Tab. 1
Curriculum objectives for participating medical students; shelter-based clinics, New York City, 2012–4
|
Objectives |
Format/Venues |
|---|---|
|
To describe epidemiology of homelessness, recognize it as a social problem with health implications, and understand the role of fundamental causes of diseases |
Readings Discussion sessions Lectures |
|
To demonstrate skills to investigate and evaluate psychosocial components/stressors of their patients illness |
Clinical sessions Clinical precepting |
|
To develop skills to address biomedical problems specific to homeless population including but not limited to consequences of substance abuse, living on streets or in transitions or in shelters |
Targeted readings Clinical sessions Clinical precepting |
|
To recognize and address barriers to healthcare access among homeless population (health system level, individual levels, and provider competency level) |
Targeted readings Discussion sessions Lectures |
|
To develop skills to efficiently use the primary care setting and its resources to address patient’s socio-medical conditions effectively |
Targeted readings Clinical sessions Team discussion |
|
To recognize and apply patient-centred approach considering patient’s priorities |
Discussion sessions Clinical precepting Lectures |
|
To develop skills in efficient use of time in primary care setting and apply evidence-based approaches to medical conditions of homeless |
Clinical sessions Clinical precepting |
|
To demonstrate skills in working collaboratively with community and grass-root organizations that provide services to homeless and to learn effective team work with case workers, support staff and shelter staff |
Team discussion Clinical precepting |
|
To develop skills in recognizing and directing patients to appropriate mental health and substance abuse programmes |
Targeted readings Clinical sessions Clinical precepting |
|
To develop skills in efficient use of time in primary care setting and apply evidence-based approaches to medical conditions of homeless |
Readings Clinical precepting |
Tab. 2
Knowledge and attitude among medical students pre- and post-curriculum in New York City shelter clinics, 2012–4
|
Pre Mean SEM N |
Post |
P value paired t-test | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
KNOWLEDGE Composite score (Yes/No, or one correct answer) |
0.2822 0.0325 18 |
0.422 0.022 15 |
p < 0.001 |
|
What is the average number of homeless persons who sleep on street each night in New York City? a) 20,000 b) at least 10,000 c) 3–4,000 d) I have no idea |
0.17 0.09 18 |
0.87 0.09 15 |
p = 0.001 |
|
What is the percentage of family homelessness among homeless population in the United States? a) 15–25 % b) 30–40 % c) 50–70 % d) I have no idea |
0.11 0.08 18 |
0.33 0.13 15 |
p = 0.082 |
|
What is among some of the most common complaints in dropping centres? a) Headache b) abdominal pain c) cough d) feet swelling |
0.08 0.08 13 |
0.62 0.15 13 |
p = 0.015 |
|
The highest cost of homeless to society comes from? a) Social services b) food and housing c) outpatient care d) hospital admission due to mental illness |
0.79 0.11 14 |
0.92 0.08 13 |
p = 0.081 |
|
What is the ethnicity/race with highest rate of homelessness among chronically homeless in New York City? a) Black b) Hispanic c) Whites d) other e) all are equally at risk |
0.53 0.12 17 |
0.80 0.11 15 |
p = 0.040 |
|
ATTITUDE Composite score a |
3.35 0.063 18 |
3.65 0.056 15 |
p < 0.001 |
|
I am comfortable being a primary care provider for a homeless person with major mental illnesses |
2.81 0.22 22 |
3.94 0.11 16 |
p = 0.001 |
|
I feel comfortable providing care to different minority and cultural groups |
4.10 0.22 22 |
4.38 0.18 16 |
p = 0.029 |
|
I feel generally overwhelmed by the complexity of the problems that homeless people have |
3.33 0.17 22 |
2.56 0.18 16 |
p = 0.003 |
|
I enjoy learning about the lives of my homeless patients |
3.90 0.17 22 |
4.63 0.13 16 |
p = 0.003 |
|
I generally believe caring for the homeless is not financially viable for my career |
2.95 0.18 22 |
2.56 0.26 16 |
p = 0.096 |
|
I feel comfortable to provide care to a homeless person with depression |
3.14 0.19 22 |
4.13 0.09 16 |
p = 0.0001 |
|
I feel comfortable to provide care to a homeless person with other mental illnesses |
2.90 0.19 22 |
4.13 0.09 16 |
p = 0.0001 |
|
I feel comfortable to provide care to a homeless person with substance abuse |
2.81 0.16 22 |
3.81 0.14 16 |
p = 0.0001 |
|
I feel comfortable to provide care to a homeless person with alcohol abuse |
2.76 0.15 22 |
3.94 0.14 16 |
p = 0.0001 |
|
I feel comfortable to help uninsured or underinsured persons to better navigate health system |
2.33 0.20 22 |
3.25 0.19 16 |
p = 0.021 |
|
I feel comfortable to negotiate plan of care with homeless patients considering their constraints and expectations |
3.05 0.18 21 |
4.00 0.20 16 |
p = 0.006 |
aLikert scale: Strongly Disagree (1) Disagree (2) Neither agree/disagree (3) Agree (4) Strongly Agree (5)
Tab. 3
Self-efficacy among medical students pre- and post-curriculum in New York City shelter clinics, 2012–4
|
SELF-EFFICACY |
Pre Mean SEM N |
Post |
P value paired t-test |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Composite score a |
3.317 0.067 18 |
3.695 0.061 12 |
p < 0.001 |
|
I believe that I can assess depression in a homeless person |
3.33 0.20 21 |
4.44 0.13 16 |
p = 0.0002 |
|
I believe that I can apply Depression score/questionnaire to assess depression in a homeless person |
3.62 0.18 21 |
4.69 0.12 16 |
p = 0.0009 |
|
I believe that I can obtain and assess psychosocial issues from a homeless person |
3.43 0.15 21 |
4.25 0.14 16 |
p = 0.0004 |
|
I believe that I can assess substance abuse in a homeless person |
3.43 0.18 21 |
4.06 0.19 16 |
p = 0.014 |
|
I believe that I can assess alcohol abuse or dependence in a homeless person |
3.48 0.16 21 |
4.19 0.14 16 |
p = 0.002 |
|
I believe that I can obtain and assess sexual history from a homeless person |
3.95 0.08 21 |
4.44 0.13 16 |
p = 0.0004 |
|
I believe that I can assess smoking history and provide smoking cessation to a homeless person |
3.86 0.13 21 |
4.56 0.13 16 |
p = 0.0003 |
|
I believe that I have skills in directing homeless persons to potential psychosocial resources |
2.24 0.14 21 |
3.57 0.22 16 |
p = 0.002 |
|
I believe that I have skills in directing homeless persons to potential and accessible biomedical resources |
2.24 0.15 21 |
3.38 0.18 16 |
p = 0.0001 |
|
I believe that I can work collaboratively with social service providers and community organizations that provide services to the homeless |
3.95 0.18 21 |
4.38 0.13 16 |
p = 0.047 |
|
I believe that I have clinical skills to detect and address most medical problems specific to the homeless population |
2.95 0.16 21 |
4.06 0.11 16 |
p = 0.0001 |
|
How has your experience here at Community Medicine Program changed your career choices to go to: Primary care residencies (Emergency Medicine, Internal Medicine, Paediatrics, OBGYN, Preventive Medicine, Family Medicine, General Surgery) |
3.11 0.11 9 |
3.56 0.16 16 |
p = 0.078 |
|
How has your experience here at Community Medicine Program changed your career choices to work with the underserved? |
3.22 0.22 19 |
4.13 0.15 16 |
p = 0.011 |
aLikert scale: Strongly disagree (1) Disagree (2) Neither agree/disagree (3) Agree (4) Strongly agree (5)
