of spherical tank

Figure 5.

Structure of PID controller

Figure 6.

WOA-GA algorithm process flowchart

Figure 7.

Block diagram of proposed WOA-GA based PID controller

Table 2.

Optimization Parameters

ParameterGAWOAWOA-GA
Lower bound [Kp, Ki, Kd][1, 0.01, -20][1, 0.01, -20][1, 0.01, -20]
Upper bound [Kp, Ki, Kd][5, 3, 5][5, 3, 5][5, 3, 5]
No. of Generations20.020.020.0
No. of Population20.020.020.0
Crossover Fraction0.8–0.8
Mutation Fraction0.2–0.2
α decrease–2 to 02 to 0
Table 3.

Controller tuning values

Sr.No.Controller TypeKpKiKd
1GA-PID1.150.03-34.34
2WOA-PID2.560.171.31
3WOA-GA-PID1.920.2-7.27
Figure 8.

Convergence curves of GA, WOA and WOAGA with population size 20

Figure 9.

Simulation and real-time control efforts and responses

Table 4.

Time domain comparison between simulation and real-time implementation

Set PointSpecificationSimulationReal-Time
GA-PIDWOA-PIDWOAGA-PIDGA-PIDWOA-PIDWOAGA-PID
19.30 cm LevelRise Time254237193305275210
Peak Time504374302512398347
Settling Time670307251680325274
Overshoot %3.211.041.252.781.561.67
Table 5.

Comparison of performance parameters in simulation and real-time implementation

Set PointControllerSimulationReal-Time
ISEIAEITAEISEIAEITAE
19.30 cm LevelGA-PID62446270046484928422
WOA-PID61436137326574124757
WOAGA-PID51830026046383983228
Figure 10.

Setpoint tracking

Table 6.

Comparison of control effort in simulation and real-time

NormSimulationReal-Time
GA-PIDWOA-PIDWOAGA-PIDGA-PIDWOA-PIDWOAGA-PID
norm 2143.79141.34139.51145.18143.71142
norm ∞65.65.65.75.75.2
Figure 11.

Disturbnce rejection

DOI: https://doi.org/10.14313/jamris-2026-035 | Journal eISSN: 2080-2145 | Journal ISSN: 1897-8649
Language: English
Page range: 26 - 35
Submitted on: Nov 4, 2025
Accepted on: Feb 2, 2026
Published on: Sep 30, 2026
Published by: Łukasiewicz Research Network – Industrial Research Institute for Automation and Measurements PIAP
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 4 issues per year

© 2026 Abhay Pakhare, Sharad Jadhav, Mukesh Patil, published by Łukasiewicz Research Network – Industrial Research Institute for Automation and Measurements PIAP
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 License.