Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Communication, Collaboration and Care Coordination: The Three-Point Guide to Cancer Care Provision for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians Cover

Communication, Collaboration and Care Coordination: The Three-Point Guide to Cancer Care Provision for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians

Open Access
|Jun 2020

Figures & Tables

Table 1

Participant characteristics.

Total number of participants in settingsSelf-identified Indigenous participants
PHCTertiary
Sex
Male63
Female116
Profession
Receptionist/admin officer11  
Aboriginal Health Workers/Professionals22  
Aboriginal Liaison Officer22  
Allied Health Coordinator11  
Maternal and Child Health Manager11  
Enrolled Nurse21  
Registered Nurse413*
Nutritionist1–  
Social Worker1–  
General Practitioner6–  
Medical Oncologist1–  
Radiation Oncologist2–  
Hematologist1–  
Total number of health facilities and geographical location
Urban area11
Inner regional1
Outer regional3
Remote area1

[i] Key: * denotes PHC setting.

Table 2

Enablers, barriers and strategies for improvement in the continuity and coordination of care within and between the PHC and cancer treating tertiary hospital as identified by study participants, displayed in IPCHS categories.

WHO IPCHS identified primary drivers of continuity and coordination of careEnablersBarriersStrategies for improving continuity and coordination of care
Interpersonal continuity (refers to patients’ experiencing continuity in their trusted therapeutic relationships, care provided based on identified personal and cultural needs provided by a central provider) [26, 41].
  • Continued relationships and trust

  • Patient follow-up and provision of holistic care

  • General practitioner (GP) as central point

  • Staff workload resulting in minimum time for patients (hospital setting)

  • Limited staff knowledge to provide adequate care

  • Education/Upskilling of staff. PHC staff – education on diagnosed cancers, treatment and management. Hospital staff – education on health and hospital associated needs of Indigenous patients.

  • Patient centred care. Aboriginal Liaison Officer (ALO) providing cultural support and care prior to patient presentation to hospital based on patient-identified needs, use of translators as required

  • Collaborative practices and proactive attitudes/practices, peer support amongst care providers within and between sectors

Longitudinal continuity (refers to patients seeing the same professional over multiple episodes of care, ensuring strategies are in place for care to be connected, and availability of a patient support network) [26, 41].
  • Proactive approach to patients care

  • Patient navigator

  • Patient support to access services

  • Systems and processes resulting in barriers to care e.g. organisation protocols resulting in a lot of paperwork and time delays)

  • Practical support for patients to access care (for example, transport, accommodation, care coordinators/navigators

  • Collaborative practices across settings to plan patient’s post-discharge care and follow-up prior to hospital discharge

  • Sharing of electronic patient records across hospital and PHC sites

  • Seeing the same care navigator/coordinator through the cancer journey across settings to deliver care continuity

  • Simpler protocols around release of patient information documents for treating PHC services to obtain copies of patient hospital records to be able to provide care continuity and quality follow-up care at the PHC end

Flexible continuity (refers to the ability to adjust care and treatment plans in response to patients changing individual needs across time [26].
  • Flexible care delivery (e.g. telehealth)

  • ‘Drop-in’ clinics

  • Extension of clinic hours (PHC)

  • Longer GP/specialist patient consultations

  • Visiting specialists/allied health professionals at PHC setting

  • Rigid hospital appointment schedules/times

  • Transport and parking costs (hospital setting)

  • Short hospital consultation times with specialists

  • Lengthy waiting times before seeing specialist (hospital setting)

  • Care flexibility (especially at the hospital) and consideration of individual patient needs when scheduling appointments (for example, travel distance), in care delivery (such as telehealth options), availability of outside business hours clinics to access allied health staff, practical considerations (for example, parking costs, public transport).

  • More consideration for appointment flexibility for patients living outside urban areas

  • More time allocated for specialists’ consultations

  • Active follow-up of patients who are unable to attend scheduled appointments

  • Patient support (help with self-management strategies and to prioritise health as needed)

  • Timely and improved communication pathways between services

  • Keeping patients informed whilst waiting to be seen in hospital

Informational continuity (refers to the provision of timely and comprehensive information in relation to patient care needs) [26].
  • Timely communication and information exchange

  • Use of technology

  • Limited communication & coordination/teamwork within hospital

  • Delayed communication and information exchange on patient treatment/condition

  • Ineffective administrative/system processes (such as some PHC having difficulty accessing paperwork)

  • Sharing of patient electronic records across settings in real time

  • Timely, frequent and ongoing communication and more use of telephone calls, case conferences between services, specialists providing updates to GP after every hospital specialist appointment (not only for changes and/or to discuss concerns)

  • Name and contact details of a contactable medical staff member as point of contact on all discharge summaries

  • Patient information – ensuring patients are aware they can access both hospital and PHC care services after hospital discharge

  • Streamlined administrative processes and paperwork (for example, streamlined release of patient information consent forms)

Cross-boundary team continuity (refers to effective collaborations among professionals in all care settings) [26].
  • Collaborative partnerships, teamwork and good relationships within and external to the organisation

  • Care management plans

  • Working in silos

  • Lack of clarity between PHC and hospital staff on who’s providing the follow-up care

  • Lack of streamlined services and system processes

  • Working together, good relationships and follow-up care. Hospital providing discharge summaries and/or paperwork to PHC in timely manner, shared patient management care plans, developing communication protocols between services, more collaboration across multidisciplinary teams in hospitals

  • Shared patient electronic records across services in real time

  • Clarity around professional roles and responsibilities (for example, role of ALO and social worker at the hospital) and clarity between hospital and PHC staff on post discharge follow-up care (who is doing what)

  • Communication/engagement with PHC such as copying GP in relevant communications with specialists, referrals, keeping PHC in the loop

  • Prompt follow-up of positive test results and communication with GP and relevant professionals

  • Hospital admission notifications and treatment updates to PHC while patient is hospitalised (with patient consent)

  • Streamlined administrative processes

  • Designated site contact person at the PHC and hospital is provided to services as a point of contact for any patient and care related enquires

Table 3

Study participants recommended strategies on improving communication between the treating hospital and PHC services.

ThemesParticipants recommendationsSample Hospital participant quotesSample PHC participant quotes
Shared patient records/care plans, use of technology Hospital and PHC: Increase use of phone calls to discuss patient care in timely manner, more timely information exchange, sharing of electronic patient records and use of other technology (e.g. telehealth, teleconferences) to discuss patient care in a timely manner. PHC: Prompt follow-up of urgent concerns, clearly documented and shared cancer treatment and management plans.“It’s about timeliness of the delivery of information and I do think that often there’s an unacceptable delay between the patient’s diagnosis and the GP getting the information, because the patients have very commonly been back to see their GP before the GP has received a letter from us.” (Hospital 6, Non-Indigenous specialist)“So, maybe if it’s consented (to share patient’s hospital records) when they (patients’) first go in… then after that’s fine. So, if paperwork has come, then they can just send it straight through… if the consent is given for the doctor to share the paperwork while our patient is still in hospital, then that might be a good thing too… because then too once again… if a doctors have got a heads up about what’s happening and what needs to be done when the patient comes out, and then they can start to organise that before they come out.” (PHC 8, Indigenous EEN)
Working collaboratively, clarity around follow-up care Hospital and PHC: Having a designated contact person at each site and associated contact phone number for health professionals to contact to discuss patients care. PHC: Clarity around post-hospital discharge follow-up care (e.g. who is doing what and when), development of agreed communication protocols and processes between services, regular face-to-face meetings to discuss patient care/needs and collaborative action to address/support patients prior to hospital discharge. Hospital: Hospital ALO’s to engage in more community engagement activities with PHC services and community, ensuring hospital has correct GP contact details for communication“I know at one point there we were doing a lot of community engagement so we were able to actually leave the hospital and go and visit organisations and things, but we kind of cut back on that community engagement. I suppose if we returned to that level of community engagement again that would probably help.” (Hospital 8, Indigenous ALO)(Regarding discharge summary paperwork) “there’s actually someone (named on discharge summary) that can be contacted … so, for instance I may not know who the registrar is, and within Queensland Health they will change during a year, so for there to be a named individual on the discharge summary that says, ‘if you’ve got any questions please phone blah blah blah, and here is my mobile number’, so that there’s a named point of contact.” (PHC 3, Non-Indigenous care coordinator RN)
Notifications/updates around hospitalisations, accurate GP details PHC: Notification from hospital to inform treating PHC of patient admission, discharge and regular updates on patient condition during hospitalisation. Hospital: having updated treating GP information for the patient.“Again, it will come down to as long as we’ve got the right GP and that the patient is going back there. I think if we see a patient and we get them through the process and treat them, we make sure that we explain to them as best we can what the recovery is going to be, we do a follow-up phone call which I do… and then send those letters to the GP. I think that’s pretty good communication and always know or trusting that a Doctor would call if they need to.” (Hospital 5, Non-Indigenous RN)“It’s just… I spose ongoing communication. What I’d like to see is more information about patients who are in the hospital… so we know who is in the hospital. Whether they’re in there for… say they got sick at home and they’re now in having treatment at palliative care. I’d like to know about all our patients… all Aboriginal patients that may be in palliative care. I’d like to know as soon as… not wait two weeks down the track.” (PHC 9, Non-Indigenous social worker)
More efficient administrative processes PHC: Hospital obtaining patients signed consent once (rather than multiple times) to release hospital treatment records to the treating PHC. Hospital: Reducing the turnaround time for hospital specialist letters to be dictated and sent to GPs, use of electronic systems“We need to be emailing these letters and they need to be going electronically to GP’s, but at an administrative level.., I think that we need to improve those communication pathways, and it needs to be electronic.. but then, there’s still this delay in the dictation process.” (Hospital 6, Non-Indigenous specialist)“Oh, it’s just I suppose it’s just the feedback. When they’ve seen the specialist you need to have that feedback from the specialist. It’s just this paperwork that you need to chase up all the time. Especially when they get into those big hospitals.” (PHC 13, Non- Indigenous EEN)
ijic-20-2-5456-g1.png
Figure 1

Drivers of continuity and care coordination from this study added to the implementation guide of the WHO Framework of Integrated People-Centred Health Services [26].

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/ijic.5456 | Journal eISSN: 1568-4156
Language: English
Submitted on: Nov 22, 2019
|
Accepted on: May 13, 2020
|
Published on: Jun 8, 2020
Published by: Ubiquity Press
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 4 issues per year

© 2020 Audra de Witt, Veronica Matthews, Ross Bailie, Gail Garvey, Patricia C. Valery, Jon Adams, Jennifer H. Martin, Frances C. Cunningham, published by Ubiquity Press
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.