Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Quantitative Methods for Evaluating the Efficacy of Thalamic Deep Brain Stimulation in Patients with Essential Tremor Cover

Quantitative Methods for Evaluating the Efficacy of Thalamic Deep Brain Stimulation in Patients with Essential Tremor

Open Access
|Nov 2013

Figures & Tables

Table 1

Background Characteristics of 22 Patients with Essential Tremor

CharacteristicMeasure
Age, in years, mean (range)64 (33–78)
Sex, no. of females/males11F/11M
Right-handedness, % (n)91 (20)
Heredity for tremor, % (n)73 (16)
Smokers, % (n)18 (4)
All tobacco use, % (n)45 (10)
Alcohol consumption in g/week, median (range)21 (0–100)
Use of β-blockers, % (n)36 (8)
Duration of treatment with deep brain stimulation in years, mean (range)5.9 (2–14)
tre-03-196-4279-2-g001.jpg
Figure 1

A. Postural tremor, dominant hand. B. Kinetic tremor, dominant hand.

Clinical tremor score (0-4) evaluated by the Essential Tremor Rating Scale in 22 patients with essential tremor, treated with deep brain stimulation. Stimulator in the “off” and “on” conditions.

Table 2

Results (scores 0–4) from Assessment of Clinical Tremor in the Dominant Hand Using the Essential Tremor Rating Scale

OFF (n = 22)ON (n = 22)
CharacteristicMedianMinMaxMedianMinMaxMedian differencep-Value1
Rest tremor00200100.13
Postural tremor10200210.002
Kinetic tremor2041031.5<0.0001
Spiral drawing4141042<0.0001
Line drawing3041042<0.0001

1 Wilcoxon signed rank test.

tre-03-196-4279-2-g002.jpg
Figure 2

Tremor registrations from one of the essential tremor patients performed with a biaxial accelerometer (CATSYS tremor pen) in the dominant hand.

Measurements in the “off” condition are shown to the left, and in the "on" condition are shown to the right.

tre-03-196-4279-2-g003.jpg
Figure 3

A. The CATSYS tremor pen B. The eurythmokinesimeter.

Tremor intensity measured by the CATSYS tremor pen, and Fitts' Law constant measured by a eurythmokinesimeter in the dominant hand, in 22 patents with essential tremor, treated with deep brain stimulation. Stimulator in the “off” and “on” conditions.

Table 3

Results from Measurement of Postural Tremor with the CATSYS System, and Rapid Pointing Movements Using a Eurythmokinesimeter, in the Dominant Hand

Off (n = 22)On (n = 22)
CharacteristicMedianMinMaxMedianMinMaxMedian ratio on/offp-Value1
The CATSYS system
↓ Tremor intensity (m/s2)2.950.0925.40.2550.1018.90.11 (0.01–1.22)<0.0001
↑ Center frequency (Hz)4.503.406.904.453.107.20.98 (0.81–1.62)0.76
↑ Frequency dispersion (Hz)0.200.103.01.150.103.603.75 (0.20–20.0)0.006
↓ Harmonic index0.990.910.990.960.870.990.98 (0.90–1.01)0.0004
The eurythmokinesimeter2
↑ Speed (mm/s)0.871<0.2811.520.9180.5391.681.17 (0.75–3.05)0.01
↑ Precision0.07580.00.5400.1150.00.6601.22 (0–2.66)0.03
↓ Imprecision0.9700.5271.00.9080.3681.00.93 (0.70–1.07)0.001
↓ Unsureness1.351.0>2.221.191.022.550.91 (0.54–1.27)0.08
↓ Tremor0.3670.0875>0.8570.2780.04801.070.69 (0.11–2.44)0.17
↓ Transit duration1.050.581>3.800.9910.5381.610.82 (0.26–1.29)0.0002
↓ Contact duration0.08700.0308>0.2220.1470.05630.4861.57 (0.34–4.11)0.0008
↓ Fitts’ Law constant0.2410.134>0.9290.1850.1120.3080.77 (0.27–1.30)<.0001
↓ Irregularity0.2320.0630>1.750.1300.04600.4540.63 (0.08–2.13)<0.0001

The arrows indicate the expected direction of improvement.

1 Wilcoxon signed rank test.

2 Three patients were unable to touch any target in the “off” condition. The missing values are replaced with the value for worst performance in the other 19 patients.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/tohm.131 | Journal eISSN: 2160-8288
Language: English
Submitted on: Jul 14, 2013
Accepted on: Sep 2, 2013
Published on: Nov 4, 2013
Published by: Columbia University Libraries/Information Services
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 1 issue per year

© 2013 Gunilla Wastensson, Björn Holmberg, Bo Johnels, Lars Barregard, published by Columbia University Libraries/Information Services
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons License.