Have a personal or library account? Click to login
What facilitates adaptation? An analysis of community-based adaptation to environmental change in the Andes Cover

What facilitates adaptation? An analysis of community-based adaptation to environmental change in the Andes

By: Felipe Murtinho  
Open Access
|Feb 2016

Figures & Tables

figures/ijc2016-2016003_fig_001.jpg
Figure 1

Fúquene Watershed location.

figures/ijc2016-2016003_fig_002.jpg
Figure 2

Precipitation trends in northern station: (a) annual rainfall (mm), (b) January fraction (%) and (c) dry spells (# of months with rainfall <20 mm). (Black line is 5-year moving average).

figures/ijc2016-2016003_fig_003.jpg
Figure 3

Percentage of WUAs implementing adaptation strategies.

Table 1:

Summary independent variables.

VariablesDescriptionExpectedMeanS.D.Min.Max.
Socio-economic settings
 Mun. water invest5-Year avg $US/hab+30.311.613.155.5
 Rural poverty% of households36.410.324.062.3
 Rural pop densityPop/Km2+51.928.023.3141.5
Resource systems and units
 Summer rainfall% of total annual rain16.20.915.118.6
 Land cover change% of change 1987–2005–16.224.1–54.924.3
Governance system
 Legal registry1=yes+0.60.40.01.0
Actors
 WUA size# users±126.1121.812.0575
 WUA incomeUS$/month/user+1.11.10.06.3
 WUA experienceYears+16.99.50.143
 Leader educationYears+8.34.81.016
 Leader resides inside community1=inside±0.80.30.01.0
Interactions
 Request external support% of total strategies+33.419.40.070
 WUA political connections%+60.936.30.0100
Table 2

OLS regression results.

Model 1Model 2Model 3Model 4
Socioeconomic settings
 Municipal water investment0.002–0.0020.0080.006
 Rural poverty–0.018–0.029*0.0050.021
 Rural population density–0.003–0.005–0.001–0.005
Resource systems and units
 Summer rainfall–0.078**–0.057–0.057–0.161***
 Land cover change–0.008**–0.010**0.0010.007
Governance systems
 Legal registry0.244–0.0310.390*0.268
Actors
 WUA size0.0000.0000.002**0.002**
 WUA income0.0240.0440.0190.261***
 WUA experience0.029***0.0140.023**0.014
 Leader education0.002–0.0110.0330.007
 Leader resides inside community0.2380.363–0.166–0.481*
Interactions
 Request external support2.829***2.688***0.3780.281
 WUA political connections0.497**0.3760.481**0.003
 Constant0.8311.560–0.3273.591*
 Adjusted R20.5530.3580.1980.205

[i] N=104. Table shows regression coefficients. *p<0.1, **p<0.05, ***p<0.01.

Dependent Var: Model 1 (Overall Adaptation Index), Model 2 (Micro-Watershed Strategies), Model 3 (Water Supply Strategies), and Model 4 (Water Demand Strategies) Index.

Table 1:

Index weights (based on Principal Component Analysis).

Overall Adaptation IndexWatershed Strategies IndexSupply Strategies IndexDemand Strategies Index
Land Purchase0.6710.564
Reforestation0.6730.776
Fences0.4950.707
Report0.5130.592
Tanks0.2940.218
Treatment Plant0.2150.776
Reservoir0.3510.629
New Sources0.2120.581
Pipes0.5010.311
Capacity Building0.0580.635
Prices0.0000.778
% of variance explained by 1st component17.87644.27334.58336.812

[i] Note: The Overall Adaptation Index has a relatively low percentage of variance explained by the first component. Other components also explain some of the variability, but only the first component has positive coefficients. This result is similar to previous studies (Vyas and Kumaranayake 2006), and could be explained by the relatively higher number of variables used in the analysis (Vyas and Kumaranayake 2006).

Table 2:

Correlation among independent variables.

Municipal Water InvestmentRural PovertyRural Population densitySummer RainfallLand cover changeLegal registryWUA SizeWUA IncomeWUA experienceLeader educationResidesRequest external supportWUA Political connections
Mun. Water Inv.1.000
Rural Poverty–0.6661.000
Rural Pop.density0.426–0.4131.000
Summer Rainfall0.259–0.323–0.0101.000
Land cover Ch.0.663–0.4370.0530.1591.000
Legal registry–0.2140.065–0.162–0.140–0.1671.000
WUA Size–0.2220.081–0.0080.066–0.2540.2741.000
WUA Income0.147–0.3210.1110.3200.0080.1530.1011.000
WUA experience0.173–0.2830.2840.1270.004–0.1470.1180.0341.000
Leader education0.036–0.2210.1100.0360.0140.2260.2340.286–0.0491.000
Resides0.1340.0020.015–0.0640.189–0.0300.070–0.2090.091–0.2671.000
Request external–0.0350.131–0.025–0.072–0.0220.2340.138–0.056–0.0200.016–0.0351.000
WUA Political0.042–0.039–0.0120.0800.051–0.1320.132–0.1000.0620.0660.0260.3131.000
DOI: https://doi.org/10.18352/ijc.585 | Journal eISSN: 1875-0281
Language: English
Published on: Feb 1, 2016
Published by: Uopen Journals
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 1 issue per year

© 2016 Felipe Murtinho, published by Uopen Journals
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.