Limits to respect for autonomy principle when caring for people with dementia: Rethinking respect for people with dementia
References
- ALLPORT, G. W. (1937):
Personality: A psychological interpretation . New York: Holt. - ALPINAR-SENCAN, Z. (2023): Provision of Healthcare for Culturally Diverse Populations: Insights from a Qualitative Study on Dementia Care with the Turkish Immigrant Community in Germany. In: F. Steger, M. Ramšak, P. Łuków & A. Muzur (eds.):
Equal access to healthcare in socially diverse societies . Freiburg: Karl Alber, pp. 155–177. - BASUR, I., GONCALVES, C. G. & WOHLWEND, M. (2018): Demenz, Urteilsfähigkeit und Sterbewunsch [Dementia, judgement and wish to die]. In:
Jusletter , August 27, pp. 1–14. - BEAUCHAMP, T. L. (2009): Autonomy and consent. In: F. Miller & A. Wertheimer (eds.):
The Ethics of consent: Theory and practice . Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 55–78. - BEUCHAMP, T. L. & CHILDRESS, J. F. (2013):
Principles of biomedical ethics . Oxford: Oxford University Press. - BECKER, P. (2018):
Patientenautonomie und informierte Einwilligung. Schlüssel und Barriere medizinischer Behandlungen [Patient autonomy and informed consent: The key to and barrier in medical treatment ]. Berlin: J. B. Metzler. - BERENDONK, C., STANEK, S. et al. (2011): Biographiearbeit in der stationären Langzeitpflege von Menschen mit Demenz Potenziale des DEMIAN-Pflegekonzepts [Biographical work in the long-term inpatient care of people with dementia: The potential of the DEMIAN care concept]. In:
Zeitschrift für Gerontologie und Geriatrie , 44(1), pp. 13–18. - BLOTENBERT, I., HOFFMANN, W. & THYRIAN, J. R. (2023): Dementia in Germany: Epidemiology and prevention potential. In:
Deutsches Arzteblatt International , 120(27–28), pp. 470–476. doi: 10.3238/arztebl.m2023.0100. - CERVONE, D. & SHODA, Y. (1999): Social-cognitive theories and the coherence of personality. In: D. Cervone & Y. Shoda (eds.):
The coherence of personality: Social-cognitive bases of consistency, variability, and organization . New York: Guilford Press, pp. 3–36. - DALY, R. L., BUNN, F. & GOODMAN, C. (2018): Shared decision-making for people living with dementia in extended care settings: A systematic review. In:
BMJ Open , 8(6):e018977. - DAVIS, A. N. (1995): The right to refuse treatment. In: T. L. Beauchamp (ed.):
Intending death: The ethics of assisted suicide and euthanasia . New Jersey: Pearson Education, pp. 109–130. - DEUTSCHER ALZHEIMER GESELLSCHAFT (2018):
Demenz. Das Wichtigste. Ein kompakter Ratgeber [Dementia. The most important: A compact guide ]. Berlin: Meta Druck. - DEUTSCHE ALZHEIMER GESELLSCHAFT E.V. SELBSTHILFE DEMENZ (2022):
Informationsblatt 1. Die Häufigkeit von Demenzerkrankungen [Information sheet 1: The prevalence of dementia ]. [online] [Retrieved January 4, 2025] Available at:https://www.deutsche-alzheimer.de/fileadmin/Alz/pdf/factsheets/infoblatt1_haeufigkeit_demenzerkrankungen_dalzg.pdf - DEUTSCHER ETHIKRAT (2012):
Demenz und Selbstbestimmung. Stellungnahme [Dementia and self-determination: Statement ]. In:Jahrbuch für Wissenschaft und Ethik [Yearbook of science and ethics ], 17(1), pp. 345–400. - DEUTSCHES ÄRZTEBLATT (2017): Zahl der Patientenverfügungen gestiegen [Increase in the number of living wills]. In:
Ärzteblatt , October 6. [online] [Retrieved September 22, 2024] Available at:https://www.aerzteblatt.de/nachrichten/81737/Zahl-der-Patientenverfuegungengestiegen . - DICHTER, M. N. & SCHMIDHUBER, M. (2016): Das Konzept Lebensqualität von Menschen mit Demenz – Zwei Ansätze zur theoretischen Auseinandersetzung [The concept of quality of life in people with dementia: Two approaches to theoretical discussion]. In:
Pflege & Gesellschaft , 21(2), pp. 114–129. - DRESSER, R. (1989): Advance directives, self-determination, and personal identity. In: C. Hackler, R. Moseley & D. E. Vawter (eds.):
Advance directives in Medicine . New York: Praeger, pp. 155–170. - DRESSER, R. (1995): Dworkin on dementia: Elegant theory, questionable policy. In:
Hastings Cent Rep ., 25(6), pp. 32–38. - DWORKIN, R. (1993):
Life’s dominion: An argument about abortion and euthanasia . New York: Alfred A. Knopf. - EDVARDSSON, D., FETHERSTONHAUGH, D. & NAY, R. (2010): Promoting a continuation of self and normality: person-centred care as described by people with dementia, their family members and aged care staff. In:
Journal of Clinical Nursing , 19(17–18), pp. 2611–2618. - FADE, R. R. & BEAUCHAMP, T. L. (1986):
A history and theory of informed consent . New York: Oxford University Press. - FAZIO, S., DOUGLAS, P., JANICE, F. & KALLYMYER, B. (2018): The fundamentals of person-centered care for individuals with dementia. In:
The Gerontologist , 18, 58(suppl_1), S10–S19. - FEDERAL STATISTICAL OFFICE (2016):
Older people in Germany and the EU . Wiesbaden: Federal Statistical Office of Germany. [online] [Retrieved January 4, 2025] Available at:https://www.bmfsfj.de/resource/blob/113952/83dbe067b083c7e8475309a88da89721/aeltere-menschen-in-deutschland-und-in-der-eu-englisch-data.pdf . - FIRLIK, A. D. (1991): A piece of my mind: Margo’s Logo. In:
JAMA, 265(2), p. 201. - HABERSTROH, J. & OSWALD, F. (2014): Unterstützung von Autonomie bei medizinischen Entscheidungen von Menschen mit Demenz durch bessere Person-Umwelt-Passung? [Support for autonomy in medical decisions for people with dementia through a better person-environment fit?]. In:
Informationsdienst Altersfragen , 41(4), pp. 16–26. - HABERSTROH, J. & MÜLER, T. (2017): Einwilligungsfähigkeit bei Demenz. Interdisziplinäre Perspektiven [Capacity for consent in dementia: Interdisciplinary perspectives]. In:
Zeitschrift für Gerontologie und Geriatrie , 50(4), pp. 298–303. - HAMPEL. H. et. al. (2011): The future of Alzheimer’s disease: The next 10 years. In:
Progress in Neurobiology , 95(4), pp. 718–728. - HENKE, O., BEHZADI, A. & HENKE, A. (2015): P-70 Utilisation of advanced care planning among migrants in berlin. In:
BMJ Supportive & Palliative Care , 5(2), A65. - HOLM, S. (2001): Autonomy, authenticity, or best interest: Everyday decision-making and persons with dementia. In:
Medicine, Health Care, and Philosophy , 4(2), pp. 153–159. - INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATION FOR MIGRATION (2021):
World migration report 2022 . Geneva: International Organization for Migration. - KALE, B., JAISWAL, P. & MASURKAR, D. (2024): Living will: Todays thoughts and actions. In:
Journal of Family Medicine and Primary Care , 13(1), pp. 20–23. - KLIE, T. (2005): Altersdemenz als Herausforderung für die Gesellschaft [Dementia in old age as a challenge for society]. In: Nationaler Ethikrat (ed.):
Tagungsdokumentation. Altersdemenz und Morbus Alzheimer [Conference documentation. Dementia in old age and Alzheimer’s disease ]. Hamburg: Druckerei in St.Pauli, pp. 65–81. - KLIE, T., VOLLMAN, J. & PANTEL, J. (2014): Autonomie und Einwilligungsfähigkeit bei Demenz als interdisziplinäre Herausforderung für Forschung, Politik und klinische Praxis [Autonomy and the ability to consent in dementia as an interdisciplinary challenge for research, politics and clinical practice]. In:
Informationsdienst Altersfragen , 41(4), pp. 5–15. [online] [Retrieved January 4, 2025] Available at:https://www.dza.de/fileadmin/dza/Dokumente/Informationsdienst_Altersfragen/Informationsdienst_Altersfragen_Heft_04_2014_Assistierte_Entscheidungen_bei_Demenz_und_eingeschr%C3%A4nkter_Einwilligungsf%C3%A4higkeit.pdf . - KOLLEK, R. (2005): Einführung. Ethische und gesellschaftliche Herausforderungen im Umgang mit Demenz [Introduction: Ethical and social challenges in dealing with dementia]. In: Deutscher Ethikrat (ed.):
Tagungsdokumentation. Demenz – Ende der Selbstbestimmung? [Conference documentation: Dementia: The end of self-determination? ]. Hamburg: BartosKersten Prindmedlendesign, pp. 11–16. - KRUSE, A. (2012): Die Lebensqualität demenzkranker Menschen erfassen und positiv beeinflussen - eine fachliche und ethische Herausforderung [Measuring and positively influencing the quality of life of people with dementia: A professional and ethical challenge]. In: Deutscher Ethikrat (ed.):
Tagungsdokumentation. Demenz – Ende der Selbstbestimmung [Conference documentation: Dementia: The end of self-determination? ]. Hamburg: BartosKersten Prindmedlendesign, pp. 27–50. - LIEBLICH, A. & JOSSELSON, R. (2013): Identity and narrative as root metaphors of personhood. In: J. Martin & M. H. Blickhard (eds.):
The psychology of personhood philosophical, historical, social-developmental, and narrative perspectives . New York: Cambridge University Press, pp. 203–233. - MCCORMACK, B. & MCCANCE T. V. (2006): Development of a framework for person-centred nursing. In:
J Adv Nurs ., 56(5), pp. 472–479. - MOYLE, W. & FETHERSTONHAUGH, D. et al. (2015): Influencers on quality of life as reported by people living with dementia in long-term care: A descriptive exploratory approach. In:
BMC Geriatr ics, 15(50). [Retrieved January 4, 2025] Available at:https://bmcgeriatr.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12877-015-0050-z#citeas - NATIONALER ETHIKRAT (2005):
Patientenverfügung. Stellungnahme [Living will: Statement ]. Berlin: Druckhaus Berlin-Mitte. - NUREMBERG CODE (1996): [online] [Retrieved September 2, 2024] Available at:
https://media.tghn.org/medialibrary/2011/04/BMJ_No_7070_Volume_313_The_Nuremberg_Code.pdf - PELLEGRINO, E. D. (2005): Some things ought never be done: Moral absolutes in clinical ethics. In:
Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics , 26(6), pp. 469–486. - QUANTE, M. (2002):
Personales Leben und menschlicher Tod. Personale Identität als Prinzip der biomedizinischen Ethik [Personal life and human death: Personal identity as a principle of biomedical ethics ]. Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp. - QUANTE, M. (2010):
Menschenwürde und personale Autonomie. Demokratische Werte im Kontext der Lebenswissenschaften [Human dignity and personal autonomy: Democratic values in the context of the life sciences ]. Hamburg: Felix Meiner. - QUANTE, M. (2019): Personale Autonomie, Dependenz und Würde im Kontext der Pflege [Personal autonomy, dependency and dignity in the context of care]. In: J. Noller (ed.):
Was sind und wie existieren Personen? Probleme und Perspektiven der gegenwärtigen Forschung [What are persons and how do they exist? Problems and perspectives of current research ]. Münster: Mentis, pp. 247–261. - ROSE, T. & DENING, K. H. (2023): Who am I? Identity, person-centred care and dementia. In:
Nursing Older People , 35(5), pp. 22–27. - SCHMIDHUBER, M. (2013a): Der Stellenwert von Autonomie für ein gutes Leben Demenzbetroffener [The importance of autonomy for a good life for people with dementia]. In:
Salzburger Beiträger zur Sozialethik [Salzburg contributions to social ethics ], 5, pp. 3–20. - SCHMIDHUBER, M. (2013b): Überlegungen zu den Grenzen der Patientenverfügung für die Selbstbestimmung von Demenzbetroffenen im Anschluss an die Dworkin-Dresser-Debatte [Reflections on the limits of living wills for the self-determination of people with dementia following the Dworking-Dresser debate]. In: J. S. Ach (ed.):
Grenzen der Selbstbestimmung in der Medizin [The limits of self-determination in medicine ]. Münster: Mentis, pp. 317–334. - SCHMIDHUBER, M. (2013c): Verlieren Demenzbetroffene ihre personale Identität? [Do people with dementia lose their personal identity?] In: G. Gasser & M. Schmidhuber (eds.):
Personale Identität, Narrativität und Praktische Rationalität. Die Einheit der Person aus metaphysischer und praktischer Perspektive [Personal identity, narrativity and practical rationality: The unity of the person from a metaphysical and a practical perspective ]. Münster: Mentis, pp. 295–311. - SCHMIDHUBER. M. (2014): Ethische Probleme der Patientenverfügung bei Demenzbetroffenen [Ethical problems of living wills for people with dementia]. In:
Ethica , 22(2), pp. 121–137. - SWISS ACADEMY OF MEDICAL SCIENCES (SAMS) (2017):
Care and treatment of people with dementia . [online] [Retrieved January 5, 2025] Available at: file:///C:/Users/Shingo/Downloads/guidelines_sams_dementia-1.pdf - SCOCCIA, D. (1990): Paternalism and respect for autonomy. In:
Ethics , 100(2), pp. 318–334. - SEIFERT-SCHÖNE, B. (2007):
Grundlagen der Medizinethik [Foundations of medical ethics ]. Stuttgart: Alfred Kröner. - THE National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research. (1978):
The Belmont report. Ethical principles and guidelines for the protection of human subjects of research . [online] [Retrieved January 5, 2025] Available at:https://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/sites/default/files/the-belmont-report-508c_FINAL.pdf . - WALKER, T. (2013): Respecting autonomy without disclosing information. In:
Bioethics , 27(7), pp. 388–394. - TEZCAN-GÜNTEKIN, H. & RAZUM, O. (2018): Pflegende Angehörige türkeistämmiger Menschen mit Demenz – Paradigmenwechsel von Ohnmacht zu Selbstmanagement [Carers of people with dementia of Turkish origin: A paradigm shift from powerlessness to selbst-management]. In:
Pflege & Gesellschaft , 32(1), pp. 69–83. - VOLLMANN, J. (2001): Advance directives in patients with Alzheimer’s disease: Ethical and clinical considerations. In:
Medicine, Health Care, and Philosophy , 4(2), pp. 161–167. - WIESEMANN, C. (2016): Vertrauen als moralische Praxis – Bedeutung für Medizin und Ethik [Trust as a moral practice: Significance for medicine and ethics]. In: H. Steinfach & C. Wiesemann (eds.):
Autonomie und Vertrauen. Schlüsselbegriffe der modernen Medizin [Autonomy and trust: Key concepts in modern medicine ]. Wiesbaden: Springer, pp. 69–99. - WHITEHOUSE, P. J. (2000): Ethical issues in dementia. In:
Dialogues in clinical neuroscience , 2(2), pp. 162–167. - WMA DECLARATION OF HELSINKI – ETHICAL PRINCIPLES FOR MEDICAL RESEARCH INVOLVING HUMAN PARTICIPANTS (1964): [online] [Retrieved September 22, 2024] Available at:
https://www.wma.net/policies-post/wma-declaration-of-helsinki/ - WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION (WHO) (2023):
Dementia , March 15. [online] [Retrieved September 22, 2024] Available at:https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/dementia . - ZICHY, M. (2014): Persönlichkeit – Zu einigen Aspekten der alltagssprachlichen Begriffsverwendung [Personality: On some aspects of the everyday language use of the term]. In: O. Friedrich & M. Zichy (eds.):
Persönlichkeit. Neurowissenschaftliche und neurophilosophische Fragestellungen [Personality: Neuroscientific and neurophilosophical issues ]. Münster: Mentis, pp. 23–48.
Language: English
Page range: 79 - 90
Published on: Jun 3, 2025
Published by: Sciendo
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 2 times per year
Keywords:
Related subjects:
© 2025 Shingo Segawa, Zümrüt Alpinar-Segawa, published by Sciendo
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 License.