Skip to main content
Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Analysing (In)Justice in the Interplay of Urbanisation and Transport: The Case of Agrarian Extractivism in the Region of Urabá in Colombia Cover

Analysing (In)Justice in the Interplay of Urbanisation and Transport: The Case of Agrarian Extractivism in the Region of Urabá in Colombia

Open Access
|Jun 2021
Read online

Figures & Tables

Fig. 1

Location of the region of Urabá in Colombia.

Source: own compilation.

Table. 1

Agrarian extractivist actors, their techno-political frames and (in)justices.

Dominant extractivist regimeSystemic conflicts
Actors and relevant social groups
  • – Spanish colony

  • – Rubber companies (Goodyear)

  • – Vegetable ivory companies (German companies)

  • – Marine transport companies (Pacific Steam Navigation Co. and Pacific Railroad Co.)

  • – Banana companies (Banacol, Uniban, Augura, etc)

  • – Port concession of Colombia

  • – Port areas in Urabá

  • – Local political institutions of Urabá

  • – Colombian government

  • – U.S. Government

  • – ANI (Asociación Nacional de Insfraestructura)

  • – PIO SAS (Puertos, Inversions y Obras S.A.)

  • – Landlord's militias

  • – Colombia's Ministry of Transport

  • – Freight transport companies

  • – Paramilitary groups

  • – Indigenous groups

  • – Rural peasant communities (local banana producers)

  • – Low-income groups

  • – Rural day labourers (colonos)

  • – UFCO employees

  • – Self-defence communities

  • – Political parties (Socialist Revolutionary Party, Communist Party and UNIR)

  • – Guerilla groups

Techno-political frames
  • – Developmental model oriented to maximising productivity, profits and efficiency of banana production

  • – Harvests of banana companies tend to have little or no processing.

  • – Governmental regulations related to mineral and oil extraction rather than to agricultural extraction

  • – UFCO territorial control systems of getting lands

  • – Agricultural landscapes revealed a huge potentiality, mainly for foreign companies

  • – Transport infrastructures planned and built focusing on the performance of the transport systems related to agro-extractivism without thinking of needs of inhabitants

  • – Ineffective land reforms due to corruption within government institutions

  • – Government of Colombia de-emphasised land reform and shifted focus to rural development through agribusiness.

  • – Law 200 (eviction of tenant farmers indiscriminately)

  • – Transport infrastructures as crucial instruments in the context of rapid economic globalisation

  • – Military violence (pre-existing power structure approved by the state)

  • – Developmental model is not being driven by principles of social and environmental well-being

  • – Little job creation for local comunities by banana companies as the harvests produced do not require much processing

  • – Societal fragmentation

  • – Rural peasants migration to agro-extractivist areas in search of better opportunities, since they were suffering huge challenges related to unemployment and lack of basic services in their rural areas

  • – Local population without an income and more likely to rely on informal, survivalist strategies

  • – Exclusion of low class population from the qualities and benefits of urban life.

  • – Urban inequity and rise to high concentrations of poverty

Urban, rural and transport (in)justices
  • – Almost all transport infrastructures and heavy machinery are related to banana production

  • – Traditional planning refrained from coordinating existing urban, transport and traffic dynamics

  • – In harvesting period families arrived and settled in private properties in temporary shelters

  • – Urban and transport planning was based on providing a better connection of the agro-extractivist region with Medellín and the main production and consumption centres of the country

  • – Transport infrastructures that support export-oriented industries

  • – La vía al mar provided a higher monocrop productivity of banana production.

  • – Road insfrastructure (4-lane design, targeted mode and type of transport, trajectory, materiality, required size of investment, etc)

  • – Urban fragmentation related to the social division of labour

  • – Inadequate provision of public services

  • – Fundamental changes related to excessive population growth rates

  • – Excessive use of available resources, in particular water resources

  • – Mobilisation of entire groups of families along the rivers and mountains of the region, establishing new urban and rural settlements

  • – Migrant influx led to an embryonic market for informal settlements in urban areas

  • – Planning and design of transport infrastructural projects propagate an unfair distribution of accessibility

  • – Changes to the rural landscape (areas accommodated different human behaviours and activities for land-use practices)

  • – Rural peasants lacking sufficient basic services provoked a constant migration of its population to the agricultural lands

  • – Small farms were replaced by large-scale agro-extractivist infrastructures (illegally appropriation)

  • – Urban clusters became concentrations of unplanned settlements

  • – Urban settlements located in protected areas and areas risking flooding

  • – Transport infrastructures contributing to the increase of traffic congestion in urban areas and excessive demand for the capacity of the road

  • – Overcrowded concentration of informal commercial activities along the highway

  • – Urban areas became a transit zone

[i] Source: own compilation.

Fig. 2

Period 1: El camino de occidente, the first infrastructure that supported extractivism.

Source: own compilation.

Fig. 3

Period 2: Tagua exploitation led to the emergence of the municipality of Apartadó.

Source: own compilation.

Fig. 4

Period 3: The natural and artificial infrastructures of the region resulted in the establishment of important precedents for the future.

Source: own compilation.

Fig. 5

Period 4: Designing a regional highway La vía al mar.

Source: own compilation.

Fig. 6

Period 5: The consolidation of the banana industry.

Source: own compilation.

Fig. 7

Period 6: The conflict.

Source: own compilation.

Fig. 8

Period 7: The post-conflict.

Source: own compilation.

Fig. 9

Location of Apartadó within the region of Urabá.

Source: own compilation.

Photo. 1

Informal urban settlements in the municipality of Apartadó.

Source: photo taken by the author.

Photo 2

Overlap of transport systems in the municipality of Apartadó.

Source: photo taken by the author.

Photo 3

Lack of infrastructure for pedestrians.

Source: photo taken by the author.

Fig. 10

Basic section of the proposed Transversal de las Américas. Lack of spaces for soft transport systems.

Source: own compilation based on Agencia Nacional de Infraestructura (ANI) data.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/quageo-2021-0011 | Journal eISSN: 2081-6383 | Journal ISSN: 2082-2103 (formerly 0137-477X)
Language: English
Page range: 35 - 61
Submitted on: Dec 17, 2020
Published on: Jun 30, 2021
Published by: Adam Mickiewicz University
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Related subjects:

© 2021 Maritza Toro López, Pieter Van den Broeck, published by Adam Mickiewicz University
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 License.