Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Exploring Acceptability and Feasibility of Evidence-Based Practice in Child Welfare Settings: A Pilot Study with Attachment-Based Family Therapy Cover

Exploring Acceptability and Feasibility of Evidence-Based Practice in Child Welfare Settings: A Pilot Study with Attachment-Based Family Therapy

Open Access
|Apr 2017

Figures & Tables

Table 1

Pre- and Post-workshop measured attitudes per item for the total group.

Attitude itemsnMean (SD) preMean (SD) postt (df)d
1. I believe that interventional manuals could be used effectively by the families I work with723.43 (0.58)3.89 (0.49)–6.00 (71)**–0.86
2. I believe that ABFT fits within the work I am doing733.70 (0.76)3.86 (0.69)–1.84 (72)–0.22
3. I’m interested to learn how to do ABFT734.22 (0.73)4.29 (0.68)–1.00 (72)–0.10
4. I already know enough intervention techniques to guide most families effectively722.46 (0.80)2.32 (0.80)1.46 (71)0.18
5. Interventional manuals are too rigid for guiding families from our service732.75 (0.78)2.29 (0.81)4.22 (72)**0.58
6. Using a manual restricts my own style of working with families732.73 (0.90)2.26 (0.88)3.68 (72)**0.53
7. By using a manual I cannot deal as flexible with crisis522.87 (0.82)2.29 (0.85)4.17 (51)**0.69
8. Meaningful change cannot take place in 16 weeks732.86 (0.98)2.79 (1.03).52 (72)0.07
9. ABFT focuses on the relation between the parent and one adolescent, and that is why it cannot be of additional value for all the other problems which the family has to deal with722.33 (0.96)2.19 (1.05).90 (71)0.14

[i] Note: * p < .006. ** p ≤ .001.

.20 Small effect, .50 Medium effect, .80 Large effect (Cohen, 1988).

To improve readability, we sorted the items based on the positively or negatively framed content.

Table 2

Pre- and Post-workshop measured attitudes per item for counselors with the most negative attitudes.

Attitude itemsnMean (SD) preMean (SD) postt (df)d
1. I believe that interventional manuals could be used effectively by the families I work with402.95 (0.22)3.78 (0.48)–10.42 (39)**–2.22
2. I believe that ABFT fits within the work I am doing272.85 (0.36)3.44 (0.70)–3.65 (26)**–1.06
3. I’m interested to learn how to do ABFT112.91 (0.30)3.45 (0.52)–3.46 (10)*–1.27
4. I already know enough intervention techniques to guide most families effectively333.21 (0.42)2.64 (0.90)3.98 (32)**0.81
5. Interventional manuals are too rigid for guiding families from our service473.23 (0.48)2.49 (0.75)5.86 (46)**1.18
6. Using a manual restricts my own style of working with families463.30 (0.51)2.43 (0.83)6.49 (45)**1.26
7. By using a manual I cannot deal as flexible with crisis363.28 (0.61)2.44 (0.84)5.15 (35)**1.14
8. Meaningful change cannot take place in 16 weeks463.48 (0.62)3.02 (0.86)3.08 (45)*0.61
9. ABFT focuses on the relation between the parent and one adolescent, and that is why it cannot be of additional value for all the other problems which the family has to deal with263.42 (0.58)2.38 (1.02)4.48 (25)**1.25

[i] Note: * p < .006. ** p ≤ .001.

.20 Small effect, .50 Medium effect, .80 Large effect (Cohen, 1988).

To improve readability, we sorted the items based on the positively and negatively framed content.

Table 3

Child report: Pre- and Post-treatment measures.

ScalenMean (SD) preMean (SD) postt (df)d
Internalizing problems (YSR)2324.06 (8.48)17.02 (8.97)3.43 (22)**.81
Withdrawn Depressed (YSR)236.61 (2.65)4.57 (2.74)2.75 (22)*.76
Anxious Depressed (YSR)2310.61 (4.94)7.46 (4.83)2.87 (22)**.64
Depressive symptoms (CDI)2217.30 (7.60)13.02 (5.37)3.34 (21)**.65

[i] Note: * .01 < p ≤ .05. ** .001 < p ≤ .01. *** p ≤ .001.

.20 Small effect, .50 Medium effect, .80 Large effect (Cohen, 1988).

Table 4

Parent report: Pre- and Post-treatment measures.

ScalenMean (SD) preMean (SD) postt (df)d
Internalizing problems (YSR)1619.54 (10.26)13.26 (8.97)2.63 (15)*.65
Withdrawn Depressed (YSR)165.94 (3.00)3.73 (2.92)3.38 (15)**.75
Anxious Depressed (YSR)169.27 (5.30)5.36 (5.10)4.62 (15)***.75

[i] Note: * .01 < p ≤ .05. ** .001 < p ≤ .01. *** p ≤ .001.

.20 Small effect, .50 Medium effect, .80 Large effect (Cohen, 1988).

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/pb.338 | Journal eISSN: 0033-2879
Language: English
Submitted on: Apr 14, 2016
|
Accepted on: Nov 18, 2016
|
Published on: Apr 12, 2017
Published by: Ubiquity Press
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 1 issue per year

© 2017 Tara Santens, Suzanne A. Levy, Guy S. Diamond, Caroline Braet, Mildred Vyvey, Elisabeth Heylboeck, Guy Bosmans, published by Ubiquity Press
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.