Legitimate Targets: What is the Applicable Legal Framework Governing the Use of Force in Rio de Janeiro?
By: Conor Foley
References
- ALERJ. 2008. Relatório Final da Comissão Parlamentar de Inquérito Destinada a Investigar a Ação de Milícias no Estado do Rio de Janeiro. Rio de Janeiro: Assembleia Legislativa do Estado do Rio de Janeiro.
- Alves, F and Otavio, C. 2022. ‘Ex-chefe de Policia Civil preso usava mortes no Jacarezinho como bandeiro de campanha’. O Globo, 9 September 2022.
https://oglobo.globo.com/politica/eleicoes-2022/noticia/2022/09/ex-chefe-de-policia-civil-preso-usava-mortes-no-jacarezinho-como-bandeira-de-campanha.ghtml , accessed 3 October 2022. - Alves, MHM and Evanson, P. 2011. Living in the Crossfire, Favela residents, drug dealers and police violence in Rio de Janeiro. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
- Amnesty International (AI). 2012. Outcome of Copenhagen Process on detainees in international military operations undermines respect for human rights. Available at:
https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/IOR50/003/2012/en/ [Last accessed 19 September 2022]. - Araújo, V. 2020. Novo secretário de Polícia Civil quer tanques em favelas e promete avançar no caso Marielle. O Globo, 27 September 2020. Available at:
https://oglobo.globo.com/rio/novo-secretario-de-policia-civil-quer-tanques-em-favelas-promete-avancar-no-caso-marielle-24663177#:~:text=O%20delegado%20Allan%20Turnowski%20n%C3%A3o,a%20Secretaria%20de%20Pol%C3%ADcia%20Civil.&text=Mas%20agora%20Turnowski%20%E2%80%94%20que%20foi,planos%20para%20enfrentar%20a%20viol%C3%AAncia [Last accessed 18 September 2022]. - Azzi, VF. forthcoming.
‘The war on criminality in Rio de Janeiro: Pacifying unruly territories?’ In: Solar, C and Pérez Ricart, C (eds.), Crime, Violence and Justice in Latin America. Abingdon: Routledge. - BBC. 2016. Four dead after police helicopter ‘shot down by gang’. BBC News Brazil, 20 November 2016. Available at:
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-38041847 [Last accessed 18 September 2022]. - Bellal, A. 2019. The War Report: Armed conflicts in 2018. The Geneva Academy of International Humanitarian Law and Human Rights.
- Bethlehem, D. 2012. Self-defense against an imminent or actual armed attack by nonstate actors. American Journal of International Law, 106(4): 770–777. DOI: 10.5305/amerjintelaw.106.4.0769
- Betim, F. 2021. Em afronta ao STF, polícia do Rio impõe sigilo a operação do Jacarezinho e outras ações na pandemia por cinco anos. El País, 26 May 2021. Available at:
https://brasil.elpais.com/brasil/2021-05-26/policia-civil-do-rio-impoe-sigilo-a-documentos-do-jacarezinho-e-outras-operacoes-por-cinco-anos-em-confronto-ao-stf.html#:~:text=A%20Pol%C3%ADcia%20Civil%20do%20Rio,letal%20da%20hist%C3%B3ria%20do%20Estado.&text=A%20corpora%C3%A7%C3%A3o%20estendeu%20o%20sigilo,5%20de%20junho%20de%202020 [Last accessed 18 September 2022]. - Brazilian Government Ministry of Defence. 2012. Livro Branco de Defesa Nacional. At:
https://www.defesa.gov.br/arquivos/2012/mes07/lbdn.pdf [accessed on 21 September 2022]. - Brazilian Government Ministry of Defence [online]. 2013. ‘Garantia da Lei e da Ordem’. 20 December.
https://www.gov.br/defesa/pt-br/arquivos/File/doutrinamilitar/listadepublicacoesEMD/md33a_ma_10a_gloa_1a_ed2013.pdf [Last accessed on 21 September 2022]. - Brazilian Government Ministry of Defence [online]. 2014. ‘Garantia da Lei e da Ordem’. 3 February.
https://www.gov.br/defesa/pt-br/assuntos/exercicios-e-operacoes/garantia-da-lei-e-da-ordem [Last accessed on 21 September 2022]. - Bruderlein, C. 2000. The Role of Non-State Actors in Building Human Security: The case of armed groups in intra-state wars. Geneva: Centre for Humanitarian Dialogue.
https://www.hdcentre.org/publications/the-role-of-non-state-actors-in-building-human-security/ . - Cano, I. 2008.
Seis por meia dúzia? Um estudo exploratório do fenômeno das chamadas ‘milícias’ no Rio de Janeiro . In: Global, J (ed.), Segurança, milícias e tráfico no Rio de Janeiro. Rio de Janeiro: Justiça Global and Fundação Heinrich Böll. pp. 48–83. - Carta Capital. 2014. [Video] Átila Roque fala do “extermínio da população jovem negra”. 30 December 2014. Available at:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZbvDqBmcj1Y [Last accessed 18 September 2022]. - Center for Civilians in Conflict (CIVIC). 2019a. Reverse the Trend: 2021–25 Strategic plan.
https://civiliansinconflict.org/approach/ [Last accessed 22 September 2022]. - Chernishova, O. 2013. ‘Recent developments in the case-law of the European Court of Human Rights related to the issue of the use of force’. Presentation in ICRC Expert Meeting. Appendix 6
https://www.icrc.org/en/doc/assets/files/publications/icrc-002-4171.pdf , accessed 3 October 2022. - Chinkin, C and Kaldor, M. 2017. International Law and New Wars. Cambridge University Press. DOI: 10.1017/9781316759868
- CIVIC. 2014. Civilian Harm Tracking: Analysis of ISAF efforts in Afghanistan. New York: CIVIC.
- CIVIC. 2019b. The Sum of All Parts: Reducing civilian harm in multinational coalition operations. New York: CIVIC.
- Comissão Parlamentar de Inquérito do Assassinato de Jovens (CPIADJ). 2015. Relatório Final. Comissão Parlamentar de Inquérito do Assassinato de Jovens.
https://www12.senado.leg.br/noticias/arquivos/2016/06/08/veja-a-integra-do-relatorio-da-cpi-do-assassinato-de-jovens , accessed 3 October 2022. - Dalby, C and Francisco, A. 2019. Militias become luxury real estate barons in Rio de Janeiro. InSight Crime, 23 April 2019. Available at:
https://insightcrime.org/news/analysis/militias-become-luxury-real-estate-barons-rio-de-janeiro/ [Last accessed 18 September 2022]. - Dowdney, L. 2003. Children of the Drug Trade: A case study of children in organized armed violence in Rio de Janeiro. Rio de Janeiro: Viva Rio/ISER (Instituto de Estudos da Religião).
- ECtHR. 1978. Ireland v UK, Appl. No. 5310/71, Judgment 18 January 1978. DOI: 10.1080/00431672.1978.9931856
- ECtHR. 1988. Brogan and others v. UK. Appl. No. 11209/84, Judgment 29 November 1988.
- ECtHR. 1993. Brannigan and MacBride v. UK. Appl. No.14553-4/89, Judgment 24 May 1993.
- ECtHR. 1995. McCann and others v. UK. Appl. No. 18984/91, 5 September 1995.
- ECtHR. 1998a. Kaya v. Turkey. Appl. No. 22729/93, Judgment 19 February 1998, para 9.
- ECtHR. 2005a. Isayeva, Yusupova and Bazayeva v. Russia. Appl. No. 57947-49/00, Judgment 24 February 2005, para 179.
- ECtHR. 2011a. Al-Skeini and Others v. UK. Appl. No. 55721/07, Judgment (Grand Chamber) 7 July 2011.
- ECtHR. 2011b. Al-Jedda v. UK. Appl. No. 27021/08, Judgment (Grand Chamber) 7 July 2011.
- ECtHR. 2014a. Hassan v. United Kingdom. Appl. No. 29750/09, Judgment (Grand Chamber), 16 September 2014.
- ECtHR. 2014b. Jaloud v. The Netherlands. Appl. No. 47708/08, Judgment (Grand Chamber), 20 November 2014.
- Escola de Cultura de Pau (ECP). 2022. Alert 2022! Report on Conflicts, Human Rights and Peacebuilding. Barcelona: Icaria.
- Estado de Minas, Chefe do’ Escritório do crime’, ‘capitão Adriano’ morre em tiroteio com a polícia, 9 February 2020. Available at:
https://www.em.com.br/app/noticia/nacional/2020/02/09/interna_nacional,1120569/chefe-do-escritorio-do-crime-capitao-adriano-morre-em-tiroteio-policia.shtml [Last accessed 18 September 2022]. - European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR). 2021. Hanan v. Germany. Appl No. 4871/16, (Grand Chamber), Judgment, 16 February 2021.
- FBSP. 2019. Anuário Brasileiro de Segurança Pública. Available at:
https://www.forumseguranca.org.br/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/Anuario-2019-FINAL_21.10.19.pdf [Last accessed 19 September 2022]. - FBSP [Fórum Brasileiro de Segurança Pública]. 2021. Anuário Brasileiro de Segurança Pública. Available at:
https://forumseguranca.org.br/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/anuario-2021-completo-v6-bx.pdf [Last accessed 19 September 2022]. - FIRJAN. 2017. Avanço da criminalidade no Estado do Rio de Janeiro: Retrato e propostas para a segurança pública. Rio de Janeiro: FIRJAN.
- Fogo Cruzado. 2020. Database Available at:
https://fogocruzado.org.br/estatisticas/ [Last accessed 19 September 2022]. - Foley, C. 2014. Pelo telefone: Rumors, truths and myths in the ‘pacification’ of the favelas of Rio de Janeiro. HASOW (Humanitarian Action in Situations Other than War) Discussion Paper 8. Rio de Janeiro.
- Foley, C. 2017. UN Peacekeeping and the Protection of Civilians: Saving succeeding generations. Cambridge University Press. DOI: 10.1017/9781108236126
- Foley, C. (ed.). 2019. In Spite of You: Bolsonaro and the new Brazilian resistance. New York: OR Books. DOI: 10.2307/j.ctvmd82x7
- Foley, C. 2022. Human Rights and Protection by UN Peace Operations. New York, International Peace Institute.
- Gearty, C. 1995. After Gibraltar. London Review of Books, 17(22), 16 November 1995.
- Gonçalves, LL. 2017. Letalidade violenta e controle ilegal do território no Rio de Janeiro. Cadernos de Segurança Pública, 9(8): 1–19.
http://www.isprevista.rj.gov.br/download/Rev20170804.pdf . - Grellet, F. 2019. Witzel sobe em helicóptero com sniper e causa polêmica. Terra, 6 May 2019. Available at:
https://www.terra.com.br/noticias/brasil/cidades/witzel-sobe-em-helicoptero-com-atirador-de-elite-e-causa-polemica,0b107d79aa61ac85cb70ef9a691d69f7gnmzuvqr.html [Last accessed 18 September 2022]. - Gross, A. 2017. The Writing on the Wall: Rethinking the international law of occupation. Cambridge University Press. DOI: 10.1017/9781316536308
- Hampson, F. 2008. The relationship between international humanitarian law and human rights law from the perspective of a human rights treaty body. International Review of the Red Cross, 90(871): 549–72. DOI: 10.1017/S1560775508000114
- Hampson, F and Lubell, N. 2013. Amicus Curiae brief submitted by Professors Francoise Hampson and Noam Lubell in the case of Hassan v. United Kingdom, Appl. No. 29750/09. Human Rights Centre, University of Essex.
- Hartman, J. 2012. The Copenhagen Process: Principles and Guidelines. Blog of the European Journal of International Law, 3 November 2012. Available at
https://www.ejiltalk.org/the-copenhagen-process-principles-and-guidelines/ [Last accessed 18 September 2022]. - Hauck, P and Peterke, P. 2010. Organized crime and gang violence in national and international Law. International Review of the Red Cross, 92(878): 407–436. DOI: 10.1017/S181638311000038X
- Henckaerts, JM and Doswald-Beck, L. 2005. Customary International Humanitarian Law. Cambridge University Press. DOI: 10.1017/CBO9780511804700
- Hirata, DV and Grillo, CC. 2017. Sintonia e amizade entre patrões e donos de morro: Perspectivas comparativas entre o comércio varejista de drogas em São Paulo e no Rio de Janeiro. Tempo Social, 29(2): 75–98. DOI: 10.11606/0103-2070.ts.2017.125494
- Hirata, DV and Grillo, CC. 2019. Sumário executivo: Operações policiais no Rio de Janeiro. Rio de Janeiro: Fundação Heinrich Böll Brasil.
- Human Rights Watch (HRW). 2021. Brazil: Investigate Rio Police Command for Deadly Raid. Available at:
https://www.hrw.org/news/2021/05/31/brazil-investigate-rio-police-command-deadly-raid [Last accessed 19 September 2022]. - Human Rights Watch (HRW). 2022. Another police raid in Rio leaves 23 dead. Available at
https://www.hrw.org/news/2022/05/26/another-police-raid-rio-leaves-23-dead , Accessed 3 October 2022. - IACHR. 2008. Juan Carlos Abella v Argentina. Case 11.137, 13 April 2008 (‘La Tablada’).
- IACtHR. 1995. Neira Alegria v. Peru, 19 January 1995, para. 74. DOI: 10.1111/j.1468-0319.1995.tb00046.x
- IACtHR. 2017. Favela Nova Brasília v Brazil. Judgment (Preliminary objections, merits, reparations and costs), 16 February 2017.
- ICC. 2007. The Prosecutor v. Thomas Lubanga Dyilo (ICC-01/04-01/06). Decision on the Confirmation of Charges, Pre-Trial Chamber I, 29 January 2007.
- ICRC. 2008. How is the Term “Armed Conflict” Defined in International Humanitarian Law? Opinion Paper, March 2008. Geneva. International Committee of the Red Cross.
- ICTY. 2008a. Prosecutor v. Ramush Haradinaj, Idriz Balaj, Lahi Brahimaj (IT-04-84). Judgment, Trial Chamber I, 3 April 2008, para. 49.
- Instituto de Segurança Pública. Available at:
https://www.ispvisualizacao.rj.gov.br:4434/ , [Last accessed 19 September 2022]. - Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR). 2010. Franklin Guillermo Aisalla Molina (Ecuador – Colombia). Report No. 112/10 (Admissibility), Inter-state Petition IP-02, October 21, 2010, paras 117–121.
- International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC). 2011. Brazil: mitigating the effects of armed violence, Interview, 16 September 2011.
https://www.icrc.org/en/doc/resources/documents/interview/2011/brazil-interview-2011-09-01.htm [Last accessed 26 September 2022]. - Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACtHR). 2000. Bámaca-Velásquez v Guatemala. Series C No. 70 [Merits].
- International Court of Justice. 1996. Legality or Threat of Use of Nuclear Weapons. Advisory Opinion of 8 July 1996, ICJ Reports 1996.
- International Criminal Court (ICC). 2008. The Prosecutor v. Germain Katanga (ICC-01/04-01/07). Decision on the Confirmation of Charges, Pre-Trial Chamber I, 30 September 2008, para. 239.
- International Criminal Tribunal for Yugoslavia (ICTY). 1995. Prosecutor v. Dusko Tadic. Decision on the Defence Motion for Interlocutory Appeal on Jurisdiction, Case No. IT-94-1-AR72, 2 October 1995.
- International Criminal Tribunal for Yugoslavia (ICTY). 2005. Prosecutor v Fatmir Limaj, Haradin Bala, Isak Musliu (IT-03-66-T). Judgment, TC II, 30 November 2005 (‘Limaj’).
- Jones, C. 2021. The War Lawyers: The United States, Israel, and Judicial Warfare. Oxford University Press. DOI: 10.1093/oso/9780198842927.001.0001
- Keenan, M and Holt, V. 2018. Preparing to Protect: Advice on Implementing NATO’s Protection of Civilians Policy. NATO ACT OPEN Publications.
- Kenkel, KM. 2006. ‘Language matters: security discourse and civil-military relations in post-ditadura Brazil’. Paper presented at the 47th Annual Convention of the International Studies Association, San Diego.
- Kilcullen, D. 2009. The Accidental Guerrilla: Fighting small wars in the midst of a big one. London: Hurst & Co.
- Kolb, R. 2003.
Applicability of international humanitarian law to forces under the command of an international organization . In Faite, A and Grenier, JL (eds.), Report: Expert Meeting on Multinational Peace Operations: Applicability of International Humanitarian Law and International Human Rights Law to UN mandated forces. Geneva: International Committee of the Red Cross. - Larsen, KM. 2012. The Human Rights Treaty Obligations of Peacekeepers. Cambridge University Press. DOI: 10.1017/CBO9781139062022
- Leeds, E. 1996. Cocaine and parallel polities in the Brazilian urban periphery: Constraints on local- level democratization. Latin American Research Review, 31(3): 47–84. DOI: 10.1017/S0023879100018136
- Leeds, E. 2007.
Rio de Janeiro . In Koonings, K and Kruijt, D (eds.), Fractured Cities: Social Exclusion, Urban Violence and Contested Spaces in Latin America. London: Zed Book. pp. 23–35. DOI: 10.5040/9781350220225.ch-002 - Lopes, M. 2022.
‘Police raid kills 18 in Rio, sparking outcry and accusations of abuse’ . Washington Post, 22 July 2022,https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2022/07/22/brazil-rio-police-raid-favela-dead/ , accessed 3 October 2022. - Lubell, N. 2010. Extraterritorial Use of Force Against Non-state Actors. Oxford University Press. DOI: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199584840.001.0001
- Lyra, D. 2020. Operários da firma: Mundo do trabalho no mundo do crime. Revista Antropolítica, 50(90): 90–115. DOI: 10.22409/antropolitica2020.i50.a43306
- Neves, Y. 2019. Death from above: The use of police helicopters in Rio de Janeiro. InSight Crime, 15 July 2019. Available at:
https://insightcrime.org/news/analysis/death-from-above-police-helicopters-rio-de-janeiro/ [Last accessed 18 September 2022]. - Manso, BP. 2020. A República das Milícias: Dos esquadrões da morte à era do Bolsonaro. São Paulo: Todavia.
- Nogueira, I and Barbon, J. 2021. Antes de apuração, diretor de Departamento de Homicídios diz que ‘não houve execução’ em operação. Folha de São Paulo, 7 May 2021. Available at:
https://www1.folha.uol.com.br/cotidiano/2021/05/antes-de-apuracao-diretor-de-departamento-de-homicidios-diz-que-nao-houve-execucao-em-operacao.shtml [Last accessed 18 September 2022]. - Olliveira, C, Couto, MI, Hirota, R and Spagnuolo, S. 2018. Tá tudo dominado: Exclusivo: as milícias assumiram o controle do Rio de Janeiro. The Intercept, 5 April 2018. Available at:
https://theintercept.com/2018/04/05/milicia-controle-rio-de-janeiro/ [Last accessed 18 September 2022]. - Peterke, S. 2012. Regulating ‘drug wars’ and other gray zone conflicts: Formal and functional approaches. HASOW (Humanitarian Action in Situations Other than War) Discussion Paper 2. Rio de Janeiro.
- Reidy, A. 1998. The approach of the European Commission and Court of Human Rights to International Humanitarian Law. International Review of the Red Cross, 324(30): 513–530. DOI: 10.1017/S0020860400091300
- Reidy, A, Hampson, F and Boyle, K. 1997. Gross violations of human Rights: Invoking the European Convention on Human Rights in the Case of Turkey. Netherlands Human Rights Quarterly, 15(2): 161–173. DOI: 10.1177/092405199701500203
- Rona, G and Wala, R. 2013. No thank you to a radical rewrite of the jus ad bellum. American Journal of International Law, 107(2): 386–390. DOI: 10.5305/amerjintelaw.107.2.0386
- Rothenburg, D. 2018. “Se eu errar, o PT volta”, diz Bolsonaro em entrevista exclusiva. Correio Braziliense, 2 November 2018. Available at:
https://www.correiobraziliense.com.br/app/noticia/politica/2018/11/02/interna_politica,717119/em-entrevista-bolsonaro-reafirma-papel-dos-militares-no-ministerio.shtml [Last accessed 18 September 2022]. - Sassòli, M. 2019. International Humanitarian Law: Rules, controversies, and solutions to problems arising in warfare. Geneva: Edward Elgar Publishing.
- Sivakumaran, S. 2012. The Law of Non-International Armed Conflict. Oxford University Press. DOI: 10.1093/law/9780199239795.001.0001
- UNAMA/OHCHR. 2021. Afghanistan: Protection of civilians in armed conflict: Annual Report 2020. Kabul: United Nations Assistance Mission in Afghanistan/Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights.
- United Nations Human Rights Committee (UNHRC). 1982. Camargo and Suarez de Guerrero v. Colombia, 31 March 1982, CCPR/C/15/D/45/1979.
- Veja. 2017. Homens ostentam armas em vídeos gravados em favelas no Rio, 1 October 2017. Available at:
https://istoe.com.br/homens-ostentam-armas-em-videos-gravados-em-favelas-no-rio/ [Last accessed 18 September 2022]. - Veja. 2018. Wilson Witzel: ‘A polícia vai mirar na cabecinha e… fogo’. 1 November 2018. Available at:
https://veja.abril.com.br/politica/wilson-witzel-a-policia-vai-mirar-na-cabecinha-e-fogo/ [Last accessed 18 September 2022]. - Viga Gaer, R. 2021.
‘At least 8 dead in mangrove after gun battle with Rio police’ . 22 November 2021, Reuters. - Winkler, T. 2016.
‘The Copenhagen Process Principles and Guidelines for Detention: Legal and political challenges” . In Rose, G and Oswald, B (eds.), Detention of Non-State Actors Engaged in Hostilities. Leiden, The Netherlands: Brill/Nijhoff. DOI: 10.1163/9789004310643_015
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/sta.826 | Journal eISSN: 2165-2627
Language: English
Page range: 5 - 5
Submitted on: Sep 20, 2021
Accepted on: Oct 27, 2022
Published on: Nov 16, 2022
Published by: Department of Peace Studies and International Development, University of Bradford
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
© 2022 Conor Foley, published by Department of Peace Studies and International Development, University of Bradford
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.