Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Reliability of CSRS-PPP for Validating the Egyptian Geodetic Cors Networks Cover

Reliability of CSRS-PPP for Validating the Egyptian Geodetic Cors Networks

By: Ashraf Abdallah and  Tarek Agag  
Open Access
|Apr 2022

Figures & Tables

Figure 1.

Layout of ESA-CORS and HARN stations
Layout of ESA-CORS and HARN stations

Figure 2.

Design of global constrained network solution ©Google Earth: (a) ESA-CORS, (b) IGS-CORS
Design of global constrained network solution ©Google Earth: (a) ESA-CORS, (b) IGS-CORS

Figure 3.

Network solution
Network solution

Figure 4.

Processing schedule
Processing schedule

Figure 5.

Dual PPP errors for ESA-CORS: (a) for DOY 201, (b) for DOY 202, and (c) for DOY 203 (static mode)
Dual PPP errors for ESA-CORS: (a) for DOY 201, (b) for DOY 202, and (c) for DOY 203 (static mode)

Figure 6.

Dual PPP errors for ESA-CORS stations (epoch-wise mode)
Dual PPP errors for ESA-CORS stations (epoch-wise mode)

Figure 7.

Dual PPP errors for IGS-CORS: (a) for DOY 201, (b) for DOY 202, and (c) for DOY 203 (static mode)
Dual PPP errors for IGS-CORS: (a) for DOY 201, (b) for DOY 202, and (c) for DOY 203 (static mode)

Figure 8.

Dual PPP errors for IGS-CORS stations (epoch-wise mode)
Dual PPP errors for IGS-CORS stations (epoch-wise mode)

List of CORS

Station IDLatitudeLongitudeHStation IDLatitudeLongitudeH
ADFON24°58′46.241″E32°52′49.913″105.97QANAN26°09′22.293″E32°43′18.173″101.20
ADWHN28°41′41.549″E30°46′01.677″64.61QANTN30°51′27.105″E32°18′36.257″34.11
ASHMN30°17′40.001″E30°59′04.720″39.67RMDNN30°17′26.508″E31°44′23.437″149.50
AYATN29°37′06.841″E31°15′22.315″58.82RSHDN31°24′19.102″E30°25′17.957″36.85
BADRN30°34′57.049″E30°42′37.032″47.94SDATN30°22′31.934″E30°29′34.676″71.50
BLTMN31°33′11.924″E31°05′40.480″30.37SHKHN31°06′24.609″E30°56′26.923″30.55
BNHAN30°28′15.304″E31°10′45.118″46.02SMLTN28°18′38.917″E30°42′39.376″71.19
CARON30°01′55.725″E31°12′55.058″75.57SUEFN29°04′53.755″E31°05′30.069″60.47
DMNHN31°02′27.912″E30°27′57.358″41.63SUZEN29°59′18.836″E32°31′19.498″47.13
ETSAN29°14′15.413″E30°47′49.999″41.64TANTN30°47′36.413″E30°59′35.224″40.81
HMOLN31°18′35.684″E31°09′02.195″44.08THATN26°46′09.649″E31°29′50.601″87.69
ISMLN30°36′15.307″E32°18′00.940″43.27TSHTN26°07′06.090″E32°05′40.335″88.37
ISNAN25°17′20.274″E32°33′28.518″102.49WAKFN26°03′41.760″E32°25′52.706″109.83
KBERN30°43′56.659″E31°40′21.508″33.15DYNGN38°04′42.788″E23°55′56.765″510.56
LXORN25°42′29.159″E32°39′09.500″110.58NICON35°08′27.558″E33°23′47.216″190.02
MNSHN26°29′00.621″E31°47′39.230″96.24NKLGN00°21′14.072″E09°40′19.660″31.49
MNZLN31°09′36.216″E31°56′04.274″36.95NOT1N36°52′33.049″E14°59′23.246″126.35
MOUSN27°38′36.827″E30°51′27.876″82.44RAMON30°35′51.388″E34°45′47.314″886.84
MTMRN30°54′45.358″E30°09′31.184″33.16YKRON06°52′14.023″W05°14′24.327″270.26

Statistics of continuous lack of observation data for ESA-CORS

Station IDDOY 201DOY 202DOY 203Station IDDOY 201DOY 202DOY 203
ADFO4 h--QANA9 h9 h9 h
ADWH1 h--QANT1 h--
BLTM6 h12 h8 hRMDN3 h--
DMNH13 h6 h5 hTHAT1 h--
ISNA2 h--TSHT8 h--
KBER16 h16 h16 hWAKF22 h--
MNSH1 h--

Statistics of static-PPP solution for ESA-CORS in millimeters

DOY201DOY202DOY203Overall mean values
ENhENhENhENh
Max.20.015.044.010.015.048.09.010.048.013.013.346.7
μ6.54.218.56.04.617.44.34.217.65.64.317.8
Min.0.01.00.01.00.00.00.00.00.00.30.30.0
RMSE7.75.622.36.45.822.74.85.022.26.35.522.4
SD4.23.812.82.33.614.82.13.813.72.93.713.8
SD95%2.11.85.82.01.86.31.91.87.02.01.86.4

List of available PPP software and free online services

Software packageProvider
PPP software packagegLABResearch group of Astronomy and Geomatics (gAGE) from the Universitat Politecnica de Catalunya (UPC) (Sanz et al. 2012)
Net_DiffGNSS Analysis Center, Shanghai Astronomical Observatory, Chinese Academy of Sciences (https://github.com/YizeZhang/Net_Diff)
PRIDE PPP-ARGNSS Research Center of Wuhan University, China (https://geodesy.noaa.gov/gps-toolbox/PRIDE.htm)
GAMPResearch group at the German Research Centre for Geosciences GFZ (Zhou et al. 2018)
Bernese GNSS V. 5.2Astronomical Institute of the University of Bern (AIUB), Switzerland (Dach & Walser 2015)
GIPSY-OASIS IIJet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL), California Institute of Technology, USA (https://gipsy-oasis.jpl.nasa.gov/index.php?page=software)
RTKLIBTomoja Takasu at Tokyo University Marine Science and Technology, Japan (http://www.rtklib.com/)
NAPEOSEuropean Space Agency (http://www.esa.int/Enabling_Support/Operations/NAPEOS)
GAMIT/GLOBKDepartment of Earth, Atmospheric, and Planetary Sciences at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) (http://geoweb.mit.edu/gg/)
PPP free online serviceCSRS-PPPCanadian Geodetic Survey (CGS) (https://webapp.geod.nrcan.gc.ca/geod/tools-outils/ppp.php)
APPS-PPPJet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL), California Institute of Technology, USA (http://apps.gdgps.net/)
GAPS-PPPGNSS Analysis and Positioning Software, Department of Geodesy and Geomatics Engineering University of New Brunswick (http://gaps.gge.unb.ca/)
magicGNSSGMV Aerospace and Defence S.A., Spain (https://magicgnss.gmv.com/)

Statistics of static-PPP solution for IGS-CORS in millimeters

DOY201DOY202DOY203Mean
ENhENhENhENh
Max.3.03.08.02.02.012.04.02.05.03.02.38.3
μ1.31.23.31.01.35.51.21.23.01.21.23.9
Min.0.00.00.00.00.01.00.01.02.00.00.31.0
RMSE1.71.64.51.31.56.71.81.23.21.61.44.8
SD1.21.23.30.90.84.21.51.21.31.21.12.9
SD95%1.00.81.00.90.81.00.50.81.30.80.81.1

CSRS-PPP processing parameters

ItemProcessing parameter
GNSS systemGPS and GLONASS
Reference systemITRF2014 (epoch 2019)
Coordinate formatXYZ/Ellipsoidal/UTM
Satellite orbit and clock ephemerisIGS final (Orbit: 15-minute interval & clock: 30-second interval)
Satellite phase center offsetsIGS-ANTEX (NGS 2021)
Receiver phase center offsetsIGS-ANTEX (NGS 2021)
Elevation angle7.5°
Sampling rate30 s
Ionospheric modelLinear ionosphere-free combination + second-order parameters
Tropospheric model

Dry: Davis (GPT) (Sakurai 1985; Kouba 2009)

Wet: Hopfield model (GPT) (Hopfield 1969; Kouba 2009)

VMF1 (Böhm & Schuh 2004)

SoftwareCSRS-PPP
Observation dataSingle/dual frequency and static/kinematic
Data transferEmail
Ocean tide loadingFES 2004 (Le Provost & Lyard 1997)
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/arsa-2022-0004 | Journal eISSN: 2083-6104 | Journal ISSN: 1509-3859
Language: English
Page range: 58 - 76
Submitted on: Oct 21, 2020
Accepted on: Mar 4, 2022
Published on: Apr 22, 2022
Published by: Polish Academy of Sciences, Space Research Centre
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 4 issues per year

© 2022 Ashraf Abdallah, Tarek Agag, published by Polish Academy of Sciences, Space Research Centre
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.