Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Citizens' Attitudes Toward Constitutional Reform: Key Trends, Influential Studies, and Future Research Directions Cover

Citizens' Attitudes Toward Constitutional Reform: Key Trends, Influential Studies, and Future Research Directions

Open Access
|Apr 2025

Figures & Tables

Fig. 1:

Publications selection PRISMA review methodology flowchart.
Publications selection PRISMA review methodology flowchart.

Fig. 4:

Number of publications.
Number of publications.

Fig. 2:

Map of co-occurrence for keyword study. Extensive bibliographic data is gathered from the WoS collection.
Map of co-occurrence for keyword study. Extensive bibliographic data is gathered from the WoS collection.

Fig. 3:

Examining current affairs hot subjects-bibliographic information derived from WoS collection.
Examining current affairs hot subjects-bibliographic information derived from WoS collection.

As of September 1, 2024, 10 papers having the highest yearly reference count citation yearly (CY)_

#ReferenceArticle# TC per year
1Pirro & Stanley, (2022)Forging, bending, and breaking: Enacting the “illiberal playbook” in Hungary and Poland16.67
2Casper et al. (2014)Popular Protest and Elite Coordination in a Coup d’état14.27
3Biermann et al. (2019)Political (non-) reform in the euro crisis and the refugee crisis: a liberal intergovernmentalist explanation11
4Schimmelfennig & Scholtz (2008)EU democracy promotion in the European neighbourhood: Political conditionality, economic development and transnational exchange10.41
5Walter (2015)Why bad governance leads to repeat civil war10.4
6Blokker (2019)Populism as a constitutional project9.83
7Beissinger et al. (2015)Explaining divergent revolutionary coalitions: Regime strategies and the structuring of participation in the Tunisian and Egyptian revolutions9.5
8Lynch & Crawford (2013)Democratization in Africa 1990–2010: an assessment. In Democratization in Africa: Challenges and Prospects8.29
9Pace (2013)Paradoxes and contradictions in EU democracy promotion in the Mediterranean: the limits of EU normative power7.79
10Farrell et al. (2020)The effects of mixed membership in a deliberative forum: The Irish constitutional convention of 2012–20146.81

Most often mentioned countries of authors_

RegionNPTCAverage article citations
UK138121412.30
USA106158420.60
Australia421406.10
Italy2816610.40
Ireland2516610.40
Germany2027917.40
Spain1816412.60
Canada161219.30
China9394.30
Chile7217.00

As of September 1, 2024, 10 papers with the most references on WoS_

#ReferenceArticleTotal Citation TC
1Schimmelfennig & Scholtz (2008)EU democracy promotion in the European neighbourhood: Political conditionality, economic development and transnational exchange177
2Huber & McCarty (2004)Bureaucratic capacity, delegation, and political reform174
3Casper et al. (2014)Popular Protest and Elite Coordination in a Coup d’état157
4Moravcsik (2006)What can we learn from the collapse of the European constitutional project?124
5Pace (2013)Paradoxes and contradictions in EU democracy promotion in the Mediterranean: the limits of EU normative power109
6Lynch & Crawford (2013)Democratization in Africa 1990–2010: an assessment109
7Albertazz & McDonnell (2005)The Lega Nord in the second Berlusconi government: In a league of its own104
8Walter (2015)Why bad governance leads to repeat civil war104
9Buchanan (1995)Federalism and individual sovereignty95
10Beissinger et al. (2015)Explaining divergent revolutionary coalitions: Regime strategies and the structuring of participation in the Tunisian and Egyptian revolutions95

Summary of research clusters_

ClusterKey keywordsPrincipal articlesProspective research opportunities and emerging research directions
Red ClusterConstitutional Reform, Democracy, Political ChangeSchimmelfennig & Scholtz (2008), Huber & McCarty (2004), Casper & Tyson (2014), Moravcsik (2006), Pace (2013), Lynch & Crawford (2013), Walter (2015), Albertazzi & McDonnell (2005), Biermann et al. (2019), Beissinger et al. (2015)Explore the interplay of elite coordination and public participation, examine the influence of governance on reform success, investigate populism’s role in constitutional changes, analyze non-reforms during crises
Green ClusterDemocracy, Constitutional Law, Citizen PerspectivesSchimmelfennig & Scholtz (2008), Huber & McCarty (2004), Casper & Tyson (2014), Moravcsik (2006), Pace (2013), Lynch & Crawford (2013), Albertazzi & McDonnell (2005), Walter (2015), Buchanan (1995)Study the impact of external actors on constitutional reforms, compare regime strategies in Tunisia and Egypt, examine the influence of populism on reforms, explore citizen participation mechanisms
Blue ClusterDecentralization, Electoral Dynamics, Citizen EngagementBuchanan (1995), Schimmelfennig & Scholtz (2008), Huber & McCarty (2004), Albertazzi & McDonnell (2005), Casper & Tyson (2014), Walter (2015), Moravcsik (2006), Pace (2013), Lynch & Crawford (2013)Investigate different types of decentralization and their effects on citizen engagement, study the intersection of decentralization and populism, analyze how electoral dynamics shape citizen attitudes toward reforms
Yellow ClusterDemocratization, Conflict, Citizen AttitudesSchimmelfennig & Scholtz (2008), Lynch & Crawford (2013), Huber & McCarty (2004), Casper & Tyson (2014), Walter (2015), Beissinger et al. (2015), Pace (2013)Examine how public dissatisfaction drives preferences for reform, explore the impact of external crises on reform processes, study citizen reactions to deliberative forums and their outcomes
Purple ClusterPolitical Parties, Parliamentary Influence, Citizen AttitudesSchimmelfennig & Scholtz (2008), Huber & McCarty (2004), Casper & Tyson (2014), Moravcsik (2006), Pace (2013), Keefer & Negretto (2024), van Leeuwen (2023)Investigate the influence of political conditionality on reforms, analyze bureaucratic capacity’s role in implementing changes, study the perceptions of EU influences on constitutional reforms, explore elite dynamics within political parties

Top 10 authors with highest rate_

Elementh_indexg_indexm_indexTCNumber of publication NPPY_start
Farrell Dm330.258932013
Flinders M330.154732005
Levy R330.23232010
Matthews F330.2142732011
Blokker P220.256222017
Cain Be220.15522005
Chaney P220.0952422004
Diamond P220.22322015
Dostal Jm220.25722017
Dunleavy P220.0831122001

Ten most often mentioned journals_

Elementh_indexg_indexm_indexTCNPPY_start
West European Politics990.42929992004
Democratization670.35328372008
Canadian Journal of Political Science-Revue Canadienne De Science Politique560.16110961994
Icon-International Journal of Constitutional Law570.27812772007
Parliamentary Affairs590.29592000
British Politics460.2676362010
Political Quarterly470.13372171995
Regional And Federal Studies440.257142009
Australian Journal of Political Science330.1033231996
British Journal of Politics & International Relations330.2144432011
Language: English
Page range: 1 - 21
Submitted on: Sep 22, 2024
Accepted on: Dec 8, 2024
Published on: Apr 22, 2025
Published by: University of Matej Bel in Banska Bystrica, Faculty of Economics
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 2 issues per year

© 2025 Sadam Abu Azam, Ziyad M. Rabei, published by University of Matej Bel in Banska Bystrica, Faculty of Economics
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.