A new approach to compare the scientific impact of scholars

Bihari, Anand; Tripathi, Sudhakar; Deepak, Akshay; Kumar, P. Mohan

A new approach to compare the scientific impact of scholars

Journal of Data and Information Science

Volume 10 (2025): Issue 2 (April 2025)

By:

Anand Bihari, Sudhakar Tripathi, Akshay Deepak and P. Mohan Kumar

Open Access

|May 2025

Figures & Tables

The last five year cumulative h-index, EM-index, and EM’-index of scholar ID 37, 54, and 2.

The cumulative h-index, EM-index, and EM’-index of scholar ID 37, 54, and 2.

The cumulative h-index, EM-index, and EM’-index of scholar ID 23, 57, 8, and 85.

The cumulative h-index, EM-index, and EM0-index of scholar ID 70 and 32.

The cumulative h-index, EM-index and EM’-index for 19 randomly selected scholars.

Year wise cumulative h-index of scholars.

Year wise cumulative EM-index of scholars.

Statistics of the dataset (dataset ref_ Bihari and Tripathi (2018))_

ID	Name	Starting Year	First Citation Year	Total Publication	Total Citation Count	Avg. Citation	Total Career
1	Adamantios Diamantopoulos	2005	2007	55	1,974	35.89	13
2	Albert Zomaya	2006	2006	291	2,306	7.92	12
3	Alireza Abbasi	2006	2007	170	1,060	6.24	12
4	András Schubert	2006	2006	41	797	19.44	12
5	András Telcs	2000	2001	18	89	4.94	18
6	Andreas Thor	2007	2007	51	526	10.31	11
7	Andrew D. Jackson	2006	2007	26	326	12.54	12
8	Anne-Wil Harzing	2007	2008	47	1,333	28.36	11
9	Aric Hagberg	2002	2003	24	504	21.00	16
10	Barry Bozeman	2006	2007	64	1,177	18.39	12
11	Ben R Martin	2007	2008	25	405	16.20	11
12	Benny Lautrup	2006	2007	5	190	38.00	12
13	Berwin Turlach	2007	2008	16	73	4.56	11
14	Birger Larsen	2006	2006	48	200	4.17	12
15	Blaise Cronin	2006	2006	53	765	14.43	12
16	C Lee Giles	2006	2008	91	574	6.31	12
17	Carlos Pecharroman	2006	2007	36	708	19.67	12
18	Caroline S. Wagner	2008	2009	15	320	21.33	10
19	Christoph Bartneck	2007	2009	63	477	7.57	11
20	Claes Wohlin	2006	2007	68	674	9.91	12
21	Clint D. Kelly	2006	2007	35	525	15.00	12
22	Dimitrios Katsaros	2006	2008	54	680	12.59	12
23	Egghe Leo	1997	1998	181	2,549	14.08	21
24	Elizabeth A. Corley	2006	2007	37	692	18.70	12
25	Erhard Rahm	2006	2007	50	622	12.44	12
26	Fiorenzo Franceschini	2006	2009	66	374	5.67	12
27	Fred Y.	2006	2007	43	227	5.28	12
28	Gad Saad	2006	2006	27	308	11.41	12
29	Gangan Prathap	2006	2008	105	353	3.36	12
30	Gary M. Olson	2007	2013	6	13	2.17	11
31	Gerhard Woeginger	2006	2006	124	618	4.98	12
32	Guang-Hong Yang	2006	2007	424	3,753	8.85	12
33	Heidi Winklhofer	2006	2008	12	138	11.50	12
34	Hendrik P. van Dalen	2006	2007	23	326	14.17	12
35	Henk F. Moed	2007	2008	37	798	21.57	11
36	Herbert Van de Sompel	2006	2006	5	45	9.00	12
37	Hirsch J. E.	1989	1990	121	5,963	49.28	29
38	James Moody	2006	2007	52	690	13.27	12
39	Jayant Vaidya	2006	2006	39	1,027	26.33	12
40	Jerome Vanclay	2006	2006	42	1,151	27.40	12
41	Johan Bollen	2006	2006	33	1,449	43.91	12
42	John Irvine	2000	2002	267	4,530	16.97	18
43	Judit Bar-Ilan	2006	2007	72	926	12.86	12
44	Kène Henkens	2007	2008	57	847	14.86	11
45	Loet Leydesdorff	2006	2007	232	4,624	19.93	12
46	Lokman Meho	2006	2006	16	907	56.69	12
47	Luca Mastrogiacomo	2009	2009	48	244	5.08	9
48	Ludo Waltman	2006	2007	69	1,899	27.52	12
49	Lutz bornmann	2006	2006	234	3,534	15.10	12
50	Maisano, Domenico A.	2009	2010	5	75	15.00	9
51	Marek Kosmulski	2005	2006	64	817	12.77	13
52	Maria Bordons	2007	2008	43	552	12.84	11
53	Mark Ffine	2006	2007	12	158	13.17	12
54	Mark Newman	2003	2006	213	2,475	11.62	15
55	Mathieu Ouimet	2007	2008	40	467	11.68	11
56	Matjaž Perc	2006	2006	215	9,754	45.37	12
57	Matthew O. Jackson	2006	2007	56	1,559	27.84	12
58	Mauno Vihinen	2002	2006	107	2,625	24.53	16
59	Michael Jennions	2006	2007	98	2,445	24.95	12
60	Michael L. Nelson	2005	2007	45	52	1.16	13
61	Miguel A. García-Pérez	2005	2007	70	729	10.41	13
62	Morten Schmidt	2009	2010	104	1,167	11.22	9
63	Nees Jan van Eck	2006	2007	61	1,664	27.28	12
64	Nils T. Hagen	2008	2009	11	145	13.18	10
65	Olle Persson	2006	2008	18	153	8.50	12
66	Paul Wouters	2006	2007	30	406	13.53	12
67	Peter Jacso	2006	2006	69	677	9.81	12
68	Raf Guns	2009	2009	27	158	5.85	9
69	Raj Kumar Pan	2006	2007	26	463	17.81	12
70	Richard S J Tol	1999	2001	174	3,327	19.12	19
71	Roberto Todeschini	2006	2007	51	1,415	27.75	12
72	Robin hankin	2007	2008	15	149	9.93	11
73	Rodrigo Costas	2007	2008	49	717	14.63	11
74	Ronald Rousseau	1993	1994	546	9,905	18.14	25
75	Ruediger mutz	2007	2007	43	968	22.51	11
76	Santo Fortunato	2006	2007	56	8,441	150.73	12
77	Serge Galam	2006	2007	30	480	16.00	12
78	Sergio Alonso	2006	2007	79	1,325	16.77	12
79	Steve Lawrence	2006	2006	12	118	9.83	12
80	Sune Lehmann	2006	2006	18	832	46.22	12
81	Terttu Luukkonen	2007	2010	6	78	13.00	11
82	Vicenç	2006	2007	148	1,460	9.86	12
83	Walter W (Woody) Powell	2006	2007	12	591	49.25	12
84	Werner Marx	2006	2008	61	635	10.41	12
85	Wolfgang Glänzel	2006	2006	95	1,268	13.35	12
86	Yannis Manolopoulos	2006	2007	89	850	9.55	12
87	Ying Ding	2005	2007	517	3,965	7.67	13
88	Yu-Hsin Liu	2006	2007	28	159	5.68	12
89	Yvonne Rogers	2003	2004	47	539	11.47	15

Publication and citation history of Author Luca Mastrogiacomo (ID=47)_

Article	2009	2010	2011	2012	2013	2014	2015	2016	2017
1	0	0	0	0	9	18	28	39	42
2	2	9	11	11	11	15	17	18	18
3	0	0	0	0	8	13	14	17	17
4	1	4	6	6	7	11	11	15	15
5	0	0	1	3	4	8	11	12	12
6	0	0	0	0	0	2	5	11	11
7	0	2	4	4	5	6	7	8	9
8	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	8	8
9	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	7	8
10	0	0	0	0	0	0	3	8	8
11	0	1	2	3	5	7	7	8	8
12	0	0	0	0	0	0	2	6	7
13	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	7	7
14	0	0	0	0	0	0	2	6	7
15	0	2	3	4	4	5	5	7	7
16	0	0	0	0	2	5	6	7	7
17	1	2	3	3	5	5	7	7	7
18	0	1	2	3	4	4	4	6	6
19	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	4	5
20	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	5	5
21	0	0	0	0	0	2	2	4	5
22	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	1	3
23	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	2	3
24	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	2	2
25	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	2	2
26	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	2	2
27	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	1	2
28	0	0	0	0	0	1	1	2	2
29	0	0	0	0	0	2	2	2	2
30	0	0	0	0	2	2	2	2	2
31	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	1
32	0	0	0	0	0	0	1	1	1
33	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	1	1
34	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	1	1
35	0	0	0	0	0	1	1	1	1
h	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	8
EM	1	2.24	2.45	2.65	3	4	4.12	4.24	4.24
EM’	1.73	3.16	3.46	3.46	4.24	5.1	5.83	6.78	6.86

Comparative statistics of 19 randomly selected scholar data with scientometric publications only_

S1. No	Name	Whole Data						Scientometrics Only
S1. No	Name	Starting Year	First Citation Year	Total Pub	Toatl Citation Count	Avg. Citation	Total Career	Starting Year	First Citation Year	Total Pub	Toatl Citation Count	Avg. Citation	Total Career
1	Caroline S. Wagner	2008	2009	15	320	21.33	10	2008	2009	11	299	27.18	10
2	Christoph Bartneck	2007	2009	63	477	7.57	11	2010	2011	5	84	16.8	8
3	Egghe Leo	1997	1998	181	2,549	14.08	21	1998	1998	83	1,943	23.41	20
4	Fiorenzo Franceschini	2006	2009	66	374	5.67	12	2006	2009	32	185	5.78	12
5	Fred Y.	2006	2007	43	227	5.28	12	2006	2007	35	208	5.94	12
6	Gad Saad	2006	2006	27	308	11.41	12	2006	2006	2	82	41	12
7	Gangan Prathap	2006	2008	105	353	3.36	12	2006	2007	43	206	4.79	12
8	Hirsche	1989	1990	121	5,963	49.28	29	2005	2005	4	3,007	751.75	13
9	Loet Leydesdorff	2006	2007	232	4,624	19.93	12	2006	2007	167	3,280	19.64	12
10	Luca Mastrogiacomo	2009	2009	48	244	5.08	9	2012	2013	14	69	4.93	6
11	Ludo Waltman	2006	2007	69	1,899	27.52	12	2007	2008	57	1,727	30.30	11
12	Lutz bornmann	2006	2006	234	3,534	15.10	12	2006	2006	227	3,422	15.07	12
13	Marek Kosmulski	2005	2006	64	817	12.77	13	2009	2010	13	56	4.31	9
14	Miguel A.	2005	2007	70	729	10.41	13	2009	2009	8	107	13.375	9
15	Peter Jacso	2006	2006	69	677	9.81	12	2006	2006	69	677	9.81	12
16	Raf Guns	2009	2009	27	158	5.85	9	2009	2009	27	158	5.85	9
17	Richard S J Tol	1999	2001	174	3,327	19.12	19	2008	2008	8	142	17.75	10
18	Ronald Rouseau	1993	1994	546	9,905	18.14	25	1998	1999	78	1,401	17.96	20
19	Wolfgang Glänzel	2006	2006	95	1,268	13.35	12	2006	2006	61	945	15.49	12

h-index, EM-index and EM’-index of all scholars (dataset ref_ Bihari and Tripathi (2018))_

ID	h-index	EM-index	EM’-index	ID	h-index	EM-index	EM’-index
1	23	17.69	21.47	46	9	12.65	19.13
2	25	10.82	15.36	47	8	4.24	6.86
3	16	8.12	11.79	48	24	12.25	15.78
4	13	10.15	15.43	49	34	13.49	16.40
5	4	4.69	5.20	50	4	4.80	5.66
6	11	8.43	9.33	51	10	13.08	13.67
7	5	8.37	11.62	52	13	8.12	12.41
8	20	10.49	16.16	53	5	5.57	9.17
9	11	9.27	12.21	54	28	11.40	17.18
10	16	11.31	12.12	55	11	7.75	8.72
11	11	7.94	8.31	56	56	19.34	26.98
12	3	1.00	2.24	57	20	12.25	13.42
13	5	3.16	4.36	58	24	16.79	17.72
14	8	4.47	6.32	59	23	16.64	17.92
15	13	10.10	12.61	60	4	3.32	4.00
16	16	6.24	8.37	61	17	6.24	8.89
17	13	9.59	11.31	62	14	11.87	16.82
18	7	10.15	11.62	63	22	12.25	15.78
19	8	7.87	13.11	64	7	5.92	6.40
20	14	7.35	9.38	65	6	6.16	7.07
21	12	7.87	10.58	66	9	9.06	10.82
22	12	11.40	13.56	67	14	8.54	9.59
23	20	15.39	24.47	68	7	4.90	6.16
24	15	8.19	9.06	69	12	7.94	8.31
25	13	8.94	9.64	70	33	13.19	15.87
26	10	5.74	8.06	71	17	13.42	14.21
27	8	4.80	6.48	72	6	5.57	7.35
28	10	6.78	8.66	73	15	8.12	12.41
29	9	6.08	8.66	74	47	16.00	26.83
30	2	1.73	3.16	75	15	9.64	13.53
31	13	6.56	9.80	76	27	35.44	49.92
32	32	11.62	18.00	77	11	10.68	12.37
33	6	5.48	5.74	78	14	15.81	16.06
34	11	6.40	7.14	79	5	6.16	6.24
35	16	9.11	14.21	80	8	11.62	22.74
36	4	3.46	4.24	81	5	4.36	5.20
37	28	35.30	51.08	82	14	15.33	23.04
38	14	8.12	12.17	83	8	11.31	12.41
39	12	13.67	18.08	84	15	6.93	8.66
40	17	12.29	13.64	85	20	10.15	15.43
41	12	13.67	25.53	86	15	10.30	11.36
42	41	12.37	16.88	87	31	10.77	18.47
43	15	10.58	14.63	88	7	5.48	5.83
44	16	8.54	9.70	89	12	7.75	9.43
45	38	11.83	17.12

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/jdis-2025-0013 | Journal eISSN: 2543-683X | Journal ISSN: 2096-157X

Journal RSS Feed

Language: English

Page range: 40 - 60

Submitted on: Sep 19, 2024

Accepted on: Dec 23, 2024

Published on: May 6, 2025

Published by: Chinese Academy of Sciences, National Science Library

In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services

Publication frequency: 4 times per year

Keywords:

h-index,

Scientific comparison,

Research impact

Related subjects:

Computer sciences,

Information technology,

Project management,

Databases and data mining

© 2025 Anand Bihari, Sudhakar Tripathi, Akshay Deepak, P. Mohan Kumar, published by Chinese Academy of Sciences, National Science Library
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.

Previous article Volume 10 (2025): Issue 2 (April 2025)Next article

A new approach to compare the scientific impact of scholars

Figures & Tables

Figure 1.

Figure 2.

Figure 3.

Figure 4.

Figure 5.

Figure 6.

Figure 7.

Figure 8.

Statistics of the dataset (dataset ref_ Bihari and Tripathi (2018))_

Publication and citation history of Author Luca Mastrogiacomo (ID=47)_

Comparative statistics of 19 randomly selected scholar data with scientometric publications only_

h-index, EM-index and EM’-index of all scholars (dataset ref_ Bihari and Tripathi (2018))_

Paradigm

My account