Evaluating quality of support from the perspective of persons with intellectual disabilities: A review

Bea Maes

doi:10.1080/15017410309512627

Evaluating quality of support from the perspective of persons with intellectual disabilities: A review

Scandinavian Journal of Disability Research

Volume 5 (2003): Issue 3

By: Bea Maes

Open Access

|Jul 2003

Abstract

Increasing importance is attached to the involvement and participation of persons with intellectual disabilities in planning and evaluating support and services. This can be explained by the changed relationship between clients and professionals and by the shift to a person‐centred approach of services that aims to provide responsive support to assist people in achieving valued ‘quality of life’ outcomes. Different strategies of quality evaluation from the perspective of persons with intellectual disabilities are discussed, including methodological issues concerning satisfaction research and the proxy‐approach. An overview is given of studies in which persons with intellectual disabilities were questioned about the quality of their life and supports. Specific attention is paid to the association of quality of life outcomes with type of service provision and support characteristics. Finally, some future challenges are indicated to promote user involvement in quality evaluation, from the perspective of researchers, service providers and persons with intellectual disabilities themselves.

References

Allen , P. 1995 . “ ‘From the bottom up: ensuring quality with service users’ ” . In Values and visions ‐changing ideas in services for people with learning difficulties , Edited by: Philpot , T. and Ward , L. 164 – 175 . London : David Fulton .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Amado , A.N. and McBride , M.W. 2002 . “ Realizing individual, organizational, and systems change: lessons learned in 15 years of training about person‐centered planning and principles ” . In Person‐centered planning. Research, practice and future directions , Edited by: Holburn , S. and Vietze , P.M. 361 – 377 . Baltimore : P.H.Brookes .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Antaki , C. and Rapley , M. 1996 . Questions and answers to psychological assessment schedules: hidden troubles in ‘Quality of life’ interviews . Journal of Intellectual Disability Research , 40 : 421 – 437 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Antaki , C. , Young , N. and Finlay , M. 2002 . Shaping clients’ answers: departures from neutrality in care‐staff interviews with persons with a learning disability . Disability and Society , 17 : 435 – 455 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Atkinson , M.J. and Zibin , S. 1996 . Quality of life measurement among persons with chronic mental illness: a critique of measures and methods , Ontario : Minister of Supply and Services Canada . (http:/www.hcsc.gc.ca/hppb/mentalhealth/pubs/quality_of_life/)
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Barnes , C. and Mercer , G. , eds. 1997 . Doing disability research , Leeds : The Disability Press .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Becker , H. , Dumas , S. , Houser , A. and Seay , P. 2000 . How organizational factors contribute to innovations in service delivery . Mental Retardation , 38 : 385 – 394 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Benjamin , M. , Capie , A. and Nossin , M. 1997 . Evaluating community services for people with a disability , Wellington : Standards and monitoring services .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Bradley , V.J. 1994 . “ Evolution of a new service paradigm ” . In Creating individual supports for people with developmental disabilities: a mandate for change at many levels , Edited by: Bradley , V.J. , Ashbaugh , J.W. and Blaney , B.C. 11 – 32 . Baltimore : Brookes .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Butterworth , J. , Steere , D.E. and Whitney‐Thomas , J. 1997 . “ Using person‐centered planning to address personal quality of life ” . In Quality of life. Vol.11: Applications to persons with disabilities , Edited by: Schalock , R. Vol.11 , 5 – 24 . Washington : American Association on Mental Retardation .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Capie , A. and Ahrens , M. 1996 . A strategie for training and involving consumers with an intellectual disability in the evaluation of their community services . British Journal of Developmental Disabilities , 42 : 36
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Cowger , C. and Snively , C. 2002 . “ Assessing client strengths: individual, family and community empowerment ” . In The strengths perspective in social work practice , Edited by: Saleebey , D. 106 – 123 . New York : Longman Publishers .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Cummins , R.A. 1995 . On the trail of the gold standard for subjective well‐being . Social Indicators Research , 35 : 179 – 200 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Cummins , R.A. 1997 . Comprehensive Quality of Life Scale. Manual: fourth edition , Melbourne , , Australia : Deakin University .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Dale , N. 1996 . Working with families of children with special needs: partnership and practice , London : Routledge .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Davis , P. and Faw , G. 2002 . “ Residential preferences in person‐centered planning: empowerment through the self‐identification of preferences and their availability ” . In Person‐centered planning. Research, practice and future directions , Edited by: Holburn , S. and Vietze , P.M. 203 – 221 . Baltimore : P.H.Brookes .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Dean , J.E.A. and Mank , D.M. 1997 . “ Continuous improvement and quality of life: Lessons from organizational management ” . In Quality of life. Vol.II: Applications to persons with disabilities , Edited by: Schalock , R. Vol.II , 165 – 179 . Washington : American Association on Mental Retardation .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Dunst , C.J. , Trivette , C.M. and Johanson , C. 1995 . “ Parent‐professional collaboration and partnerships ” . In Supporting & strenghtening families. Volume 1: Methods, strategies and practices , Edited by: Dunst , C.J. , Trivette , C.M. and Deal , A.G. Volume 1 , 197 – 212 . Cambridge : Brookline Books .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Emerson , E. 1999 . Residential supports for people with intellectual disabilities: questions and challenges from the UK . Journal of Intellectual and Developmental Disability , 24 : 309 – 319 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Emerson , E. and Hatton , C. 1996 . Deinstitutionalization in the UK. Outcomes for sevice users . Journal of Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities , 21 : 17 – 37 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Emerson , E. , Robertson , J. , Gregory , N. , Hatton , C. , Kessissoglou , S. , Hallam , A. , Knapp , M. , Järbrink , K. , Walsh , P.N. and Netten , A. 2000a . Quality and costs of community‐based residential supports, village communities, and residential campuses in the United Kingdom . American Journal on Mental Retardation , 105 : 81 – 102 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Emerson , E. , Robertson , J. , Gregory , N. , Kessissoglou , S. , Hatton , C. , Hallam , A. , Knapp , M. , Järbrink , K. , Netten , A. and Linehan , C. 2000b . The quality and costs of community‐based residential supports and residential campuses for people with severe and complex disabilities . Journal of Intellectual and Developmental Disability , 25 : 263 – 279 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Emerson , E. , Robertson , J. , Gregory , N. , Hatton , C. , Kessissoglou , S. , Hallam , A. , Jarbrink , K. , Knapp , M. , Netten , A. and Walsh , P.N. 2001 . Quality and costs of supported living residences and group homes in the United Kingdom . American Journal on Mental Retardation , 106 : 401 – 415 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Felce , D. 1998 . The determinants of staff and resident activity in residential services for people with severe intellectual disability: moving beyond size, building design, location and number of staff . Journal of Intellectual and Developmental Disability , 23 : 103 – 120 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Felce , D. , Jones , E. and Lowe , K. 2002 . “ Active support: planning daily activities and support for people with severe mental retardation ” . In Person‐centered planning. Research, practice and future directions , Edited by: Holburn , S. and Vietze , P.M. 247 – 269 . Baltimore : P.H.Brookes .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Felce , D. , Lowe , K. , Perry , J. , Baxter , H. , Jones , E. , Hallam , A. and Beecham , J. 1998 . Service support to people in Wales with severe intellectual disability and the most severe challenging behaviours: processes, outcomes and costs . Journal of Intellectual Disability Research , 42 : 390 – 408 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Felce , D. , Lowe , K. , Beecham , J. and Hallam , A. 2000 . Exploring the relationships between costs and quality of services for adults with severe intellectual disabilities and the most severe challenging behaviours in Wales: a multivariate regression analysis . Journal of Intellectual and Developmental Disability , 25 : 307 – 326 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Felce , D. and Perry , J. 1996 . “ Exploring current conceptions of quality of life: A model for people with and without disabilities ” . In Quality of life in health promotion and rehabilitation. Conceptual approaches, issues and applications , Edited by: wick , R. Ren , Brown , I. and Nagler , M. 51 – 62 . London : Sage publications .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Finlay , W.M.L. and Lyons , E. 2001 . Methodological issues in interviewing and using self‐report questionnaires with people with mental retardation . Psychological Assessment , 13 : 319 – 335 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Forrester‐Jones , R. , Carpenter , J. , Cambridge , P. , Tate , A. , Hallam , A. , Knapp , M. and Beecham , J. 2002 . The quality of life of people 12 years after resettlement from long stay hospitals: users’ views on their living environment, daily activities and future aspirations . Disability and Society , 17 : 741 – 758 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Gardner , J. , Carran , D.T. and Nudler , S. 2001 . “ Measuring quality of life and quality of services through personal outcome measures: implications for public policy ” . In International Review of Research in Mental Retardation , Edited by: Glidden , L.M. Vol.24 , 75 – 100 . San Diego : Academic Press .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Goode , D. 1994 . Quality of life for persons with disabilities: international perspectives and issues , Cambridge : Brookline books .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Goodley , D. 2000 . Self‐advocacy in the lives of people with learning difficulties — The politics of resilience , Buckingham : Open University Press .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Gregory , N. , Robertson , J. , Kessissoglou , S. , Emerson , E. and Hatton , C. 2001 . Factors associated with expressed satisfaction among people with intellectual disability receiving residential supports . Journal of Intellectual Disability Research , 45 : 279 – 291 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Griffin , D.K. , Rosenberg , H. , Cheyney , W. and Greenberg , B. 1996 . A comparison of self‐esteem and job satisfaction of adults with mild mental retardation in sheltered workshops and supported employment . Education and Training in Mental Retardation and Developmental Disability , 31 : 142 – 150 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Hatton , C. 1998 . Whose quality of life is it anyway? Some problems with the emerging quality of life consensus . Mental Retardation , 36 : 104 – 115 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Hatton , C. and Ager , A. 2002 . Quality of life measurement and people with intellectual disabilities: a reply to Cummins . Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities , 15 : 254 – 260 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Hatton , C. , Emerson , E. , Robertson , J. , Henderson , D. and Cooper , J. 1996 . Factors associated with staff support and user lifestyle in services for people with multiple disabilities: a path analytic approach . Journal of Intellectual Disability Research , 40 : 466 – 477 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Heal , L.W. and Sigelman , C.K. 1996 . “ Methodological issues in quality of life measurement ” . In Quality of life. Vol.1: Conceptualization and measurement , Edited by: Schalock , R.L. Vol.1 , 91 – 104 . Washington : American Association on Mental Retardation .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Heller , T. , Miller , A.B. and Hsieh , K. 2002 . Eight‐year follow‐up of the impact of environmental characteristics on well‐being of adults with developmental disabilities . Mental Retardation , 40 : 366 – 378 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Hensel , E. , Rose , J. , Steinfert Kroese , B. and Banks‐Smith , J. 2002 . Subjective judgements of quality of life: a comparison study between people with and those without a disability . Journal of Intellectual Disability Research , 46 : 95 – 107 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Hogg , J. , Reeves , D. , Roberts , J. and Mudford , O.C. 2001 . Consistency, context and confidence in judgements of affective communication in adults with profound intellectual and multiple disabilities . Journal of Intellectual Disability Research , 45 : 18 – 29 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Holburn , S. and Vietze , P.M. , eds. 2002 . Person‐centered planning. Research, practice and future directions , Baltimore : P.H. Brookes .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Howe , J. , Horner , R.H. and Newton , J.S. 1998 . Comparison of supported living and traditional residential services in the state of Oregon . Mental Retardation , 36 : 1 – 11 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Keith , K.D. 2001 . “ International quality of life: current conceptual, measurement, and implementation issues ” . In International Review of Research in Mental Retardation , Edited by: Glidden , L.M. Vol.24 , 49 – 74 . San Diego : Academic Press .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Kim , S. , Larson , S. and Lakin , K. 2001 . Behavioral outcomes of deinstitutionalization for people with intellectual disabilities: a review of U.S. studies conducted between 1980 and 1999 . Journal of Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities , 26 : 15 – 34 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Larsson , G. and Larsson , B.W. 2001 . Quality of care and service as perceived by adults with developmental disabilities, their parents, and primary caregivers . Mental Retardation , 39 : 249 – 258 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Lord , J. and Hutchison , P. 2003 . Indiviualised support and funding: building blocks for capacity building and inclusion . Disability and Society , 18 : 71 – 86 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Luckasson , R.A. , Coulter , D.L. , Polloway , E.A. , Reiss , S. , Schalock , R.L. , Snell , M.E. , Spitalnik , D.M. and Stark , J.A. 1992 . Mental Retardation: definition, classification, and systems of support , Washington : American Association on Mental Retardation .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Maes , B. , Bruyninckx , W. and Goffart , K. 2003 . Trajectbegeleiding voor personal met een handicap [Support brokerage for persons with a disability] , Leuven : Acco .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Maes , B. , Geeraert , L. and Van den Bruel , B. 2000 . Developing a model for quality evaluation in residential care for people with intellectual disabilities . Journal of Intellectual Disability Research , 44 : 544 – 552 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Maes , B. , Petry , K. and Demuynck , J. Expression of feelings and preferences by persons with profound multiple disabilities . Presentation at the Meeting of the IASSID‐Special Interest Group ‘Persons with profound multiple disabilities’ . March 2003 , Amsterdam .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Maes , B. , Van Hove , G. , Van Puyenbroeck , J. , Van der Veken , K. , Van Driessche , C. and Boone , M. 2001 . Een kader voor de organisatie van vraaggestuurde ondersteuning voor mensen met een handicap en hun omgeving [A framework for the organisation of person‐centered support for persons with a disability and their family] , Leuven/Gent : University of Leuven/University of Gent, Department of orthopedagogics .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
McVilly , K.R. , Burton‐Smith , R.M. and Davidson , J.A. 2000 . Concurrence between subject and proxy ratings of quality of life for people with and without intellectual disabilities . Journal of Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities , 25 : 19 – 40 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Neumayer , R. and Bleasdale , M. 1996 . Personal lifestyle preferences of people with an intellectual disability . Journal of Intellectual and Developmental Disability , 21 : 91 – 115 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Newton , J.S. , Horner , R.H. , Ard , W.R. , LeBaron , N. and Sappington , G. 1994 . A conceptual model for improving the social life of individuals with mental retardation . Mental Retardation , 32 : 392 – 402 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
O'Brien , C.L. and O'Brien , J. 2002 . “ The origins of person‐centered planning ‐ A community of practice perspective ” . In Person‐centered planning. Research, practice and future directions , Edited by: Holburn , S. and Vietze , P.M. 3 – 27 . Baltimore : P.H.Brookes .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Pedlar , A. , Haworth , L. and Hutchison , P. 1999 . A textured life: empowerment and adults with developmental disabilities , Waterloo : Wilfrid Laurier University Press .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Perry , J. and Felce , D. 2002 . Subjective and objective quality of life assessment: responsiveness, response bias, and resident:proxy concordance . Mental Retardation , 40 : 445 – 456 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Reid , D.H. and Green , C.W. 2002 . “ Person‐centered planning with people who have severe multiple disabilities: validated practices and misapplications ” . In Person‐centered planning. Research, practice and future directions , Edited by: Holburn , S. and Vietze , P.M. 183 – 202 . Baltimore : P.H.Brookes .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Renwick , R. and Brown , I. 1996 . “ The Centre for Health Promotion's conceptual approach to quality of life: being, belonging and becoming ” . In Quality of life in health promotion and rehabilitation. Conceptual approaches, issues and applications , Edited by: Renwick , R. , Brown , I. and Nagler , M. 75 – 88 . London : Sage publications .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Robertson , J. , Emerson , E. , Gregory , N. , Hatton , C. , Kessissoglou , S. , Hallam , A. and Linehan , C. 2001 . Social networks of people with mental retardation in residential settings . Mental Retardation , 39 : 201 – 214 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Sands , D.G. and Kozleski , E.B. 1994 . Quality of life differences between adults with and without disabilities . Education and Training in Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities , 29 : 90 – 101 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Sands , D.J. , Kozleski , E.B. and Goodwin , L.D. 1991 . Whose needs are we meeting? Results of a consumer satisfaction survey of persons with developmental disabilities in Colorado . Research in Developmental Disabilities , 12 : 297 – 314 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Schalock , R.L. 1996a . “ Quality of life and quality assurance ” . In Quality of life in health promotion and rehabilitation. Conceptual approaches, issues and applications , Edited by: Renwick , R. , Brown , I. and Nagler , M. 104 – 118 . London : Sage publications .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Schalock , R.L. 1996b . “ Reconsidering the conceptualization and measurement of quality of life ” . In Quality of Life. Vol.1. Conceptualization and measurement , Edited by: Schalock , R.L. Vol.1 , 123 – 139 . Washington : American Association on Mental Retardation .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Schalock , R.L. , Brown , I. , Brown , R. , Cummins , R.A. , Felce , D. , Matikka , L. , Keith , D.K. and Parmenter , T. 2002 . Conceptualization, measurement, and application of quality of life for persons with intellectual disabilities: report of an international panel of experts . Mental Retardation , 40 : 457 – 470 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Schwartz , A.A. , Jacobson , J.W. and Holburn , S.C. 2000 . Defining person centeredness: results of a two consensus methods . Education and Training in Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities , 35 : 235 – 249 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Stalker , K. and Harris , P. 1998 . The exercise of choice by adults with intellectual disabilities: a literature review . Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities , 11 : 60 – 76 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Stancliffe , R.J. 1997 . Community‐living‐unit size, staff presence and resident's choice‐making . Mental Retardation , 35 : 1 – 9 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Stancliffe , R.J. 2000 . Proxy respondents and quality of life . Evaluation and Program Planning , 23 : 89 – 93 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Stancliffe , R.J. , Abery , B.H. and Smith , J. 2000 . Personal control and the ecology of community living settings: beyond living‐unit size and type . American Journal on Mental Retardation , 105 : 431 – 454 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Stancliffe , R.J. and Keane , S. 2000 . Outcomes and costs of community living: a matched comparison of group homes and semi‐independent living . Journal of Intellectual and Developmental Disability , 25 : 281 – 305 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Stancliffe , R.J. and Lakin , K.C. 1998 . Analysis of expenditures and outcomes of residential alternatives for persons with developmental disabilities . American Journal on Mental Retardation , 102 : 552 – 568 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Taylor , S.J. , Bogdan , R. and Racino , J.A. , eds. 1991 . The community participation series: Vol.1 Life in the community: case studies of organizations supporting people with disabilities , Vol.1 , Baltimore : P.H. Brookes .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Tøssebro , J. 1995 . Impact of size revisited: relation of number of residents to self‐determination and deprivatization . American Journal on Mental Retardation , 100 : 59 – 67 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Vlaskamp , C. 1993 . Een kwestie van perspectief Methodiekontwikkeling in de zorg voor ernstig meervoudig gehandicapten [A matter of perspective. Development of a method in the care for persons with profound multiple disabilities] , Assen : Van Gorcum .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Walmsley , J. 2001 . Normalisation, emancipatory research and inclusive research in learning disability . Disability and Society , 16 : 187 – 205 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Ward , L. , ed. 1998 . Innovations in advocacy and empowerment for people with intellectual disabilities , Chorley : Lisieux Hall .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Wheeler , J.J. 1996 . The use of interactive focus groups to aid in the identification of perceived service and support delivery needs of persons with developmental disabilities and their families . Education and Training in Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities , 31 : 294 – 303 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Wehmeyer , M.L. and Metzler , C.A. 1995 . How self‐determinated are people with mental retardation? The national consumer survey . Mental Retardation , 33 : 111 – 119 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Wehmeyer , M.L. and Bolding , N. 2001 . Enhanced self‐determination of adults with intellectual disability as an outcome of moving to community‐based work or living environments . Journal of Intellectual Disability Research , 45 : 371 – 383 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Whittaker , A. 1995 . “ Partnership in practice: user participation in services for people with learning difficulties ” . In Values and visions ‐ changing ideas in services for people with learning difficulties , Edited by: Philpot , T. and Ward , L. 176 – 185 . London : David Fulton .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Young , I. , Sigafoos , J. , Suttie , J. , Ashman , A. and Grevell , P. 1998 . Deinstitutionalization of persons with intellectual disabilities: a review of Australian studies . Journal of Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities , 23 : 155 – 170 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article
Zirpoli , T.J. , Wieck , C. , Hancox , D. and Skarnulis , E.R. 1994 . Partners in policy‐making. The first five years . Mental Retardation , 32 : 422 – 425 .
Search in Google Scholar Back to article