A Typology for Evaluating Community Science: From Aspirational Goals to Measurable Outcomes
Abstract
Community science efforts often address environmental issues affecting community well-being, particularly among economically disadvantaged populations. However, the lack of clear evaluation frameworks makes defining success of these efforts difficult. Combining an evaluative lens with practitioners’ perspectives, we developed a typology that describes success in concrete ways using measurable incremental outcomes for conceptual or long-term goals. We interviewed 12 experienced practitioners about goals and outcomes relevant to their projects. Using thematic and content analyses, we analyzed the interviews to draft our Goal-Outcome Typology, which we refined with practitioner feedback and SMART guidelines (specific, measurable, attainable, relevant, and timely). The final Typology consists of eight goals: (1) improved community identity, (2) enhanced community empowerment, (3) community efforts seen as credible, (4) established community governance structure, (5) increased community-level science literacy, (6) new or enforced policies or regulations, (7) improved quality of life in the community, and (8) expansion or replication of the community effort. Each goal includes example outcomes illustrated with a practice-based vignette. Practitioners can tailor the Typology for their own context, embed it within a logic model, and develop measures of their outcomes to understand and share the progress and impact of their efforts. Evaluating these measures can help refine project activities, recruit and retain members, acquire funding, and inform research on how community science achieves social and environmental change. Ultimately, the Typology addresses an important gap in providing resources that support community priorities while advancing evidence-based community science practice.
© 2026 Cathlyn Merritt Davis, Tina Phillips, Veronica Del Bianco, Jenna Linhart, Herizo Andrianandrasana, Clare Cannon, Kimberly Cooke, Jonathan London, Garima Raheja, Mónica Ramírez-Andreotta, Kristine Stepenuck, published by Ubiquity Press
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.