Assessing Trust in Community Science Data From Multiple Perspectives to Understand System-Level Impacts
Abstract
Despite advancements in the field, generation of community science data exceeds its application. To better understand what shapes data use at a system level, we examine perceptions of data quality and trust in data usage from the perspectives of volunteers and professionals by leveraging a community wildlife monitoring program. We surveyed 486 volunteers on their perceptions of the data before and after participation. We next interviewed 6 volunteers, 4 scientists, and 4 policymakers to further investigate factors influencing trust in the data to support decision-making. Volunteer surveys showed positive shifts in perceived data quality after participation, but trust in use of the data for management decisions remained unchanged. Interviewed volunteers described positive perceptions of data quality, attributed to the “real” nature of photos, the scale of the project, and the reputation of the program. Volunteers viewed the data as a supplemental source for making management decisions but were not willing to rely on it as the sole source of information. Interestingly, interviews with professionals largely mirrored these themes as they described positive perceptions of data quality (attributed to scale and program design) and willingness to rely on the Snapshot Wisconsin project data as a supporting, but not primary, resource. Relevance of the data affected professionals’ willingness to rely on it (e.g., applying data from a generalist wildlife monitoring program to species-specific decisions). We provide a conceptual model for trust within this system and suggest opportunities to inform trust-building for other participatory science efforts.
© 2026 Christine Anhalt-Depies, Kyra Ricci Shaw, published by Ubiquity Press
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.