Skip to main content
Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Satisfaction with Retirement: A Qualitative Comparative Analysis with Social Network Analysis Cover

Satisfaction with Retirement: A Qualitative Comparative Analysis with Social Network Analysis

Open Access
|Feb 2023

Figures & Tables

Table 1

Categorization of the outcome with QCA.

ValueDefinition
0Completely unsatisfied
0.1Dissatisfied, critical, and without hope of improvement in the future
0.2Dissatisfied and critical
0.3Dissatisfied
0.4Understands that has only a little amount of money, but is not dissatisfied
0.5Indifferent
0.6Knows that there are others in a worse situation
0.7Satisfied
0.8Satisfied and knows that he/she possesses more than others
0.9Satisfied and knows that he/she earn more than others and can travel at any time
1Very satisfied

[i] QCA, qualitative comparative analysis.

Figure 1

Level of satisfaction with retirement per person interviewed. Source: Fieldwork October 2019–January 2020 in Santiago, Chile.

Table 2

Sufficient pathways for satisfaction with retirement.

No.Variable nameSufficient conditions Consistency
1Amount of pension each month0.797
2Having a chronical disease (or not)0.767
5Working by choice (or not)0.660
7District in which they live during retirement0.676
29Size of SSN0.617
30Size of SSN with no kin0.624
34Efficiency of SSN0.669
35Reciprocity of material aid0.629
36Reciprocity of intimate interaction0.620
39Reciprocity of physical assistance0.736

[i] Note: For interpretation of a consistency: between 0.8–1.0 is high; 0.6–0.7 is modest; and the rest are low.

Table 3

Sufficient paths to being satisfied with retirement.

D*EA*~B*~C*~D~A*B*C*~D~A*B*~D*~E
Consistency0.9300.9950.9160.955
Covered cases*4, 11, 169, 8, 1030, 25, 22, 28, 213, 22
Solution coverage0.4600.3960.5010.501
Solution consistency0.9300.9950.9200.920

[i] Notes: *These are the cases with membership in the sufficient path bigger than 0.5.

Table 4

Necessary conditions for satisfaction with retirement I.

No.Variable nameCoverageConsistency
3Living with someone else0.4080.835
4Someone helping with domestic tasks0.4350.890
8Age0.5580.756

[i] Note: For interpretation, a consistency between 0.8–1.0 is high; 0.6–0.7 is modest; and the rest are low. Bold values shown a high level of consistency.

Table 5

Necessary conditions for satisfaction with retirement II.

No.Variable nameCoverageConsistency
11Completion of school education0.5100.803
13Not having had children prior to 18 years of age0.4740.858
14Having had both parents in childhood0.4690.937

[i] Note: For interpretation, a consistency between 0.8–1.0 is high; 0.6–0.7 is modest; and the rest are low. Bold values shown a high level of consistency.

Table 6

Necessary conditions for satisfaction with retirement III.

No.Variable nameCoverageConsistency
16Ego received intimate interaction0.4970.756
18Ego received feedback0.5030.677
19Ego received physical assistance0.5650.748
20Ego received positive interaction0.5420.661
21Ego has not received negative interaction0.4370.843

[i] Note: For interpretation, a consistency between 0.8–1.0 is high; 0.6–0.7 is modest; and the rest are low. Bold values shown a high level of consistency.

Table 7

Necessary conditions for satisfaction with retirement IV.

No.Variable nameCoverageConsistency
22Ego gives material aid0.5680.724
23Ego gives intimate interaction0.4290.638
25Ego gives feedback0.4760.630
26Ego gives physical assistance0.5560.622
27Ego gives positive interaction0.5260.646
28Ego does not give negative interaction0.4110.874

[i] Note: For interpretation, a consistency between 0.8–1.0 is high; 0.6–0.7 is modest; and the rest are low. Bold values shown a high level of consistency.

Figure 2

Patricio's SSN. SSN, social support network.

Table 8

Necessary conditions for satisfaction with retirement V.

No.Variable nameCoverageConsistency
31Density SSN0.5180.740
32Density SSN no kin0.4510.613
33IQV SSN0.4930.803
42Constrain SSN0.5330.786

[i] Note: For interpretation, a consistency between 0.8–1.0 is high; 0.6–0.7 is modest; and the rest are low. Bold values shown a high level of consistency.

[ii] IQV, Index of Qualitative Variation; SSNs, social support networks.

AMOUNTMONTH (Fuzzy)Amount of money (in Chilean peso) that EGO received each month0: Absence of money; 0.1: $0–$99,999; 0.2: $100,000–$199,999; 0.3: $200,000–$299,999; 0.4: $300,000–$399,999; 0.5: $400,000–$499,999; 0.6: $500,000–$599,999; 0.7: $600,000–$699,999; 0.8: $700,000–$799,999; 9: $800,000–$899,999; 10: >$900,000.
HEALTH (Crisp)Whether the participant has a chronical disease now0: Have a chronical disease; 1: Does not have a chronical disease
HOUSE (Crisp)Whether the participant lives with someone or not0: Living alone; 1: Not living alone
DOMESTIC (Crisp)Whether the participant has at least one person who helps him/her with domestic tasks0: Nobody to do domestic work; 1: Have someone to do domestic work
WORKNOW (Fuzzy)Whether the participant works or not0: Currently working, but not for choice; 0.6: Not working; 1: Currently working, but for choice
PARTNER (Crisp)Whether the participant has his/her partner alive0: Partner not alive; 1: Partner alive
DISTRICT (Fuzzy)Where the participant lives0.1: Quinta Normal (low class); 0.6: La Reina (middle class); 1: Vitacura (high class)
AGE (Fuzzy)Age of the participant0: <60 years; 0.1: 60–63 years; 0.2: 64–67 years; 0.3: 68–71 years; 0.4: 72–75 years; 0.5: 76–79 years; 0.6: 80–83 years; 0.7: 84–87 years; 0.8: 88–91 years; 0.9: 92–95 years; 1: >95 years
GENDER (Crisp)Gender of the participant0: Woman; 1: Man
BIRTH (Crisp)Where the participant was born, whether in the capital or not0: Not born in the capital; 1: Born in the capital
SCHOOL (Crisp)Whether the participant has completed schooling0: Not finished schooling; 1: Finished schooling
WORKCHILD (Crisp)Whether the participant started working before attaining 18 years of age0: Started working before have 18 years old; 1: started working after have 18 years old
CHILDREN (Crisp)Whether the participant had children prior to attaining 18 years of age0: Had children before 18 years of age; 1: Have not had children prior to 18 years of age
PARENTS (Fuzzy)Whether the participant had both or one parent alive and in contact with him/her, during their childhood0: Did not have both parents; 0.6: Had only one parent alive in childhood; 1: Had both parents alive in childhood
SSEGO1 (Fuzzy)Number of people who give material aids to ego0: No one; 0.3: One person; 0.7: Two people; 1: Three or more people
SSEGO2 (Fuzzy)Number of people who give intimate interaction to ego0: No one; 0.3: One person; 0.7: Two people; 1: Three or more people
SSEGO3 (Fuzzy)Number of people who give advice to ego0: No one; 0.3: One person; 0.7: Two people; 1: Three or more people
SSEGO4 (Fuzzy)Number of people who give feedback to ego0: No one; 0.1: One person; 0.2: Two people; 0.3: Three people; 0.4: Four people; 0.5: Five people; 0.6: Six people; 0.7: Seven people; 0.8: Eight people; 0.9: Nine people; 1: ≥10 people
SSEGO5 (Fuzzy)Number of people who give physical assistance to ego0: No one; 0.3: One person; 0.7: Two people; 1: Three or more people
SSEGO6 (Fuzzy)Number of people who give positive interaction to ego0: No one; 0.1: One person; 0.2: Two people; 0.3: Three people; 0.4: Four people; 0.5: Five people; 0.6: Six people; 0.7: Seven people; 0.8: Eight people; 0.9: Nine people; 1: ≥10 people
SSEGO7 (Fuzzy)Number of people who give negative interaction to ego0: Three or more people; 0.3: Two people; 0.7: One person; 1: No one
SSALTER1 (Fuzzy)Number of people who give material aids to ego0: No one; 0.3: One person; 0.7: Two people; 1: Three or more people
SSALTER2 (Fuzzy)Number of people who give intimate interaction to alter0: No one; 0.3: One person; 0.7: Two people; 1: Three or more people
SSALTER3 (Fuzzy)Number of people who give advice to alter0: No one; 0.3: One person; 0.7: Two people; 1: Three or more people
SSALTER4 (Fuzzy)Number of people who give feedback to alter0: No one; 0.1: One person; 0.2: Two people; 0.3: Three people; 0.4: Four people; 0.5: Five people; 0.6: Six people; 0.7: Seven people; 0.8: Eight people; 0.9: Nine people; 1: ≥10 people
SSALTER5 (Fuzzy)Number of people who give physical assistance to alter0: No one; 0.3: One person; 0.7: Two people; 1: Three or more people
SSALTER6 (Fuzzy)Number of people who give positive interaction to alter0: No one; 0.1: One person; 0.2: Two people; 0.3: Three people; 0.4: Four people; 0.5: Five people; 0.6: Six people; 0.7: Seven people; 0.8: Eight people; 0.9: Nine people; 1: ≥10 people
SSALTER7 (Fuzzy)Number of people who give negative interaction to alter0: Three or more people; 0.3: Two people; 0.7: One person; 1: No one
SIZENumber of alters in the network0: 0; 0.1: 1 or 2; 0.2: 3 or 4; 0.3: 5 or 6; 0.4: 7 or 8; 0.5: 9 or 10; 0.6: 11 or 12; 0.7: 13 or 14; 0.8; 15 or 16; 0.9: 17 or 18; 1: ≥19
SIZENOKINTotal number of alters having no kin in the network0: 0; 0.1: 1; 0.2: 2; 0.3: 3; 0.4: 4; 0.5: 5; 0.6: 6; 0.7: 7; 0.8; 8; 0.9: 9; 1: ≥10
DENSITYSocial network measure of the density of the complete networkThis measure takes values between 0 and 1.
DENSITYNOKINSocial network measure of the density of the network without kinThis measure takes values between 0 and 1.
IQV (Fuzzy)Social network measure of heterogeneity in the diversity of the types of support received by egoThis measure takes values between 0 and 1.
EFFICENCYSocial network measure of the efficiency of the networkThis measure takes values between 0 and 1.
Mutuality1Social network measure of the reciprocity of the material aids networkThis measure takes values between 0 and 1, by min–max normalization. The minimum value here was 0 and the maximum was 4.
Mutuality2Social network measure of the reciprocity of the intimate interaction networkThis measure takes values between 0 and 1, by min–max normalization. The minimum value here was 0 and the maximum was 6.
Mutuality3Social network measure of the reciprocity of the advice networkThis measure takes values between 0 and 1, by min–max normalization. The minimum value here was 0 and the maximum was 3.
Mutuality4Social network measure of the reciprocity of the feedback networkThis measure takes values between 0 and 1, by min–max normalization. The minimum value here was 0 and the maximum was 12.
Mutuality5Social network measure of the reciprocity of the physical assistance networkThis measure takes values between 0 and 1, by min–max normalization. The minimum value here was 0 and the maximum was 6.
Mutuality6Social network measure of the reciprocity of the positive interaction networkThis measure takes values between 0 and 1, by min–max normalization. The minimum value here was 0 and the maximum was 11.
Mutuality7Social network measure of the reciprocity of the negative interaction networkThis measure takes values between 0 and 1, by min–max normalization. The minimum value here was 0 and the maximum was 3.
ConstrainnorSocial network measure of the aggregate constrains of the networkThis measure takes values between 0 and 1.

[i] IQV, index of qualitative variation; QCA, qualitative comparative analysis.

SectionConditionsModels
12345
Dependent variableSATISFPENSION (Fuzzy)XXXXX
Conditions from the present situation of the people interviewedAMOUNTMONTH (Fuzzy)XX
HEALTH (Crip)XX
HOUSE (Crisp)XX
DOMESTIC (Crip)XX
WORKNOW (Fuzzy)XX
PARTNER (Crisp)XX
DISTRICT (Fuzzy)XX
AGE (Fuzzy)XX
GENDER (Crisp)XX
Conditions from the past of the people interviewedBIRTH (Crisp)XX
SCHOOL (Crisp)XX
WORKCHILD (Crisp)XX
CHILDREN (Crisp)XX
PARENTS (Fuzzy)XX
Conditions from the SNA – relational approachSSEGO1 (Fuzzy)XX
SSEGO2 (Fuzzy)XX
SSEGO3 (Fuzzy)XX
SSEGO4 (Fuzzy)XX
SSEGO5 (Fuzzy)XX
SSEGO6 (Fuzzy)XX
SSEGO7 (Fuzzy)XX
SSALTER1 (Fuzzy)XX
SSALTER2 (Fuzzy)XX
SSALTER3 (Fuzzy)XX
SSALTER4 (Fuzzy)XX
SSALTER5 (Fuzzy)XX
SSALTER6 (Fuzzy)XX
SSALTER7 (Fuzzy)XX
DENSITYXX
DENSITYNONKINXX
IQV (Fuzzy)XX
EFFICENCYXX
RECIPROCITY1XX
RECIPROCITY2XX
RECIPROCITY3XX
RECIPROCITY4XX
RECIPROCITY5XX
RECIPROCITY6XX
RECIPROCITY7XX
ConstrainnorXX

[i] IQV, index of qualitative variation; QCA, qualitative comparative analysis; SNA, social network analysis.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/connections-2022-0002 | Journal eISSN: 2816-4245 (formerly 0226-1766) | Journal ISSN: 0226-1766
Language: English
Page range: 1 - 25
Published on: Feb 28, 2023
Published by: International Network for Social Network Analysis (INSNA)
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 1 issue per year

© 2023 Francisca Ortiz Ruiz, Wendy Olsen, published by International Network for Social Network Analysis (INSNA)
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.