Have a personal or library account? Click to login
A Comparative Analysis of Sector Diversification in Australia, India and China Cover

A Comparative Analysis of Sector Diversification in Australia, India and China

Open Access
|Mar 2024

Figures & Tables

ASX portfolio with different investment restrictions based on asymmetric DCC GARCH model estimated correlations_

Consumer DiscretionaryConsumer StaplesEnergyHealth Care IndexIndustriesInformation TechnologyMaterialsReal EstateTelecommunications ServicesOptimal Portfolio ReturnPortfolio Standard DeviationSharpe Ratio
Investment weights (Equally weighted)11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %8.35 %16.57 %0.3528
Investment weights (no short sell)0.00 %0.00 %30.56 %54.72 %0.00 %5.76 %8.96 %0.00 %0.00 %16.48 %14.76 %0.9474
Investment weights (no short sell with max 50% in one sector)0.00 %0.00 %32.15 %50.00 %0.00 %7.81 %10.04 %0.00 %0.00 %16.43 %14.70 %0.9475
Investment weights (no short sell with max 20% in one sector)0.00 %0.00 %20.00 %20.00 %20.00 %20.00 %20.00 %0.00 %0.00 %13.57 %13.72 %0.8069
Investment weights (100% short sale)-4.98 %-10.89 %50.75 %49.93 %49.75 %-5.65 %28.46 %-50.08 %-7.29 %43.40 %21.66 %1.8883
Investment weights (100% short sale with max 50% in one sector)-4.47 %-10.90 %50.00 %49.82 %49.78 %-5.59 %28.42 %-49.93 %-7.13 %33.38 %18.27 %1.8270
Investment weights (100% short sale with max 20% in one sector)20.00 %20.00 %20.0 %20.00 %20.00 %20.00 %20.00 %-60.00 %20.00 %23.24 %16.46 %1.4119

SSE portfolio with different investment restrictions based on asymmetric DCC GARCH model estimated correlations

Consumer DiscretionaryConsumer StaplesEnergyFinancialsHealth CareIndustrialsMaterialsTelecommunications ServiceUtilitiesOptimal Portfolio ReturnPortfolio Standard DeviationSharpe Ratio
Investment weights (Equally weighted)11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %19.54 %14.69 %0.9213
Investment weights (no short sell)0.00 %63.13%0.00%25.21 %11.66 %0.00 %0.00 %0.00 %0.00 %28.87 %16.24 %1.4080
Investment weights (no short sell with max 50% in one sector)0.00 %50.00 %0.00 %29.43 %20.57 %0.00 %0.00 %0.00 %0.00 %28.03 %15.77 %1.3968
Investment weights (no short sell with max 20% in one sector)13.97 %20.00 %20.00 %20.00 %20.00 %0.00 %5.69 %0.00 %0.52 %24.05 %16.32 %1.1776
Investment weights (100% short sale)-7.23 %97.01 %14.56 %42.33 %28.59 %-28.70 %-10.53 %-18.09 %-17.96 %39.69 %21.84 %1.5430
Investment weights (100% short sale with max 50% in one sector)-1.87 %50.00 %14.78 %41.74 %38.12 %-15.09 %-4.86 %-12.50 %-10.33 %32.62 %18.11 %1.4697
Investment weights (100% short sale with max 20% in one sector)17.98 %20.00 %20.00 %20.00 %20.00 %-7.55 %8.87 %-3.83 %4.53 %24.43 %15.58 %1.1831

Nine sector indices equally weighted portfolio (out of sample)

ASX in AustraliaNSE in IndiaSSE in China
Portfolio mean Annual return8.67%4.94%-2.19%
Portfolio standard deviation9.47%1.17%11.69%
Sharpe ratio0.6521-1.7626-.7006

Summary statistics of sector indices – ASX, SSE, and NSE

ASX SectorPeriodObservationMeanVarianceSkewnessMin.Max.Range
Consumer Discretionary2004/4/14-2012/4/132087-0.0062%0.0295%-0.0895-14.3601%8.8923%23.2524%
Consumer Staples2004/4/14-2012/4/1320870.0422%0.0267%-1.1054-17.8561%9.6798%37.5360%
Energy2004/4/14-2012/4/1320870.0615%0.0483%-0.8292-19.8730%13.0450%32.9180%
ASX 200 Health Care Index2004/4/14-2012/4/1320870.0573%0.0286%-0.7165-13.9715%8.8720%22.8434%
Industries2004/4/14-2012/4/1320870.0193%0.0298%-0.8702-15.8409%8.4423%24.2832%
Information Technology2004/4/14-2012/4/1320870.0498%0.0454%0.4556-15.8558%12.6206%28.4764%
Materials2004/4/14-2012/4/1320870.0508%0.0554%-0.6826-16.1608%11.7786%27.9394%
Real Estate2004/4/14-2012/4/132087-0.0118%0.0411%-1.1577-18.4891%10.1560%28.6451%
Telecommunications Services2004/4/14-2012/4/1320870.0006%0.0298%-0.7163-13.2126%8.2886%21.5012%
SSE SectorPeriodObservationMeanVarianceSkewnessMin.Max.Range
Consumer Discretionary2005/1/4-2012/4/1318980.0653%0.0438%-0.6002-10.1840%9.2418%19.4258%
Consumer Staples2005/1/4-2012/4/1318980.1040%0.0375%-0.3588-10.0824%8.6832%18.7656%
Energy2005/1/4-2012/4/1318980.0733%0.0504%-0.1526-9.7384%9.2123%18.9506%
Financials2005/1/4-2012/4/1318980.0835%0.0461%-0.1012-9.4742%9.5227%18.9968%
Health Care2005/1/4-2012/4/1318980.0857%0.0419%-0.5047-9.9085%9.2736%19.1821%
Industrials2005/1/4-2012/4/1318980.0453%0.0392%-0.4705-9.6167%9.5346%19.1513%
Materials2005/1/4-2012/4/1318980.0612%0.0480%-0.4250-9.5166%8.2052%17.7218%
Telecommunications Services2005/1/4-2012/4/1318980.0460%0.0533%-0.2445-10.4016%9.5988%20.0004%
Utilities2005/1/4-2012/1318980.0443%0.0358%-0.5564-10.2425%8.1968%18.4393%
NSE SectorPeriodObservationMeanVarianceSkewnessMin.Max.Range
Automobile2004/4/14-2012/4/1320870.0484%0.0508%-0.1788-13.5417%17.2685%30.8102%
Banking2004/4/14-2012/4/1320870.0543%0.0565%-0.1451-15.3694%19.8858%35.2553%
Energy2004/4/14-2012/4/1320870.1203%0.0691%-0.1176-19.5035%18.2817%37.7852%
Financial2004/4/14-2012/4/1320870.0823%0.0421%0.1709-9.9427%13.4082%23.3510%
Fast Moving Consumer Goods2004/4/14-2012/4/1320870.0603%0.0220%0.1068-6.8357%9.2418%16.0775%
Information Technology2004/4/14-2012/4/1320870.0414%0.0421%-0.0185-13.9893%14.6993%28.6886%
Midea2004/4/14-2012/4/1320870.0847%0.0633%0.2265-11.9898%20.0595%32.0492%
Metal2004/4/14-2012/4/132087-0.0602%0.0989%0.3840-44.3656%44.0013%88.3669%
Pharmaceuticals2004/4/14-2012/4/1320870.0467%0.0209%-0.4688-9.1241%12.6615%21.7857%

NSE portfolio with different investment restrictions based on asymmetric DCC GARCH model estimated correlations_

AutomobileBankingEnergyFinancialFast Moving Consumer GoodsInformation TechnologyMideaMetalPharmaceuticalsOptimal Portfolio ReturnPortfolio Standard DeviationSharpe Ratio
Investment weights (Equally weighted)11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %11.11 %15.74 %13.60 %0.6428
Investment weights (no short sell)0.00 %0.00 %39.86 %28.82 %14.48 %0.00 %16.83 %0.00 %0.00 %28.34 %15.61 %1.3678
Investment weights (no short sell with max 50% in one sector)0.00 %0.00 %39.86 %28.82 %14.48 %0.00 %16.83 %0.00 %0.00 %28.34 %15.61 %1.3678
Investment weights (no short sell with max 20% in one sector)0.00 %0.00 %20.00 %20.00 %20.00 %0.00 %20.00 %0.00 %2.00 %23.21 %12.70 %1.2492
Investment weights (100% short sale)-9.15 %-5.89 %50.28 %49.87 %49.87 %-5.80 %28.53 %-50.36 %-7.33 %49.81 %23.11 %1.8526
Investment weights (100% short sale with max 50% in one sector)-9.12 %-5.90 %50.00 %49.76 %49.90 %-5.74 %28.49 %-50.22 %-7.18 %49.69 %23.04 %1.8526
Investment weights (100% short sale with max 20% in one sector)9.58 %8.95 %20.00 %20.00 %20.00 %14.68 %20.00 %-33.21 %20.00 %32.39 %16.00 %1.5872

Out of sample test result

ASXNSESSE
Optimal portfolio returnPortfolio standard deviationSharpe ratioOptimal portfolio returnPortfolio standard deviationSharpe ratioOptimal portfolio returnPortfolio standard deviationSharpe ratio
Investment weights (no short sell)19.99%9.32%1.877016.53%11.12%0.856721.56%13.98%1.1134
Investment weights (no short sell & maximum 20% weights in single sector)19.54%9.16%1.860215.03%12.25%0.655513.35%12.99%0.5659
Investment weights (no short sell & maximum 50% weights in single sector)15.32%9.66%1.327113.53%10.05%0.64906.28%11.68%0.0243
Investment weights (maximum 100% short sell)84.71%26.31%3.124979.67%35.43%2.050995.49%27.61%3.2411
Investment weights (maximum 100% short sell & maximum 20% weights in single sector)48.57%17.17%2.682351.09%24.24%1.818454.80%19.10%2.5579
Investment weights (maximum 100% short sell & maximum 50% weights in single sector)21.35%10.40%1.811920.80%17.08%0.808312.22%12.22%0.9052

Benchmark index

ASX in AustraliaNSE in IndiaSSE in China
Portfolio mean Annual return8.35%15.74%19.54%
Portfolio standard deviation16.62%16.51%18.70%
Sharpe ratio0.35170.52960.7237

Sector indices list

ASX Sector IndexSector IndexPeriodObservation
ASX 200 Consumer Discretionary IndexConsumer Discretionary2004/4/14-2012/4/132087
ASX 200 Consumer Staples IndexConsumer Staples2004/4/14-2012/4/132087
ASX 200 Energy IndexEnergy2004/4/14-2012/4/132087
ASX 200 Health Care IndexASX 200 Health Care Index2004/4/14-2012/4/132087
ASX 200 Industrials IndexIndustries2004/4/14-2012/4/132087
ASX 200 Information Technology IndexInformation Technology2004/4/14-2012/4/132087
ASX 200 Materials IndexMaterials2004/4/14-2012/4/132087
ASX 200 Real Estate IndexReal Estate2004/4/14-2012/4/132087
ASX 200 Telecommunications Services IndexTelecommunications Services2004/4/14-2012/4/132087
SSE Sector IndexSector IndexPeriodObservation
SSE Consumer Discretionary Sector IndexConsumer Discretionary2005/1/4-2012/4/131898
SSE Consumer Staples Sector IndexConsumer Staples2005/1/4-2012/4/131898
SSE Energy Sector IndexEnergy2005/1/4-2012/4/131898
SSE Financials Sector IndexFinancials2005/1/4-2012/4/131898
SSE Health Care Sector IndexHealth Care2005/1/4-2012/4/131898
SSE Industrials Sector IndexIndustrials2005/1/4-2012/4/131898
SSE Materials IndexMaterials2005/1/4-2012/4/131898
SSE Telecommunications Services Sector IndexTelecommunications Services2005/1/4-2012/4/131898
SSE Utilities Sector IndexUtilities2005/1/4-2012/4/131898
NSE Sector IndexSector IndexPeriodObservation
CNX Automobile Sector IndexAutomobile2004/4/14-2012/4/132087
CNX Banking Sector IndexBanking2004/4/14-2012/4/132087
CNX Energy Sector IndexEnergy2004/4/14-2012/4/132087
CNX Financial Sector IndexFinancial2004/4/14-2012/4/132087
CNX Fast Moving Consumer Goods Sector IndexFast Moving Consumer Goods2004/4/14-2012/4/132087
CNX Information Technology Sector IndexInformation Technology2004/4/14-2012/4/132087
CNX Midea SectorMidea2004/4/14-2012/4/132087
CNX Metal SectorMetal2004/4/14-2012/4/132087
CNX Pharmaceuticals Sector IndexPharmaceuticals2004/4/14-2012/4/132087
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/fprj-2018-0004 | Journal eISSN: 2206-1355 | Journal ISSN: 2206-1347
Language: English
Page range: 76 - 100
Submitted on: Aug 22, 2017
Accepted on: Dec 22, 2017
Published on: Mar 19, 2024
Published by: Financial Advice Association of Australia
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 2 issues per year

© 2024 Suneel Maheshwari, Rakesh Gupta, Jinze Li, published by Financial Advice Association of Australia
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.