Criminal Liability Nuances of Medical Negligence During the COVID-19 Pandemic

Pranka, Darius

doi:10.2478/bjlp-2022-0006

Abstract

Under normal circumstances, the medical negligence of doctors in most European (continental) states is assessed within the limits of criminal liability under the criminal laws of each state, without exception in the case of COVID-19 or another pandemic. The author raises the question of whether doctors, in the performance of their duties and in the provision of treatment services during the COVID-19 pandemic, deserve any relief from their liability due to errors or negligence in the performance of their duties that have resulted in the consequences of damage to health or life loss of patients. The article provides an analysis of the special laws created for such situations and adopted in Poland and Italy while presenting the shortcomings and advantages of such legal regulation and distinguishing the discussion issues raised by legal scholars and practitioners of the abovementioned states. The author criticises the attempt to adopt a similar legal act in Lithuania and at the same time proposes to discuss the possibility of changing the existing legal regulation and setting limits on the criminal liability of doctors during the COVID-19 pandemic.

References

1. Bednarek, Katarzyna. “Good Samaritan Clause.” Vox Medici No. 1/247 (2021): 6–7.
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
2. Close, Eliana, Simon Young, Tina Cockburn, et al. “Legal Challenges to ISU Triage Decisions in the Covid-19 Pandemic: How Effectively Does the Law Regulate Bedside Rationing Decisions in Australia?” UNSW Law Journal Vol. 44(1) (2021).10.53637/FSJG1698
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
3. Cioffi, Andrea, and Raffaella Rinaldi. “Covid-19 and Medical Liability: A Delicate Balance.” Medico-Legal Journal 1-2 (2020) //DOI: 10.1177/0025817220935879.
Open DOI Search in Google Scholar Back to article
4. d’Alojaa, Ernesto, Gabriele Fincob, Roberto Demontisa, et al. “COVID-19 and Medical Liability: Italy Denies the Shield to its Heroes.” EClinicalMedicine 25 (2020) // DOI: 10.1016/j.eclinm.2020.100470.
Open DOI Search in Google Scholar Back to article
5. Kociemba, Alicja. “Releasing Medical Personnel from Criminal Liability for Medical Errors Committed during the Fight against COVID-19” // https://legalis.pl/zwolnienie-personelu-medycznego-z-odpowiedzialnosci-karnej-za-bledy-medyczne-popelnione-podczas-walki-z-covid-19/.
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
6. Kwiatkowska, Monika. “Liability for a Medical Error during an Epidemic, Good Samaritan Clause.” LEX/el. (2020).
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
7. Labanauskas, Liutauras, Viktoras Justickis, and Aistė Sivakovaitė. “Feasibility of law. The Current Medical Liability Increase Trend.” Social Sciences Studies 4(8) (2010): 89–107.
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
8. Napoli, Pietro Emanuele, Matteo Nioi, Ernesto d’Aloja, and Maurizio Fossarello. “Safety Recommendations and Medical Liability in Ocular Surgery during the COVID-19 Pandemic: An Unsolved Dilemma.” Journal of Clinical Medicine Vol. 9 (5) (2020) // DOI: 10.3390/jcm9051403.
Open DOI Search in Google Scholar Back to article
9. Oliva, Antonio, et al. “Liability of Health Care Professionals and Institutions during COVID-19 Pandemic in Italy: Symposium Proceedings and Position Statement.” J Patient Saf 16 (2020): e299–e302.10.1097/PTS.0000000000000793
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
10. Parisi, G. Saverio, Guido Viel, Rossana Cecchi, and Massimo Montisci. “COVID-19: The Wrong Target for Healthcare Liability Claims.” Legal Medicine 46 (2020) // DOI: 10.1016/j.legalmed.2020.101718.
Open DOI Search in Google Scholar Back to article
11. Plebanek, Ewa. “Exclusion of Criminal Liability for Medical Malpractice during the COVID-19 Pandemic.” Palestra 1-2 (2021).
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
12. Potulski, Jacek. “The Polish Model of the ‘Good Samaritan Clause’ – a Criminal Law Perspective.” Studia Prawnicze Vol. 3 (87) (2021).
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
13. Pranka, Darius. “The Price of Medical Negligence – Should it Be Judged by the Criminal Court in the Context of the Jurisprudence of the European Court of Human Rights?” Baltic Journal of Law & Politics Vol. 14, No. 1 (2021): 124–152 // DOI: 10.2478/bjlp-2021-0006.
Open DOI Search in Google Scholar Back to article
14. Ricci, Giovanna, Graziano Pallotta, Ascanio Sirignano, Francesco Amenta, and Giulio Nittari. “Consequences of COVID-19 Outbreak in Italy: Medical Responsibilities and Governmental Measures.” Front. Public Health Vol. 8 (2020) // DOI: 10.3389/fpubh.2020.588852.
Open DOI Search in Google Scholar Back to article
15. Ricci, Marco, and Gallina Pasquale. “COVID-19—Immunity from Prosecution for Physicians Forced to Allocate Scarce Resources: The Italian Perspective.” Critical Care 24:295 (2020).10.1186/s13054-020-03028-9
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
16. Romańczuk-Grącka, Marta. “Conflicts of Doctor’s Duties in the Case of an Extreme Shortage of Intensive Care Beds and the Good Samaritan Clause from the Perspective of Criminal Law.” Bialystok Legal Studies Vol. 26, No. 6 (2021) // DOI: 10.15290/bsp.2021.26.06.10.
Open DOI Search in Google Scholar Back to article
17. Stauch, Marc. The Law of Medical Negligence in England and Germany. A Comparative Analysis. Oxford and Portland, Oregon: Hart Publishing, 2008.
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
18. Tomczak, Maria. “Exclusion of Criminal Liability for Medical Error during the COVID-19 Pandemic.” Kortowski Przegląd Prawniczy No. 3 (2021) // DOI: 10.31648/kpp.7116.
Open DOI Search in Google Scholar Back to article
19. Tozzo, Pamela, Caterina Politi, Andrea Gabbin, and Luciana Caenazzo. “To Take Care of Those on the Front Line against COVID-19: Is it Possible to Limit Medical Liability?” Sci Justice 60(4) (2020): 311–312 // DOI: 10.1016/j.scijus.2020.05.001.
Open DOI Search in Google Scholar Back to article
20. Trabucco, Fabio Ratto. “The COVID -19 Post – Lockdown Italian Scenario from an Eco – Socio – Legal Perspective.” Bialystok Legal Studies Vol. 25, No. 3 (2020): 99–116.10.15290/bsp.2020.25.03.07
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
21. Zawiejski, Piotr. “The so-called Good Samaritan Clause” [Medical Law System. Volume III. Legal Liability in Connection with Medical Activities]. LEX/el. (2020).
Search in Google Scholar Back to article

Criminal Liability Nuances of Medical Negligence During the COVID-19 Pandemic

Abstract

Paradigm

My account