Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Gender and managerial competence: a comparison of male and female first-line nurse managers in Indonesia Cover

Gender and managerial competence: a comparison of male and female first-line nurse managers in Indonesia

Open Access
|Apr 2021

Figures & Tables

Managerial competence according to gender (N = 256)_

Managerial competenceMale (n = 54)Female (n = 202)tp

Mean ± SDMean ± SD
Applying quality care improvement3.77 ± 0.9023.91 ± 0.801−1.1510.251
Utilizing informatics3.68 ± 0.7253.85 ± 0.766−1.4750.142
Facilitating spiritual nursing care3.62 ± 0.7633.77 ± 0.744−1.2320.219
Leadership3.69 ± 0.6513.67 ± 0.7030.1650.869
Self-management3.61 ± 0.7613.69 ± 0.764−0.6970.486
Staffing and professional development3.53 ± 1.1303.59 ± 0.991−0.3950.693
Financial management3.22 ± 0.8573.15 ± 0.8400.5220.602
Total dimension3.62 ± 0.6323.67 ± 0.635−0.5920.555

Leadership dimension of managerial competence according to gender (N = 256)_

ActivitiesMaleFemale

MeanSDMeanSD
Facilitating nursing staff in collaboration with other health professions in practice, especially with medical doctors in providing patient-centered care2.411.412.131.38
Shared decision-making by involving staff in the process of change2.191.394.200.83
Effectively assigning task responsibility and authority to subordinates4.050.994.090.96
Establishing mutual trust and respect by dealing with others in a fair manner4.130.914.010.94
Arranging schedules and supporting flexible self-scheduling for staff4.040.934.041.08
Advocating for staff in assertive and confident manner4.210.954.170.98
Giving safe and proper legal and ethical care3.521.193.461.45
Becoming role model of professional and visioning behavior3.471.393.960.80
Leading and inviting staff to pray before working in the unit4.110.934.080.91
Collaborating and communicating with other health professions in inter-disciplinary team3.371.073.201.46
Providing positive feedback and reinforcement for improvement of staff performance3.241.383.801.09
Identifying strengths of staff and capitalizing on those strengths4.081.004.021.02
Dealing with anger, criticism, and frustration in a constructive manner3.391.123.441.19
Evaluating nurses staff performance based on standard and key performance indicators3.431.172.561.51

Dimensions of self-management, staffing and professional development, and financial management according to gender (N = 256)_

ItemsMaleFemale

MeanSDMeanSD
Self-management
  Getting involved in professional associations and professional development programs3.611.223.921.01
  Engaging in self-evaluation program in the hospital3.701.183.811.13
  Involved in developing a policy brief and advocacy to policy makers4.300.724.50.74
  Achieving certification in an appropriate field/specialty3.591.163.571.26
  Managing self through continuing education and participating in nursing management research/training/course3.761.043.841.04
  Engaging in regular supervision or consulting with superordinates2.741.392.551.39
Staffing and professional development
  Managing the number and qualification of nurse staff based on the standard of hospital3.561.443.471.45
  Determining and evaluating staffing needs3.541.253.621.15
  Setting up learning opportunities, trainings, and continuing education and others related to nurse staff development3.501.343.701.26
  Identifying and matching the competence of nurse staff with patient acuity3.561.283.601.26
Financial management
  Actively participating in arranging a practical annual budget for the unit that includes volume, revenue, personnel, supplies, and capital equipment3.591.223.531.35
  Communicating fiscal management expectations and outcomes to staffs and other stakeholders2.431.472.461.43
  Implementing cost-benefit analysis approach in financial plan in the unit4.240.704.330.72
  Coordinating with supervisors among departments2.631.402.301.44

Facilitating spiritual nursing care dimension of managerial competence according to gender (N = 256)_

ActivitiesMaleFemale

MeanSDMeanSD
Relieving staff spiritual distress3.631.103.870.92
Reviewing and identifying the influence of cultural beliefs, values, and spiritual on nursing care3.371.313.561.21
Explaining and demonstrating spiritual care practice to staff and patients3.441.183.631.11
Referring effectively and articulately to other spiritual nursing care based on the situation and preference of staff and patient3.351.203.471.19
Paying attention to the spiritual needs of staff3.311.133.451.23
Facilitate staff to provide spiritual nursing care to patient and families and respect their diversity and differences4.060.964.220.85
Coaching or mentoring staff in developing problem-solving skills4.240.824.200.83

Applying quality care improvement and informatics utilization dimension of managerial competence according to gender (N = 256)_

ItemsMaleFemale

MeanSDMeanSD
Applying quality care improvement
  Continually understanding and measuring quality of care in terms of structure, process, and outcomes3.721.123.841.06
  Using evidence-based practice in nursing care4.150.964.310.90
  Analyzing the workflow of unit and identifying errors, causes, and their effects in nursing service3.561.093.820.95
  Actively participating in setting nursing practice standards or guidelines for nursing care in unit3.671.133.701.14
Utilizing informatics
  Utilizing technology to manage patients3.330.993.331.05
  Integrating technology into nursing documentation3.481.373.571.25
  Evaluating the effect of information technology (IT) on patient care and delivery system4.130.874.510.73
  Using information system to support nursing practice3.800.984.011.01
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/fon-2021-0006 | Journal eISSN: 2544-8994 | Journal ISSN: 2097-5368
Language: English
Page range: 49 - 58
Submitted on: Apr 27, 2020
Accepted on: Jun 26, 2020
Published on: Apr 30, 2021
Published by: Shanxi Medical Periodical Press
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 4 times per year

© 2021 Joko Gunawan, Yupin Aungsuroch, Mary L. Fisher, Anna M. McDaniel, published by Shanxi Medical Periodical Press
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.