Have a personal or library account? Click to login

Nursing students’ knowledge of patient safety and development of competences over their academic years: Findings from a longitudinal study

Open Access
|Mar 2021

Figures & Tables

Diagram 1

Participant flow recruitment and inclusion.
Participant flow recruitment and inclusion.

PS knowledge acquired in the classroom and PS competence developed in the clinical settings as perceived by students (=90) over the years_

BNSc: general featuresPS knowledge developed in the classroom
Factors and items, mean, 95% CI1st year P*2nd year P**3rd year P***1st year P*2nd year P** 3rd year P***

Working in team4.1 (4.0-4.2)4.05 (3.93-4.18)4.02 (3.90-4.15)4.18 (4.07-4.29)4.11 (3.99-4.23) 4.22 (4.09-4.35)

1. Team dynamics and authority/ power differences4.13 (3.99-4.27)4.18 (4.04-4.31)4.13 (3.99-4.28)4.31 (4.18-4.44)4.31 (4.18-4.44) 4.40 (4.26-4.54)
2. Managing interprofessional conflicts4.10 (3.93-4.27)3.99 (3.82-4.16)3.88 (3.71-4.05)4.10 (3.94-4.26)4.02 (3.86-4.18) 4.13 (3.97-4.29)
3. Debriefing and supporting team members after an adverse event/close call4.16 (3.99-4.32)4.01 (3.82-4.20)3.91 (3.74-4.08)4.21 (4.04-4.38)4.06 (3.88-4.23) 4.22 (4.04-4.41)
4. Sharing authority, leadership, decision-making4.14 (3.99-4.28)4.16 (4.00-4.31)4.10 (3.97-4.23)4.13 (3.98-4.29)4.20 (4.06-4.34) 4.28 (4.13-4.43)
5. Encouraging team members to speak up, question, challenge, advocate, and be accountable as appropriate to address safety issues4.13 (3.97-4.30)4.08 (3.91-4.25)4.10 (3.97-4.28)4.24 (4.08-4.41)4.03 (3.85-4.21) 4.13 (3.95-4.32)

Communicating effectively4.38 (4.25- 4.51)4.33 (4.18-4.47)4.50 (4.27-4.72)4.43 (4.27-4.58)4.33 0.027 (4.21-4.45) 4.51 (4.38-4.64)

6. Enhancing PS through clear and consistent communication with patients4.42 (4.28-4.56)4.45 (4.31-4.59)4.44 (4.32-4.57)4.61 (4.48-4.73)4.43 (4.30-4.56) 4.52 (4.38-4.66)
7. Enhancing PS through effective communication with healthcare providers4.41 (4.28-4.54)4.38 (4.23-4.53)4.40 (4.27-4.53)4.45 (4.31-4.58)4.41 (4.29-4.54) 4.54 (4.41-4.68)
8. Effective verbal/nonverbal communication abilities to prevent adverse events4.43 (4.16-4.48)4.21 (4.06-4.37)4.66 (4.01-4.70)4.38 (4.22-4.54)4.22 (4.08-4.36) 4.48 (4.33-4.66)

Managing safety risk4.12 (3.98-4.25)4.19 (4.04-4.34)4.27 (4.15-4.38)4.18 (4.05-4.31)4.07 <0.01 (3.91-4.22) 4.38 <0.01 (4.26-4.51)

9. Recognizing routine situations in which safety problems may arise4.26 (4.12-4.39)4.32 (4.19-4.44)4.31 (4.18-4.44)4.36 (4.22-4.49)4.30 (4.16-4.44) 4.47 (4.33-4.60)
10. Identifying and implementing safety solutions4.15 (4.00-4.29)4.31 (4.20-4.43)4.28 (4.16-4.40)4.24 (4.10-4.37)4.10 (3.97-4.23) 4.36 (4.22-4.49)
11. Anticipating and managing high- risk situations4.06 (3.85-4.26)4.18 (4.04-4.32)4.22 (4.09-4.35)4.06 (3.8-4.26)4.02 (3.85-4.19) 4.34 (4.20-4.49)

Understanding human and environmental factors4.21 (4.10-4.33)4.18 (4.04-4.31)4.27 (4.13-4.40)4.36 (4.25-4.47)4.27 (4.16-4.38)<0.014.48 (4.36-4.60)

12. The role of human factors (fatigue) affecting PS4.20 (4.05-4.35)4.26 (4.09-4.42)4.27 (4.10-4.44)4.43 (4.30-4.56)4.49 (4.35-4.62) 4.41 (4.26-4.56)
13. Safe application of health technology4.12 (3.67-4.27)4.06 (3.89-4.22)4.19 (4.04-4.34)4.27 (4.10-4.44)4.09 (3.95-4.23) 4.46 (4.31-4.60)
14. The role of environmental factors, such as workflow, ergonomics, and resources, which effect PS4.33 (4.18-4.49)4.28 (4.15-4.40)4.36 (4.21-4.50)4.40 (4.24-4.56)4.26 (4.12-4.39) 4.41 (4.26-4.56)

Recognizing and responding to adverse events4.12 (4.00-4.24)4.16 (4.04-4.28)4.25 (4.13-4.37)4.19 (4.06-4.32)4.06 (3.95-4.18)<0.014.27 (4.13-4.41)

15. Recognizing an adverse event or close call4.16 (4.03-4.28)4.19 (4.06-4.32)4.32 (4.19-4.45)4.18 (4.03-4.33)4.16 (4.02-4.29) 4.33 (4.18-4.49)
16. Reducing harm by addressing immediate risks for patients and others involved4.16 (4.02-4.29)4.19 (4.03-4.35)4.27 (4.13-4.40)4.31 (4.17-4.46)4.08 (3.93-4.22) 4.35 (4.21-4.49)
17. Disclosing an adverse event to the patient4.12 (3.95-4.30)4.19 (4.04-4.34)4.12 (3.96-4.28)4.13 (3.96-4.31)4.08 (3.83-4.19) 4.17 (3.98-4.35)
18. Participating in timely event analysis, reflective practice, and planning in order to prevent recurrence4.07 (3.92-4.21)4.13 (3.99-4.28)4.30 (4.15-4.45)4.16 (3.99-4.32)4.03 (3.87-4.20) 4.29 (4.13-4.45)

Culture of safety4.24 (4.14-4.34)4.06 (3.86-4.25)4.26 (4.09-4.44)4.38 (4.28-4.47)4.06 (3.88-4.25)<0.014.38 (4.21-4.55)

19. The ways in which healthcare is complex and has many vulnerabilities4.08 (3.93-4.23)4.02 (3.86-4.19)4.19 (4.05-4.34)4.29 (4.13-4.45)4.07 (3.91-4.22) 4.36 (4.23-4.50)
20. Having a questioning attitude and speaking up when you see things that may be unsafe4.40 (4.26-4.54)4.36 (4.21-4.50)4.56 (4.43-4.68)4.50 (4.39-4.61)4.49 (4.37-4.62) 4.69 (4.58-4.80)
21. The importance of a supportive environment encouraging patients and providers to speak up when they have safety concerns4.29 (4.16-4.42)4.37 (4.21-4.52)4.38 (4.22-4.53)4.46 (4.33-4.59)4.30 (4.15-4.45) 4.51 (4.38-4.65)
22. Systems, system failures, and their role in adverse events4.20 (4.04-4.36)4.07 (3.91-4.23)4.33 (4.18-4.48)4.28 (4.11-4.44)3.98 (3.82-4.13) 4.36 (4.21-4.51)

Total4.19 (4.11-4.28)4.16 (4.06-4.26)4.26 (4.16-4.32)4.28 (4.20-4.37)4.15 (4.07-4.23)<0.014.37 (4.27-4.47)

How PS concepts are integrated and actualized in the nursing curriculum as perceived by students_

Items, mean (95% CI)1st year2nd year3rd yearp*p**p***
1. As a student, the scope of practice was very clear to me4.02 (3.88-4.17)4.15 (4.03-4.27)4.34 (4.22-4.46)-0.007<0.001
2. There is consistency in how PS issues were dealt with by different preceptors in the clinical setting3.94 (3.77-4.12)3.87 (3.70-4.05)4.13 (3.96-4.29)-0.005-
3. I had sufficient opportunity to learn and interact with members of interdisciplinary teams3.94 (3.78-4.11)4.16 (4.02-4.30)4.25 (4.13-4.38)0.019-<0.001
4. I gained a solid understanding that reporting adverse events and close calls can lead to changes and reduce the reoccurrence of such events4.22 (4.08-4.37)4.22 (4.08-4.37)4.30 (4.15-4.44)---
5. PS was well integrated into the overall program4.39 (4.26-4.52)4.43 (4.31-4.55)4.60 (4.48-4.72)-0.0210.007
6. Clinical aspects of PS (e.g., hand hygiene, transferring patients, medication safety) were well covered in our program4.37 (4.23-4.50)4.48 (4.36-4.61)4.60 (4.49-4.72)--0.002
7. “System” aspects of PS were well covered in our program4.01 (3.85-4.17)4.06 (3.90-4.21)4.30 (4.16-4.43)-0.0020.002

General and specific features on PS of the BNSs involved in the study

BNSc: general features
Admission and enrolmentA nationwide entry exam is mandatory for all BNSc candidates. Candidates must have at least 12 years of prior education to applying. The candidates-to-places ratios in the involved nursing program were 2.7 to 1.
Program duration180 university credits; 5,400 hours; 3 years.
Theoretical and practical clinical learning modelAccording to the block system model, 5 months/year are dedicated to lectures and 6 months/year to clinical training. One month/year is dedicated to a mandatory holiday.
LecturesApproximately 30 credits/year, 36–40 hours per week. It is compulsory for students to attend at least 70% of the scheduled lectures.
Clinical trainingApproximately 20 credits/year, 36 hours/ week. Attendance is mandatory for 100% of the scheduled hours of learning. These hours are as follows:
1. 1st year: 30 hours of skill labs and 480 hours of clinical training (two periods of practical experience in medical and surgical units);
2. 2nd year: 30 hours of skill labs and 600 hours of clinical training (three periods of practical experience in specialised medical and surgical units);
3. 3rd year: 30 hours of labs and 840 hours of clinical training (seven periods of practical experience in acute [intensive care, stroke unit], sub-acute [medical, surgical care], maternal and childcare and community care [mental health, nursing home, home care].
Number of examinationsTotal = 20 exams. Students may progress from one year to the next after having obtained positive results in the theoretical and practical examinations.
Final examinationThe BNSc ends with one exam consisting of a professional license and thesis discussion. The commission is composed of Faculty and members of the Nursing Board.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/sjph-2021-0017 | Journal eISSN: 1854-2476 | Journal ISSN: 0351-0026
Language: English
Page range: 114 - 123
Submitted on: Jun 17, 2020
Accepted on: Feb 3, 2021
Published on: Mar 18, 2021
Published by: National Institute of Public Health, Slovenia
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 4 issues per year

© 2021 Valentina Bressan, Giulia Causero, Simone Stevanin, Lucia Cadorin, Antonietta Zanini, Giampiera Bulfone, Alvisa Palese, published by National Institute of Public Health, Slovenia
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 3.0 License.