Have a personal or library account? Click to login
The discourse of generational segmentation and the implications for postgraduate medical education Cover

The discourse of generational segmentation and the implications for postgraduate medical education

Open Access
|Apr 2013

Figures & Tables

Table 1

The different generations approach to technology, market selection and health care

Generation

Technology

Marketing

Health care

Greatest Generation 1925–1944

Grew up with radio and party lines, do not require many of today’s technological advancements

Marvel at their grandchildren’s technological expertise; do not share the integral need for technology in their everyday life

– Is this necessary?

Loyal consumers

Will shop around if necessary

Value quality over efficiency

Standard options satisfy them; customization not always necessary/valued

Trust credentialed institutions to provide them with what they need

– Give Me What I Need

Believe in the doctor as a gatekeeper who will assist in navigating the health care system

View the doctor as a trusted authority figure to make appropriate health care decisions for them

High users of health care due to co-morbidities and end of life needs

The Boomers (i.e. their children) increasingly making their health care decisions

– Direct Me

Baby Boomers 1945–1964

The beta generation for much of today’s technology; also sceptical about technology as bringing many problems as solutions

Expect that technology will be available to support the personalization they expect from all of their service experiences

– Beta Testers

Customization of products/services is important

Less concerned with reputations and credentials

Value products and services that offer prestige i.e. ‘membership has its privileges’

Respond to messages/services that allow them to gain control of their time through personalization

– Pursue Me

Active consumers of health care

Interested in a physician’s credentials as well as a hospital’s reputation

Likely to do extensive research, prior to visiting a doctor including internet searches

Expect to engage in a dialogue about the care they or their parents receive; tend to focus on personal wellness and fighting the ageing process

– Engage Me

Gen Xers 1965–1984

The first PC generation

Technology is a necessity, helps them control their schedules and their children’s schedules. It is not uncommon to see two Gen X parents in a coffee shop beaming play dates to each other from their iphones or Blackberries

– Balancing Act

Rely on peer referrals more than any other generations

Look for personalization, options, and control of the sale

– What do My Friends Say?

Expect health care to be designed around them and their family’s needs rather than an ordinary physician/patient relationship

Distrustful of institutions and disdainful of hierarchy and authority

In search of a free flow of information; want electronic health care records and will use them to become advocates for their own care

Engage in online disease management programmes and virtual coaching sessions on a variety of health topics

Prefer to be self sufficient in health care as in other areas of their lives

Would rather learn to diagnose their child’s ear infection than wait an hour for a doctor to perform the same simple examination

– Educate Me

Millennials 1985–2005

Techno savvy generation, digital natives

Believe that electronic/digital connections with others are acceptable as face-to-face communication

Use technology to build and expand social networks and constantly communicate with ‘friends’

With the advent of Facebook, the Internet, Twitter, YouTube, etc., the concept of friendship has evolved from the boy next door, to the girl across the globe

– The world is Technology

Raised to be consumers; have very high brand awareness

Expect high quality and easy to handle experiences

Expect the buying experience to be interactive; want products that are customized and unique, sold by companies with an altruistic attitude

Raised with a significant environmental consciousness, prefer socially responsible companies as their suppliers

– Interact with Me

Primarily interact with the health care system through paediatrics, obstetrics & gynaecology and sports medicine

They are looking for immediate interactions that are technology based

They will not wait for appointments, surgery dates, etc. preferring real time, and individualized, problem resolution

– Connect With Me

Table 2

The different generations relationship with (medical) education

Educational characteristic

Greatest Generation 1925–1944

Baby Boomers 1945–1964

Gen X’ers 1965–1984

Millennials 1985–2005

Authority

Conformers, authority rules

Command and control

Usually uncomfortable with authority figures

Question legitimacy of authority

Comfortable with authority

Not intimidated by authority

Believe respect must be earned

Question authority

Signs of respect

Revere authority/superiors

Give special treatment

Revere authority/superiors

Give special treatment

Demand authority

Expect to be held in esteem

Expect to be listened to based on earned professional/academic achievement

Demand authority

Expect to be held in esteem

Expect to be listened to based on the number of contacts/followers in network e.g. Twitter, Facebook

Source of knowledge

Personal experiences

Storytelling

Trial and error

Books and libraries

Microfilms

Experts/intellectuals

Experiments

Electronic media, E-books

CD ROMs

Online information/databases

WWW, Wikipedia

Google, You Tube

Social networks

Favoured learning approach

Apprenticeship

Lectures

Pen and paper

Slides/overhead sheets

Emails

PowerPoint presentations

Simulations

(Serious) gaming

You Tube instructions

Virtual teaching on the web

Reaction to feedback

May feel insulted by continuous feedback

May feel insulted by continuous feedback

Feel at home with feedback

Not dependent on immediate and continuous feedback

Thrive on immediate and continuous feedback

Feel insecure without feedback

Key value

Feeling valued

Feeling valued

Feeling valued

Feeling valued

Box 1

Characteristics of the Millennial physician

Expert in the science of medicine and the (interrelationships between) social sciences and humanities related to clinical care

Skilled in communications, care giving and interpersonal relationships including patient advocacy and cultural sensitivity

Is a professional, including being ethical and functioning as a member or leader of a team

Life-long learner, able to reflect and evaluate self, and improving based on practice, experience and feedback

Knowledgeable about the health care system, including the principles of economics, public health, management, quality assurance and patient safety

Language: English
Published on: Apr 16, 2013
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 1 issue per year

© 2013 Jamiu O. Jamiu O. Busari, published by Bohn Stafleu van Loghum
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.