Editorial board publication strategy and acceptance rates in Turkish national journals

Tutuncu, Lokman

doi:10.2478/jdis-2023-0019

Figures & Tables

Journals with the lowest acceptance rates_

Name	N	AR	INSD.	SSCI	ISRA1	CIT.	Field	Index
Psikoloji Calismalari	178	12%	22	42	0.34	77.44	FEF	ESCI
Sanat ve Tasarim D.	22	14%	13	0	1	0	Art	TR
Balikesir SBED	169	18%	23	5	0.82	23.13	GSS	TR
Istanbul Business Res.	140	18%	12	6	0.67	12	FEAS	ESCI
Kuramsal Egitimbilim	211	19%	4	4	0.5	18.5	Educ	TR
Akdeniz Sanat Dergisi	80	20%	46	0	1	0	Art	TR
Uls. Yon. Iktisat ve Isl.	185	22%	27	18	0.6	41.67	FEAS	TR
Erzincan Egitim Fak.	128	24%	22	22	0.5	17.06	Educ	TR
Akademik Incelemeler	97	24%	4	4	0.5	1	GSS	TR
Sosyal Bilimler Aras.	76	24%	36	11	0.76	8.79	GSS	TR
Siyasal: J. of Pol. Sci.	106	25%	12	4	0.75	13.6	FEAS	ESCI
Sakarya Ilahiyat Fak.	111	25%	6	2	0.75	2.67	Theo.	ESCI
Dil Dergisi	16	25%	11	10	0.52	11.14	FEF	TR
Eskisehir OGU IIBF	148	26%	58	8	0.88	8.25	FEAS	ESCI
Econ. Culture & Soc.	144	27%	30	56	0.35	265.1	FEF	ESCI
Darulfunun Ilahiyat	116	29%	12	2	0.85	0	Theo.	SCOPUS
Ege Egitim Dergisi	95	29%	44	48	0.48	39.5	Educ.	TR
Humanitas	125	29%	72	0	1	0	GSS	TR
Ege Academic Review	132	29%	10	30	0.25	49.4	FEAS	ESCI
Litera: Dil, Edebiyat	110	29%	68	0	1	0.09	FEF	ESCI
Trabzon Ilahiyat	101	30%	15	0	1	0.09	Theo.	TR
B. Ecevit Ilahiyat	51	31%	5	1	0.83	0	Theo.	TR
KTU SBE Sos. Bil.	67	31%	12	19	0.38	47.91	GSS	TR
Anadolu Educ. Sci.	56	34%	5	4	0.56	29	Educ.	TR
Ankara Egitim Bil.	70	34%	11	14	0.44	28.67	Educ.	TR
Anadolu Uni. SBD	246	34%	92	26	0.78	40.82	GSS	TR
AYNA Klinik Psik.	73	34%	43	93	0.32	110.5	FEF	TR
Total (Average)	3,053	(26%)	715	429	(0.66)	(31.3)

Robustness tests_

Variable	Probit	Heckman1	Heckman2	Heckman3	Heckman4
AGE	0.694***
AGE	[3.42]
FEMALE	0.994**
FEMALE	[2.48]
ENGLISH	0.818**
ENGLISH	[2.34]
SSCI		-0.208**	-0.228**
SSCI		(-2.34)	(-2.56)
INSIDER			0.218**
INSIDER			(2.12)
ISRA1				0.872***
			(3.14)
CITATION					-0.064*
CITATION					(-1.75)
WOSS		-0.297**	-0.314**	-0.307**	-0.288*
WOSS		(-1.99)	(-2.17)	(-2.11)	(-1.91)
SUBMIT		-0.206**	-0.204**	-0.205**	-0.201**
SUBMIT		(-2.44)	(-2.37)	(-2.39)	(-2.39)
Inverse Mills		0.309***	0.287***	0.285***	0.324***
Inverse Mills		(3.17)	(2.87)	(2.95)	(3.37)
Controls	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Constant	-3.997**	0.287	0.053	-0.52	0.225
Constant	[-5.53]	(0.61)	(0.11)	(-1.05)	(0.48)
F/χ²	22.54***	7.75***	7.29***	8.71***	7.09***
R²	17.26	20.1	22.11	23.04	19.49
N	216	216	216	216	216

Journals with the largest acceptance rates_

Name	N	AR	INSD.	SSCI	ISRA1	CIT.	Field	Index
KSU Sosyal Bilimler	141	91%	67	6	0.92	10.56	GSS	TR
Gumushane Ilahiyat	37	89%	16	0	1	0	Theo.	TR
Mavi Atlas	42	88%	11	0	1	0	FEF	TR
SDU FEF Dergisi	73	88%	49	5	0.91	3.6	FEF	TR
Nevşehir HBVU SBE	231	84%	3	0	1	0.4	GSS	TR
Inonu Egitim Fak.	107	83%	49	1	0.98	0	Educ.	TR
Karen-Karadeniz Ar.	40	83%	3	0	1	0	GSS	TR
Cukurova Ilahiyat	78	83%	31	7	0.82	7	Theo.	TR
Ataturk Yolu Dergisi	47	83%	117	6	0.95	0.36	FEF	TR
Omer Halisdemir IIBF	85	82%	28	4	0.88	9.75	FEAS	TR
Dicle IIBF Dergisi	52	81%	43	10	0.81	6.25	FEAS	TR
Sanat Tarihi Yilligi	21	81%	19	3	0.86	2.57	FEF	ESCI
Cedrus: Akdeniz Uyg.	31	81%	49	50	0.49	236.6	FEF	TR
Yildirim Bey. Hukuk	66	80%	22	0	1	0	Law	TR
Hacett. Hukuk Fak.	91	80%	0	1	0	0.67	Law	TR
MKU SBE Dergisi	49	80%	87	37	0.7	198.2	GSS	TR
KSU Ilahiyat Fak.	24	79%	15	0	1	1.8	Theo.	TR
Batı Anadolu Egitim	105	79%	83	42	0.66	20.57	Educ.	TR
Tarih Arastirmalari	57	79%	45	1	0.98	0	FEF	TR
Ticaret ve Fikri Mul.	33	79%	27	0	1	0.2	Law	TR
Bilimname	58	78%	9	0	1	4.67	Theo.	ESCI
Dicle SBED	104	78%	21	0	1	0	GSS	TR
Inonu Hukuk Fak.	49	78%	24	5	0.83	6.73	Law	TR
Gümüş. Iletisim Fak.	61	77%	20	0	1	0	Comm.	TR
Trakya Egitim Der.	177	76%	37	19	0.66	13	Educ.	TR
Selcuk SBED	110	75%	119	7	0.94	6.35	GSS	TR
Marmara Hukuk	60	75%	11	0	1	0	Law	TR
Total (Average)	2,029	(81%)	1,005	204	(0.87)	(19.6)

Journal statistics and research data_

Name	Field	N	AR	Female	INS	SSCI	FWOS	ISRA1	ISRA2	CIT.
Abant Sosyal Bilimler	GSS	166	0.54	0.04	60	6	6	0.91	0.91	0.80
Adiyaman SBD	GSS	129	0.56	0.47	44	8	11	0.85	0.80	2.59
Afet ve Risk Dergisi	GSS	87	0.63	0.35	149	58	34	0.72	0.81	49.59
Afyon Kocatepe SBD	GSS	302	0.68	0.11	120	31	42	0.79	0.74	11.41
Ahi Evran SBED	GSS	98	0.62	0.25	89	6	9	0.94	0.91	5.06
Akademik Incelemeler	GSS	97	0.24	0.33	4	4	5	0.50	0.44	1.00
Anadolu Uni. SBD	GSS	246	0.34	0.45	92	26	22	0.78	0.81	40.82
Anemon Mus SBD	GSS	120	0.64	0.19	23	7	7	0.77	0.77	4.44
Balikesir SBED	GSS	169	0.18	0.13	23	5	7	0.82	0.77	23.13
Bilgi Yonetimi	GSS	34	0.47	0.00	28	1	2	0.97	0.93	4.00
Bingol SBED	GSS	91	0.73	0.00	16	1	2	0.94	0.89	0.00
Celal Bayar SBD	GSS	163	0.73	0.45	21	1	3	0.95	0.88	0.91
Cukurova SBED	GSS	82	0.6	0.53	97	24	24	0.80	0.80	9.94
Dicle Üni. SBED	GSS	104	0.78	0.00	21	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
DEU Denizcilik Fak.	GSS	31	0.48	0.29	26	40	10	0.39	0.72	68.71
DEU SBED	GSS	167	0.54	0.67	6	1	2	0.86	0.75	0.00
Dumlupinar SBD	GSS	151	0.52	0.39	154	20	25	0.89	0.86	5.45
Eskişehir OGU SBD	GSS	48	0.42	0.50	53	19	18	0.74	0.75	6.55
Firat Uni. SBD	GSS	244	0.39	0.00	13	2	6	0.87	0.68	3.67
Gaziantep Uni. SBD	GSS	222	0.61	0.35	28	35	29	0.44	0.49	119.05
Gumushane SBED	GSS	171	0.5	0.50	54	1	2	0.98	0.96	0.06
Hitit SBD	GSS	82	0.39	0.67	3	1	3	0.75	0.50	5.00
Humanitas - Uls. SBD	GSS	125	0.29	0.50	72	0	3	1.00	0.96	0.00
Igdir Uni. SBD	GSS	106	0.5	0.40	26	24	8	0.52	0.76	76.60
Intl. J. of Social Inquiry	GSS	54	0.69	0.00	7	1	1	0.88	0.88	1.75
Insan Haklari Yilligi	GSS	4	0.5	0.33	9	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
KSU Sosyal Bil. D	GSS	141	0.91	0.33	67	6	5	0.92	0.93	10.56
Karadeniz SBD	GSS	104	0.43	0.08	71	35	29	0.67	0.71	14.16
KTU SBE SBD	GSS	67	0.31	0.18	12	19	30	0.39	0.29	47.91
Karen-Karadeniz Ars.	GSS	40	0.83	0.18	31	7	9	0.82	0.78	7.00
Kocaeli Sosyal Bil.	GSS	19	0.53	0.50	35	26	13	0.57	0.73	26.75
Mukaddime	GSS	51	0.45	0.00	43	19	17	0.69	0.72	15.90
MKU SBED	GSS	49	0.8	0.14	87	37	32	0.70	0.73	198.21
Nevşehir HBVU SBE	GSS	231	0.84	0.20	3	0	1	1.00	0.75	0.40
Pamukkale Spor Bil.	GSS	45	0.24
Pamukkale SBD	GSS	306	0.67	0.53	31	15	20	0.67	0.61	6.37
SAVSAD Savunma	GSS	36	0.36	0.14	119	9	6	0.63	0.71	9.43
Selcuk SBED	GSS	110	0.75	0.18	132	7	14	0.94	0.89	6.35
Selcuk Sosyal MYO	GSS	109	0.56	0.35	36	12	12	0.92	0.92	8.70
Sosyal Bilimler Ars.	GSS	76	0.24	0.07		11	12	0.77	0.75	8.79
Spor Bilimleri Der.	GSS	31	0.42		4
Trakya SBD	GSS	58	0.62	0.67	13	1	0	0.80	1.00	1.67
YYU SBED	GSS	123	0.4	1.00	15	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
AIBU Egitim Fak.	Educ.	147	0.55	0.33	16	1	2	0.94	0.89	0.33
Ahi Evran Egitim	Educ.	94	0.63	0.14	60	29	18	0.67	0.77	28.86
Anadolu J. Edu. Sci.	Educ.	56	0.34	0.25	5	4	5	0.56	0.50	29.00
Ankara Egitim Bil.	Educ.	70	0.34	0.67	11	14	13	0.44	0.46	28.67
Ankara Eg. Bil. Ozel	Educ.	62	0.39	0.78	71	112	116	0.39	0.38	20.69
Bartın Egitim Fak.	Educ.	101	0.64	0.86	23	64	51	0.26	0.31	54.64
Batı Anadolu Egitim	Educ.	105	0.79	0.73	83	42	49	0.66	0.63	20.57
Bayburt Egitim Fak.	Educ.	38	0.71	0.14	36	8	6	0.82	0.86	7.29
Boğaziçi Egitim Der.	Educ.	52	0.5	0.40	4	16	10	0.20	0.29	25.00
Buca Egitim Fak.	Educ.	110	0.73	0.63	62	52	45	0.54	0.58	26.50
Cumhuriyet Uls. Eg.	Educ.	133	0.44	0.39	45	24	21	0.65	0.68	11.57
Cukurova Egitim F.	Educ.	152	0.39	0.79	66	30	33	0.69	0.67	33.07
Ege Egitim Dergisi	Educ.	95	0.29	0.86	44	48	58	0.48	0.43	39.50
Erzincan Egitim F.	Educ.	128	0.24	0.31	22	22	15	0.50	0.59	17.06
Gazi Egitim Fak.	Educ.	141	0.4	0.39	90	116	79	0.44	0.53	82.56
Inonu Egitim Fak.	Educ.	107	0.83	0.33	3	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
Kastamonu Egitim	Educ.	36	0.53	0.45	47	25	25	0.65	0.65	21.15
Kocaeli Egitim	Educ.	53	0.57	0.74	24	36	41	0.40	0.37	19.33
Kuramsal Egitimbilim	Educ.	211	0.19	1.00	4	4	5	0.50	0.44	18.50
Marmara Atatürk Eg.	Educ.	42	0.67	0.46	60	54	49	0.53	0.55	18.00
MAKU Egitim Fak.	Educ.	157	0.68	0.48	86	33	45	0.72	0.66	19.44
MSKU Egitim Fak.	Educ.	63	0.68	0.55	30	19	29	0.61	0.51	21.09
Necatibey Egitim Fak.	Educ.	24	0.63	0.71	35	18	16	0.66	0.69	45.00
Ondokuz Mayıs Eğ.	Educ.	34	0.59	0.43	99	26	24	0.79	0.80	16.57
Pamukkale Egitim F.	Educ.	185	0.36	0.33	16	36	35	0.31	0.31	207.33
Sakarya J. of Educ.	Educ.	89	0.53	0.48	245	95	79	0.72	0.76	26.92
Spormetre Beden Eg.	Educ.	106	0.49	0.29	108	16	9	0.87	0.92	8.29
Trakya Egitim Dergisi	Educ.	177	0.76	0.57	37	19	28	0.66	0.57	13.00
Turk Egitim Bilimleri	Educ.	100	0.55	0.00	42	18	17	0.70	0.71	42.00
Uludağ Egitim Fak.	Educ.	71	0.46	0.75	34	24	15	0.59	0.69	62.92
Yuksekogretim ve Bilim	Educ.	122	0.48
YYU Egitim Fakultesi	Educ.	138	0.37	0.24	40	30	38	0.57	0.51	25.47
Akademik Arast. Calis.	FEAS	96	0.35	0.14	2	2	4	0.50	0.33	1.71
Akdeniz IIBF Dergisi	FEAS	47	0.36	0.59	34	33	17	0.51	0.67	114.65
Alanya Akademik Bakis	FEAS	179	0.55	0.00	1	2	3	0.33	0.25	7.50
Anadolu ve Balkan Ars.	FEAS	42	0.6	0.20	71	11	22	0.87	0.76	1.60
Ankara HBVU IIBF	FEAS	125	0.48	0.44	89	29	15	0.75	0.86	22.56
Bingol IIBF Dergisi	FEAS	123	0.39	0.00	12	3	2	0.80	0.86	1.57
Çankırı Karatekin IIBF	FEAS	98	0.42	0.55	7	7	8	0.50	0.47	10.45
Cumhuriyet IIBF	FEAS	129	0.44	0.20	89	38	29	0.70	0.75	13.85
Dicle IIBF Dergisi	FEAS	52	0.81	0.08	43	10	12	0.81	0.78	6.25
DEU Isletme Fakultesi	FEAS	20	0.45	1.00	1	27	16	0.04	0.06	85.00
Ege Akademik Bakis	FEAS	132	0.29	0.60	10	30	16	0.25	0.38	49.40
Ege Stratejik Ars.	FEAS	16	0.69	0.00	8	2	2	0.80	0.80	0.00
Ekoist J. Econometrics	FEAS	47	0.64	0.00	1	24	21	0.04	0.05	37.33
Ekonomik ve Sos. Ars.	FEAS	65	0.45	0.00	14	0	1	1.00	0.93	0.00
Erciyes IIBF	FEAS	61	0.46	0.53	57	119	69	0.32	0.45	472.41
Eskişehir OGU IIBF	FEAS	148	0.26	0.25	58	8	8	0.88	0.88	8.25
Finansal Ars. ve Calis.	FEAS	19	0.37	0.25	33	1	1	0.97	0.97	1.25
Hacettepe Saglik Idaresi	FEAS	114	0.43	1.00	20	7	5	0.74	0.80	58.00
Hacettepe IIBF	FEAS	85	0.45	0.71	30	64	39	0.32	0.43	117.57
Iktisat Politikasi Ars.	FEAS	59	0.46	0.20	30	3	4	0.91	0.88	7.60
Istanbul Business Res.	FEAS	140	0.18	0.33	12	6	4	0.67	0.75	12.00
Istanbul Iktisat Dergisi	FEAS	81	0.51	0.33	7	20	9	0.26	0.44	114.67
Izmir Iktisat Dergisi	FEAS	135	0.44	0.20	25	6	8	0.81	0.76	2.10
J. Research in Business	FEAS	82	0.56	0.40	8	3	2	0.73	0.80	1.40
J. Tourism, Leisure & H.	FEAS	24	0.625	0.38	42	45	18	0.48	0.70	233.00
Kafkas IIBF Dergisi	FEAS	134	0.44	0.06	38	6	8	0.86	0.83	8.44
KMU Sosyal ve Ekon. Ars.	FEAS	105	0.63	0.43	30	6	5	0.83	0.86	8.71
Marmara Siyasal Bilimler	FEAS	52	0.37	0.36	22	2	1	0.92	0.96	0.09
Mehmet Akif IIBF D.	FEAS	118	0.64	0.43	56	12	15	0.82	0.79	11.57
Ömer Halisdemir IIBF	FEAS	85	0.82	0.25	28	4	7	0.88	0.80	9.75
Oneri	FEAS	31	0.71	0.42	39	5	10	0.89	0.80	1.42
Optimum Ekonomi	FEAS	53	0.43	0.00	7	15	6	0.32	0.54	26.60
Siyasal: J. Political Sci.	FEAS	106	0.25	0.80	12	4	4	0.75	0.75	13.60
Sosyal Siyaset Konf.	FEAS	46	0.63	0.14	27	0	3	1.00	0.90	0.00
SDU Vizyoner Dergisi	FEAS	133	0.65	0.00	25	0	2	1.00	0.93	0.00
Toplum ve Sosyal Hizmet	FEAS	138	0.43	0.71	144	41	10	0.78	0.94	20.79
Türkiye Ortadogu Calis.	FEAS	30	0.40	0.36	40	11	13	0.78	0.75	2.64
Uls. Ekonomi ve Yenilik	FEAS	46	0.37	0.33	43	11	21	0.80	0.67	44.44
Uls. Iktisadi ve Idari Inc.	FEAS	81	0.65	0.36	172	50	63	0.77	0.73	29.12
Uls. Yon. Iktisat ve Isletme	FEAS	185	0.22	0.22	27	18	19	0.60	0.59	41.67
Yonetim Bilimleri Dergisi	FEAS	64	0.69	0.00	53	0	3	1.00	0.95	0.27
Yonetim ve Ekonomi Ars.	FEAS	135	0.67	0.43	19	0	3	1.00	0.86	0.71
Yon. ve Ekonomi: CBU	FEAS	70	0.59	0.20	51	12	9	0.81	0.85	14.50
Ankara DTCF	FEF	132	0.45	0.54	66	5	13	0.93	0.84	0.69
Alman Dili ve Edebiyatı	FEF	35	0.43	0.57	53	1	9	0.98	0.85	0.29
Anadolu	FEF	10	0.70	0.60	24	21	10	0.53	0.71	35.20
Anadolu Arastırmaları	FEF	30	0.53	0.25	6	3	2	0.67	0.75	1.00
Antropoloji	FEF	32	0.63	0.50	139	50	13	0.74	0.91	67.90
Archivum Anatolicum	FEF	25	0.64	0.33	30	1	1	0.97	0.97	0.00
Atatürk Edebiyat Fak.	FEF	30	0.50	0.20	15	2	3	0.88	0.83	3.20
Atatürk Yolu	FEF	47	0.83	0.36	117	6	8	0.95	0.94	0.36
AYNA Klinik Psikoloji	FEF	73	0.34	1.00	43	93	18	0.32	0.70	110.50
Belgi Dergisi	FEF	64	0.50	0.09	143	4	11	0.97	0.93	0.73
Çanakkale Ars. Türk Y.	FEF	26	0.65	0.00	5	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
Cedrus: Akdeniz Uygar.	FEF	31	0.81	0.20	49	50	18	0.49	0.73	236.60
Ceviribilim ve Uygulama.	FEF	30	0.63	0.67	49	11	12	0.82	0.80	1.00
Cografi Bilimler Dergisi	FEF	32	0.66	0.50	140	27	16	0.84	0.90	71.00
Cografya Dergisi	FEF	65	0.62	0.38	65	10	7	0.87	0.90	18.13
Cukurova Türkoloji Ars.	FEF	89	0.46	0.33	89	1	1	0.99	0.99	0.67
Dil Dergisi	FEF	16	0.25	0.29	11	10	8	0.52	0.58	11.14
Ege Cografya Dergisi	FEF	51	0.57	0.40	54	22	9	0.71	0.86	118.20
Fe Dergi	FEF	53	0.38	1.00	7	9	5	0.44	0.58	4.80
Hacettepe Edebiyat Fak.	FEF	131	0.40	0.59	123	85	59	0.59	0.68	28.68
Hacettepe Türkiyat Ars.	FEF	61	0.49	0.50	5	9	9	0.36	0.36	6.00
Intl. J. Geography & Ed.	FEF	66	0.62	0.00	82	0	1	1.00	0.99	0.00
Istanbul Ceviribilim	FEF	30	0.70	0.40	10	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
Istanbul Edebiyat Fak.	FEF	51	0.65	0.11	47	3	4	0.94	0.92	0.11
J. Econ. Culture & Soc.	FEF	144	0.27	0.38	30	56	36	0.35	0.45	265.13
Kaygı Uludag Felsefe	FEF	49	0.69	0.20	12	3	5	0.80	0.71	0.60
Litera: Dil, Edebiyat.	FEF	110	0.29	0.73	68	0	12	1.00	0.85	0.09
Marmara Türkiyat Ars.	FEF	74	0.41	0.33	21	3	3	0.88	0.88	0.00
Mavi Atlas	FEF	42	0.88	0.29	11	0	4	1.00	0.73	0.00
Osmanli Bilimi Ars.	FEF	39	0.67	0.71	80	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
Psikoloji Calismalari	FEF	178	0.12	1.00	22	42	32	0.34	0.41	77.44
Sanat Tarihi Dergisi	FEF	82	0.72	0.67	66	1	11	0.99	0.86	0.67
Sanat Tarihi Yilligi	FEF	21	0.81	0.86	19	3	6	0.86	0.76	2.57
SDU FEF Sosyal Bil.	FEF	73	0.88	0.20	49	5	7	0.91	0.88	3.60
Tarih Araştirmalari D.	FEF	57	0.79	0.20	45	1	1	0.98	0.98	0.00
Temasa Erciyes Felsefe	FEF	48	0.63	0.00	38	1	8	0.97	0.83	0.00
Trakya Edebiyat Fak.	FEF	44	0.68	0.40	39	1	3	0.98	0.93	0.00
Türk Dünyası Incele.	FEF	53	0.49	0.00	6	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
Türkiyat Mecmuası	FEF	66	0.38	0.00	11	1	2	0.92	0.85	0.00
Uludag FEF Sosyal Bil.	FEF	67	0.72	0.33	99	0	1	1.00	0.99	0.67
Yakın Donem Türkiye	FEF	40	0.63	0.25	24	1	3	0.96	0.89	0.13
Amasya Ilahiyat D.	Theo.	78	0.37	0.36	6	0	3	1.00	0.67	0.00
Ankara İlahiyat D.	Theo.	104	0.41	0.54	18	0	4	1.00	0.82	0.00
Artuklu Akademi	Theo.	37	0.62	0.18	36	0	7	1.00	0.84	0.00
Bilimname	Theo.	58	0.78	0.67	9	0	4	1.00	0.69	4.67
Bingol Ilahiyat F.	Theo.	69	0.48	0.13	28	1	2	0.97	0.93	0.00
Bozok Ilahiyat D.	Theo.	75	0.36	0.60	13	1	3	0.93	0.81	0.07
BEÜ İlahiyat D.	Theo.	51	0.31	0.33	5	1	2	0.83	0.71	0.00
Cumhuriyet Ilahiyat	Theo.	183	0.37	0.50	4	0	1	1.00	0.80	0.00
Çukurova Ilahiyat F.	Theo.	78	0.83	0.23	49	1	5	0.98	0.91	0.00
Darulfunun Ilahiyat	Theo.	116	0.29	0.42	12	2	10	0.86	0.55	0.00
Dergiabant	Theo.	39	0.67	0.17	5	0	2	1.00	0.71	0.00
Eskisehir OGU Il.	Theo.	121	0.45	0.57	46	2	10	0.96	0.82	0.04
Firat Ilahiyat F. Der.	Theo.	52	0.67	0.38	48	0	1	1.00	0.98	0.00
Gumushane Ilahiyat	Theo.	37	0.89	0.25	16	0	1	1.00	0.94	0.00
Harran Ilahiyat D.	Theo.	52	0.4	0.24	12	0	1	1.00	0.92	0.00
Hitit İlahiyat Fak.	Theo.	140	0.38	0.43	8	0	3	1.00	0.73	0.00
Islam Tetkikleri D.	Theo.	80	0.41	0.20	16	0	2	1.00	0.89	0.20
KSU Ilahiyat D.	Theo.	24	0.79	0.00	15	0	7	1.00	0.68	1.80
Kilis 7 Aralik Ilahiyat	Theo.	49	0.71	0.10	21	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
Kocatepe İslami İlim.	Theo.	53	0.57	0.17	11	0	1	1.00	0.92	0.00
Marifetname	Theo.	40	0.53	0.20	17	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
Marmara Ilahiyat	Theo.	34	0.5	0.11	54	11	16	0.83	0.77	8.22
Medya ve Din Ars.	Theo.	40	0.63	0.00	16	0	7	1.00	0.70	1.00
Mizanul-Hak	Theo.	73	0.66	0.27	19	0	3	1.00	0.86	0.00
Ondokuz Mayıs Il.	Theo.	87	0.47	0.57	6	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
Pamukkale Ilahiyat	Theo.	73	0.63	0.56	4	1	5	0.80	0.44	0.00
Sakarya Ilahiyat D.	Theo.	111	0.25	0.33	6	2	8	0.75	0.43	2.67
Sirnak Ilahiyat D.	Theo.	59	0.42	0.08	6	0	1	1.00	0.86	0.00
Tasavvur-Tekirdag	Theo.	116	0.44	0.29	25	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
Tokat Ilmiyat Dergisi	Theo.	60	0.53	0.14	36	0	8	1.00	0.82	0.14
Trabzon Ilahiyat	Theo.	101	0.3	0.09	15	0	6	1.00	0.71	0.09
Uludag Ilahiyat	Theo.	59	0.51	0.13	43	0	7	1.00	0.86	0.13
Ankara HBV Hukuk	Law	68	0.54	0.45	23	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
Ankara Hukuk Fak.	Law	96	0.52	0.80	23	0	4	1.00	0.85	0.00
Ceza Hukuku ve Krim.	Law	26	0.54	0.50	42	1	8	0.98	0.84	0.07
Hacettepe Hukuk Fak.	Law	91	0.80	0.50	0	1	3	0.00	0.00	0.67
Inonu Hukuk F.	Law	49	0.78	0.36	24	5	3	0.83	0.89	6.73
Marmara Hukuk Ars.	Law	60	0.75	0.38	11	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
N. Erbakan Hukuk	Law	60	0.60	0.40	19	0	1	1.00	0.95	0.00
Public&Private Intl. Law	Law	35	0.69	0.78	43	0	5	1.00	0.90	0.00
Selcuk Hukuk Fakultesi	Law	101	0.61	0.41	19	0	1	1.00	0.95	0.00
SDU Hukuk Fakultesi	Law	52	0.69	0.13	33	1	2	0.97	0.94	0.13
Ticaret ve Fikri Mulk.	Law	33	0.79	0.60	27	0	2	1.00	0.93	0.20
Yildirim Beyazit Hukuk	Law	66	0.80	0.57	22	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
Akdeniz Iletisim Fak.	Comm	74	0.45	0.63	27	0	6	1.00	0.82	0.38
Erciyes İletişim	Comm	91	0.69	0.17	10	0	2	1.00	0.83	0.00
Gumushane Iletisim	Comm	61	0.77	0.43	20	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
Iletisim Kuram ve Ars.	Comm	107	0.43	0.53	34	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
Inonu Iletisim Fak.	Comm	48	0.63	0.32	58	0	6	1.00	0.91	0.11
Moment Dergi	Comm	68	0.47	0.75	2	1	2	0.67	0.50	0.00
Selcuk Iletisim	Comm	36	0.42	0.64	40	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
Türkiye Iletisim Ars.	Comm	109	0.46	0.55	44	4	11	0.92	0.80	3.09
Akdeniz Sanat Der.	Art	80	0.20	0.50	46	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
Art-e Sanat Dergisi	Art	133	0.58	0.44	47	3	3	0.94	0.94	0.06
Atatürk Güzel Sanatlar	Art	40	0.40	0.29	47	20	17	0.70	0.73	7.07
Eurasian J. Music	Art	28	0.54	0.67	5	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
Konservatoryum	Art	22	0.68	0.33	1	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
Musicologist	Art	13	0.69	0.33	6	1	3	0.86	0.67	0.00
Sanat ve Tasarim Der.	Art	22	0.14	1.00	13	0	0	1.00	1.00	0.00
Yedi: Sanat, Tasarim.	Art	83	0.51	0.67	24	2	1	0.92	0.96	0.00

Submissions and acceptance rates by field_

	All	Mean	Median	Min	Max	St. Dev.
Number of Submissions (n)
All Journals (n=219)	18,317	83.6	70	4	306	52.3
-GSS (n=43)	4,889	114	104	4	306	74.5
-Education (n=32)	3,199	100	101	24	211	48.2
-FEAS (n=43)	3,731	86.7	82	16	185	44.9
-FEF (n=41)	2,397	58.5	51	10	178	36.3
-Theology (n=32)	2,349	73.4	65	24	183	35.5
-Law (n=12)	737	61.4	60	26	101	24.7
-Communication (n=8)	594	74.2	71	36	109	26.5
-Art (n=8)	421	52.6	34	13	133	42
WOSS Journals (n=29)	2,808	96.8	106	13	185	50.8
NONWOSS (n=190)	15,509	81.6	68	4	306	52.4
Acceptance Rates (%)
All Journals (n=219)	51%	54%	53%	12%	91%	17%
-GSS (n=43)	55%	53%	53%	18%	91%	18%
-Education (n=32)	51%	52%	53%	19%	83%	17%
-FEAS (n=43)	47%	49%	45%	18%	82%	16%
-FEF (n=41)	51%	57%	63%	12%	88%	18%
-Theology (n=32)	48%	52%	49%	25%	89%	17%
-Law (n=12)	67%	68%	69%	52%	80%	11%
-Communication (n=8)	53%	54%	47%	42%	77%	14%
-Art (n=8)	46%	47%	52%	14%	69%	21%
WOSS Journals (n=29)	37%	43%	39%	12%	81%	19%
NONWOSS (n=190)	54%	55%	54%	14%	91%	16%

Logistic regressions for determinants of acceptance rate_

	Baseline	Journal1	Joumal2	Joumal3	Journal4	Journal5	Editor1	Editor2	Editor3
SSCI		-0.188**	-0.209**				-0.089***	-0.098***
SSCI		[-2.37]	[-2.57]				[-4.85]	[-5.30]
INSIDER			0.211**					0.075***
INSIDER			[2.30]					[4.98]
ISRA1				0.804***
ISRA1				[3.17]
ISRA2					0.652**
ISRA2					[2.53]
CITATION						-0.059*			-0.027***
CITATION						[-1.82]			[-3.14]
WOSS	-0.297**	-0.300**	-0.314**	-0.306**	-0.259*	-0.292**	-0.055***	-0.546***	-0.552***
WOSS	[-2.11]	[-2.18]	[-2.37]	[-2.29]	[-1.85]	[-2.10]	[-13.72]	[-13.83]	[-13.75]
FEMALE	-0.512***	-0.416**	-0.359*	-0.343*	-0.421**	-0.441**	-0.068***	-0.053**	-0.07***
FEMALE	[-2.86]	[-2.22]	[-1.84]	[-1.80]	[-2.25]	[-2.36]	[-2.66]	[-2.07]	[-2.71]
SUBMIT	-0.178**	-0.187**	-0.186**	-0.188**	-0.171**	-0.182**
SUBMIT	[-2.40]	[-2.46]	[-2.39]	[-2.42]	[-2.23]	[-2.40]
AGE	-0.116**	-0.104*	-0.108*	-0.112*	-0.121**	-0.108*
AGE	[-1.99]	[-1.75]	[-1.83]	[-1.89]	[-2.05]	[-1.84]
Controls	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Constant	1.339***	1.32***	1.042***	0.528	0.7	1.312***	0.086	0.001	0.084*
Constant	[3.72]	[3.59]	(2.68)	[1.22]	[1.60]	[3.61]	[1.76]	[0.03]	[1.70]
Log likelihood	-100.731	-100.507	-100.218	-100.119	-100.378	-100.579	-1101.4	-1100.33	-1101.95
N	216	216	216	216	216	216	2,360	2,360	2,360

Journal summary statistics_

Variable	Mean	Median	Min	Max	St. Dev.
AR (%)	54	53	12.3	91	17.1
INSIDER	3.72	2.84	0	17.5	3.01
SSCI	1.24	0.44	0	12	1.95
FWOS	1.12	0.80	0	11.67	1.34
ISRA1	0.79	0.86	0	1	0.23
ISRA2	0.76	0.8	0	1	0.20
CITATION	20.9	2.34	0	472	51
SIZE	11	9	1	48	7.3
AGE	23.7	19	4	98	18.5
SUBMIT	83.7	70	4	306	52.3
WOSS	0.13	0	0	1	0.34
FEMALE (%)	37.7	35.7	0	100	25

Correlation matrix_

	AR	INSIDER	SSCI	FWOS	ISRA1	ISRA2	CITATION	SUBMIT	WOSS	AGE
AR	1
INSIDER	0.155**	1
SSCI	-0.192***	0.196***	1
FWOS	-0.169**	0.20***	0.862***	1
ISRA1	0.260***	0.22***	-0.833***	-0.741***	1
ISRA2	0.255***	0.396***	-0.61***	-0.737***	0.868***	1
CITATION	-0.166**	0.20***	0.911***	0.795***	-0.768***	-0.559***	1
SUBMIT	-0.218***	-0.064	0.057	0.118*	-0.086	-0.152**	0.131*	1
WOSS	-0.238***	0.039	0.015	0.152*	0.012	-0.101	-0.008	0.093	1
AGE	0.131*	0.135**	0.141**	0.133*	-0.066	-0.02	0.1	0.014	0.278***	1
FEMALE	-0.197***	-0.059	0.228***	0.176***	-0.246***	-0.198***	0.192***	0.052	0.206***	0.171**

Editorial board publication strategy and acceptance rates in Turkish national journals

Figures & Tables

Figure 1.

Figure 2.

Figure 3.

Figure 4.

Figure 5.

Figure 6.

Figure 7.

Figure 8.

Journals with the lowest acceptance rates_

Robustness tests_

Journals with the largest acceptance rates_

Journal statistics and research data_

Submissions and acceptance rates by field_

Logistic regressions for determinants of acceptance rate_

Journal summary statistics_

Correlation matrix_

Paradigm

My account