Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Long‑Term Impact of HEAT Educational Intervention in the Emergency Department in Karachi, Pakistan Cover

Long‑Term Impact of HEAT Educational Intervention in the Emergency Department in Karachi, Pakistan

Open Access
|Sep 2025

Figures & Tables

Table 1

Socio‑demographic and clinical characteristics of patients visiting the ED with heat‑related illnesses pre‑intervention (2013–2017) and post‑intervention (2018–2022) (n = 308).

PRE‑INTERVENTION (2013–2017) (N = 184)POST‑INTERVENTION (2018–2022) (N = 124)P‑VALUE
Age in Years51.43 ± 18.3342.52 ± 17.39<0.001*
Male117 (64)101 (82)<0.001*
Female67 (36)23 (19)
Triage Category
Priority level 134 (19)32 (26)<0.043*
Priority level 249 (27)37 (30)
Priority level 394 (51)45 (36)
Priority level 47 (4)10 (8)
Presenting Complain
Fever135 (73)71 (57)<0.003*
Malaise/Nausea/Vomiting70 (38)110 (89)<0.001*
Weakness33 (18)25 (20)0.624
Altered Mental Status26 (14)26 (21)0.116
Shortness of Breath (SOB)13 (7)26 (21)<0.001*
Headache10 (5)24 (19)<0.001*
Faint/Dizziness/Syncope9 (5)23 (19)<0.001*
Fall19 (10)10 (8)0.505
Chest1 (1)27 (22)<0.001*
Abdominal Pain2 (1)22 (18)<0.001*
Palpitations8 (4)15 (12)<0.011*
Anxiety17 (9)6 (5)0.150
Body ache9 (5)7 (6)0.770
Chills3 (2)7 (6)<0.051
Urinary4 (2)2 (2)0.727
Gasping1 (1)4 (3)0.068
Cramp2 (1)0 (0)0.244
Triage Vitals
Systolic Blood Pressure (BP) mmHg117.03 ± 36.85126.87 ± 23.830.009*
Diastolic Blood Pressure (BP) mmHg70.59 ± 22.9476.17 ± 14.530.017*
Heart Rate (HR)101.07 ± 35.1699.25 ± 26.450.624
Temperature (Celsius)38.08 ± 4.4537.55 ± 1.40.200

[i] *p < 0.05 indicates statistical significance.

Table 2a

Number of heat‑related diagnoses and management pre‑intervention (2013–2017) and post‑intervention (2018–2022) (n = 308).

PRE‑INTERVENTION (2013–2017) N = 184 (%)POST‑INTERVENTION (2018–2022) N = 124 (%)P‑VALUE
Heat Diagnosis
Total Heat Diagnosis184 (59.7)124 (40.3)0.0008*
Heat Exhaustion63 (34)85 (69)<0.001*
Heat Stroke114 (62)29 (23)<0.001*
Heat Syncope1 (1)0 (0)0.411
Heat Cramp4 (2)0 (0)0.098
Heat Rashes2 (1)5 (4)0.089
Heat intolerance0 (0)1 (1)0.222
Any other heatrelated illness0 (0)4 (3)0.014*
Management
IV Fluid Administration70 (39)82 (66)<0.001*
Sponging42 (23)17 (14)0.046*
Ice Pack2 (1)2 (2)0.689

[i] *p < 0.05 indicates statistical significance.

Table 2b

Yearly trend in the diagnosis of heat‑related illnesses pre‑intervention (2013–2017) and post‑intervention (2018–2022).

YEARHEATH EXHAUSTION 148 (%)HEAT STROKE 143 (%)OTHER HEAT‑RELATED ILLNESSES* 4 (%)
Pre‑Intervention
20130 (0%)1 (1%)0 (0%)
20141 (1%)1 (1%)0 (0%)
201558 (39%)108 (76%)5 (29.5%)
20161 (1%)1 (1%)1 (5.9%)
20173 (2%)3 (2%)1 (5.9%)
Post‑Intervention
201831 (21%)5 (3%)4 (23.5%)
201923 (16%)9 (6%)1 (5.9%)
20208 (5%)2 (1%)1 (5.9%)
202114 (9%)9 (6%)4 (23.5%)
20229 (6%)4 (3%)0 (0%)

[i] *Other HRIs include heat syncope, heat cramps, heat rashes, heat intolerance, and any other heat‑related illness.

aogh-91-1-4749-g1.png
Figure 1

Trends in heat‑related diagnoses and their correlation with maximum average ambient temperature in summer months (May, June, and July) pre‑intervention (2013–2017) and post‑intervention (2018–2022).

aogh-91-1-4749-g2.png
Figure 2

Yearly trends in diagnosis and management of heat‑related illnesses pre‑intervention (2013–2017) and post‑intervention (2018–2022).

Table 3

Patient outcomes for heat‑related illnesses pre‑intervention (2013–2017) and post‑intervention (2018–2022) (n = 308).

PRE‑INTERVENTION (2013–2017) (N = 184)POST‑INTERVENTION (2018–2022) (N = 124)P‑VALUE
ED Disposition
Discharged94 (51)82 (66)
Referral36 (20)25 (20)
Leave against medical advice (LAMA)0 (0)12 (10)<0.001*
Admission49 (27)4 (3)
Expired5 (3)1 (1)
Admissions(n = 49)(n = 4)
HDU/CCU/ICU16 (33)3 (75)0.089
General Ward Adults33 (67)1 (25)
Length of Stay (Median IQR in minutes)148 (1440 ‑ 38)245 (383 ‑ 147)<0.001*
Mortality
ED Mortality5 (3)1 (1)0.234
Hospital Mortality (n = 53)11 (6)2 (2)0.062
Total Mortality16 (9)3 (2)0.025*

[i] HDU/CCU/ICU*= High Dependency Unit, Critical Care Unit, Intensive Care Unit.

Table 4a

Interrupted time series (ITS) analyses from 2013 to 2022 for the months of May to July.

ESTIMATE (β)P‑VALUECI (95%)
Heat Diagnosis–1.63<0.001*–2.28 to −0.99
Heat Exhaustion−0.740.34−2.29 to 0.80
Heat Stroke−4.060.056−8.2 to 0.10
IV Fluids–0.720.09–1.5 to 0.13
Sponging Use–0.510.64–2.70 to 1.68

[i] *Ice pack was not included in this table due to the limited cell count.

Table 4b

Analyses from 2013 to 2022 for the months of May to July excluding the extreme heat days in 2015.

ESTIMATE (β)P‑VALUECI (95%)
Heat Diagnosis2.18<0.001*1.21 to 3.16
Heat Exhaustion0.450.014*0.15 to 0.98
Heat Stroke0.440.081−0.95 to 0.58
IV Fluids2.07<0.001*1.08 to 3.25
Sponging Use1.820.23–1.16 to 4.82

[i] *Ice pack was not included in this table due to the limited cell count.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/aogh.4749 | Journal eISSN: 2214-9996
Language: English
Submitted on: Mar 27, 2025
Accepted on: Aug 20, 2025
Published on: Sep 13, 2025
Published by: Ubiquity Press
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 1 issue per year

© 2025 Uzma Rahim Khan, Syed Ghazanfar Saleem, Aliza Shah, Ahmed Raheem, Muskaan Abdul Qadir, Salima Kerai, Fozia Parveen, Saima Ali, Junaid A. Razzak, Nadeem Ullah Khan, published by Ubiquity Press
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.