Roads and Military Provisioning During the French and Indian War (1754–1763): The Faunal Remains of Fort Shirley, PA in Context

Martin Welker; Shane Billings; Jonathan Burns; Sarah McClure

doi:10.5334/oq.40

Abstract

Early British generals faced serious challenges in delivering and storing sufficient provisions for 18th century British soldiers and colonial militia. This analysis investigates the influence of developed road systems that facilitated delivery of provisions and resulted in distinctive dietary patterning. The comparison of faunal data from forts located on major road systems with frontier garrisons and associated Native American villages like Fort Shirley and Aughwick Old Town, a short-lived (1754–1756) French and Indian War frontier fortification in central Pennsylvania, indicates a significantly reduced reliance on domestic livestock at these more inaccessible locations. These results suggest that road infrastructure heavily influenced military provisioning, encouraged adaptation to frontier living through reliance on wild game, and resulted in varied dietary practices at military installations in eastern North America.

References

1Africa, JS. 1883. History of Huntingdon County, Pennsylvania. Huntingdon, PA: Huntingdon County Historical Society.
Back to article
2Albarella, U. 2005. Meat Production and Consumption in Town and Country. In: Giles, K and Dyer, C (eds.), Town and Country in the Middle Ages: Contrasts, Contacts, and Interconnections, 131–148. Leeds: Maney Publishing.
Back to article
3Anderson, F. 1984. A People’s Army: Massachusetts Soldiers and Society in the Seven Years’ War. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.
Back to article
4Anderson, N. 1959. The General Chooses a Road. The Western Pennsylvania Historical Magazine, 42(2): 109–138.
Back to article
5Antony, B. 1972. Life in Wellington’s Army. Brighton, UK: Tom Donovan.
Back to article
6Balkwill, D and Cumbaa, SL. 1987. Salt Pork and Beef Again? The Diet of French and British Soldiers at the Casemate, Bastion St. Louis, Quebec. Research Bulletin 252, Environment Canada, Parks. Report on file at the Canadian Museum of Nature.
Back to article
7Bannerman, G. 2004. Merchants and the Military in Eighteenth-Century Britain: British Army Contracts and Domestic Supply, 1739–1763. Unpublished thesis (PhD), King’s College London.
Back to article
8Beattie, D. 1986. The Adaptation of the British Army to Wilderness Warfare, 1755–1763. In: Ultee, M (ed.), Adapting to Conditions: War and Society in the Eighteenth Century, 56–83. Tuscaloosa, AL: University of Alabama Press.
Back to article
9Boscawen, H. 2011. The Capture of Louisbourg, 1758. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press.
Back to article
10Breitburg, E. 1983. Bone Discardment Patterns and Meat Procurement Strategies at British Fort Loudoun (Tennessee), 1756–1760. Unpublished thesis (MA), Vanderbilt University.
Back to article
11Brophy, JK and Crisman, K. 2013. A Taphonomic Evaluation of Three Intact Pork Barrels from the Steamboat Heroine (1838). Historical Archaeology, 47(4): 71–85. DOI: 10.1007/BF03377124
Back to article
12Brown, CL and Gustafson, CE. 1979. A Key to the Postcranial Skeletal Remains of Cattle/Bison, Elk, and Horse. Laboratory of Anthropology Reports of Investigations 57. Pullman: Washington State University.
Back to article
13Brownell, EE. 1943. Map of Mohawk Country: From 1690 to 1790. Philadelphia, PA. Reproduced by E. E. Brown.
Back to article
14Burns, JA, Drobnock, GJ and Smith, JM. 2010. Croghan at Aughwick: History, Maps, and Archaeology Collide in the Search for Fort Shirley. Pioneer American Society Transactions, 33: 14–31.
Back to article
15Campbell, WJ. 2009. An Adverse Patron: Land, Trade, and George Croghan. Pennsylvania History: A Journal of Mid-Atlantic Studies, 76: 117–140.
Back to article
16Carlson, JK. 2012. Culinary Creolization: Subsistence and Cultural Interaction at Fort Michilimackinac, 1730–1761. Archaeological Completion Report Series 18. Mackinac Island, MI: Mackinac Island State Park Commission.
Back to article
17Clark, DT. 2003. An Analysis of Faunal Remains from Fort Loudoun (44FK593), a French and Indian War Period Site. Report Prepared for the Virginia Department of Historic Resources. Winchester, VA: Regional Preservation Office.
Back to article
18Cleland, CE. 1970. Comparison of the Faunal Remains from French and British Refuse Pits at Fort Michilimackinac: A Study in Changing Subsistence Practices, 3: 8–23. Canadian Historic Sites: Occasional Papers in Archaeology and History.
Back to article
19Coe, MD. 2006. The Line of Forts Historical Archaeology on the Colonial Frontier of Massachusetts. Lebanon, NH: University Press of New England.
Back to article
20Crass, DC and Wallsmith, DL. 1992. Where’s the Beef? Food Supply at an Antebellum Frontier Post. Historical Archaeology, 26: 2–23. DOI: 10.1007/BF03373530
Back to article
21Cubbison, D. 2010. The British Defeat of the French in Pennsylvania, 1758. Jefferson, NC: McFarland and Co.
Back to article
22Dalton, EC. 2011. Faunal Analysis at Fort Hunter: A French and Indian Supply Fort in Pennsylvania. Unpublished thesis (BA hons), Franklin and Marshall College.
Back to article
23Dollerhide, W. 1997. Map Guide to American Migration Routes, 1735–1815. Bountiful, UT: Heritage Quest.
Back to article
24Dunbar, W. 1760. Letter to Gen. Thomas Gage, 15 March. In: The Thomas Gage Papers. Ann Arbor, MI: Clements Library.
Back to article
25Forbes, J. 1758a. Letter to Lt. Col. Henry Bouquet, July 14. In: Procter, JA (ed.), Writings of General John Forbes relating to his service in North America, 1938. Menasha, WI: The Collegiate Press.
Back to article
26Forbes, J. 1758b. Letter to Lt. Col. Henry Bouquet, May 29. In: Procter, JA (ed.), Writings of General John Forbes relating to his service in North America, 1938. Menasha, WI: The Collegiate Press.
Back to article
27Forbes, J. 1758c. Letter to Bouquet, June 27. In: Procter, JA (ed.), Writings of General John Forbes relating to his service in North America, 1938. Menasha, WI: The Collegiate Press.
Back to article
28Forbes, J. 1758d. Letter to Gen. James Abercrombie, July 9. In: Procter, JA (ed.), Writings of General John Forbes relating to his service in North America, 1938. Menasha, WI: The Collegiate Press.
Back to article
29Forbes, J. 1758e. Letter to Lt. Col. Henry Bouquet, September 2. In: Procter, JA (ed.), Writings of General John Forbes relating to his service in North America, 1938. Menasha, WI: The Collegiate Press.
Back to article
30Forbes, J. 1758f. Letter to Gen. James Abercrombie, September 4. In: Procter, JA (ed.), Writings of General John Forbes relating to his service in North America, 1938. Menasha, WI: The Collegiate Press.
Back to article
31Forbes, J. 1758g. Letter to William Pitt, September 6. In: Procter, JA (ed.), Writings of General John Forbes relating to his service in North America, 1938. Menasha, WI: The Collegiate Press.
Back to article
32Forbes, J. 1758h. Letter to Gen. James Abercrombie, October 8. In: Procter, JA (ed.), Writings of General John Forbes relating to his service in North America, 1938. Menasha, WI: The Collegiate Press.
Back to article
33Forbes, J. 1758i. Letter to Lt. Col. Henry Bouquet, October 25. In: Procter, JA (ed.), Writings of General John Forbes relating to his service in North America, 1938. Menasha, WI: The Collegiate Press.
Back to article
34Forbes, J. 1758j. Letter to Lt. Col. Henry Bouquet, November 22. In: Procter, JA (ed.), Writings of General John Forbes relating to his service in North America, 1938. Menasha, WI: The Collegiate Press.
Back to article
35Forbes, J. 1758k. Letter to Gen. James Abercrombie, September 21. In: Procter, JA (ed.), Writings of General John Forbes relating to his service in North America, 1938. Menasha, WI: The Collegiate Press.
Back to article
36Forbes, J. 1758l. Letter to Lt. Col. Henry Bouquet, September 23. In: Procter, JA (ed.), Writings of General John Forbes relating to his service in North America, 1938. Menasha, WI: The Collegiate Press.
Back to article
37Forbes, J. 1758m. Letter to Gen. James Abercrombie, October 24. In: Procter, JA (ed.), Writings of General John Forbes relating to his service in North America, 1938. Menasha, WI: The Collegiate Press.
Back to article
38Forbes, J. 1758n. Letter to Lt. Col. Henry Bouquet, October 30. In: Procter, JA (ed.), Writings of General John Forbes relating to his service in North America, 1938. Menasha, WI: The Collegiate Press.
Back to article
39Forbes, J. 1758o. Letter to Gen. James Abercrombie, November 17. In: Procter, JA (ed.), Writings of General John Forbes relating to his service in North America, 1938. Menasha, WI: The Collegiate Press.
Back to article
40Forbes, J. 1758p. Letter to Joshua Howell, August 26. In: Forbes Headquarters Papers. University of Virginia Library, Charlottesville, Virginia.
Back to article
41Forbes, J. 1758q. Letter to Lt. Col. Henry Bouquet, June 10. In: Procter, JA (ed.), Writings of General John Forbes relating to his service in North America, 1938. Menasha, WI: The Collegiate Press.
Back to article
42Gilbert, BM. 2003. Mammalian Osteology. Columbia, MO: Missouri Archaeology Society Inc.
Back to article
43Gladwin, H. 1761. Letter to Gen. Thomas Gage, May 24. In: The Thomas Gage Papers. Ann Arbor, MI: Clements Library.
Back to article
44Grimm, JL. 1970. Archaeological Investigation of Fort Ligonier 1960–1965. Annuls of the Carnegie Museum 42.
Back to article
45Guilday, JE. 1970. Animal Remains from Archaeological Excavations at Fort Ligonier. In: Grimm, JL (ed.), Archaeological Investigation of Fort Ligonier 1960–1965, 177–186. Annuls of the Carnegie Museum 42.
Back to article
46Hanson, L and Hsu, DP. 1975. Casements and Cannonballs, Archaeological Investigations at Fort Stanwix, Rome, New York. Publications in Anthropology 14. Washington, DC: Department of the Interior.
Back to article
47Harcourt, RA. 1974. The Dog in Prehistoric and Early Historic Britain. Journal of Archaeological Science, 1: 151–175. DOI: 10.1016/0305-4403(74)90040-5
Back to article
48Hillson, S. 2005. Teeth. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI: 10.1017/CBO9780511614477
Back to article
49Hoops, A. 1758. Letter to Col. H. Bouquet, June 17. In: Stevens, SK, Kent, DH and Roland, LJ (eds.), The Papers of Henry Bouquet, 1941. Harrisburg: Pennsylvania Historical Commission.
Back to article
50John Milner Associates. 1978. Fort Frederick: An Archaeological Investigation of the Southwest Bastion and Areas Exterior to the North and West Walls. Report prepared for the State of Maryland Department of Natural Resources.
Back to article
51Jolly, RL. 2013. Fort Loudoun, Virginia: A French and Indian War Period Fortification Built by George Washington. In: Babits, LE and Gandulla, S (eds.), Archaeology of French and Indian War Frontier Forts, 102–122. Gainesville, FL: University Press of Florida. DOI: 10.5744/florida/9780813049069.003.0007
Back to article
52Jones, EL and Gabe, C. 2015. The Promise and Peril of Older Collections: Meta-Analyses and the Zooarchaeology of Late Prehistoric/Early Historic New Mexico. Open Quaternary, 1(6): 1–13. DOI: 10.5334/oq.ag
Back to article
53King, AC. 1984. Animal Bones and the Dietary Identity of Military and Civilian Groups in Roman Britain, Germany and Gaul. In: Blagg, TFC and King, AC (eds.), Military and Civilian in Roman Britain, 187–217. Oxford: British Archaeological Reports.
Back to article
54Knox, J. 1769. An Historical Journal of The Campaigns in North-America, for the Years 1757, 1758, 1759, and 1860: Containing The Most Remarkable Occurrences of that Period; Particularly The Two Sieges of Quebec, &c. &c. The Orders of the Admirals and General Officers; Descriptions of the Countries where the Author has served, with their Forts and Garrisons; their Climates, Soil, Produce; and A Regular Diary of the Weather. As Also Several Manifesto’s, a Mandate of the Late Bishop of Canada; The French Orders and Disposition for the Defence of the Colony, &c. &c. &c, 1. London: Johnston and Dodsley.
Back to article
55Kopperman, PE. 2007. The British Army in North America and the West Indies, 1755–83: A Medical Perspective. In: Hudson, GL (ed.), British Military and Naval Medicine 1600–1830, 51–86. New York: Editions Rodopi B. V.
Back to article
56Lacock, JK. 1914. Braddock Road. Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography, 38(1): 1–38.
Back to article
57Landon, DB. 1996. Feeding Colonial Boston: A Zooarchaeological Study. Historical Archaeology, 30(1): i–vii, 1–153.
Back to article
58Martin, TJ. 1991. An Archaeological Perspective on Animal Exploitation Patterns at French Colonial Sites in the Illinois Country. In: Walthall, JA (ed.), French Colonial Archaeology: The Illinois Country and the Western Great Lakes, 189–200. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
Back to article
59Martin, TJ and Mallard, AM. 2008. Animal Remains from the Fort Ashby Site (46MI58), Mineral County West Virginia. Technical Report 2008-000-7. Springfield: Illinois State Museum.
Back to article
60Mayer, HA. 2006. From Forts to Families: Following the Army into Western Pennsylvania, 1758–1766. The Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography, 130(1): 5–43.
Back to article
61McBride, WS. 2013. “To Preserve the Forts, and the Families Gathered into Them”: Archaeology of Edwards’s Fort, Capon Bridge, West Virginia. In: Babits, LE and Gandulla, S (eds.), Archaeology of French and Indian War Frontier Forts, 139–157. Gainesville, FL: University Press of Florida. DOI: 10.5744/florida/9780813049069.003.0009
Back to article
62Mercer, H. 1758. Letter to Col. H. Bouquet, September 14. In: Stevens, SK, Kent, DH and Roland, LJ (eds.), The Papers of Henry Bouquet, 1941. Harrisburg: Pennsylvania Historical Commission.
Back to article
63Mudar, K. 1978. The Effects of Socio-Cultural Variables on Food Preferences in Early 19^th-Century Detroit. Conference on Historic Site Archaeology Papers 1977, 12: 322–391.
Back to article
64Nagaoka, L. 2005. Differential Recovery of Pacific Island Fish Remains. Journal of Archaeological Science 32(6): 941–955. DOI: 10.1016/j.jas.2004.12.011
Back to article
65Parker, KL. 1970. Anglo-American Wilderness Campaigning, 1954–64: Logistical and Tactical Developments. Unpublished dissertation (PhD), Columbia University.
Back to article
66Pippen, DS. 2010. For Want of Provisions: An Archaeological and Historical Investigation of the British Soldier at Fort Haldimand (1778–84). Unpublished dissertation (PhD), Syracuse University.
Back to article
67Poirier, DA. 1976. Camp Reading: Logistics of a Revolutionary War Winter Encampment. Northeast Historical Archaeology, 5(12): 40–52.
Back to article
68Purdue, JR. 1983. Epiphyseal Closure in White-Tailed Deer. The Journal of Wildlife Management, 47(4): 1207–1213. DOI: 10.2307/3808195
Back to article
69Reitz, EJ. 1986. Urban/Rural Contrasts in Vertebrate Fauna from the Southern Atlantic Coastal Plain. Historical Archaeology, 20: 47–58. DOI: 10.1007/BF03374070
Back to article
70Rogers, H, Bartholomew, A and Armstrong, AK. 1998. Faunal Remains. In: Walker, DN (ed.), Archaeology at the Fort Laramie Quartermaster Dump Area, 1994–1996, 213–231. Cultural Resource Selections Intermountain Region, National Park Service 13. Denver: National Park Service.
Back to article
71Rouvalis, C. 2013. Commerce and Conflict on the 18^th Century Frontier. American Archaeology, 17(3): 32–37.
Back to article
72Scott, EM. 1985. French Subsistence at Fort Michilimackinac, 1715–1781: The Clergy and the Traders. Archaeological Completion Report Series 9., Mackinac Island, MI: Mackinac Island State Park Commission.
Back to article
73Scott, EM. 2008. Who Ate What? Archaeological Food Remains and Cultural Diversity. In: Reitz, E, Scarry, CM and Scudder, SJ (eds.), Case Studies in Environmental Archaeology, 357–374. New York: Springer. DOI: 10.1007/978-0-387-71303-8_18
Back to article
74Shaffer, BS. 1992. Quarter-Inch Screening: Understanding Biases in Recovery of Vertebrate Faunal Remains. American Antiquity, 57(1): 129–136. DOI: 10.2307/2694839
Back to article
75Shapiro, G. 1978. Early British Subsistence Strategy at Michilimackinac: An Analysis of Faunal Remains from the 1977 Season. In: Heldman, DP (ed.), Excavations at Fort Michilimackinac, 1977: House 1 of South Southeast Row House, 161–177. Archaeological Completion Report Series 2. Mackinac Island, MI: Mackinac Island State Park Commission.
Back to article
76Silver, IA. 1969. The Aging of Domestic Animals. In: Bothwell, D and Higgs, E (eds.), Science in Archaeology: A Survey of Progress and Research, 283–302. New York: Preager Publishers.
Back to article
77Sipe, CH. 1930. The Principle Indian Towns of Western Pennsylvania. Western Pennsylvania History, 13(2): 104–122.
Back to article
78Spittler, RS. 2014. A Geophysical Investigation: Locating the Native American Settlement at Fort Shirley. Unpublished thesis (MA), Indiana University of Pennsylvania.
Back to article
79Sullivan, T. 1997. From Redcoat to Rebel: The Thomas Sullivan Journal. In: Lee, J (ed.), Berwyn Heights, MD: Heritage Books.
Back to article
80Thomas, J. 1776. Map of Pennsylvania Exhibiting not on the Improved Parts of that Province, but also its Extensive Frontiers: Laid down from Actual Surveys, and Chiefly from the Late Map of W. Scull Published in 1770; and Humbly Inscribed to the Honorable Thomas Penn and Richard Penn Esquires True and Absolute Proprietaries & Governors of the Province of Pennsylvania and the Territories thereunto belonging. London: Sayer and Bennett.
Back to article
81Tokar, JR. 1999. Redcoat Resupply! Strategic Logistics and Operational Indecision in the American Revolutionary War, 1775–1783. Monograph on file, Fort Leavenworth, KS: School of Advanced Military Studies, United States Army Command and General Staff College.
Back to article
82Tourigny, ED. 2017. Eating Barrelled Meat in Upper Canada: Cultural and Archaeological Implications. International Journal of Historical Archaeology.
Back to article
83Volwiler, AT. 1926. George Croghan and the Westward Movement, 1741–1782. Cleveland: Arthur H. Clarke and Co.
Back to article
84Wainwright, ND. 1965. George Croghan: Wilderness Diplomat. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.
Back to article
85Webster, G. 1982. An Analysis of Faunal Materials from the Well at Fort Loudoun, Pennsylvania. Report on file at the State Museum of Pennsylvania.
Back to article

Roads and Military Provisioning During the French and Indian War (1754–1763): The Faunal Remains of Fort Shirley, PA in Context

Abstract

Paradigm

My account