Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Stigmatization and Validation of Atheism, Literalism, and Non-Literalism in the Discourse over Evolutionary Theory Cover

Stigmatization and Validation of Atheism, Literalism, and Non-Literalism in the Discourse over Evolutionary Theory

By: Eric O. Silva  
Open Access
|Jan 2018

Figures & Tables

Table 1

Number of letters by time period.

YearN
1987–199880
199966
200026
200114
200259
200330
200465
2005318
200689
200722
200825
201278
2013156
Total1028
Table 2

Findings.

Framing ProcessImplicit PolarizationDistancingArticulation
DefinitionObliquely denies compatibility between faith and evolution.Claims one’s position is unlike that of another.Connects two positions to each other.
Frame ConstructedEquivalence, evolutionary theory equated with atheism.Nonequivalence, faith in God is independent of acceptance of evolution.Nonequivalence, faith in God is independent of acceptance of evolution
Evolutionist Version(s)E.g., evolution is evidence based, while faith is not.1. Evolutionary theory from atheism.
2. Religion from science.
3. Non-literalism from literalism.
1. Evolutionist believers.
2. God involved with evolution.
3. Biblical reconciliation.
Anti-Evolutionist Version(s)E.g., Christians reject evolution.1. Anti-evolutionism distanced from faith.
2. Literalism from non-literalism.
Not applicable.
Stigmatizes Atheism bycasting it as a contaminant.casting it as a contaminant, contradicting its truth claims.not acknowledging its existence, contradicting its truth claims.
Stigmatizes Non-Literalism bynot acknowledging its existence, contradicting its truth claims.casting it as inferior.Not Applicable.
Stigmatizes Literaism bycasting it as a contaminant.casting it as inferior, contradicting its truth claims.not acknowledging its existence, contradicting its truth claims.
Validates Atheism byrepresenting its truth claims.Not applicable.Not applicable.
Validates Non-Literalism byNot applicable.representing its truth claims.representing its truth claims.
Validates Literalism byrepresenting its truth claims.representing its truth claims.Not applicable.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/snr.44 | Journal eISSN: 2053-6712
Language: English
Published on: Jan 17, 2018
Published by: Ubiquity Press
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 1 issue per year

© 2018 Eric O. Silva, published by Ubiquity Press
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.