Have a personal or library account? Click to login
Gathering the needles: evaluating the impact of gold open access content with traditional subscription journals Cover

Gathering the needles: evaluating the impact of gold open access content with traditional subscription journals

By: Alison Bobal and  Jill Emery  
Open Access
|Jul 2016

Figures & Tables

Table 1

Hybrid OA overview by publisher (December 2015)

Hybrid OA overview
Publisher Hybrid program nameYear beganNo of journals participating
ElsevierElsevier Open Access20061,690 out of 3,696
Nature Publishing GroupNPG Open200778 out of 136
SAGE PublicationsSAGE Choice2006769 out of 800
Springer BVSpringer Open Choice20041,657 out of 2,181
John Wiley & SonsWiley Open Access2004743 out of 1,500
Table 2

Cost of hybrid publication by publisher (2016)

Cost of hybrid publishing
PublisherAverage hybrid APCsIntermixed with subscriptions?
ElsevierUS$500-US$5,000No, completely separate
Nature Publishing GroupUS$1,350-US$5,200Discount given on subscriptions
SAGE PublicationsUS$750-US$3,000Discounts given on subscriptions but not on packages
Springer BVUS$3,000Website notes they take OA into consideration re. subscription cost
John Wiley & SonsUS$3,000Discounts given on subscriptions
Table 3

Usage by year, percentage of GOA usage, publisher and institution

Downloads for 2014 and 2015
Portland State University20142015University of Nebraska Medical Center20142015
Elsevier total usage190,658192,618Elsevier total usage212,433259,119
Elsevier GOA usage4,0107,570Elsevier GOA usage7,89513,757
% of Elsevier GOA usage2.1%3.9%% of Elsevier GOA usage3.7%5.3%
Nature PG total usage16,97818,635Nature PG total usage77,04186,627
Nature PG GOA usage1,3532,136Nature PG GOA usage6,53712,034
% of Nature PG GOA usage8.0%11.5%% of Nature PG GOA usage8.5%13.9%
Sage total usage92,73062,199Sage total usage17,88620,622
Sage GOA usage279254Sage GOA usage687311
% of SAGE GOA usage0.3%0.4%% of SAGE GOA usage3.8%1.5%
Springer total usage45,24839,966Springer Total usage23,48435,696
Springer GOA usage2,2212,468Springer GOA usage2,4452,681
% of Springer GOA usage4.9%6.2%% of Springer GOA usage10.4%7.5%
Wiley total usage90,64471,512
Wiley GOA usage1,1591,611
% of Wiley GOA usage1.3%2.3%
Table 4

Journals with the highest number of GOA full-text article requests (‘top’) by institution

Top GOA titles 2014
Portland State UniversityUniversity of Nebraska Medical Center
1. PNAS (National Academy of Sciences)1. PNAS (National Academy of Sciences)
2. Nature (NPG)2. Nature (NPG)
3. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences (Elsevier)3. Journal of Biological Chemistry (ASBMB)
4. BioScience (AIBS)4. British Journal of Cancer (NPG)
5. BMJ Quality & Safety (BMJ)5. American Journal of Pathology (Elsevier)
6. Northwest Science (NSA)6. Oncogene (NPG)
7. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences (Royal Society)7. Bioinformatics (OUP)
8. Energy Procedia (Elsevier)8. The Lancet (Elsevier)
9. Climatic Change (Springer)9. Genome Research (Cold Springs Harbor Laboratory Press)
10. Journal of Homosexuality (Taylor & Francis)10. Journal of Hepatology (Elsevier)
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1629/uksg.291 | Journal eISSN: 2048-7754
Language: English
Published on: Jul 5, 2016
Published by: Ubiquity Press
In partnership with: Paradigm Publishing Services
Publication frequency: 3 issues per year

© 2016 Alison Bobal, Jill Emery, published by Ubiquity Press
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.