Skip to main content
Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Development of a Culturally Relevant Physical Activity Intervention for Navajo Cancer Survivors Cover

Development of a Culturally Relevant Physical Activity Intervention for Navajo Cancer Survivors

Open Access
|Jun 2019

Figures & Tables

Table 1

Stakeholders in the development of a physical activity (PA) intervention with the Navajo population.

Stakeholder GroupRole
End-Users
  • Cancer survivors

  • Survivor family members and friends

  • Determine need/desire for PA program among Native cancer survivors

  • Describe barriers, facilitators, and preferences for PA intervention

  • Provide ideas for sustainability of the PA intervention

  • Identify gaps in community knowledge related to PA and cancer prevention

  • Participate in and evaluate culturally and clinically tailored cancer survivor PA intervention for Navajo cancer survivors

Governance
  • Institutional Review Boards: Navajo Nation Human Research Review Board

  • Navajo Nation Governmental Organizations: Health Department Agency Councils, Chapter Houses

  • Support planning and implementation of qualitative study and PA intervention including review of protocol as well as providing space for participant consent, focus groups, and interviews

  • Affirm need and community support for program (vote and signed resolutions)

  • Oversee safety for research participants

Influencers
  • National Institute of Health (NIH)

  • Partnership for Native American Cancer Prevention (NACP)

  • Native Community Action Committee

  • Provide funding mechanism, peer review, tracking, and financial support

  • Facilitate understanding of tribal processes, norms, and preferences

  • Provide introduction to other stakeholders

  • Champion program in community

  • Facilitate dissemination of outreach materials and research findings

Providers
  • Local healthcare facilities: Arizona Oncology Associates

  • Community health organizations focused on serving Native Americans locally: Indian Health Services, Tribally directed health facilities (638), Native Americans for Community Action

  • Native serving and/or Native owned fitness facilities

  • University faculty, students, and study staff

  • Facilitate identification of survivors that may benefit from the program

  • Provide space for consent of participants

  • Provide space for PA intervention

  • Increase scope of practice through specific training in cancer exercise

  • Support initiation and implementation of the program

  • Provide coaching throughout intervention, including on-site and at-home (via phone, email, or text depending on participant preference)

  • Facilitate sustainability of the program

Table 2

IM of a PA intervention for Navajo cancer survivors.

Theoretical ConstructIntervention ObjectivesStrategies for Activity or Group SessionsStrategies for Individual Activities
Perceptions (PEN-3)
  • Reinforce accurate beliefs about cancer causes, environmental, and behavioral factors

  • Reduce inaccurate beliefs about cancer

  • Tap into resilience in culture and emphasis on tribal kinship, family, and community support

  • Improve understanding of quantity and intensity of PA. during and after cancer treatment

  • Promote health, fitness, and balance with cultural beliefs

  • Health coaching to increase perceived control over health

  • Provide education about cancer in Navajo and English and disseminate widely across community and partner agencies

  • Facilitate recognition of strength in the community in general and with regard to treatment and health post-diagnosis

  • Personalize the education depending on individuals’ beliefs and level of knowledge

Enablers (PEN-3)/Perceived Barriers (HBM)
  • Decrease structural barriers to seeking treatment where possible (financial, logistic, and cultural)

  • Support local organizations’ capacity to provide services

  • Decrease fear about screening and finding out test results

  • Promote knowledge regarding the U.S. healthcare system (what services are available and where to access services)

  • Reinforce trust of community health representatives

  • Improve skills to promote communication with healthcare providers about cancer among all family members as well as community members

  • Discuss healthy changes that are possible within structural and environmental limitations at the family and individual level

  • Disseminate information about screening recommendations (where to seek treatment and services for translation and patient navigation throughout the community and local organizations)

  • Challenge negative beliefs about screening and learning about results with anecdotes and published data on screening benefits

  • Practice communication with medical providers (role-playing)

  • Practice goal setting and self-monitoring as effective techniques for improving diet and PA

  • Highlight culminating event to facilitate behavioral strategies of (goal-setting/self-monitoring) aimed at engaging entire community

  • Employ local, culturally sensitive partnership and support where possible

  • Educate healthcare providers about Navajo culture and appropriate communication and activities

  • Educate healthcare providers about our program as a resource for their patients

  • Review individual and familial structural barriers and ways to address them

  • Match patients with appropriate local site even if care is received in urban setting (expecting more sites in full project)

  • Engage in personalized goal-setting based on individuals’ activity level with all family members

  • Stepwise approach to reach ACSM cancer survivor exercise targets

  • Be a resource on signs and symptoms for reducing activity/stopping activity/seeking consult with program and/or healthcare provider

  • Review home-based program activities based on activity monitors

  • Practice communication with health provider one-on-one for issues participants are not comfortable discussing in group setting

  • Reinforce progress towards individual and family goals and ability to self-monitor progress

  • Facilitate individuals identifying optimal program for them including: activity choices, group vs. solo activities, and home + center or another site

Nurturers (PEN-3) (Supportive and/or discouraging influences of families and friends including eating tradition, community and events, spirituality and soul, values of friends)
  • Reinforce the value of healthy traditional foods and PA in cancer prevention, prevention of other chronic disease, and overall quality of life

  • Reinforce cultural beliefs of restoring balance and aerobic PA

  • Emphasize importance of and provide skills needed to seek social support at the family and community level

  • Reinforce the importance of information about cancer for family and community members, including appropriate PA recommendations for survivors

  • Discuss cultural aspects of balance, health, physical activity, and dietary habits

  • Share real-life examples of coping strategies gathered from the qualitative study in Navajo cancer survivors

  • Facilitate social support of fellow participants due to shared experiences and success/learned lessons; draw on prior successes

  • Reinforce the cultural value of gaining knowledge for dissemination to other family members (who are generally at elevated risk for cancer) and other members in the local community

  • Reinforce ability and importance of seeking and providing support

  • Provide individualized and family education based on cultural and clinical knowledge of cancer

  • Review success in employing coping strategies

Perceived Susceptibility (HBM)
  • Reinforce accurate beliefs about susceptibility and decrease prevalence of inaccurate beliefs

  • Reduce fatalism about diagnosis and provide more optimistic view

  • Provide and discuss culturally and clinically relevant educational materials about susceptibility, screening, and PA recommendations for cancer survivors

  • Disseminate materials throughout local community organizations and leadership as well as within the family

  • Review knowledge of PA recommendations during and after treatment (back-teaching)

  • Review benefits of activity for each individual and their family members based on type of cancer

Perceived Benefits (HBM)
  • Improve knowledge on the role of PA for several different cancer types and in recurrence for several cancers

  • Improve knowledge on the benefits of PA for fatigue and quality of life among family and community

  • Improve knowledge on the importance of early detection and following treatment and screening recommendations for patient and family members

  • Improve knowledge of adequate intensity required to achieve protective benefits

  • Provide culturally appropriate education to survivors and family/community members on the importance of activity for cancer prevention, control, fatigue, and quality of life

  • Group discussion on benefits of early detection

  • Group discussion on health behaviors currently engaged in/successful changes made in the past

  • Reinforce accurate individual and family beliefs

  • Challenge inaccurate beliefs

  • Review individual list of pros and cons and emphasize individual reason for engaging in healthy behaviors and personal control

Perceived Severity (HBM)
  • Increase knowledge on cancer survival rates, advances in treatment, and the importance of early diagnosis and therapy

  • Provide information that although cancer is a serious condition, survival rates of many cancers have improved, particularly with early diagnosis and adequate treatment

  • Participants develop a list of pros/cons of engaging in regular screening, PA, and healthy/traditional diet

  • Discuss reasons and consequences of engaging in healthy behaviors

  • Challenge inaccurate beliefs

  • Reinforce accurate beliefs through education via teaching, one-on-one conversations, handing out fliers, and encouraging participants to ask questions

Self-Efficacy (HBM)
  • Increase self-efficacy for secondary cancer prevention among patients, family members, and at organizational/community level

  • Increase self-efficacy to engage in behavioral strategies of PA and other health behaviors

  • Increase sense of self-control and self-determination at the community level to improve quality of life and cancer fatigue

  • Increase ability to seek and utilize resources, including social support of peers, family, and community members

  • Empower participants to take control of their own and families’ health

  • Reduce anxiety or discomfort associated with changes among patients, family members, and community members

  • Emphasize opportunity for participants to improve experiences of other family/community members

  • Provide information on baseline activity status and progress towards goals

  • Share successes at the group level and among family/community

  • Offer direct encouragement and positive verbal reinforcement during on-site sessions

  • Draw upon the camaraderie of group sessions to motivate individuals

  • Group discussion on successes achieved to overcome health challenges (e.g., treatment side effects) during and post-treatment

  • Group discussion on influencing family and community members in a positive way with encouraging PA

  • Positive reinforcement of healthy behaviors; draw upon strengths and successes

  • Encourage open and honest communication about challenges, successes, and progress

Table 3

Culturally sensitive elements and dimensions incorporated into PA intervention for Navajo survivors.

InterventionaCulturally sensitive elementsRestoring Balance PA Program
LanguageCulturally appropriate; culturally syntonic language
  • Bilingual students and staff, including bilingual Navajo healthcare worker with deep cultural knowledge to facilitate introductions to the intervention and explanation of the PA program and protocol, consent, and to follow-up with participants throughout the intervention

  • Questionnaires were modified to include cultural activities/terms and eliminate irrelevant activities/terms

  • Intervention materials are developed in Navajo language and different formats (print, video) to be accessible to all family and community members

PersonsRole of ethnic/racial similarities & differences between client & staff in shaping study relationship
  • Native students and staff on intervention team

  • Partnering with Native serving wellness facility for on-site sessions and at-home remote coaching and goal setting

  • Native community action committee, Navajo Nation Human Research Review Board, Navajo Chapter House, Navajo Regional Agency Councils, Native university faculty and leadership for advice and support

  • Include family members in intervention

  • Engage with local community organizations to discuss programming at community level

MetaphorsSymbols & concepts shared with the population; sayings in intervention
  • Native introductions and motivational sayings in introduction to study and in program materials

  • Train Navajo local trainers to deliver program to build capacity and serve as role models

  • Name, logo, and materials incorporate valued natural elements, traditional activities, concept of balance

  • Logo elements include: feathers for blessing and curing; 12 dots for time – days and nights; spiral for four ages of life (infancy, youth, middle, old age); sky band leading to happiness; and feet for walking, which was the most common form of exercise in the qualitative analysis

ContentCultural knowledge: values & traditions; uniqueness of groups (social, economic, historical, & political)
  • Traditions of running, walking, dancing, tending livestock and land for aerobic components

  • Regional SES, history, and politics informed site expansion to trusted Native focused sites which improved proximity, positive community relations, sustainability potential, and incorporated Native employees

  • Cultural values such as peace, balance, and harmony incorporated in PA intervention

  • Varied preference for community vs. at-home and group vs. individual program, thus incorporated flexibility to meet any of these preferences

  • Each participant can tailor to individual exercise preferences and surroundings in consultation with site trainer (e.g., herding sheep, running on open land on the reservation, etc.)

  • Family and friends of the cancer survivors invited to participate in the intervention program alongside survivors to enhance support and reduce perspective of cancer as a contagion

  • Provide materials to easily disseminate content throughout the community and foster sustainability

ConceptsIntervention concepts consonant with culture and context
  • Blending of within culture aerobic activities with additional cancer exercise recommendations for resistance training

  • Focus on the positive effects of PA rather than cancer, which is not a culturally desirable discussion topic

  • Culturally specific motivations for PA, such as “restoring balance” to life, incorporated in intervention materials, rather than other motivations for PA (e.g., weight loss)

  • Program named “Restoring Balance”

  • Focus on the value and uniqueness of tribal kinship and importance of family and community support

GoalsTransmission of positive and adaptive cultural values; support adaptive values from the culture of origin
  • Celebrates and supports Native resilience, resourcefulness, seeking balance in life, especially post-trauma (i.e. cancer and cancer treatment)

  • Partially removes barriers to family and community support for survivors by including family/friends in the program

  • Support Navajo cancer survivor value to help prevent cancer in others through education for community on cancer risk factors, screening, and prevention through outreach materials and inclusion in the intervention

MethodsDevelopment and/or cultural adaptation of intervention methods
  • ACSM cancer exercise guidelines culturally adapted using PEN-3 and Health Belief (HBM) models to understand PA among Navajo survivors and inclusive of elements above

  • PA recommendations for types of activities and settings were modified to fit cultural preferences, habits, and environment (i.e., outdoor walking, home resistance exercises, etc.)

  • Select community organizations were found to be trusted, so these sites will be used for delivering the PA intervention, such as tribal serving health clinic or local community Chapter House

  • Native and Native serving staff and students will be trained to expand scope of practice to cancer exercise and will be used to deliver the intervention

  • Local training to support local community to sustain the intervention once the study is complete

  • The Navajo language will be used in the intervention phase during recruitment and follow up with participants

ContextConsideration of changing contexts in assessment during intervention: social supports and relationship to tribe; economic and social context of intervention
  • Community based program, inclusion of family and friends, to combat reported social isolation

  • Free intervention with reimbursement for time and travel in addition to building of community capacity to ameliorate travel/environmental barriers to PA and promote sustainability in locations proximal to survivors

  • Sites with good tribal relations selected and research team active in communication with stakeholders and maintaining good tribal relations to address mistrust of Western medicine among some survivors and community members

[i] a Adapted from Bernal, Bonilla & Bernillo, 1995

DOI: https://doi.org/10.33596/coll.40 | Journal eISSN: 2638-4396
Language: English
Page range: 15 - 15
Published on: Jun 13, 2019
Published by: University of Miami Libraries
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services

© 2019 Hendrik D. de Heer, Jennifer Bea, Brian Kinslow, Ravina Thuraisingam, Luis Valdez, Etta Yazzie, Anna L. Schwartz, published by University of Miami Libraries
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.