Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Identifying Inconsistencies in Data Quality Between FAOSTAT, WOAH, UN Agriculture Census, and National Data Cover

Identifying Inconsistencies in Data Quality Between FAOSTAT, WOAH, UN Agriculture Census, and National Data

Open Access
|Sep 2024

Figures & Tables

dsj-23-1630-g1.png
Figure 1

Graph of cattle Populations in the USA between 1960–2020.

dsj-23-1630-g2.png
Figure 2

Graph of sheep Populations in Ethiopia between 1993–2017.

dsj-23-1630-g3.png
Figure 3

The growth rates for cattle in the USA from USA national data are shown as a histogram with the normal curve superimposed on top. The first STD line is red, the second STD is black, and the third STD is yellow.

dsj-23-1630-g4.png
Figure 4

The growth rates for sheep in Ethiopia from FAOSTAT (Top) and WOAH (Bottom) are plotted to normal curves. The first standard deviation line is red, the second standard deviation line is black, and the third standard deviation line is yellow.

dsj-23-1630-g5.png
Figure 5

The interquartile ranges for cattle in the United States of America. This shows the interquartile ranges of the yearly rate of change in animal population numbers from the sources FAOSTAT, WOAH, UN Agriculture Census Data, and the National data from the United States. Note that the data from the UN Agriculture Census Data was taken in two different years, 2001 and 2012, so the rate of change was averaged across the 11 years.

dsj-23-1630-g6.png
Figure 6

The interquartile ranges for sheep in Ethiopia between 1960 and 2020. Shows the interquartile ranges of the yearly rate of change in animal population numbers from the sources FAOSTAT and WOAH.

dsj-23-1630-g7.png
Figure 7

The interquartile range for goats in South Africa. Shows the interquartile ranges of the yearly rate of change in animal population numbers from the sources FAOSTAT and WOAH between 1960 and 2020.

dsj-23-1630-g8.png
Figure 8

The interquartile ranges for goats in South Africa excluding the outliers.

dsj-23-1630-g9.png
Figure 9

Finding the rate of change between two five-year averages for the chicken population in the United States of America.

dsj-23-1630-g10.png
Figure 10

The rate of change between trailing five-year averages for the cattle population in Botswana for the sources FAOSTAT and WOAH.

dsj-23-1630-g11.png
Figure 11

Shows the population of cattle in Botswana between 2000 and 2020 for FAOSTAT, WOAH, and UN Agriculture Census data.

dsj-23-1630-g12.png
Figure 12

Finding the rate of change between two trailing five-year averages for the cattle population in India.

DATA SOURCETIMESPECIESCOUNTRY ISO3SOURCEPOTENTIAL REASONING
FAOSTAT2008ChickensUSA5 Year Population AvgChange in counting method for chickens
FAOSTAT1970–1980CattleUSA5 Year Population Avg and Growth RatesReduction in red meat consumption in Americans
WOAH2009SheepETHIQRLikely inconsistency in data collection or distribution
WOAH2006CattleARGIQRLikely inconsistency in data collection or distribution
UN2007GoatsMEXIQRUnknown, likely miss counting given other sources being significantly higher for this year
Language: English
Submitted on: Sep 19, 2023
Accepted on: Aug 17, 2024
Published on: Sep 18, 2024
Published by: Ubiquity Press
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 1 issue per year

© 2024 Ian McKechnie, Kassy Raymond, Deborah Stacey, published by Ubiquity Press
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.