Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Comprehensive Assessment of Meta-Analysis and Contingent Valuation Technique for Sustainable Management of Wetland of Middle Ganga Plain Cover

Comprehensive Assessment of Meta-Analysis and Contingent Valuation Technique for Sustainable Management of Wetland of Middle Ganga Plain

Open Access
|Jun 2022

Figures & Tables

Fig. 1

Location of Suraha Tal Wetland in Uttar Pradesh, India.Source: own study.
Location of Suraha Tal Wetland in Uttar Pradesh, India.Source: own study.

Fig. 2

The number of people willing to pay.
The number of people willing to pay.

Fig. 3

The application of CMA to draw out the environmental value.CMA – comprehensive meta-analysis.Source: own study.
The application of CMA to draw out the environmental value.CMA – comprehensive meta-analysis.Source: own study.

Major functions of Suraha Tal Wetland_

People’s perception of functions of Suraha TalStrongly acceptedModerately acceptedAccepted in weak mannerNot accepted
Fishing is one of important functions of Suraha Tal5622184
Water of Suraha Tal is used for irrigation puposes573193
Suraha Tal is also useful for agriculture543286
Aquaculture is popular function in Suraha Tal5630104
Suraha Tal is useful for water drainage5230810
Suraha Tal controls flood50331710
Suraha Tal helps to purify air4238128
Water of Suraha Tal is used for household works5622184
Suraha Tal is popular tourist destination5823172
Suraha tal helps to maintain flora and fauna diversity4032317
Mean52.129.314.85.8
Median543014.85.8
Standard deviation5.7541223694.8104920056.3931781822.586679163

Steps followed for the valuation of the wetland_

ActivitiesMethods
Making checklist of use and non-use values of wetlandObservation of functions, discussions with stakeholders and local communities, review of related literature
Point out important use and non-use valuesRanking of goods, services and threats by stakeholders and local communities
Selection of valuation techniqueReview of literature related to wetland valuation and selection of most efficient technique
Questions set upPreparation of questionnaires for stakeholders, local communities and govt. officials
Collection of dataSurvey (household/govt. offices/tourists), market survey for valuation of goods
Quantification of values of goods and servicesAnalysis

Different types of ecosystem services provided by wetlands_

Ecosystem servicesExamples
Provisioning services
FoodManufacturing of fish, wild game, fruits and grains
Fresh waterStorage of water for domestic, industrial and agricultural use
Fibre and fuelProduction of logs, fuel wood, peat, fodder
BiochemicalMedicines extraction and other materials from biota
Genetic materialsGenes for resistance to plant pathogens, ornamental species and so on
Regulating services
Climate regulationStorages of greenhouse gases; influence local and regional temperature, precipitation, and other climatic processes
Water regulationGroundwater extraction rate and recharge
Water purification and waste water treatmentRetention, recovery and removal of excess nutrients and other pollutants
Erosion regulationRetention of soils and sediments
Natural hazard regulationManagement of flood control, storm protection
PollinationHabitat for pollinators
Cultural services
Spiritual and inspirationalSource of inspiration; many religions attach spiritual and religious values to aspects of wetland ecosystems
RecreationalOpportunities for recreational activities
AestheticMany people find beauty or aesthetic value in aspects of wetland ecosystems
EducationalOpportunities for formal and informal education and training
Supporting services
Soil formationSediment retention and accumulation of organic matter
Nutrient cyclingStorage, recycling, processing, and acquisition of nutrients

Pearson’s correlation among the indicators_

WTPAGEEDUFAMINCDISENVLND
WTP10.420.950.310.840.340.750.82
AGE0.4210.72−0.340.68−0.22−0.180.82
EDU0.950.721−0.250.86−0.640.210.75
FAM0.31−0.34−0.2510.760.660.810.92
INC0.840.680.860.7610.97−0.350.89
DIS0.34−0.22−0.640.660.971−0.510.64
ENV0.75−0.180.210.81−0.35−0.5110.56
LND0.520.820.750.920.890.640.561

Total valuation of water lily in Suraha Tal Wetland in 2015_

Ingredients of water lilyMarket priceProduction of last yearTotal market price
Water lily flowerINR 20 × kg−1244.75 kgINR 4,895
Water lily rootINR 30 × kg−1326.34 kgINR 9,790

Major threats of Suraha Tal Wetland_

People’s perceptionStrongly acceptedModerately acceptedAccepted in weak mannerNot accepted
Water holding capacity is decreased by sedimentation of Suraha Tal4530205
Household sewage increases eutrophication in Suraha Tal5230810
Overfishing destroys the fish diversity in Suraha Tal4233187
Excessive aquaculture destroys the balance of ecosystem of Suraha Tal4032317
Solid waste is dumped in Suraha Tal4628197
Agricultural washout decreases water quality5525128
Flora and fauna diversity of Suraha Tal is at risk3235120
Suraha Tal is shrinking by size5228128
Mean45.530.12516.6259
Median45.53015.57.5
Standard deviation7.559293.181987.130174.65986

Total value of lotus and associated parts in Suraha Tal Wetland in 2015_

Ingredients of lotusMarket priceProduction of last yearTotal price
Lotus flowerINR 2 × piece−1650,000 flowersINR 1,300,000
PetalsINR 30 × kg−174 kgINR 2,220
StamenINR 200 × kg−143 kgINR 8,600
LeafINR 300 × hundred leaves−12,700 leavesINR 8,100
RootINR 25 × kg−162 kgINR 1,550

List of literature included for CMA_

Study nameYear of publication (number of observation)
Fish diversity
Singh et al.2009 (42)
Swarup and Singh1975 (52)
Singh et al.2012 (56)
Pandey et al.2010 (59)
Lakshman Ram1976 (48)
Srivastava and Srivastava2009 (53)
Water quality
Shukla et al.2015 (20)
Pandey et al.2015 (20)
Mishra and Sharma2015 (22)
Mishra et al.2015 (24)
Sharma and Soni2013 (96)
Other faunal diversity
Sharma and Agarwal (a)2012 (29)
Sharma and Agarwal (b)2012 (20)
Srivastava and Srivastava2012(92)
Cultural aspects
Srivastava and Srivastava2012 (7)

Explanatory indicators for willingness to pay_

No.IndicatorsExplanation of indicators
1AGERespondent’s age
2EDURespondent’s education level
3FAMRespondent’s family size or number of family members
4INCFamily’s annual income
5DISDistance of respondent’s home from Suraha Tal Wetland
6ENVWhether respondent is part of eco-development community or not
7LNDFamily’s total landholding size

Valuation of the market price of fish production in Suraha Tal Wetland in 2015_

SeasonProduction of fishTotal market price of fish
Pre-monsoon2,000 kgINR 250,000
Monsoon5,000 kgINR 2,250,000
Post-monsoon3,000 kgINR 750,000

Total valuation of cultivated crops_

Cultivated cropsProduction in last year (in kg)Total profit (INR)
Wheat24240,522
Arahar24723,269
Peas26532,466
Maize22920,795
Gram22227,284
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/quageo-2022-0015 | Journal eISSN: 2081-6383 | Journal ISSN: 2082-2103
Language: English
Page range: 153 - 165
Submitted on: Aug 19, 2021
|
Published on: Jun 24, 2022
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 4 issues per year
Related subjects:

© 2022 Malabika Biswas Roy, Abhishek Kumar, Debanjana Chatterjee, Sudipa Halder, published by Adam Mickiewicz University
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.