An Examination on the Effectiveness of Stakeholder Participation in Urban Planning: A Case Study of Long- Distance Bus Terminal (LDBT) Project, Jaffna
Abstract
Stakeholder participation in urban planning has become central to ensure inclusivity and success. This research aims to examine the effectiveness of stakeholder participation efforts within urban planning in Sri Lanka and its outcomes. Past studies have underscored that urban development projects in Sri Lanka often fall short of expectation due to various reasons including the lack of stakeholder support. Meanwhile, successive governments or responsible planning institutions have historically been reluctant to conduct formal evaluations to identify the reasons for success or failures, with a specific focus on the effective participation of stakeholders in the planning process. This has resulted in a serious lack of empirical evidence for experiential learning and guidance for participatory urban planning in Sri Lanka, despite the availability of wider literature in this field. Moreover, there exists no commonly applicable universal framework for assessing stakeholder engagement in the planning process, resulting in the need to develop contextually fitting evaluation framework. In this study, the researchers address this critical yet often overlooked aspect of systematically evaluating the effectiveness of stakeholder participation in urban planning processes in Sri Lanka by proposing a four phase multi-method evaluation framework, and, applying to a case study of Long-Distance Bus Terminal (LDBT) project in Jaffna. The study assesses the effectiveness of stakeholder participation process incorporated in the overall planning and implementation stages of the project using the framework from both process (procedural) and outcome (substantive) perspectives. The multi-method evaluation framework revealed that while the stakeholder participation process demonstrated procedural strengths—such as accessible formal engagement and active involvement of institutional stakeholders—it fell short in achieving substantive influence, equitable representation, and long-term integration of stakeholder input. This highlights a consistent gap between participation opportunities offered and the actual decision-making power experienced by stakeholders.
© 2025 R. Noordeen, V. Vaikunthanathan, published by Town & Country Planning Research Unit, University of Moratuwa
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 License.