Carrots and Sticks as Incentive Mechanisms for the Optimal Initiation of Insolvency Proceedings

Cepec, Jaka; Kovac, Mitja

doi:10.1515/danb-2016-0005

Abstract

The pursuit of ex-ante efficiency in bankruptcy law has been widely discussed in recent law and economics literature. However, the exact incentive mechanisms inducing the optimal commencement of bankruptcy proceedings have generally been exempted from the current scholarly debate. Using the law and economics tools and comparative analysis, this paper seeks to identify insolvency-specific optimal incentive mechanisms, while using the general theory on carrots and sticks in legal regulations. The paper suggests the employment of mixed-sticks-and-carrots incentive mechanisms for managers’ prompt proposals of insolvency proceedings as an optimal regulatory response. Moreover, the article provides comparative evidence that exclusive use of sticks or carrots in French, German, US, English, and Slovenian legal systems results in sub-optimal initiation of insolvency proceedings and may also induce adverse effects on prompt initiation.

References

Adler, B. E., Capkun, V., Weiss, L.A. (2006). Theory and Evidence on the Bankruptcy Initiation Problem. American Law & Economics Association Annual Meetings, Paper 53.
Search in Google Scholar
Adler, B. E., Capkun V., Weiss, L.A. (2013). Value Destruction in the New Era of Chapter 11. The Journal of Law, Economics & Organization, 29(2), 461–483.10.1093/jleo/ewr004
Search in Google Scholar
Armour, J. (2001). The Law and Economics of Corporate Insolvency: A Review. ESRC Centre for Business Research, University of Cambridge Working paper, 197.
Search in Google Scholar
Baird, D. G., Jackson, T. H. (1984). Possession and Ownership: An Examination of the Scope of Article 9. Stanford Law Review, 35, 175–212.10.2307/1228662
Search in Google Scholar
Baird, D. G. (1991). The Initiation Problem in Bankruptcy. International Review of Law & Economics, 11(2), 223–232.10.1016/0144-8188(91)90020-E
Search in Google Scholar
Baird, D. G. (1996). A World without Bankruptcy. In Bhandari, J. S., Weiss, L.A. (Ed.). Corporate Insolvency, Economic and legal Perspectives. Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9780511609435.008
Search in Google Scholar
Bebchuk, L.A. (2002). Ex ante Costs of Violating Absolute Priority in Bankruptcy. Journal of Finance, 57(1), 445–460.10.1111/1540-6261.00427
Search in Google Scholar
Bharath, S. T., Panchapakesan V., Werner I. (2007). The Changing Nature of Chapter 11. Working Paper, University of Michigan.
Search in Google Scholar
Bowers, J.W., Whither. (1992). What Hits the Fan? Murphy’s Law, Bankruptcy Theory, and the Elementary Economics of Loss Distribution. Georgia Law Review, 1, 27–84.
Search in Google Scholar
Cabrillo, F., Depoorter, B.W. (2000). Bankruptcy Proceedings. In Bouckaert, B., De Geest, G. (Ed.). Encyclopedia Of Law & Economics. Cheltenham, Northampton: Edward Elgar and The University Of Ghent.
Search in Google Scholar
Cepec, J. (2014). Pravno ekonomska analiza insolvenčnih postopkov. Doctoral thesis, Universtity of Ljubljana, Faculty of Law.
Search in Google Scholar
Cepec, J. (2013). Zakaj potrebujemo insolvenčno pravo?: perspektiva ekonomske analize prava. Lexonomica, 5(2), 163–178.
Search in Google Scholar
Coase, R. H. (1960). The Problem of Social Cost. Journal of Law and Economics, 3, 1–70.10.1086/466560
Search in Google Scholar
Cooter, R., Ulen T. (2004). Law and Economics (4th ed.). Boston: Pearson.
Search in Google Scholar
De Geest, G., Dari-Mattiacci, G. (2010). Carrots, Sticks, and the Multiplication Effect. The Journal of Law, Economics & Organization, 26(2), 365–384.10.1093/jleo/ewn026
Search in Google Scholar
De Geest, G., Dari-Mattiacci, G. (2013). The rise of carrots and the decline of sticks. University of Chicago Law Review, 80, 341–392.
Search in Google Scholar
Eidenmüller, H. (2006). Trading in Times of Crisis: Formal Insolvency Proceedings, Workouts and the Incentives for Shareholders/Managers. European Business Organization Law Review, 7(1), 239–258.10.1017/S1566752906002394
Search in Google Scholar
Euler Hermes Kreditversicherungs-AG. (2006). Zentrum für Insolvenz Universität Mannheim, Ursachen von Insolvenzen Gründe für Unternehmensinsolvenzen aus der sicht Von Insolvenzverwaltern. Wirtschaft Konkret Nr. 414.
Search in Google Scholar
Frouté, P. (2007). Theoretical Foundation for a Debtor Friendly Bankruptcy Law in Favour of Creditors. European Journal of Law and Economics, 24(3), 201–214.10.1007/s10657-007-9033-7
Search in Google Scholar
Finch, V. (2009). Corporate Insolvency Law, Perspectives and Principles (Second Edition). Cambridge: University Press.10.1017/CBO9781139175395
Search in Google Scholar
Goode, R. (2011). Principles of Corporate Insolvency Law. London: Sweet & Maxwell.
Search in Google Scholar
Hart, O. (1999). Different Approaches to Bankruptcy. Harvard Institute of Economic Research Paper No. 1903.
Search in Google Scholar
Henderson, M. T. (2007). Paying CEOs in Bankruptcy: Executive Compensation when Agency Costs are Low. Northwestern University Law Review, 101(1), 1543–1619.
Search in Google Scholar
International Monetary Fund. (1999). Orderly & Effective Insolvency Procedures, Key Issues. Legal Department, International Monetary Fund.
Search in Google Scholar
Jackson, T. H. (1982). Bankruptcy, Non-Bankruptcy Entitlements and the Creditors’ Bargain. Yale Law Journal, 91(5), 857–907.10.2307/796070
Search in Google Scholar
Jackson, T. H. (1985). Translating Assets and Liabilities to the Bankruptcy Forum. Journal of Legal Studies, 14(1), 73–114.10.1086/467766
Search in Google Scholar
Jackson, T. H. (2001). The logic and limits of Bankruptcy law. Washington D.C.: Beard Books.
Search in Google Scholar
Kennedy, D. S., Bailey, J. S., Clift, R. S. (2000). The Involuntary Bankruptcy Process: A Study of the Relevant Statutory and Procedural Provisions and Related Matters. University of Memphis Law Review, 31, 3–59.
Search in Google Scholar
Kramer, R., Peter, F. K. (2012). Insolvenzrecht, Grundkurs für Wirtschaftswissenschaftler. Wiesbaden: Gabler Verlag, Springer Fachmedien.10.1007/978-3-658-00026-4
Search in Google Scholar
Lazear, P. E. (1995). Personnel Economics. Boston: MIT Press Books.
Search in Google Scholar
Listokin, Y. (2007). Paying for Performance in Bankruptcy: Why CEOs should be compensated with debt. University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 155(4), 777–832.
Search in Google Scholar
Madaus, S. (2013). Reconsidering the Shareholder’s Role in Corporate Reorganisations under Insolvency Law. International Insolvency Review, 22, 106–117.10.1002/iir.1209
Search in Google Scholar
Marinč, M., Vlahu, R. (2011). The Economics of Bank Bankruptcy Law. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer.
Search in Google Scholar
Martin, N. (2005). The Role of History and Culture in Developing Bankruptcy and Insolvency Systems: The Perils of Legal Transplantation. Boston College International and Comparative Law Review, 28(1), 1–77.
Search in Google Scholar
McCormack, G. (2007). Control and Corporate Rescue: An Anglo-American Evaluation. The International and Comparative Law Quarterly, 56(3), 515–551.10.1093/iclq/lei181
Search in Google Scholar
McCormack, G. (2009). Apples and Oranges? Corporate Rescue and Functional Convergence in the US and UK. International Insolvency Review, 18(2), 109–134.10.1002/iir.171
Search in Google Scholar
Moss, G. (1998). Chapter 11: An English Lawyer’s Critique. Insolvency Intelligence, 11, 17–21.
Search in Google Scholar
Omar, P. (2014). A Reform in Search of a Purpose: French Insolvency Law Changes (Again!). International Insolvency Review, 23(3), 201–220.10.1002/iir.1227
Search in Google Scholar
Payne, J. (2014). Debt Restructuring in English Law: Lessons from the US and the Need for Reform. University of Oxford, Legal Research Paper Series, Paper No. 89/2013.10.2139/ssrn.2321615
Search in Google Scholar
Picker, R. C. (1992). Voluntary Petitions and the Creditors’ Bargain. University of Cincinnati Law Review, 61(2), 519–542.
Search in Google Scholar
Posner, R.A. (2011). Economic analysis of law (8th edition). Austin, Texas; Wolters Kluwer, Law & Business.
Search in Google Scholar
Rasmussen, R. K., Skeel, D.A. (1995). The Economic Analysis of Corporate Insolvency Law. American Insolvency Law Review, 3, 85–115.
Search in Google Scholar
Shavell, S. (2004). Foundations of Economic Analysis of Law. Cambridge, Massachusetts: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.10.4159/9780674043497
Search in Google Scholar
Shu-Acquaye, F. (2011). American Corporate Law: Directors’ fiduciary Duties and Liability During Solvency, Insolvency and Bankruptcy in Public Corporations. University Of Puerto Rico Business Law Journal, 2(1), 2011, 1–20.
Search in Google Scholar
Skeel, D.A. (2003). The Past, Present and Future of Debtor-in-Possession Financing. Cardozo Law Review, 25(5), 1905–1934.
Search in Google Scholar
Skeel, D.A. (2003). Creditors’ Ball, The “New” New Corporate Governance in Chapter 11. University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 152(2), 917–951.10.2307/3313038
Search in Google Scholar
Stiglitz, J. E. (2001). Bankruptcy Laws, Basic Economic Principles. In Claessens et al (Ed.). Resolution of Financial Distress, An International Perspective on the Design of Insolvency Laws (1–24). Washington D.C.: The World Bank.
Search in Google Scholar
Sorensen, K. E. (2013). Disqualifying Directors in the EU. Nordic & European Company Law Working Paper Series, 10–43.
Search in Google Scholar
Tabb, C. J. (1997). The Law of Bankruptcy. Westbury, New York: The Foundation Press.
Search in Google Scholar
Warren, E. (1993). Bankruptcy Policymaking in an Imperfect World. Michigan Law Review, 92(2), 336–387.10.2307/1289668
Search in Google Scholar
Warren, E., Westbrook, W. (2001). The Law of Debtors and Creditors (Fourth Edition). Gaithersburg: Aspen Law & Business.
Search in Google Scholar
Wathne, K. H., Heide, J. B. (2000). Opportunism in Interfirm Relationships: Forms, Outcomes, and Solutions. Journal of Marketing, 64(4), 36–51.10.1509/jmkg.64.4.36.18070
Search in Google Scholar
Weber, R. (2006). Can the Sauvegarde Reform Save French Bankruptcy Law: A Comparative Look at Chapter 11 and French Bankruptcy Law from an Agency Cost Perspective Note. Michigan Journal of International Law, 27, 257–302.
Search in Google Scholar
Westbrook, W., Booth, C. D., Paulus, C. G., Rajak, H. (2010). A global view of Business Insolvency Systems. Washington, D.C.: The World Bank.10.1163/ej.9789004180253.i-300
Search in Google Scholar
White, M. J. (2001). Bankruptcy Procedure in Countries Undergoing Financial Crises. In Claessens et al (Ed.). Resolution of Financial Distress, An International Perspective on the Design of Insolvency Laws (25–43). Washington D.C.: The World Bank.
Search in Google Scholar
White, M. J. (2005). Economic Analysis of Corporate and Personal Bankruptcy Law. National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) Working Paper 11536.10.3386/w11536
Search in Google Scholar
Wittman, A. D. (1984). Liability for Harm or Restitution for Benefit? Journal of Legal Studies, 13(1), 57–80.10.1086/467733
Search in Google Scholar
Zajc, K., Cepec, J. (2012). Globalna finančna kriza in novele Zakona o finančnem poslovanju, postopkih zaradi insolventnosti in prisilnem prenehanju. Podjetje in Delo, 38(6/7), 1290–1303.
Search in Google Scholar
Zweigert, K., Kötz, H. (2004). An Introduction to Comparative Law. New York: Oxford University Press.
Search in Google Scholar

Carrots and Sticks as Incentive Mechanisms for the Optimal Initiation of Insolvency Proceedings

Abstract

Paradigm

My account