Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Disputes Over the Concept of Ecological Economics and Environmental Economics in the Light of the Works of Professor Tomasz Żylicz Cover

Disputes Over the Concept of Ecological Economics and Environmental Economics in the Light of the Works of Professor Tomasz Żylicz

Open Access
|Aug 2021

Figures & Tables

Transdisciplinary sources of ecological economics

DisciplinesThe scope of interest in ecological economics
Social sciences and humanities
  • historical, ethical, sociological and psychological foundations and dependencies of environmental protection;

  • elements of environmental education and ecological ethics;

Political science
  • study of interest groups and their importance in the protection of the natural environment and the creation of environmental law;

  • principles governing the protection of the natural environment in societies and communities;

  • development (evolution) of the goals and strategies of balanced and sustainable development;

Law and legal sciences
  • codification of instruments and standards of environmental protection in the national and international dimension;

  • creation of new solutions in the field of the law of protection and use of the natural environment;

Environmental sciences
  • recognition of the impact of individual interactions (processes, substances) on the natural environment;

  • study of the consequences of negative and positive impacts on the natural environment and the methods of their formation;

  • analysis of the state of the natural environment and individual ecosystems on micro to global scale;

Technical sciences
  • development of techniques (technologies, devices, and methods) for the protection of the natural environment;

  • developing low-centric methods of influencing the elements and components of the natural environment;

  • rationalization of the use of resources, values and services of the natural environment;

  • developing technical progress in accordance with the BAT philosophy;

Economics
  • the use of optimization algorithms in the use and impact on the natural environment;

  • creation of appropriate methods of valorisation of elements and components of the natural environment;

  • development and implementation of a new paradigm of modern economics.

Research areas of ecological economics, according to R_ Constanzy, H_ Daly’ego and J_ Bartholomew

From–ToEconomic sectorsEcological sectors
Economic sectorsOrthodox trends in economics, traditional models of economic growthEconomics of the environment and natural resources, an ecologically-economically sustainable growth model
Ecological sectorsEconomics of natural resources, durable growth modelEcology, zero growth model
Ecological economy, the concept of sustainable development

Ecological and environmental economics paths in identifying and solving problems of the natural environment

Ecological economyEnvironmental economics
The paradigm of greening the economyThe paradigm of economising the natural environment
Creating ways of understanding the relationship between the natural environment - man - economy based on ecology, ethics and philosophyUsing the achievements of modern economics and economic thinking
Building a proper ecological awareness and life (consumption) attitudesLaunching effective market mechanisms to solve ecological problems
Practical use of resources, values and services of the natural environment, taking into account the criteria of intra- and intergenerational justicePractical use of resources, values and services of the natural environment with the use of static and dynamic optimisation methods
Economics of sustainable development

Comparison of conventional and ecological economics in terms of R_ Constanza, H_ Daly and J_ Bartholomew

Feature‘Conventional’ economyEcological economy
General view of the worldMechanistic, static, atomistic, individual preferences are recognized as basic data and dominant forces to be considered in the analysis, natural resources unlimited thanks to technologies and substitutionA dynamic systemic, evolutionary; preferences, technologies and organisms co-evolve to reflect a wide spectrum of ecological opportunities and constraints, people are responsible for their role in social and natural systems and their sustainability
TimeframeShort: 50 years, usually 1–4Multiscale: days to centuries multiscalar synthesis
Spatial frameworkLocal – International: Basic Analysis Units Companies and CountriesLocal-global: scale hierarchy
Genre frameworkOnly peopleEntire ecosystems, including man: recognizes the relationship between nature and man
Primary macro targetGrowth of the national economySustainability of the ecological and economic system
The primary target of microMaximize profit (company) or utility (person): this drive leads to the macro goal, external costs and benefits ignoredMust be aligned with the macro goal: social organization and cultural institutions at a higher level of the temporal and spatial hierarchy resolve conflicts arising from short-sighted lower-level micro-goals
Assumption of technological progressVery optimisticCautious sceptical
Scientific characterMonodisciplinaryTransdisciplinary
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/ceej-2021-0014 | Journal eISSN: 2543-6821 | Journal ISSN: 2544-9001
Language: English
Page range: 201 - 211
Published on: Aug 20, 2021
Published by: Faculty of Economic Sciences, University of Warsaw
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 1 issue per year

© 2021 Stanisław Czaja, published by Faculty of Economic Sciences, University of Warsaw
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 License.