Addressing problems of practice: Leadership practices, instructional capacity, and teacher collective efficacy through Professional Learning Communities in the United States
Abstract
This qualitative action research study examined how iterative professional learning community (PLC) cycles influenced instructional capacity and collective teacher efficacy in a high-needs Title I elementary school in the southeastern United States. In the United States, Title I schools receive additional federal funding to support students from economically disadvantaged communities, often requiring school leaders to implement targeted strategies for continuous school improvement. Grounded in Bandura’s (1986) social cognitive theory and informed by Dewitt’s (2019) Collective Efficacy Cycle, the study explored how school leaders structured collaborative planning processes to support novice and veteran teachers. The study focused on three research questions related to leadership support for collaborative planning, teacher perceptions of the influence of PLCs on instructional practice, and the learning generated through the action research process. Data collection included semi-structured interviews, focus groups, collaborative planning observations, teacher efficacy surveys, researcher reflections, and artifact analysis. Findings suggested that structured collaborative norms, iterative reflection, and shared leadership strengthened teacher confidence, instructional responsiveness, and collaborative problem solving. Teachers reported that PLC participation enhanced instructional preparedness and created opportunities for shared accountability and collective learning. The study contributes to the growing body of international research demonstrating how instructional leadership and collaborative professional learning can strengthen teacher practice and support continuous school improvement in complex school settings.
© 2026 Aliceson Nobles, Jami Royal Berry, published by New Zealand Educational Administration and Leadership Society
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 License.
