Figure 1
![Per capita gross domestic product (GDP) of Japan and South Korea. Source: Lee and Chung [2013].](https://sciendo-parsed.s3.eu-central-1.amazonaws.com/6471f95d215d2f6c89db739f/j_ijme-2019-0023_fig_001.jpg?X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Content-Sha256=UNSIGNED-PAYLOAD&X-Amz-Credential=ASIA6AP2G7AKBOL75CYT%2F20251214%2Feu-central-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Date=20251214T195528Z&X-Amz-Expires=3600&X-Amz-Security-Token=IQoJb3JpZ2luX2VjEHMaDGV1LWNlbnRyYWwtMSJHMEUCIQDnyRNdjT0oAuC3STqhsnfBi9%2FrPV9Tst%2FWfoI5ojCrvQIgO%2BXDScf%2FTQhB%2Fxsv1%2BSRkjZ%2FMuH8YK6ihnMA%2F7G8SQkqvQUIPBACGgw5NjMxMzQyODk5NDAiDALGYUsNzbB7sZbVPiqaBQGFLEoBYAfQB%2BiQaXs5N5UxiFEwTXHFqrZTucHmInbGgZV72TMDbNK1jY2w60BUuCkL0eirQ4rQgUl9H%2BnzjPNarf46RgqRxC4aY%2B15QRKzudcYm%2FdC8ZiSCy1mV13Qb53EkLTDc5ioKfb9jvZUHisCy1zfnxSJFh9S3HH%2B1pzFjn8jlh9h9zNWbS44YLUmWgFD7RCmMi3E1ZlaT7y89CxY5gJWbC1SdS3vsdwOgoTAuU0cFGMN%2B%2BrTPqaLphKg7QPrtefEmF%2BjM53jGWmRX7zyygU5Q0N%2BNSUcJBnHC%2FkHrxN5nfGTTHLCBPxh9ix%2B9oPVKMcleyStQ9WBlUtzjxt8PCa2z50jzIHUshb4AsMSy10NbYZ0i1yrMrihDtYvIX%2Bd7yT2v3r5SCylmSAj5ShNlrXwkUnczeDOgsvGvUuugQvtK8Y6bJEp9vSrxrqL%2BeHze%2By8VCEW7kGeO0IkeLMbauIcv0ud49MkqCmgs9QuhsS7Oh23Y5xyyF%2FXQQkpuAcRZZaED%2Brx4kLGaYe3sQex0TFdOo2H4zPpQS5iBY%2Botw0D%2BIbTpWnj4mH5NQ6GkO8jCZtT8eYoO0x%2FyuQbg6YYs1ctE%2F6%2BkgNSWQkYwkiUbrCJjFeR4TRFBeca0%2FLePaPT75fIZ9To8Sm32vY4kP6aQpPZ4vBIZ0VrhBp16gpTkN3AlTlXjqQmtIszsrRdArlNo0bp6Uo7OppeXrQ3%2FQ0WB1ADYmtGWHrFsMlKGMRbAUC6Dh7Gxen1D2wrwf%2BsVzcirZDfCKuvaDeqTngAZwf11%2B0F00n0Cl6HiP8apKR7Lk8rQfn48ssqgrHFjBfRP1t2exqbbU3vX6is5xmTEDvDZwjORLsphsunMBRvgL9%2FXxm6IE4Wwth0XTDPjPzJBjqxAePCrXra0NNaE172XIAqbJ8kI0lXBWH5vMH1HN8XRDDk0gNa0UUyVMsbLG4cnqPHWg6L0GCEmN6%2BJtiQVj11nSl1Z6%2B9QyUifA%2F45eJKqBSLYysKfblyo1%2FM9LlCTsw7aNFVBlmBmL%2FyPA9YugAPAGihcGKzFS8%2FPwXAKONzObpsHQcDafoc3jWpgCqingGMF69f%2BQ%2Bxim8GrC%2FfsAkE11Qfc0ewYqJIP6zXVwT6enkSnQ%3D%3D&X-Amz-Signature=3d0c808eb52cefc6652458cc71f9ec862c5a506af692a658c8f95a58c10a4efc&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&x-amz-checksum-mode=ENABLED&x-id=GetObject)
Figure 2
![Science and technology competitiveness – Japan and South Korea. Source: Lee and Chung [2013].](https://sciendo-parsed.s3.eu-central-1.amazonaws.com/6471f95d215d2f6c89db739f/j_ijme-2019-0023_fig_002.jpg?X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Content-Sha256=UNSIGNED-PAYLOAD&X-Amz-Credential=ASIA6AP2G7AKBOL75CYT%2F20251214%2Feu-central-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Date=20251214T195528Z&X-Amz-Expires=3600&X-Amz-Security-Token=IQoJb3JpZ2luX2VjEHMaDGV1LWNlbnRyYWwtMSJHMEUCIQDnyRNdjT0oAuC3STqhsnfBi9%2FrPV9Tst%2FWfoI5ojCrvQIgO%2BXDScf%2FTQhB%2Fxsv1%2BSRkjZ%2FMuH8YK6ihnMA%2F7G8SQkqvQUIPBACGgw5NjMxMzQyODk5NDAiDALGYUsNzbB7sZbVPiqaBQGFLEoBYAfQB%2BiQaXs5N5UxiFEwTXHFqrZTucHmInbGgZV72TMDbNK1jY2w60BUuCkL0eirQ4rQgUl9H%2BnzjPNarf46RgqRxC4aY%2B15QRKzudcYm%2FdC8ZiSCy1mV13Qb53EkLTDc5ioKfb9jvZUHisCy1zfnxSJFh9S3HH%2B1pzFjn8jlh9h9zNWbS44YLUmWgFD7RCmMi3E1ZlaT7y89CxY5gJWbC1SdS3vsdwOgoTAuU0cFGMN%2B%2BrTPqaLphKg7QPrtefEmF%2BjM53jGWmRX7zyygU5Q0N%2BNSUcJBnHC%2FkHrxN5nfGTTHLCBPxh9ix%2B9oPVKMcleyStQ9WBlUtzjxt8PCa2z50jzIHUshb4AsMSy10NbYZ0i1yrMrihDtYvIX%2Bd7yT2v3r5SCylmSAj5ShNlrXwkUnczeDOgsvGvUuugQvtK8Y6bJEp9vSrxrqL%2BeHze%2By8VCEW7kGeO0IkeLMbauIcv0ud49MkqCmgs9QuhsS7Oh23Y5xyyF%2FXQQkpuAcRZZaED%2Brx4kLGaYe3sQex0TFdOo2H4zPpQS5iBY%2Botw0D%2BIbTpWnj4mH5NQ6GkO8jCZtT8eYoO0x%2FyuQbg6YYs1ctE%2F6%2BkgNSWQkYwkiUbrCJjFeR4TRFBeca0%2FLePaPT75fIZ9To8Sm32vY4kP6aQpPZ4vBIZ0VrhBp16gpTkN3AlTlXjqQmtIszsrRdArlNo0bp6Uo7OppeXrQ3%2FQ0WB1ADYmtGWHrFsMlKGMRbAUC6Dh7Gxen1D2wrwf%2BsVzcirZDfCKuvaDeqTngAZwf11%2B0F00n0Cl6HiP8apKR7Lk8rQfn48ssqgrHFjBfRP1t2exqbbU3vX6is5xmTEDvDZwjORLsphsunMBRvgL9%2FXxm6IE4Wwth0XTDPjPzJBjqxAePCrXra0NNaE172XIAqbJ8kI0lXBWH5vMH1HN8XRDDk0gNa0UUyVMsbLG4cnqPHWg6L0GCEmN6%2BJtiQVj11nSl1Z6%2B9QyUifA%2F45eJKqBSLYysKfblyo1%2FM9LlCTsw7aNFVBlmBmL%2FyPA9YugAPAGihcGKzFS8%2FPwXAKONzObpsHQcDafoc3jWpgCqingGMF69f%2BQ%2Bxim8GrC%2FfsAkE11Qfc0ewYqJIP6zXVwT6enkSnQ%3D%3D&X-Amz-Signature=e153b3599460b632b05bb2571057a7471a3f447dacbdb7b686cdce6101c993d7&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&x-amz-checksum-mode=ENABLED&x-id=GetObject)
Figure 3
![Global technological ranking – Japan and South Korea. Source: Lee and Chung [2013].](https://sciendo-parsed.s3.eu-central-1.amazonaws.com/6471f95d215d2f6c89db739f/j_ijme-2019-0023_fig_003.jpg?X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Content-Sha256=UNSIGNED-PAYLOAD&X-Amz-Credential=ASIA6AP2G7AKBOL75CYT%2F20251214%2Feu-central-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Date=20251214T195528Z&X-Amz-Expires=3600&X-Amz-Security-Token=IQoJb3JpZ2luX2VjEHMaDGV1LWNlbnRyYWwtMSJHMEUCIQDnyRNdjT0oAuC3STqhsnfBi9%2FrPV9Tst%2FWfoI5ojCrvQIgO%2BXDScf%2FTQhB%2Fxsv1%2BSRkjZ%2FMuH8YK6ihnMA%2F7G8SQkqvQUIPBACGgw5NjMxMzQyODk5NDAiDALGYUsNzbB7sZbVPiqaBQGFLEoBYAfQB%2BiQaXs5N5UxiFEwTXHFqrZTucHmInbGgZV72TMDbNK1jY2w60BUuCkL0eirQ4rQgUl9H%2BnzjPNarf46RgqRxC4aY%2B15QRKzudcYm%2FdC8ZiSCy1mV13Qb53EkLTDc5ioKfb9jvZUHisCy1zfnxSJFh9S3HH%2B1pzFjn8jlh9h9zNWbS44YLUmWgFD7RCmMi3E1ZlaT7y89CxY5gJWbC1SdS3vsdwOgoTAuU0cFGMN%2B%2BrTPqaLphKg7QPrtefEmF%2BjM53jGWmRX7zyygU5Q0N%2BNSUcJBnHC%2FkHrxN5nfGTTHLCBPxh9ix%2B9oPVKMcleyStQ9WBlUtzjxt8PCa2z50jzIHUshb4AsMSy10NbYZ0i1yrMrihDtYvIX%2Bd7yT2v3r5SCylmSAj5ShNlrXwkUnczeDOgsvGvUuugQvtK8Y6bJEp9vSrxrqL%2BeHze%2By8VCEW7kGeO0IkeLMbauIcv0ud49MkqCmgs9QuhsS7Oh23Y5xyyF%2FXQQkpuAcRZZaED%2Brx4kLGaYe3sQex0TFdOo2H4zPpQS5iBY%2Botw0D%2BIbTpWnj4mH5NQ6GkO8jCZtT8eYoO0x%2FyuQbg6YYs1ctE%2F6%2BkgNSWQkYwkiUbrCJjFeR4TRFBeca0%2FLePaPT75fIZ9To8Sm32vY4kP6aQpPZ4vBIZ0VrhBp16gpTkN3AlTlXjqQmtIszsrRdArlNo0bp6Uo7OppeXrQ3%2FQ0WB1ADYmtGWHrFsMlKGMRbAUC6Dh7Gxen1D2wrwf%2BsVzcirZDfCKuvaDeqTngAZwf11%2B0F00n0Cl6HiP8apKR7Lk8rQfn48ssqgrHFjBfRP1t2exqbbU3vX6is5xmTEDvDZwjORLsphsunMBRvgL9%2FXxm6IE4Wwth0XTDPjPzJBjqxAePCrXra0NNaE172XIAqbJ8kI0lXBWH5vMH1HN8XRDDk0gNa0UUyVMsbLG4cnqPHWg6L0GCEmN6%2BJtiQVj11nSl1Z6%2B9QyUifA%2F45eJKqBSLYysKfblyo1%2FM9LlCTsw7aNFVBlmBmL%2FyPA9YugAPAGihcGKzFS8%2FPwXAKONzObpsHQcDafoc3jWpgCqingGMF69f%2BQ%2Bxim8GrC%2FfsAkE11Qfc0ewYqJIP6zXVwT6enkSnQ%3D%3D&X-Amz-Signature=191f1e40c71e9035615a55dd8670fd1bd8afba70fa38da268b3ce95da4c6f3a6&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&x-amz-checksum-mode=ENABLED&x-id=GetObject)
Figure 4

Figure 5

Figure 6
![Seoul and Seoul Metropolitan Region (SMR). Source: Wan and An [2017].](https://sciendo-parsed.s3.eu-central-1.amazonaws.com/6471f95d215d2f6c89db739f/j_ijme-2019-0023_fig_006.jpg?X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Content-Sha256=UNSIGNED-PAYLOAD&X-Amz-Credential=ASIA6AP2G7AKBOL75CYT%2F20251214%2Feu-central-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Date=20251214T195528Z&X-Amz-Expires=3600&X-Amz-Security-Token=IQoJb3JpZ2luX2VjEHMaDGV1LWNlbnRyYWwtMSJHMEUCIQDnyRNdjT0oAuC3STqhsnfBi9%2FrPV9Tst%2FWfoI5ojCrvQIgO%2BXDScf%2FTQhB%2Fxsv1%2BSRkjZ%2FMuH8YK6ihnMA%2F7G8SQkqvQUIPBACGgw5NjMxMzQyODk5NDAiDALGYUsNzbB7sZbVPiqaBQGFLEoBYAfQB%2BiQaXs5N5UxiFEwTXHFqrZTucHmInbGgZV72TMDbNK1jY2w60BUuCkL0eirQ4rQgUl9H%2BnzjPNarf46RgqRxC4aY%2B15QRKzudcYm%2FdC8ZiSCy1mV13Qb53EkLTDc5ioKfb9jvZUHisCy1zfnxSJFh9S3HH%2B1pzFjn8jlh9h9zNWbS44YLUmWgFD7RCmMi3E1ZlaT7y89CxY5gJWbC1SdS3vsdwOgoTAuU0cFGMN%2B%2BrTPqaLphKg7QPrtefEmF%2BjM53jGWmRX7zyygU5Q0N%2BNSUcJBnHC%2FkHrxN5nfGTTHLCBPxh9ix%2B9oPVKMcleyStQ9WBlUtzjxt8PCa2z50jzIHUshb4AsMSy10NbYZ0i1yrMrihDtYvIX%2Bd7yT2v3r5SCylmSAj5ShNlrXwkUnczeDOgsvGvUuugQvtK8Y6bJEp9vSrxrqL%2BeHze%2By8VCEW7kGeO0IkeLMbauIcv0ud49MkqCmgs9QuhsS7Oh23Y5xyyF%2FXQQkpuAcRZZaED%2Brx4kLGaYe3sQex0TFdOo2H4zPpQS5iBY%2Botw0D%2BIbTpWnj4mH5NQ6GkO8jCZtT8eYoO0x%2FyuQbg6YYs1ctE%2F6%2BkgNSWQkYwkiUbrCJjFeR4TRFBeca0%2FLePaPT75fIZ9To8Sm32vY4kP6aQpPZ4vBIZ0VrhBp16gpTkN3AlTlXjqQmtIszsrRdArlNo0bp6Uo7OppeXrQ3%2FQ0WB1ADYmtGWHrFsMlKGMRbAUC6Dh7Gxen1D2wrwf%2BsVzcirZDfCKuvaDeqTngAZwf11%2B0F00n0Cl6HiP8apKR7Lk8rQfn48ssqgrHFjBfRP1t2exqbbU3vX6is5xmTEDvDZwjORLsphsunMBRvgL9%2FXxm6IE4Wwth0XTDPjPzJBjqxAePCrXra0NNaE172XIAqbJ8kI0lXBWH5vMH1HN8XRDDk0gNa0UUyVMsbLG4cnqPHWg6L0GCEmN6%2BJtiQVj11nSl1Z6%2B9QyUifA%2F45eJKqBSLYysKfblyo1%2FM9LlCTsw7aNFVBlmBmL%2FyPA9YugAPAGihcGKzFS8%2FPwXAKONzObpsHQcDafoc3jWpgCqingGMF69f%2BQ%2Bxim8GrC%2FfsAkE11Qfc0ewYqJIP6zXVwT6enkSnQ%3D%3D&X-Amz-Signature=3120bb47a0edf928e555becccd9a442a047a86a29d97414e40a7e3aae88d93d2&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&x-amz-checksum-mode=ENABLED&x-id=GetObject)
Figure 7
![Tokyo’s long period of economic stagnation. Source: IMF quoted in The Economist [2012].](https://sciendo-parsed.s3.eu-central-1.amazonaws.com/6471f95d215d2f6c89db739f/j_ijme-2019-0023_fig_007.jpg?X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Content-Sha256=UNSIGNED-PAYLOAD&X-Amz-Credential=ASIA6AP2G7AKBOL75CYT%2F20251214%2Feu-central-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Date=20251214T195528Z&X-Amz-Expires=3600&X-Amz-Security-Token=IQoJb3JpZ2luX2VjEHMaDGV1LWNlbnRyYWwtMSJHMEUCIQDnyRNdjT0oAuC3STqhsnfBi9%2FrPV9Tst%2FWfoI5ojCrvQIgO%2BXDScf%2FTQhB%2Fxsv1%2BSRkjZ%2FMuH8YK6ihnMA%2F7G8SQkqvQUIPBACGgw5NjMxMzQyODk5NDAiDALGYUsNzbB7sZbVPiqaBQGFLEoBYAfQB%2BiQaXs5N5UxiFEwTXHFqrZTucHmInbGgZV72TMDbNK1jY2w60BUuCkL0eirQ4rQgUl9H%2BnzjPNarf46RgqRxC4aY%2B15QRKzudcYm%2FdC8ZiSCy1mV13Qb53EkLTDc5ioKfb9jvZUHisCy1zfnxSJFh9S3HH%2B1pzFjn8jlh9h9zNWbS44YLUmWgFD7RCmMi3E1ZlaT7y89CxY5gJWbC1SdS3vsdwOgoTAuU0cFGMN%2B%2BrTPqaLphKg7QPrtefEmF%2BjM53jGWmRX7zyygU5Q0N%2BNSUcJBnHC%2FkHrxN5nfGTTHLCBPxh9ix%2B9oPVKMcleyStQ9WBlUtzjxt8PCa2z50jzIHUshb4AsMSy10NbYZ0i1yrMrihDtYvIX%2Bd7yT2v3r5SCylmSAj5ShNlrXwkUnczeDOgsvGvUuugQvtK8Y6bJEp9vSrxrqL%2BeHze%2By8VCEW7kGeO0IkeLMbauIcv0ud49MkqCmgs9QuhsS7Oh23Y5xyyF%2FXQQkpuAcRZZaED%2Brx4kLGaYe3sQex0TFdOo2H4zPpQS5iBY%2Botw0D%2BIbTpWnj4mH5NQ6GkO8jCZtT8eYoO0x%2FyuQbg6YYs1ctE%2F6%2BkgNSWQkYwkiUbrCJjFeR4TRFBeca0%2FLePaPT75fIZ9To8Sm32vY4kP6aQpPZ4vBIZ0VrhBp16gpTkN3AlTlXjqQmtIszsrRdArlNo0bp6Uo7OppeXrQ3%2FQ0WB1ADYmtGWHrFsMlKGMRbAUC6Dh7Gxen1D2wrwf%2BsVzcirZDfCKuvaDeqTngAZwf11%2B0F00n0Cl6HiP8apKR7Lk8rQfn48ssqgrHFjBfRP1t2exqbbU3vX6is5xmTEDvDZwjORLsphsunMBRvgL9%2FXxm6IE4Wwth0XTDPjPzJBjqxAePCrXra0NNaE172XIAqbJ8kI0lXBWH5vMH1HN8XRDDk0gNa0UUyVMsbLG4cnqPHWg6L0GCEmN6%2BJtiQVj11nSl1Z6%2B9QyUifA%2F45eJKqBSLYysKfblyo1%2FM9LlCTsw7aNFVBlmBmL%2FyPA9YugAPAGihcGKzFS8%2FPwXAKONzObpsHQcDafoc3jWpgCqingGMF69f%2BQ%2Bxim8GrC%2FfsAkE11Qfc0ewYqJIP6zXVwT6enkSnQ%3D%3D&X-Amz-Signature=691abd2607e55176a04baf9dad1a628f74abbe4b3fbe14992ef0ff44613a2169&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&x-amz-checksum-mode=ENABLED&x-id=GetObject)
Figure 8

Figure 9

Figure 10

Figure 11
![Population growth in Seoul Metropolitan Region (SMR). Source: Cox [2011]. Graph created by authors.](https://sciendo-parsed.s3.eu-central-1.amazonaws.com/6471f95d215d2f6c89db739f/j_ijme-2019-0023_fig_0011.jpg?X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Content-Sha256=UNSIGNED-PAYLOAD&X-Amz-Credential=ASIA6AP2G7AKBOL75CYT%2F20251214%2Feu-central-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Date=20251214T195528Z&X-Amz-Expires=3600&X-Amz-Security-Token=IQoJb3JpZ2luX2VjEHMaDGV1LWNlbnRyYWwtMSJHMEUCIQDnyRNdjT0oAuC3STqhsnfBi9%2FrPV9Tst%2FWfoI5ojCrvQIgO%2BXDScf%2FTQhB%2Fxsv1%2BSRkjZ%2FMuH8YK6ihnMA%2F7G8SQkqvQUIPBACGgw5NjMxMzQyODk5NDAiDALGYUsNzbB7sZbVPiqaBQGFLEoBYAfQB%2BiQaXs5N5UxiFEwTXHFqrZTucHmInbGgZV72TMDbNK1jY2w60BUuCkL0eirQ4rQgUl9H%2BnzjPNarf46RgqRxC4aY%2B15QRKzudcYm%2FdC8ZiSCy1mV13Qb53EkLTDc5ioKfb9jvZUHisCy1zfnxSJFh9S3HH%2B1pzFjn8jlh9h9zNWbS44YLUmWgFD7RCmMi3E1ZlaT7y89CxY5gJWbC1SdS3vsdwOgoTAuU0cFGMN%2B%2BrTPqaLphKg7QPrtefEmF%2BjM53jGWmRX7zyygU5Q0N%2BNSUcJBnHC%2FkHrxN5nfGTTHLCBPxh9ix%2B9oPVKMcleyStQ9WBlUtzjxt8PCa2z50jzIHUshb4AsMSy10NbYZ0i1yrMrihDtYvIX%2Bd7yT2v3r5SCylmSAj5ShNlrXwkUnczeDOgsvGvUuugQvtK8Y6bJEp9vSrxrqL%2BeHze%2By8VCEW7kGeO0IkeLMbauIcv0ud49MkqCmgs9QuhsS7Oh23Y5xyyF%2FXQQkpuAcRZZaED%2Brx4kLGaYe3sQex0TFdOo2H4zPpQS5iBY%2Botw0D%2BIbTpWnj4mH5NQ6GkO8jCZtT8eYoO0x%2FyuQbg6YYs1ctE%2F6%2BkgNSWQkYwkiUbrCJjFeR4TRFBeca0%2FLePaPT75fIZ9To8Sm32vY4kP6aQpPZ4vBIZ0VrhBp16gpTkN3AlTlXjqQmtIszsrRdArlNo0bp6Uo7OppeXrQ3%2FQ0WB1ADYmtGWHrFsMlKGMRbAUC6Dh7Gxen1D2wrwf%2BsVzcirZDfCKuvaDeqTngAZwf11%2B0F00n0Cl6HiP8apKR7Lk8rQfn48ssqgrHFjBfRP1t2exqbbU3vX6is5xmTEDvDZwjORLsphsunMBRvgL9%2FXxm6IE4Wwth0XTDPjPzJBjqxAePCrXra0NNaE172XIAqbJ8kI0lXBWH5vMH1HN8XRDDk0gNa0UUyVMsbLG4cnqPHWg6L0GCEmN6%2BJtiQVj11nSl1Z6%2B9QyUifA%2F45eJKqBSLYysKfblyo1%2FM9LlCTsw7aNFVBlmBmL%2FyPA9YugAPAGihcGKzFS8%2FPwXAKONzObpsHQcDafoc3jWpgCqingGMF69f%2BQ%2Bxim8GrC%2FfsAkE11Qfc0ewYqJIP6zXVwT6enkSnQ%3D%3D&X-Amz-Signature=20f0519eaf71335c010d80842366a08923eeebecb2667611762fe36d692518e7&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&x-amz-checksum-mode=ENABLED&x-id=GetObject)
Figure 12
![Population growth in Seoul city. Source: Cox [2011]. Graph created by the authors.](https://sciendo-parsed.s3.eu-central-1.amazonaws.com/6471f95d215d2f6c89db739f/j_ijme-2019-0023_fig_0012.jpg?X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Content-Sha256=UNSIGNED-PAYLOAD&X-Amz-Credential=ASIA6AP2G7AKBOL75CYT%2F20251214%2Feu-central-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Date=20251214T195528Z&X-Amz-Expires=3600&X-Amz-Security-Token=IQoJb3JpZ2luX2VjEHMaDGV1LWNlbnRyYWwtMSJHMEUCIQDnyRNdjT0oAuC3STqhsnfBi9%2FrPV9Tst%2FWfoI5ojCrvQIgO%2BXDScf%2FTQhB%2Fxsv1%2BSRkjZ%2FMuH8YK6ihnMA%2F7G8SQkqvQUIPBACGgw5NjMxMzQyODk5NDAiDALGYUsNzbB7sZbVPiqaBQGFLEoBYAfQB%2BiQaXs5N5UxiFEwTXHFqrZTucHmInbGgZV72TMDbNK1jY2w60BUuCkL0eirQ4rQgUl9H%2BnzjPNarf46RgqRxC4aY%2B15QRKzudcYm%2FdC8ZiSCy1mV13Qb53EkLTDc5ioKfb9jvZUHisCy1zfnxSJFh9S3HH%2B1pzFjn8jlh9h9zNWbS44YLUmWgFD7RCmMi3E1ZlaT7y89CxY5gJWbC1SdS3vsdwOgoTAuU0cFGMN%2B%2BrTPqaLphKg7QPrtefEmF%2BjM53jGWmRX7zyygU5Q0N%2BNSUcJBnHC%2FkHrxN5nfGTTHLCBPxh9ix%2B9oPVKMcleyStQ9WBlUtzjxt8PCa2z50jzIHUshb4AsMSy10NbYZ0i1yrMrihDtYvIX%2Bd7yT2v3r5SCylmSAj5ShNlrXwkUnczeDOgsvGvUuugQvtK8Y6bJEp9vSrxrqL%2BeHze%2By8VCEW7kGeO0IkeLMbauIcv0ud49MkqCmgs9QuhsS7Oh23Y5xyyF%2FXQQkpuAcRZZaED%2Brx4kLGaYe3sQex0TFdOo2H4zPpQS5iBY%2Botw0D%2BIbTpWnj4mH5NQ6GkO8jCZtT8eYoO0x%2FyuQbg6YYs1ctE%2F6%2BkgNSWQkYwkiUbrCJjFeR4TRFBeca0%2FLePaPT75fIZ9To8Sm32vY4kP6aQpPZ4vBIZ0VrhBp16gpTkN3AlTlXjqQmtIszsrRdArlNo0bp6Uo7OppeXrQ3%2FQ0WB1ADYmtGWHrFsMlKGMRbAUC6Dh7Gxen1D2wrwf%2BsVzcirZDfCKuvaDeqTngAZwf11%2B0F00n0Cl6HiP8apKR7Lk8rQfn48ssqgrHFjBfRP1t2exqbbU3vX6is5xmTEDvDZwjORLsphsunMBRvgL9%2FXxm6IE4Wwth0XTDPjPzJBjqxAePCrXra0NNaE172XIAqbJ8kI0lXBWH5vMH1HN8XRDDk0gNa0UUyVMsbLG4cnqPHWg6L0GCEmN6%2BJtiQVj11nSl1Z6%2B9QyUifA%2F45eJKqBSLYysKfblyo1%2FM9LlCTsw7aNFVBlmBmL%2FyPA9YugAPAGihcGKzFS8%2FPwXAKONzObpsHQcDafoc3jWpgCqingGMF69f%2BQ%2Bxim8GrC%2FfsAkE11Qfc0ewYqJIP6zXVwT6enkSnQ%3D%3D&X-Amz-Signature=b0bdee30296893ae199547abc2d9bce677107c6dc60248ced1d5d71e97682ebe&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&x-amz-checksum-mode=ENABLED&x-id=GetObject)
Figure 13

Figure 14

Changing of key actors in Songdo development
| 1986–1988 | 1989–2001 | 2002 | 2003–2010 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Key actors | City government | City government, nation-state | Nation-state, city government, international developer, domestic developer | Nation-state, city government, international developer, domestic developer, civic organizations |
| Scales | Local | Local, national | National, local, global | National, local, global |