Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Nursing students’ experiences with improving cultural competence through education and practices in rural Indonesia: a qualitative study† Cover

Nursing students’ experiences with improving cultural competence through education and practices in rural Indonesia: a qualitative study†

Open Access
|Mar 2025

Figures & Tables

Question guide list_

Question
  • Can you explain the situation related to the learning process to improve cultural competence while on campus, including teaching capacity, teaching curriculum forms, and related subjects?

  • Can you explain the situation related to the learning process to improve cultural competence in the clinic, including mentor capacity, forms of practice, and related courses?

  • How do you apply theory in your practice to improve your cultural competence?

  • What problem-solving strategies do you use if you experience obstacles during the learning process on campus and in the clinic?

  • What are your expectations regarding increasing cultural competence during learning?

  • Is there anything else you would like to say?

Main themes, subthemes, and examples of quotes from the experiences of nursing students while learning cultural competency on campuses and clinics in rural areas of Indonesia_

Themes and subthemesIllustrative quotes
Themes 1: Perceptions of cultural competence
Cultural competence includes awareness, sensitivity, knowledge, and skills related to culture“I consider that cultural competence is broad and can be related to how we are aware, sensitive, understand and we can show it to patients when providing nursing care” (P22)
Cultural competence is something that nurses need to have“When I am in clinical practice and meet different patients, I feel that cultural competence is necessary for a nurse” (P9)
How to learn to respect different cultures“The main thing about cultural competence is related to efforts to respect patients with different cultures” (P17)
Cultural competence is an important thing“Cultural competence is always important” (P16)
Themes 2: Learning cultural competence in the classroom
Some lessons support the improvement of cultural competence“While on campus, there were 3–4 courses which I felt were very supportive to increase our understanding of cultural competence” (P2)
Teaching on campus is going well“At our university, learning related to cultural competence goes very well and supports the learning process” (P21)
There are various ethnic groups in the class“Our class has many friends with various ethnicities, so it helps us to learn well about different cultures” (P27)
There are differences in perceptions among students regarding cultural competence learning“In discussions during lectures and practice, we often have different views about cultural competence” (P1)
Theme 3: Experience in a practical
Meet different cultures“Clinical practice allows us to meet patients from different cultures” (P18)
There is a conflicting culture in the practice field“Some cultures conflict with the care we provide, so we must communicate well (P20).”
Provide care that is culturally appropriate for the patient“Professionally, we try to provide care according to the patient’s culture” (P18)
Receiving violent threats“The patient and his family almost beat me because they misunderstood” (P11)
Theme 4: Expectations of learning related to cultural competence
Need to increase understanding of the patient’s cultural background“After meeting patients at the practice site, I feel the need to improve cultural competence so that I am better prepared for graduation” (P28)
Learn to negotiate with patients from different cultures“Ultimately, we need to learn to negotiate with patients of different cultures to reduce conflict” (P23)
Addition of learning related to culture in the practice field“In the practice area, there needs to be additional learning assistance about cultural competence; I feel it is very limited and only focuses on action” (P4)
Theme 5: Cultural learning barriers
The curriculum needs to provide sufficient opportunities to learn about the culture“After I was in clinical practice, I felt there was still a lack of cultural lessons, and our educational curriculum was very limited to support it” (P18)
Very diverse culture“Various cultures make us often confused about implementing culturally sensitive care for patients” (P7)
Low competency capacity of mentors“Our biggest challenge in clinical practice rests on the low competence of our clinical mentors so that the teaching received is not optimal” (P12)
Language difficulties“Patients who come from different cultures have different languages, and it is difficult for us to understand when communicating” (P6)

Characteristics of participants_

CharacteristicsFrequencyPercentage (%)
Gender
  Female1856
  Male1444
Age (years)
  15–191031
  20–241547
  25–29516
  30–3526
Type of education
  Diploma 3 in nursing1031
  Diploma 4 of nursing26
  Bachelor of nursing2063
Length of time in college
  2–3 years825
  4–6 years2475
Religion
  Catholic1031
  Muslim825
  Protestant928
  Hindu516
Origin culture
  Rote39
  Flores516
  Sumba39
  Timor413
  Alor39
  Jawa39
  Sulawesi39
  Papua39
  Timor Leste39
  Sabu26
Frequency of clinical practice in a year
  31547
  21031
  1722
Length of clinical practice in one practice period
  1–3 months39
  4–6 months1753
  7–10 months1238
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/fon-2025-0005 | Journal eISSN: 2544-8994 | Journal ISSN: 2097-5368
Language: English
Page range: 37 - 45
Submitted on: Sep 9, 2024
Accepted on: Sep 21, 2024
Published on: Mar 14, 2025
Published by: Shanxi Medical Periodical Press
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 4 issues per year

© 2025 Petrus Kanisius Siga Tage, Fepyani Thresna Feoh, Maria Yasintha Goa, Angela Muryanti Gatum, Herliana Monika Azi Djogo, Erna Febriyanti, published by Shanxi Medical Periodical Press
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.