Have a personal or library account? Click to login
The COVID-19 Pandemic in Latin American and Caribbean countries: Gender Differentials in Labor Market Dynamics Cover

The COVID-19 Pandemic in Latin American and Caribbean countries: Gender Differentials in Labor Market Dynamics

Open Access
|Dec 2023

Figures & Tables

Figure 1

Female and Male employment rates and Gender Gap over Time.Source: PNADC for Brazil, ENE for Chile, ENCFT for the Dominican Republic, and ENOE and ENOE-N for Mexico.Note: Employment rates in percentage. The gender gap is calculated as the male minus the female employment rates and is expressed in percentage points.

Figure 2

Labor market transitions: Pre- and Post-Pandemic – Women.Note: Table reports the percentage of individuals in a given labor market state, given their labor market state one year earlier. The Post-pandemic period starting labor market state is 2020Q1. Pre-pandemic period starting labor market state are 2017Q1, 2018Q1, 2019Q1. We pool together different panels to compute the Pre-pandemic statistics.Source: For Brazil: PNADC, for Chile: ENE, for Dominican Republic: ENCFT, and for Mexico: ENOE and ENOE-N.

Figure 3

Labor market transition matrices Pre- and Post-Pandemic – Men.Note: Table reports the percentage of individuals in a given labor market state, given their labor market state one year earlier. The Post-pandemic period starting labor market state is 2020Q1. Pre-pandemic period starting labor market state are 2017Q1, 2018Q1, 2019Q1. We pool together different panels to compute the Pre-pandemic statistics.Source: For Brazil: PNADC, for Chile: ENE, for Dominican Republic: ENCFT, and for Mexico: ENOE and ENOE-N.

Figure 4

Labor Market Stocks.Note: LFP and Employment denote dependent variable =1 if, respectively, labor market participant and employed. Female denotes coefficients for the impact of being female (β2 in equation (1)); Female*Post denotes the differential impact of the pandemic for women with respect to men (β3 in equation (1)). Vertical lines denote 95% confidence intervals. A more complete set of results is available in Table C.3.

Figure 5

Labor Market Stocks by Quarter.Note:: LFP and Employment denote dependent variable =1 if, respectively, labor market participant and employed. Female denotes coefficients for the impact of being female (β2 in equation (B.1)); F*QKP denotes the differential impact of the pandemic for women with respect to men in pandemic quarter K (δk in equation (B.1)). Vertical lines denote 95% confidence intervals. A more complete set of results is available in Table C.4.

Figure 6

Labor Market Flows.Notes: Job loss and Job gain denote dependent variable = 1 if, respectively, workers lost their job or non-workers found a job, taking as initial condition the first quarter of each year. Female denotes coefficients for the impact of being female (β2 in equation (2)); Rτ ×Fi denotes the differential impact of the pandemic for women with respect to men (β3 in equation (2)). Vertical lines denote 95% confidence intervals. A more complete set of results is available in Table C.3.

Figure 7

Labor Market Flows by Quarter.Notes: Job loss and Job gain denote dependent variable =1 if, respectively, workers lost their job or non-workers found a job, taking as initial condition the first quarter of each year. Female denotes coefficients for the impact of being female; F*QKP denotes the differential impact of the pandemic for women with respect to men in pandemic quarter K. Vertical lines denote 95% confidence intervals. A more complete set of results is available in Table C.4.

Figure 8

Labor Market Stocks by Children Presence and Age.Notes: LFP and Employment denote dependent variable = 1 if, respectively, labor market participant and employed. Female denotes coefficients for the impact of being female with the corresponding age and presence of children with respect to men; Female*Post denotes the differential impact of the pandemic for women with the corresponding age and presence of children with respect to men. No Kids includes both women without children at home and women with children at home older than 17. Vertical lines denote 95% confidence intervals. A more complete set of results is available in Table C.5.

Figure 9

Labor Market Stocks by Children Presence and Age and Quarter.Notes: LFP and Employment denote dependent variable = 1 if, respectively, labor market participant and employed. Female denotes coefficients for the impact of being female with the corresponding age and presence of children with respect to men; F*QKP denotes the differential impact of the pandemic for women with the corresponding age and presence of children with respect to men in pandemic quarter K. No Kids includes both women without children at home and women with children at home older than 17. Vertical lines denote 95% confidence intervals. A more complete set of results is available in Table C.6

Figure 10

Labor Market Flows by Children Presence and Age.Notes: Job loss and Job gain denote dependent variable =1 if, respectively, workers lost their job or non-workers found a job, taking as initial condition the first quarter of each year. Female denotes coefficients for the impact of being female with the corresponding age and presence of children with respect to men; Female*Post denotes the differential impact of the pandemic for women with the corresponding age and presence of children with respect to men. No Kids includes both women without children at home and women with children at home older than 17. Vertical lines denote 95% confidence intervals. A more complete set of results is available in Table C.5.

Figure 11

Labor Market Flows by Children Presence and Age and Quarter.Notes:Job loss and Job gain denote dependent variable =1 if, respectively, workers lost their job or non-workers found a job, taking as initial condition the first quarter of each year. Female denotes coefficients for the impact of being female with the corresponding age and presence of children with respect to men; F*QKP denotes the differential impact of the pandemic for women with the corresponding age and presence of children with respect to men in pandemic quarter K. No Kids includes both women without children at home and women with children at home older than 17. Vertical lines denote 95% confidence intervals. A more complete set of results is available in Table C.6.

Figure 12

Labor Market Stocks by Education.Note: LFP and Employment denote dependent variable =1 if, respectively, labor market participant and employed. Female denotes coefficients for the impact of being female with the corresponding education level with respect to men; Female*Post denotes the differential impact of the pandemic for women with the corresponding education level with respect to men. Low denotes 0 to 8 years of education completed; Medium 9 to 13 years; and High 14 or more. Vertical lines denote 95% confidence intervals. A more complete set of results is available in Table C.7.

Figure 13

Labor Market Flows by Education.Note: Job loss and Job gain denote dependent variable =1 if, respectively, workers lost their job or non-workers found a job, taking as initial condition the first quarter of each year. Female denotes coefficients for the impact of being female with the corresponding education level with respect to men; Female*Post denotes the differential impact of the pandemic for women with the corresponding education level with respect to men. Low denotes 0 to 8 years of education completed; Medium 9 to 13 years; and High 14 or more. Vertical lines denote 95% confidence intervals. A more complete set of results is available in Table C.7.

Figure 14

Labor Market Stocks and Flows by Job TypeNote: Employment denotes dependent variable =1 if employed. Job loss and Job gain denote dependent variable = 1 if, respectively, workers lost their job or non-workers found a job, taking as initial condition the first quarter of each year. Female denotes coefficients for the impact of being female with a given job type with respect to men; Female*Post denotes the differential impact of the pandemic for women with a given job type with respect to men. Formal, Informal, Self-Employed denotes that the state of employment of reference is, respectively, in a formal job, an informal job or as self-employed. Vertical lines denote 95% confidence intervals. A more complete set of results is available in Table C.8.

Attrition rates in Brazil and Mexico

Panel IDPanelt1–t2t2–t3t3–t4t4–t5Average

Brazil
12017Q1–2018Q112%9%9%8%10%
22017Q2–2018Q212%10%8%10%10%
32017Q3–2018Q313%10%10%8%10%
42017Q4–2018Q412%10%8%8%10%
52018Q1–2019Q112%10%9%8%10%
62018Q2–2019Q213%10%9%8%10%
72018Q3–2019Q313%10%9%10%10%
82018Q4–2019Q413%10%12%10%11%
92019Q1–2020Q113%13%11%12%12%
102019Q2–2020Q216%13%14%16%15%
112019Q3–2020Q314%15%18%10%14%
122019Q4–2020Q419%20%11%9%15%
132020Q1–2021Q125%12%11%.16%

Mexico

12017Q1–2018Q17%6%4%4%5%
22017Q2–2018Q2
32017Q3–2018Q37%6%4%4%5%
42017Q4–2018Q47%5%4%3%5%
52018Q1–2019Q17%5%5%3%5%
62018Q2–2019Q2
72018Q3–2019Q37%5%3%3%5%
82018Q4–2019Q47%5%5%3%5%
92019Q1–2020Q17%6%4%3%5%
102019Q2–2020Q2
112019Q3–2020Q37%5%.48%20%
122019Q4–2020Q48%.49%18%25%
132020Q1–2021Q1.52%21%.36%

Stocks and Flows regressions: coefficient of interests

BrazilChileDom. Rep.Mexico




(1)(2)(1)(2)(1)(2)(1)(2)
Panel A. LFP
Female−0.188 (0.001)***−0.202 (0.001)***−0.208 (0.003)***−0.209 (0.003)***−0.236 (0.006)***−0.253 (0.006)***−0.316 (0.002)***−0.314 (0.002)***
Post−0.039 (0.002)***−0.049 (0.002)***−0.062 (0.005)***−0.053 (0.006)***−0.036 (0.005)***−0.032 (0.007)***−0.041 (0.003)***−0.043 (0.003)***
Female*Post−0.012 (0.003)***−0.013 (0.003)***−0.038 (0.008)***−0.036 (0.008)***−0.031 (0.009)***−0.032 (0.009)***0.003 (0.005)0.004 (0.005)
Observations1,184,2711,184,271221,542221,54263,48863,488674,409674,409
R−squared0.0530.1180.0700.1010.0960.1180.1360.163

Panel B. Employment
Female−0.193 (0.002)***−0.212 (0.001)***−0.202 (0.003)***−0.206 (0.003)***−0.255 (0.006)***−0.273 (0.007)***−0.306 (0.002)***−0.306 (0.002)***
Post−0.050 (0.002)***−0.067 (0.002)***−0.088 (0.006)***−0.077 (0.007)***−0.040 (0.005)***−0.046 (0.007)***−0.060 (0.003)***−0.060 (0.004)***
Female*Post−0.011 (0.004)***−0.012 (0.003)***−0.021 (0.009)**−0.019 (0.009)**−0.022 (0.010)**−0.022 (0.010)**0.015 (0.005)***0.015 (0.005)***
Observations1,184,2711,184,271221,542221,54263,48863,488674,409674,409
R−squared0.0470.1070.0570.0860.0970.1170.1190.143

Panel C. Job loss
Female0.033 (0.002)***0.051 (0.002)***0.039 (0.005)***0.038 (0.004)***0.049 (0.008)***0.054 (0.008)***0.141 (0.003)***0.136 (0.003)***
Post0.030 (0.003)***0.048 (0.005)***0.232 (0.012)***0.091 (0.025)***0.073 (0.007)***0.079 (0.016)***0.032 (0.004)***0.020 (0.006)***
Female*Post0.030 (0.004)***0.029 (0.004)***0.036 (0.017)**0.005 (0.012)0.038 (0.013)***0.035 (0.012)***−0.013 (0.007)*−0.011 (0.007)
Observations178,649178,64924,77024,77010,55010,55082,08782,087
R-squared0.0070.0790.0530.4570.0320.0700.0340.103

Panel D. Job gain
Female−0.178 (0.005)***−0.191 (0.004)***−0.220 (0.012)***−0.165 (0.011)***−0.261 (0.033)***−0.268 (0.033)***−0.278 (0.009)***−0.277 (0.009)***
Post−0.214 (0.007)***−0.180 (0.010)***−0.022 (0.028)−0.187 (0.035)***−0.114 (0.042)***−0.032 (0.060)−0.187 (0.018)***−0.189 (0.021)***
Female*Post0.060 (0.008)***0.061 (0.008)***−0.013 (0.032)0.050 (0.025)**0.025 (0.044)0.021 (0.043)0.084 (0.019)***0.086 (0.019)***
Observations73,56273,5629,9569,9563,0173,01729,00829,008
R-squared0.0560.1000.0390.3360.0660.1050.0460.064

Comparison of demographic characteristics between different samples

AllAll in panel + All who attritedAll in panel

WomenMenWomenMenWomenMen

(1)(2)(3)(4)(5)(6)
Brazil
Pre-pandemic period: 2017Q1 to 2020Q1
Age39.6139.2239.5239.1340.7240.33
Low educ level0.320.390.320.390.310.38
Medium educ level0.440.440.440.440.440.44
High educ level0.240.180.240.180.250.18
At least one kid 0–50.250.250.250.250.240.24
At least one kid 6–120.330.290.330.290.330.30
At least one kid 13–170.270.230.260.220.270.23
During-pandemic period: 2020Q2 to 2020Q4
Age39.7339.3839.6339.2940.6240.36
Low educ level0.290.360.300.370.260.33
Medium educ level0.450.450.440.440.450.45
High educ level0.260.190.260.190.290.22
At least one kid 0–50.250.240.250.240.230.23
At least one kid 6–120.330.290.330.280.330.29
At least one kid 13–170.260.220.250.210.260.22

Mexico

Pre-pandemic period: 2017Q1 to 2020Q1
Age39.3738.9939.3338.9240.0539.66
Low educ level0.170.170.170.160.160.16
Medium educ level0.540.530.540.530.550.54
High educ level0.290.310.290.310.280.29
At least one kid 0–50.300.290.300.290.290.28
At least one kid 6–120.410.360.400.360.410.37
At least one kid 13–170.320.280.320.280.330.30
During-pandemic period: 2020Q2 to 2020 Q4
Age39.5339.1439.3939.0640.0239.57
Low educ level0.150.160.150.150.150.15
Medium educ level0.550.540.550.540.560.54
High educ level0.300.310.300.310.290.30
At least one kid 0–50.290.270.290.280.280.26
At least one kid 6–120.400.350.400.350.400.36
At least one kid 13–170.320.270.310.270.320.28

Dominican Republic

Pre-pandemic period: 2017Q1 to 2020Q1
Age38.3038.02 40.1239.54
Low educ level0.320.40 0.330.43
Medium educ level0.410.43 0.410.41
High educ level0.270.17 0.260.16
At least one kid 0–50.370.32 0.330.30
At least one kid 6–120.450.34 0.470.35
At least one kid 13–170.350.26 0.380.28
During-pandemic period: 2020Q2 to 2020Q4
Age38.3638.09 39.9039.48
Low educ level0.290.39 0.310.42
Medium educ level0.440.45 0.430.43
High educ level0.270.17 0.260.15
At least one kid 0–50.350.31 0.350.31
At least one kid 6–120.430.32 0.470.35
At least one kid 13–170.320.23 0.360.27

Chile

Pre-pandemic period: 2017Q1 to 2020Q1
Age40.0739.63 41.7241.72
Low educ level0.180.20 0.240.27
Medium educ level0.460.46 0.460.46
High educ level0.360.34 0.310.27
At least one kid 0–50.300.26 0.280.24
At least one kid 6–120.390.31 0.390.31
At least one kid 13–170.290.23 0.300.23
During-pandemic period: 2020Q2 to 2020Q4
Age40.2139.65 41.9241.40
Low educ level0.170.18 0.170.18
Medium educ level0.460.46 0.460.45
High educ level0.380.36 0.370.37
At least one kid 0–50.290.25 0.240.22
At least one kid 6–120.390.31 0.380.33
At least one kid 13–170.290.22 0.310.23

Pre and During-Pandemic Labor market Transition Matrices for Women

Brazil

Pre-Pandemic period Final: During-Pandemic period Final:


FormalInformalSelf-empUnempOLFFormalInformalSelf-empUnempOLF

Initial:Formal0.820.060.020.040.06Initial:Formal0.800.030.010.050.10
Informal0.240.410.080.100.17Informal0.140.370.050.140.30
Self-emp0.080.070.610.060.19Self-emp0.040.030.560.070.29
Unemp0.170.140.090.250.35Unemp0.120.060.050.320.44
OLF0.050.070.090.110.69OLF0.030.030.050.080.81

Chile

Pre-Pandemic period Final: During-Pandemic period Final:


FormalInformalSelf-empUnempOLFFormalInformalSelf-empUnempOLF

Initial:Formal0.860.030.020.040.05Initial:Formal0.800.020.010.040.13
Informal0.250.350.140.080.18Informal0.140.100.120.150.49
Self-emp0.070.100.540.040.25Self-emp0.030.040.310.070.54
Unemp0.250.120.110.180.34Unemp0.140.060.050.170.58
OLF0.070.060.110.080.68OLF0.040.030.090.080.76

Dominican Republic

Pre-Pandemic period Final: During-Pandemic period Final:


FormalInformalSelf-empUnempOLFFormalInformalSelf-empUnempOLF

Initial:Formal0.910.030.020.020.03Initial:Formal0.860.020.010.030.08
Informal0.130.660.020.060.13Informal0.110.530.040.040.27
Self-emp0.030.030.790.020.13Self-emp0.030.050.640.010.26
Unemp0.130.160.080.160.47Unemp0.110.060.060.110.66
OLF0.040.080.110.070.70OLF0.020.050.080.040.82

Mexico

Pre-Pandemic period Final: During-Pandemic period Final:


FormalInformalSelf-empUnempOLFFormalInformalSelf-empUnempOLF

Initial:Formal0.770.090.020.020.10Initial:Formal0.770.060.020.030.12
Informal0.190.440.080.030.25Informal0.150.390.080.050.33
Self-emp0.050.130.430.020.37Self-emp0.040.100.420.030.42
Unemp0.230.180.080.100.41Unemp0.200.150.060.070.52
OLF0.060.110.120.040.67OLF0.060.070.090.030.74

Stocks and Flows regressions: coefficient of interests by pandemic quarters

BrazilChileDom. Rep.Mexico




(1)(2)(1)(2)(1)(2)(1)(2)
Panel A. LFP
Female*Q1P−0.007 (0.003)**−0.008 (0.003)***−0.033 (0.009)***−0.031 (0.009)***−0.028 (0.010)***−0.029 (0.010)***
Female*Q2P−0.019 (0.004)***−0.020 (0.004)***−0.045 (0.009)***−0.043 (0.009)***−0.041 (0.010)***−0.041 (0.010)***0.001 (0.006)0.001 (0.005)
Female*Q3P−0.011 (0.005)**−0.013 (0.004)***−0.036 (0.011)***−0.036 (0.010)***−0.023 (0.012)*−0.023 (0.012)*0.007 (0.007)0.008 (0.007)
Observations1,184,2711,184,271221,542221,54263,48863,488674,409674,409
R-squared0.0540.1180.0700.1010.0970.1180.1360.163

Panel B. Employment
Female*Q1P−0.002 (0.004)−0.003 (0.003)−0.019 (0.010)*−0.017 (0.010)*−0.007 (0.010)−0.008 (0.010)
Female*Q2P−0.018 (0.004)***−0.019 (0.004)***−0.019 (0.010)*−0.017 (0.010)*−0.032 (0.011)***−0.032 (0.011)***0.011 (0.006)*0.011 (0.006)*
Female*Q3P−0.017 (0.005)***−0.019 (0.005)***−0.027 (0.012)**−0.026 (0.011)**−0.032 (0.013)**−0.032 (0.013)**0.021 (0.007)***0.021 (0.007)***
Observations1,184,2711,184,271221,542221,54263,48863,488674,409674,409
R−squared0.0470.1070.0570.0860.0980.1170.1190.143

Panel C. Job loss
Female*Q1P0.022 (0.003)***0.022 (0.003)***0.038 (0.010)***0.036 (0.009)***0.034 (0.009)***0.032 (0.009)***
Female*Q2P0.019 (0.003)***0.018 (0.003)***−0.005 (0.007)−0.008 (0.007)0.015 (0.007)**0.013 (0.007)*0.064 (0.007)***0.065 (0.007)***
Female*Q3P−0.009 (0.002)***−0.009 (0.002)***−0.024 (0.006)***−0.027 (0.006)***−0.015 (0.006)**−0.017 (0.006)***−0.026 (0.007)***−0.025 (0.007)***
Observations411,231411,23180,11380,11324,91324,913148,678148,678
R−squared0.0080.0360.0200.0570.0270.0420.0230.050

Panel D. Job gain
Female*Q1P0.013 (0.005)**0.013 (0.005)**−0.012 (0.020)−0.012 (0.020)−0.077 (0.031)**−0.078 (0.031)**
Female*Q2P0.026 (0.006)***0.026 (0.006)***0.059 (0.017)***0.059 (0.017)***0.072 (0.026)***0.071 (0.025)***−0.083 (0.021)***−0.084 (0.021)***
Female*Q3P0.043 (0.006)***0.042 (0.006)***0.032 (0.019)*0.032 (0.019)*0.076 (0.027)***0.075 (0.026)***0.078 (0.021)***0.078 (0.021)***
Observations168,773168,77329,46329,4637,1977,19752,81852,818
R−squared0.0190.0490.0200.0630.0340.0490.0150.052

Stocks and Flows regressions: coefficient of interests by level of education

BrazilChileDom. Rep.Mexico




LowMediumHighLowMediumHighLowMediumHighLowMediumHigh




(1)(2)(3)(1)(2)(3)(1)(2)(3)(1)(2)(3)
Panel A. LFP
Female−0.285 (0.003)***−0.200 (0.002)***−0.068 (0.002)***−0.280 (0.011)***−0.278 (0.004)***−0.113 (0.004)***−0.303 (0.011)***−0.268 (0.009)***−0.121 (0.011)***−0.380 (0.004)***−0.372 (0.002)***−0.163 (0.003)***
Post−0.057 (0.004)***−0.043 (0.003)***−0.027 (0.004)***−0.077 (0.019)***−0.049 (0.008)***−0.044 (0.008)***−0.031 (0.009)***−0.035 (0.008)***−0.029 (0.013)**−0.050 (0.009)***−0.038 (0.004)***−0.042 (0.005)***
Female*Post−0.017 (0.006)***−0.030 (0.004)***−0.017 (0.005)***−0.054 (0.027)**−0.051 (0.012)***−0.029 (0.011)***−0.021 (0.016)−0.055 (0.014)***−0.009 (0.017)0.014 (0.014)−0.002 (0.007)−0.002 (0.009)
Observations 1,184,271 221,542 63,488 674,409
R−squared 0.127 0.111 0.125 0.176

Panel B. Employment
Female−0.280 (0.003)***−0.219 (0.002)***−0.081 (0.003)***−0.276 (0.011)***−0.272 (0.005)***−0.113 (0.005)***−0.321 (0.011)***−0.294 (0.010)***−0.131 (0.013)***−0.370 (0.005)***−0.364 (0.002)***−0.156 (0.003)***
Post−0.078 (0.004)***−0.063 (0.003)***−0.041 (0.004)***−0.127 (0.021)***−0.071 (0.009)***−0.066 (0.009)***−0.036 (0.009)***−0.060 (0.010)***−0.036 (0.015)**−0.074 (0.010)***−0.055 (0.005)***−0.058 (0.006)***
Female*Post−0.016 (0.007)**−0.031 (0.005)***−0.011 (0.006)*−0.010 (0.028)−0.041 (0.013)***−0.010 (0.013)−0.022 (0.016)−0.027 (0.015)*−0.015 (0.020)0.032 (0.015)**0.008 (0.007)0.010 (0.010)
Observations 1,184,271 221,542 63,488 674,409
R−squared 0.113 0.094 0.124 0.154

Panel C. Job loss
Female0.065 (0.004)***0.055 (0.003)***0.024 (0.003)***0.074 (0.016)***0.047 (0.006)***0.021 (0.006)***0.067 (0.015)***0.049 (0.012)***0.040 (0.014)***0.186 (0.009)***0.169 (0.004)***0.060 (0.004)***
Post0.053 (0.006)***0.048 (0.005)***0.039 (0.006)***0.226 (0.038)***0.071 (0.026)***0.082 (0.026)***0.063 (0.018)***0.093 (0.019)***0.079 (0.023)***0.029 (0.012)**0.022 (0.007)***0.012 (0.009)
Female*Post0.052 (0.009)***0.041 (0.006)***0.012 (0.006)**−0.088 (0.041)**0.056 (0.019)***−0.013 (0.016)0.039 (0.023)*0.060 (0.020)***−0.007 (0.023)−0.013 (0.020)−0.020 (0.009)**0.009 (0.011)
Observations 178,649 24,770 10,550 82,087
R-squared 0.080 0.459 0.072 0.107

Panel D. Job gain
Female−0.198 (0.006)***−0.210 (0.007)***−0.102 (0.013)***−0.081 (0.026)***−0.236 (0.016)***−0.117 (0.018)***−0.252 (0.050)***−0.293 (0.053)***−0.258 (0.077)***−0.191 (0.019)***−0.335 (0.013)***−0.250 (0.017)***
Post−0.158 (0.012)***−0.210 (0.014)***−0.173 (0.021)***−0.089 (0.058)−0.207 (0.044)***−0.217 (0.042)***−0.085 (0.073)0.063 (0.082)−0.079 (0.102)−0.186 (0.038)***−0.167 (0.028)***−0.233 (0.034)***
Female*Post0.051 (0.011)***0.086 (0.012)***0.035 (0.022)−0.042 (0.058)0.101 (0.039)***0.005 (0.038)0.070 (0.064)−0.092 (0.072)0.132 (0.099)0.076 (0.040)*0.061 (0.027)**0.141 (0.036)***
Observations 73,562 9,956 3,017 29,008
R-squared 0.102 0.340 0.112 0.066

Descriptive Statistics by Gender and Pandemic Period

BrazilChileDom. Rep.Mexico




WomenMenWomenMenWomenMenWomenMen
Pre-pandemic period
Demographics
Age40.1839.6940.9940.1239.5438.8239.9739.36
0–8 years of educ0.320.380.120.110.330.430.170.16
9–13 years of educ0.440.440.470.470.410.420.560.55
14+ years of educ0.250.180.410.420.260.150.280.29
At least one children 0–50.250.240.300.260.360.310.300.29
At least one children 6–120.330.300.380.300.480.360.420.38
At least one children 13–170.270.230.300.240.380.290.340.29
Employment
Employee formal0.410.500.470.660.340.400.350.58
Employee informal0.090.090.070.070.150.090.150.20
Self employed0.120.230.110.130.160.430.100.13
Unemployed0.080.070.050.060.040.020.020.03
OLF0.300.110.290.090.300.060.380.06

Observations476,332387,872103,13178,47715,45513,748227,556178,745
Individuals102,08583,15922,04116,7753,3332,96149,85139,169
Quarters4.674.664.684.684.644.644.564.56

Post-pandemic period
Demographics
Age40.1439.7641.1440.5639.8939.1240.0339.38
0–8 years of educ0.270.340.100.100.310.430.150.15
9–13 years of educ0.450.450.450.430.420.420.560.55
14+ years of educ0.280.210.450.460.270.150.290.30
At least one children 0–50.240.240.250.220.360.320.280.27
At least one children 6–120.330.290.390.330.460.360.400.36
At least one children 13–170.260.210.300.240.370.290.330.28
Employment
Employee formal0.400.500.450.670.340.400.350.56
Employee informal0.090.080.040.040.140.080.130.19
Self employed0.120.230.090.090.150.420.100.13
Unemployed0.080.070.060.070.040.020.020.04
OLF0.310.120.360.120.330.080.390.08

Observations175,873144,19423,84016,09418,28615,99945,15536,363
Individuals36,82930,2235,3433,6033,8773,39612,3029,935
Quarters4.784.774.464.474.724.713.673.66

Sample Size by Panels Periods and Countries

Panel IDPanel Period Observations

BrazilChileDom. Rep.Mexico
12017Q1–2017Q4Observations85,72824,0122,78449,496
Individuals21,4326,00369612,374
Quarters4444
22017Q2–2018Q2Observations104,56030,0103,465
Individuals20,9126,002693
Quarters555
32017Q3–2018Q3Observations104,16530,1753,64561,160
Individuals20,8336,03572912,232
Quarters5555
42017Q4–2018Q4Observations104,34530,4152,73063,725
Individuals20,8696,08354612,745
Quarters5555
52018Q1–2018Q4Observations85,08424,9603,02850,820
Individuals21,2716,24075712,705
Quarters4444
62018Q2–2019Q2Observations102,35025,9253,635
Individuals20,4705,185727
Quarters555
72018Q3–2019Q3Observations102,69510,2103,69564,010
Individuals20,5392,04273912,802
Quarters5555
82018Q4–2019Q4Observations98,0254,9852,96562,210
Individuals19,60599759312,442
Quarters5555
92019Q1–2019Q4Observations77,2529163,25654,880
Individuals19,31322981413,720
Quarters4444
102019Q2–2020Q2Observations87,2353,3656,325
Individuals17,4476731,265
Quarters555
112019Q3–2020Q3Observations88,2609,3658,76532,340
Individuals17,6521,8731,7538,085
Quarters5554
122019Q4–2020Q4Observations83,8008,02010,87526,888
Individuals16,7601,6042,1756,722
Quarters5554
132020Q1–2020Q4Observations60,77219,1848,32022,290
Individuals15,1934,7962,0807,430
Quarters4443

Stocks and Flows regressions: coefficient of interests by type of employment

BrazilChileDom. Rep.Mexico




Formal WEInformal WESEFormal WEInformal WESEFormal WEInformal WESEFormal WEInformal WESE




(1)(2)(3)(1)(2)(3)(1)(2)(3)(1)(2)(3)
Panel A. Employment
Female−0.006 (0.002)***0.070 (0.001)***−0.064 (0.002)***−0.056 (0.004)***0.031 (0.002)***0.026 (0.003)***−0.006 (0.010)0.177 (0.007)***−0.171 (0.009)***−0.073 (0.002)***0.044 (0.002)***0.030 (0.002)***
Post0.016 (0.003)***−0.007 (0.002)***−0.009 (0.003)***0.031 (0.006)***−0.011 (0.004)***−0.020 (0.006)***−0.019 (0.008)**−0.002 (0.007)0.021 (0.008)***−0.010 (0.005)**0.005 (0.004)0.005 (0.004)
Female*Post0.011 (0.004)**−0.012 (0.003)***0.001 (0.004)−0.005 (0.009)−0.012 (0.005)**0.017 (0.008)**0.028 (0.013)**−0.028 (0.010)***−0.000 (0.013)0.032 (0.007)***−0.031 (0.006)***−0.001 (0.006)
Observations836,760836,760836,760162,027162,027162,02748,52948,52948,529496,498496,498496,498
R-squared0.1000.0730.0420.0480.0230.0310.1540.0780.1260.1260.0870.031

Panel B. Job loss
Female0.028 (0.002)***0.065 (0.007)***0.105 (0.005)***0.019 (0.004)***0.062 (0.016)***0.112 (0.013)***0.015 (0.009)*0.128 (0.022)***0.102 (0.017)***0.071 (0.003)***0.201 (0.007)***0.297 (0.009)***
Post0.033 (0.005)***0.061 (0.011)***0.077 (0.007)***0.058 (0.025)**0.265 (0.044)***0.216 (0.035)***0.079 (0.018)***0.126 (0.030)***0.067 (0.018)***0.004 (0.006)0.057 (0.012)***0.038 (0.014)***
Female*Post0.023 (0.004)***0.087 (0.014)***0.018 (0.009)*0.009 (0.013)−0.048 (0.046)−0.038 (0.032)−0.001 (0.015)0.058 (0.037)0.057 (0.026)**0.001 (0.007)−0.017 (0.016)−0.054 (0.020)***
Observations178,649178,649178,64924,77024,77024,77010,55010,55010,55082,08782,08782,087
R-squared0.0820.0820.0820.4620.4620.4620.0810.0810.0810.1150.1150.115

Panel C. Job gain
Female−0.036 (0.007)***0.111 (0.007)***−0.075 (0.008)***−0.103 (0.022)***0.021 (0.020)0.082 (0.022)***−0.070 (0.043)0.249 (0.048)***−0.179 (0.056)***−0.078 (0.011)***−0.027 (0.012)**0.106 (0.012)***
Post0.024 (0.019)−0.006 (0.019)−0.018 (0.021)0.053 (0.057)−0.109 (0.045)**0.056 (0.056)−0.004 (0.070)−0.003 (0.095)0.007 (0.103)−0.008 (0.030)0.004 (0.032)0.003 (0.030)
Female*Post0.005 (0.018)−0.035 (0.019)*0.030 (0.020)−0.086 (0.066)0.034 (0.055)0.052 (0.067)0.023 (0.056)−0.198 (0.069)***0.175 (0.078)**0.018 (0.029)−0.012 (0.030)−0.006 (0.028)
Observations19,84419,84419,8442,5462,5462,54666766766710,54610,54610,546
R-squared0.0930.0540.0370.0530.0450.0690.1090.0770.0830.0890.0430.054

Stocks and Flows regressions: coefficient of interests by children age and presence_

BrazilChileDom. Rep.Mexico




No kids0−5 only6−17No kids0−5 only6−17No kids0–5 only6–17No kids0–5 only6–17




(1)(2)(3)(1)(2)(3)(1)(2)(3)(1)(2)(3)
Panel A. LFP
Female–0.145 (0.002)***–0.268 (0.003)***–0.240 (0.002)***–0.125 (0.005)***–0.264 (0.008)***–0.260 (0.004)***–0.209 (0.012)***–0.315 (0.017)***−0.264 (0.007)***−0.221 (0.003)***−0.365 (0.005)***−0.359 (0.002)***
Post−0.044 (0.003)***−0.045 (0.005)***−0.046 (0.003)***−0.079 (0.009)***−0.059 (0.013)***−0.058 (0.006)***−0.036 (0.009)***−0.027 (0.012)**−0.038 (0.006)***−0.054 (0.005)***−0.030 (0.007)***−0.030 (0.003)***
Female*Post−0.007 (0.005)−0.012 (0.009)−0.022 (0.004)***−0.017 (0.013)−0.016 (0.023)−0.058 (0.010)***0.002 (0.018)−0.075 (0.027)***−0.038 (0.011)***−0.000 (0.009)−0.005 (0.015)−0.004 (0.006)
Observations 1,184,271 221,542 63,488 674,409
R−squared 0.113 0.104 0.119 0.166

Panel B. Employment
Female−0.143 (0.002)***−0.291 (0.004)***−0.256 (0.002)***−0.114 (0.005)***−0.268 (0.009)***−0.261 (0.004)***−0.218 (0.013)***−0.338 (0.018)***−0.289 (0.008)***−0.205 (0.003)***−0.360 (0.005)***−0.355 (0.002)***
Post−0.056 (0.004)***−0.059 (0.006)***−0.059 (0.003)***−0.102 (0.010)***−0.091 (0.016)***−0.087 (0.008)***−0.038 (0.010)***−0.028 (0.015)*−0.045 (0.007)***−0.073 (0.006)***−0.053 (0.009)***−0.048 (0.004)***
Female*Post−0.009 (0.005)*−0.003 (0.010)−0.021 (0.005)***−0.010 (0.015)0.008 (0.025)−0.035 (0.012)***0.003 (0.019)−0.060 (0.029)**−0.026 (0.012)**0.011 (0.010)0.011 (0.016)0.006 (0.007)
Observations 1,184,271 221,542 63,488 674,409
R−squared 0.101 0.089 0.118 0.145

Panel C. Job loss
Female0.031 (0.003)***0.070 (0.005)***0.061 (0.003)***0.025 (0.008)***0.074 (0.015)***0.074 (0.007)***0.043 (0.016)***0.089 (0.025)***0.049 (0.010)***0.089 (0.005)***0.158 (0.009)***0.158 (0.004)***
Post0.028 (0.004)***0.040 (0.007)***0.035 (0.004)***0.249 (0.017)***0.279 (0.034)***0.224 (0.016)***0.082 (0.013)***0.087 (0.020)***0.068 (0.009)***0.034 (0.007)***0.031 (0.012)***0.026 (0.005)***
Female*Post0.027 (0.006)***0.013 (0.011)0.037 (0.006)***−0.007 (0.025)0.006 (0.047)0.054 (0.021)**0.021 (0.024)0.078 (0.041)*0.038 (0.015)**−0.001 (0.012)0.010 (0.021)−0.016 (0.009)*
Observations 178,649 24,770 10,550 82,087
R−squared 0.065 0.156 0.060 0.094

Panel D. Job gain
Female−0.126 (0.006)***−0.293 (0.016)***−0.247 (0.007)***−0.112 (0.019)***−0.320 (0.043)***−0.305 (0.019)***−0.230 (0.047)***−0.392 (0.099)***−0.297 (0.056)***−0.183 (0.013)***−0.393 (0.028)***−0.368 (0.014)***
Post−0.193 (0.009)***−0.223 (0.027)***−0.241 (0.012)***0.011 (0.037)0.066 (0.089)−0.086 (0.047)*−0.123 (0.055)**−0.088 (0.132)−0.112 (0.069)−0.196 (0.023)***−0.123 (0.062)**−0.184 (0.030)***
Female*Post0.053 (0.010)***0.069 (0.029)**0.073 (0.013)***−0.048 (0.046)−0.121 (0.100)0.051 (0.051)0.069 (0.063)−0.033 (0.139)0.019 (0.072)0.079 (0.027)***0.016 (0.065)0.088 (0.032)***
Observations 73,562 9,956 3,017 29,008
R-squared 0.076 0.059 0.083 0.058

Pre and During-Pandemic Labor market Transition Matrices for Men

Brazil

Pre-Pandemic period Final: During-Pandemic period Final:


FormalInformalSelf-empUnempOLFFormalInformalSelf-empUnempOLF

Initial:Formal0.830.040.050.040.04Initial:Formal0.830.030.040.050.06
Informal0.240.330.240.110.09Informal0.170.380.160.130.17
Self-emp0.100.100.660.070.07Self-emp0.070.050.650.090.15
Unemp0.210.150.230.230.18Unemp0.150.100.130.340.28
OLF0.080.070.130.140.59OLF0.050.050.080.120.70

Chile

Pre-Pandemic period Final: During-Pandemic period Final:


FormalInformalSelf-empUnempOLFFormalInformalSelf-empUnempOLF

Initial:Formal0.850.030.030.050.03Initial:Formal0.800.020.020.070.09
Informal0.310.300.190.090.11Informal0.250.130.140.160.31
Self-emp0.140.140.580.060.09Self-emp0.080.050.350.160.36
Unemp0.360.130.160.170.18Unemp0.270.040.090.190.40
OLF0.160.100.120.120.51OLF0.150.040.090.190.54

Dominican Republic

Pre-Pandemic period Final: During-Pandemic period Final:


FormalInformalSelf-empUnempOLFFormalInformalSelf-empUnempOLF

Initial:Formal0.910.020.030.030.02Initial:Formal0.820.050.040.030.07
Informal0.210.630.110.030.03Informal0.140.600.120.060.08
Self-emp0.030.040.870.020.04Self-emp0.030.020.830.020.10
Unemp0.180.150.360.150.16Unemp0.140.140.140.030.55
OLF0.050.060.290.050.55OLF0.040.070.200.060.63

Mexico

Pre-Pandemic period Final: During-Pandemic period Final:


FormalInformalSelf-empUnempOLFFormalInformalSelf-empUnempOLF

Initial:Formal0.800.100.030.030.03Initial:Formal0.800.090.030.040.05
Informal0.280.440.160.050.07Informal0.210.450.150.070.12
Self-emp0.120.260.490.040.09Self-emp0.100.210.470.060.17
Unemp0.320.250.140.110.17Unemp0.260.150.130.160.29
OLF0.130.170.140.100.46OLF0.100.140.110.080.56

Stocks and Flows regressions: coefficient of interests by pandemic quarters and children age and presence

BrazilChileDom. Rep.Mexico




No kids0–5 only6–17No kids0–5 only6–17No kids0–5 only6–17No kids0–5 only6–17




(1)(2)(3)(1)(2)(3)(1)(2)(3)(1)(2)(3)
Panel A. LFP
Female*Q1P−0.001 (0.005)−0.013 (0.009)−0.017 (0.005)***−0.018 (0.015)0.001 (0.028)−0.051 (0.012)***−0.001 (0.018)−0.077 (0.029)***−0.030 (0.012)**
Female*Q2P−0.017 (0.006)***−0.012 (0.011)−0.029 (0.005)***−0.019 (0.016)−0.028 (0.027)−0.063 (0.012)***0.003 (0.020)−0.069 (0.031)**−0.056 (0.012)***0.003 (0.010)−0.011 (0.017)−0.010 (0.007)
Female*Q3P−0.007 (0.007)−0.012 (0.013)−0.024 (0.006)***−0.013 (0.018)−0.026 (0.031)−0.061 (0.013)***0.006 (0.024)−0.079 (0.035)**−0.027 (0.015)*−0.005 (0.012)0.003 (0.020)0.005 (0.008)
Observations 1,184,271 221,542 63,488 674,409
R-squared 0.113 0.104 0.120 0.166

Panel B. Employment
Female*Q1P−0.001 (0.005)−0.001 (0.010)−0.010 (0.005)**−0.001 (0.016)0.060 (0.031)*−0.047 (0.013)***0.006 (0.019)−0.061 (0.029)**−0.002 (0.012)
Female*Q2P−0.016 (0.006)**−0.007 (0.012)−0.029 (0.006)***−0.009 (0.017)−0.014 (0.030)−0.025 (0.014)*0.007 (0.021)−0.054 (0.033)*−0.046 (0.014)***0.013 (0.010)0.001 (0.018)0.000 (0.007)
Female*Q3P−0.017 (0.008)**−0.001 (0.015)−0.031 (0.007)***−0.025 (0.019)−0.042 (0.034)−0.031 (0.015)**−0.008 (0.025)−0.067 (0.038)*−0.036 (0.016)**0.009 (0.012)0.028 (0.022)0.014 (0.009)
Observations 1,184,271 221,542 63,488 674,409
R-squared 0.101 0.089 0.118 0.146

Panel C. Job loss
Female*Q1P0.013 (0.004)***0.021 (0.008)**0.030 (0.004)***0.001 (0.015)0.022 (0.029)0.065 (0.013)***0.025 (0.017)0.082 (0.030)***0.029 (0.011)***
Female*Q2P0.022 (0.004)***−0.000 (0.008)0.021 (0.004)***−0.006 (0.011)0.004 (0.019)−0.011 (0.009)−0.002 (0.014)0.026 (0.026)0.021 (0.009)**0.042 (0.012)***0.086 (0.023)***0.078 (0.009)***
Female*Q3P−0.002 (0.004)−0.012 (0.007)*−0.014 (0.003)***−0.011 (0.010)−0.033 (0.015)**−0.037 (0.008)***−0.008 (0.011)−0.040 (0.019)**−0.020 (0.008)**−0.005 (0.013)−0.046 (0.020)**−0.033 (0.009)***
Observations 411,231 80,113 24,913 148,678
R-squared 0.031 0.054 0.039 0.044

Panel D. Job gain
Female*Q1P0.022 (0.007)***−0.015 (0.022)0.010 (0.010)0.001 (0.026)−0.015 (0.079)−0.022 (0.036)−0.084 (0.043)**−0.278 (0.115)**−0.034 (0.050)
Female*Q2P0.023 (0.007)***0.028 (0.022)0.034 (0.010)***0.025 (0.024)0.023 (0.078)0.120 (0.029)***0.104 (0.035)***0.218 (0.061)***0.030 (0.046)−0.055 (0.028)**−0.228 (0.074)***−0.103 (0.035)***
Female*Q3P0.022 (0.008)***0.084 (0.024)***0.061 (0.011)***−0.013 (0.023)−0.058 (0.100)0.095 (0.031)***0.115 (0.038)***0.013 (0.122)0.076 (0.044)*0.041 (0.030)0.181 (0.069)***0.107 (0.035)***
Observations 168,773 29,463 7,197 52,818
R-squared 0.026 0.026 0.043 0.019
Language: English
Submitted on: May 11, 2022
|
Published on: Dec 22, 2023
Published by: Sciendo
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 1 issue per year

© 2023 Mariana Viollaz, Mauricio Salazar-Saenz, Luca Flabbi, Monserrat Bustelo, Mariano Bosch, published by Sciendo
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.